Search PubMedSearch

PubMed · 8246481

The need for replication.

Abstract

Replication provides verification and disconfirmation functions for the scholarly fields. Relatively few replications were found in a survey of studies in JSHD and JSHR over a recent decade. Based on the probabilities of Type I and Type II errors, there are likely to be approximately 50 to 250 false findings in this literature. Because many studies had relatively small sample sizes, replication would be helpful for extending the generalization of their results. These data underscore the urgency for more replications in the field.

Explore related subjects

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

J R Muma. 1993. The need for replication.. https://doi.org/10.1044/jshr.3605.927

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related citations

More education in paediatric audiology needed for child welfare clinic nurses and doctors.

Opinions on formal and further education in paediatric audiology were surveyed by interviewing nurses and doctors in 28 Finnish child welfare clinics. Over half of the nurses recalled that they had been taught hearing screening during their period of practical training. Regarding formal teaching in paediatric audiology, the majority of doctors referred to courses in either otolaryngology, paediatrics or both. None of the doctors and only three of the nurses had taken part in any updating courses dealing with paediatric audiology during the last three years, and it turned out that no such courses had been arranged in three of the five hospital districts. However, 17 out of the 27 doctors and 23 out of the 28 nurses expressed their interest in further education. The present amount of formal education in paediatric audiology was ascertained from all five Finnish medical faculties and the five nursing schools in the provinces of Oulu and Lapland. The university departments of otolaryngology carry the major responsibility for teaching in paediatric audiology, which includes one to two hours of lectures and none to four hours of tutorials, depending on the faculty concerned. The amount of audiometric training at nursing schools varies from none to five hours and that of lectures in otolaryngology from three to twenty hours. Better co-ordination between departments of otolaryngology, general practice and paediatrics is needed when arranging teaching in paediatric audiology for medical students. Trainee child welfare nurses seem to need more guided practice in audiometry, and there is an obvious need for increasing the amount of practice in audiological departments. Specialist clinics should plan and implement a programme for updating training in paediatric audiology, including evaluation of the programme.

Audiology