Evaluation of Oxford nanopore sequencing for antimicrobial resistance surveillance in Salmonella: comparison with phenotypic antimicrobial susceptibility in a large-scale study.

Abstract

UNLABELLED: Salmonella is a major zoonotic foodborne pathogen, and antimicrobial resistance (AMR) in Salmonella presents a significant public health challenge. Compared with conventional antimicrobial susceptibility testing (AST), whole-genome sequencing (WGS) provides a more rapid and comprehensive approach to AMR characterization, thereby informing antimicrobial selection and supporting public health surveillance. In this study, Oxford Nanopore Technology (ONT)-based WGS was performed on 1,490 Salmonella isolates collected through nationwide surveillance in Taiwan in 2025. Genotypic resistance inferred from WGS data was compared with phenotypic AST results to assess the performance of ONT-WGS. Overall, WGS-inferred resistance showed high concordance with phenotypic resistance for most antimicrobials. However, major genotype-phenotype discordance was observed, attributed to four categories: (i) breakpoint-dependent classification, (ii) reduced or absent phenotypic expression of resistance genes, (iii) minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC) modulation by ramAp, and (iv) absence of known AMR determinants. Notable discrepancies included tigecycline resistance without known genetic determinants, nalidixic acid resistance linked to ramAp-mediated MIC elevation, and a high prevalence of colistin resistance (35.7%) in S. Enteritidis, with most resistant isolates lacking identifiable AMR determinants. Additionally, a significant proportion of ESBL- and AmpC-producing isolates were classified as susceptible or intermediate to cefotaxime and ceftazidime under CLSI criteria, highlighting the potential for misclassification and treatment failure. These findings demonstrate that ONT-WGS enables accurate and comprehensive AMR characterization by directly identifying resistance determinants and avoiding potential misclassification associated with breakpoint-based AST interpretations. When interpreted appropriately, WGS can support better antimicrobial selection and serve as a valuable alternative to conventional susceptibility testing. IMPORTANCE: Accurate prediction of antimicrobial resistance is essential for appropriate therapy and effective surveillance of Salmonella. However, discordance between genotype-based predictions and phenotypic antimicrobial susceptibility testing (AST) can complicate clinical interpretation. In this nationwide study of 1,490 Salmonella isolates, we show that Oxford Nanopore Technology-based whole-genome sequencing (ONT-WGS) provides rapid and comprehensive detection of antimicrobial resistance determinants with high concordance to phenotypic AST. We further identify four major mechanisms underlying genotype-phenotype discordance, including breakpoint-dependent classification, reduced or absent phenotypic expression of resistance genes, minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC) modulation by ramAp, and the absence of known AMR determinants. These findings demonstrate how WGS can complement conventional AST, improve interpretation of challenging susceptibility results, and strengthen genomic surveillance of emerging antimicrobial-resistant Salmonella.