Mechanistic inquiry into decrease in probability of defibrillation success with increase in complexity of preshock reentrant activity.

Abstract

Energy requirements for successful antiarrhythmia shocks are arrhythmia specific. However, it remains unclear why the probability of shock success decreases with increasing arrhythmia complexity. The goal of this research was to determine whether a diminished probability of shock success results from an increased number of functional reentrant circuits in the myocardium, and if so, to identify the responsible mechanisms. To achieve this goal, we assessed shock efficacy in a bidomain defibrillation model of a 4-mm-thick slice of canine ventricles. Shocks were applied between a right ventricular cathode and a distant anode to terminate either a single scroll wave (SSW) or multiple scroll waves (MSWs). From the 160 simulations conducted, dose-response curves were constructed for shocks given to SSWs and MSWs. The shock strength that yielded a 50% probability of success (ED(50)) for SSWs was found to be 13% less than that for MSWs, which indicates that a larger number of functional reentries results in an increased defibrillation threshold. The results also demonstrate that an isoelectric window exists after both failed and successful shocks; however, shocks of strength near the ED(50) value that were given to SSWs resulted in 16.3% longer isoelectric window durations than the same shocks delivered to MSWs. Mechanistic inquiry into these findings reveals that the two main factors underlying the observed relationships are 1) smaller virtual electrode polarizations in the tissue depth, and 2) differences in preshock tissue state. As a result of these factors, intramural excitable pathways leading to delayed breakthrough on the surface were formed earlier after shocks given to MSWs compared with SSWs and thus resulted in a lower defibrillation threshold for shocks given to SSWs.