Strain-level differences in Gardnerella urinary tract persistence and pathogenesis are consistent with comparative phylogenomic analyses.

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Gardnerella is a genus of gram variable anaerobic bacteria that is commonly present in the female urogenital tract, especially during bacterial vaginosis (BV). BV is linked with increased risk of urinary tract infections (UTI) and Gardnerella has been frequently detected in urine collected directly from the bladder. Understanding the contribution of Gardnerella to urogenital pathogenesis has been complicated by its genetic heterogeneity and a shortage of data from in vivo models. Recently, a clinical isolate of Gardnerella displayed covert pathogenesis in a mouse urinary tract inoculation model, triggering urothelial exfoliation and promoting UTI by uropathogenic E. coli. Data from clinical studies suggests differential association of Gardnerella phylogenetic clades with BV or urogenital infections. In vitro data has demonstrated heterogeneity in the presence and expression of putative virulence determinants between Gardnerella strains. This study was designed to compare diverse Gardnerella strains in vivo to identify genomic variation associated with urinary tract persistence and pathogenesis. METHODS: Eighteen Gardnerella clinical isolates from each of the four main phylogenetic clades were individually inoculated transurethrally into female C57BL/6 mice. Bacteriuria was monitored by quantitative culturing of Gardnerella in urine. Pathologic features were assessed by immunofluorescent and histological staining of bladder tissues. Pan-genome phylogenetic analyses were performed on the 18 Gardnerella isolates used for mouse infections to identify accessory genes that were associated with observable in vivo phenotypes, including long and short-term persistence, urothelial exfoliation and bladder edema. Genes that were significantly associated to phenotype were then matched against a pangenome analysis of 291 publicly available Gardnerella genomes to determine the conservation of these putative colonization and virulence factors across the genus. RESULTS: Gardnerella strains displayed clear differences in persistence and pathogenesis in the mouse bladder that were congruent with phylogeny. Clade 2 strains were more persistent in the urinary tract whereas strains from the other three clades either caused transient bacteriuria or were undetectable. Strains from clade 2 and 4 induced urothelial exfoliation while edema was triggered by strains from clades 2, 3 and 4. Pangenome analyses revealed 45 genes that were associated with in vivo persistence and pathogenicity. Among the wider 291 publicly available genomes, clade 2 strains encoded more of the genes associated with bacteriuria phenotypes compared to strains in the other three clades. Exfoliation-associated genes were present in most clade 4 strains. Clade 3 strains lack most of the in vivo-associated genes, whereas clade 1 strains were more heterogenous. CONCLUSIONS: This study provides in vivo evidence for differential urinary tract colonization and pathogenesis by strains from different clades/species within the genus Gardnerella and identifies new putative persistence and virulence factors. Utilizing the in vivo data from tested strains, pangenome analyses predicts that clade 2 Gardnerella are the most likely to persist in the urinary tract and that clades 2 and 4 have the highest uropathogenic potential. These findings inform future targeted screening and treatment approaches aimed at limiting harmful Gardnerella urinary tract exposures.