Some models of neutral evolution, compensatory evolution, and the shifting balance process.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Animals↗
SEARCH · Search PubMed
Results for “Compensatory Evolution”
Search indexed PubMed citations on genomics, clinical trials, systematic reviews and public health. Explore titles, authors and supplied subject terms, then open the PubMed record.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Adaptation to the deleterious effects of antimicrobial drug resistance mutations by compensatory evolution.
Compensatory mutations, due to their ability to mask the deleterious effects of another mutation, are important for the adaptation and evolution of most organisms. Resistance to antibiotics, antivirals, antifungals, herbicides and insecticides is usually associated with a fitness cost. As a result of compensatory evolution, the initial fitness costs conferred by resistance mutations (or other deleterious mutations) can often be rapidly and efficiently reduced. Such compensatory evolution is potentially of importance for (i) the long-term persistence of drug resistance, (ii) reducing the rate of fitness loss associated with the accumulation of deleterious mutations in small asexual populations, and (iii) the evolution of complexity of cellular processes.
Amino Acid Sequence↗
The rate of compensatory evolution.
A two-locus model is presented to analyze the evolution of compensatory mutations occurring in stems of RNA secondary structures. Single mutations are assumed to be deleterious but harmless (neutral) in appropriate combinations. In proceeding under mutation pressure, natural selection and genetic drift from one fitness peak to another one, a population must therefore pass through a valley of intermediate deleterious states of individual fitness. The expected time for this transition is calculated using diffusion theory. The rate of compensatory evolution, kappa c, is then defined as the inverse of the expected transition time. When selection against deleterious single mutations is strong, kappa c becomes independent on the recombination fraction r between the two loci. Recombination generally reduces the rate of compensatory evolution because it breaks up favorable combinations of double mutants. For complete linkage, kappa c is given by the rate at which favorable combinations of double mutants are produced by compensatory mutation. For r > O, kappa c decreases exponentially with r. In contrast, kappa c becomes independent of r for weak selection. We discuss the dynamics of evolutionary substitutions of compensatory mutants in relation of WRIGHT's shifting balance theory of evolution and use our results to analyze the substitution process in helices of mRNA secondary structures.
Evolution, Molecular↗
Compensatory evolution of interacting gene products through multifunctional intermediates.
When two mutations are singly deleterious but neutral or beneficial together, compensatory evolution can occur. The accumulation of derived, compensated genotypes contributes to the evolution of genetic incompatibilities between diverging populations or species. Previous two locus/two allele models have shown that compensatory evolution is appreciable only with tight linkage, the possibility of nearly simultaneous mutations, and/or a way to overcome negative selection against the singly mutated genotype. These conditions are often not met. Even when they are met, compensatory evolution is still predicted to be extremely slow, and in many scenarios selective advantage of the compensated genotype does little to accelerate it. Despite these obstacles, empirical studies suggest that it occurs readily. We describe here a set of related two locus/three allele models that invoke plausible neutral intermediates capable of productive interaction with both ancestral and compensated products of the interacting locus. These models are explored with analytical and computer simulation methods. The effect of these stepping-stone alleles on the evolution of ancestor-descendant incompatibilities is often profound, making the difference between evolution and stasis in several situations, including in small populations, when codominance or haploidy prevents shielding of mismatched genotypes, and in the absence of positive selection on the derived genotype. However, in large populations these intermediates can either speed or slow the evolution of incompatible genotypes relative to the two-allele case, depending on the specific fitness model. These results suggest that population size, the source of adaptive benefit, and the structural details of heteromeric gene product complexes interact to influence the path by which intergenic incompatibility evolves.
Computer Simulation↗
Compensatory evolution to DNA replication stress is robust to nutrient availability.
Evolutionary repair refers to the compensatory evolution that follows perturbations in cellular processes. While evolutionary trajectories are often reproducible, other studies suggest they are shaped by genotype-by-environment (GxE) interactions. Here, we test the predictability of evolutionary repair in response to DNA replication stress-a severe perturbation impairing the conserved mechanisms of DNA synthesis, resulting in genetic instability. We conducted high-throughput experimental evolution on Saccharomyces cerevisiae experiencing constitutive replication stress, grown under different glucose availability. We found that glucose levels impact the physiology and adaptation rate of replication stress mutants. However, the genetics of adaptation show remarkable robustness across environments. Recurrent mutations collectively recapitulated the fitness of evolved lines and are advantageous across macronutrient availability. We also identified a novel role of the mediator complex of RNA polymerase II in adaptation to replicative stress. Our results highlight the robustness and predictability of evolutionary repair mechanisms to DNA replication stress and provide new insights into the evolutionary aspects of genome stability, with potential implications for understanding cancer development.
DNA Replication↗
Compensatory Evolution Following Deleterious Episodes of GC-biased Gene Conversion in Rodents.
GC-biased gene conversion (gBGC) is a widespread evolutionary force associated with meiotic recombination that favors the accumulation of deleterious AT to GC substitutions in proteins, moving them away from their fitness optimum. In many mammals, recombination hotspots have a rapid turnover, leading to episodic gBGC, with the accumulation of deleterious mutations stopping when the recombination hotspot dies. Selection is therefore expected to act to repair the damage caused by gBGC episodes through compensatory evolution. However, this process has never been studied or quantified so far. Here, we analyzed the nucleotide substitution pattern in coding sequences of a highly diversified group of Murinae rodents. Using phylogenetic analyses of about 70,000 coding exons, we identified numerous exon-specific, lineage-specific gBGC episodes, characterized by a clustering of synonymous AT to GC substitutions and by an increasing rate of nonsynonymous AT to GC substitutions, many of which are potentially deleterious. Analyzing the molecular evolution of the affected exons in downstream lineages, we found evidence for pervasive compensatory evolution after deleterious gBGC episodes. Compensation appears to occur rapidly after the end of the episode and to be driven by the standing genetic variation rather than new mutations. Our results demonstrate the impact of gBGC on the evolution of amino-acid sequences and underline the key role of epistasis in protein adaptation. This study contributes to a growing body of literature emphasizing that adaptive mutations, which arise in response to environmental changes, are just 1 subset of beneficial mutations, alongside mutations resulting from oscillations around the fitness optimum.
Gene Conversion↗
Disruption of mitonuclear coadaptation and compensatory evolution after an extreme dietary shift in carnivorous butterflies.
Mitochondrial function depends on tight coordination between mitochondrial and nuclear genomes, which requires long-term coevolution to maintain mitonuclear coadaptation. While mitonuclear incompatibility is typically studied in the context of hybridization, other evolutionary scenarios that may disrupt coadaptation between the two genomes remain less explored. Here, we propose that extreme ecological niche shifts may disrupt mitonuclear coadaptation, which we test in carnivorous Miletinae butterflies with an extreme dietary transition. By generating high-quality genome assemblies, we found that Miletinae exhibit extensive chromosomal rearrangements. Comparative phylogenomic analyses revealed a striking asymmetric mitonuclear evolutionary response: Miletinae exhibit elevated mitochondrial nucleotide substitution rates compared to phytophagous relatives, whereas nuclear rates remain stable. This shift reverses the typical lepidopteran pattern where nuclear rates exceed mitochondrial rates. Interestingly, this mitochondrial acceleration is driven primarily by relaxed purifying selection rather than positive selection. To sustain mitochondrial function, the nuclear genome of Miletinae underwent pervasive, multilayered compensatory evolution. We detected strong signatures of positive selection and accelerated evolution in nuclear genes directly interacting with mitochondrial components across oxidative phosphorylation (OXPHOS) complexes, the mitochondrial translation, and replication and transcription machinery. Furthermore, this nuclear compensatory response extends to systems governing mitochondrial homeostasis, including protein quality control and RNA degradation and stabilization. Our results support a model in which extreme ecological transitions can disrupt ancestral mitonuclear coadaptation and promote the emergence of a new coadapted state through systemic nuclear compensation. This study broadens the conceptual framework of mitonuclear coevolution and highlights its role in facilitating evolutionary persistence after major ecological shifts.
Animals↗
RNA secondary structure and compensatory evolution.
The classic concept of epistatic fitness interactions between genes has been extended to study interactions within gene regions, especially between nucleotides that are important in maintaining pre-mRNA/mRNA secondary structures. It is shown that the majority of linkage disequilibria found within the Drosophila Adh gene are likely to be caused by epistatic selection operating on RNA secondary structures. A recently proposed method of RNA secondary structure prediction based on DNA sequence comparisons is reviewed and applied to several types of RNAs, including tRNA, rRNA, and mRNA. The patterns of covariation in these RNAs are analyzed based on Kimura's compensatory evolution model. The results suggest that this model describes the substitution process in the pairing regions (helices) of RNA secondary structures well when the helices are evolutionarily conserved and thermodynamically stable, but fails in some other cases. Epistatic selection maintaining pre-mRNA/mRNA secondary structures is compared to weak selective forces that determine features such as base composition and synonymous codon usage. The relationships among these forces and their relative strengths are addressed. Finally, our mutagenesis experiments using the Drosophila Adh locus are reviewed. These experiments analyze long-range compensatory interactions between the 5' and 3' ends of Adh mRNA, the different constraints on secondary structures in introns and exons, and the possible role of secondary structures in RNA splicing.
Alcohol Dehydrogenase↗
Compensatory evolution in the human malaria parasite Plasmodium ovale.
The fixation of neutral compensatory mutations in a population depends on the effective population size of the species, which can fluctuate dramatically within a few generations, the mutation rate, and the selection intensity associated with the individual mutations. We observe compensatory mutations and intermediate states in populations of the malaria parasite Plasmodium ovale. The appearance of compensatory mutations and intermediate states in P. ovale raises interesting questions about population structure that could have considerable impact on the control of the associated disease.
Animals↗
Compensatory evolution reveals functional interactions between ribosomal proteins S12, L14 and L19.
Certain mutations in S12, a ribosomal protein involved in translation elongation rate and translation accuracy, confer resistance to the aminoglycoside streptomycin. Previously we showed in Salmonella typhimurium that the fitness cost, i.e. reduced growth rate, due to the amino acid substitution K42N in S12 could be compensated by at least 35 different mutations located in the ribosomal proteins S4, S5 and L19. Here, we have characterized in vivo the fitness, translation speed and translation accuracy of four different L19 mutants. When separated from the resistance mutation located in S12, the three different compensatory amino acid substitutions in L19 at position 40 (Q40H, Q40L and Q40R) caused a decrease in fitness while the G104A change had no effect on bacterial growth. The rate of protein synthesis was unaffected or increased by the mutations at position 40 and the level of read-through of a UGA nonsense codon was increased in vivo, indicating a loss of translational accuracy. The mutations in L19 increased sensitivity to aminoglycosides active at the A-site, further indicating a perturbation of the decoding step. These phenotypes are similar to those of the classical S4 and S5 ram (ribosomal ambiguity) mutants. By evolving low-fitness L19 mutants by serial passage, we showed that the fitness cost conferred by the L19 mutations could be compensated by additional mutations in the ribosomal protein L19 itself, in S12 and in L14, a protein located close to L19. Our results reveal a novel functional role for the 50 S ribosomal protein L19 during protein synthesis, supporting published structural data suggesting that the interaction of L14 and L19 with 16 S rRNA could influence function of the 30 S subunit. Moreover, our study demonstrates how compensatory fitness-evolution can be used to discover new molecular functions of ribosomal proteins.
Amino Acid Substitution↗
Mechanisms and convergence of compensatory evolution in mammalian mitochondrial tRNAs.
The function of protein and RNA molecules depends on complex epistatic interactions between sites. Therefore, the deleterious effect of a mutation can be suppressed by a compensatory second-site substitution. In relating a list of 86 pathogenic mutations in human tRNAs encoded by mitochondrial genes to the sequences of their mammalian orthologs, we noted that 52 pathogenic mutations were present in normal tRNAs of one or several nonhuman mammals. We found at least five mechanisms of compensation for 32 pathogenic mutations that destroyed a Watson-Crick pair in one of the four tRNA stems: restoration of the affected Watson-Crick interaction (25 cases), strengthening of another pair (4 cases), creation of a new pair (8 cases), changes of multiple interactions in the affected stem (11 cases) and changes involving the interaction between the loop and stem structures (3 cases). A pathogenic mutation and its compensating substitution are fixed in a lineage in rapid succession, and often a compensatory interaction evolves convergently in different clades. At least 10%, and perhaps as many as 50%, of all nucleotide substitutions in evolving mammalian tRNAs participate in such interactions, indicating that the evolution of tRNAs proceeds along highly epistatic fitness ridges.
Animals↗
Biological cost and compensatory evolution in fusidic acid-resistant Staphylococcus aureus.
Fusidic acid resistance resulting from mutations in elongation factor G (EF-G) of Staphylococcus aureus is associated with fitness costs during growth in vivo and in vitro. In both environments, these costs can be partly or fully compensated by the acquisition of secondary intragenic mutations. Among clinical isolates of S. aureus, fusidic acid-resistant strains have been identified that carry multiple mutations in EF-G at positions similar to those shown experimentally to cause resistance and fitness compensation. This observation suggests that fitness-compensatory mutations may be an important aspect of the evolution of antibiotic resistance in the clinical environment, and may contribute to a stabilization of the resistant bacteria present in a bacterial population.
Amino Acid Sequence↗
Compensatory evolution in rifampin-resistant Escherichia coli.
This study examines the intrinsic fitness burden associated with RNA polymerase (rpoB) mutations conferring rifampin resistance in Escherichia coli K12 (MG1655) and explores the nature of adaptation to the costs of resistance. Among 28 independent Rif(r) mutants, the per-generation fitness burden (in the absence of rifampin) ranged from 0 to 28%, with a median of 6.4%. We detected no relationship between the magnitude of the cost and the level of resistance. Adaptation to the costs of rif resistance was studied by following serial transfer cultures for several Rif(r) mutants both in the presence of rifampin and in the absence. For cultures evolved in the absence of rifampin, single clones isolated after 200 generations were more fit than their ancestor; we saw no association between increased fitness and changes in the level of rifampin resistance; and in all cases, increased fitness was due to compensatory mutations, rather than to reversion to drug sensitivity. However, in the parallel evolution experiments in the presence of rifampin, overall levels of resistance increased as did relative fitness-for all strains save one that had an initially high level of resistance. Among the evolved clones tested, five (of seven) demonstrated increased transcription efficiency (assessed using a semiquantitative RT-PCR protocol). The implications of these results for our understanding of adaptive molecular evolution and the increasing clinical problem of antibiotic resistance are discussed.
Amino Acid Sequence↗
Analyses on mutation patterns, detection of population bottlenecks, and suggestion of deleterious-compensatory evolution among members of the genus Potyvirus.
Viruses of the family Potyviridae exhibited a robust single-nucleotide polymorphism profile at the between-species level, conforming to the neutral theory rule. However, the ratios of nonsynonymous to synonymous mutations (Ka/Ks) were relatively greater between-species than within-species in viral cistrons examined from members of the genus Potyvirus, indicating a relaxation on constraint. Judged by the McDonald and Kreitman's test, the fixation frequencies for nonsynonymous mutations across the genomes of closely related potyviruses were greater than expected, suggesting population bottlenecks at speciation. These mutation patterns are best explained by a deleterious-compensatory model.
Animals↗
Compensatory evolution of a precursor messenger RNA secondary structure in the Drosophila melanogaster Adh gene.
Evidence for the evolutionary maintenance of a hairpin structure possibly involved in intron processing had been found in intron 1 of the alcohol dehydrogenase gene (Adh) in diverse Drosophila species. In this study, the putative hairpin structure was evaluated systematically in Drosophila melanogaster by elimination of either side of the stem using site-directed mutagenesis. The effects of these mutations and the compensatory double mutant on intron splicing efficiency and ADH protein production were assayed in Drosophila melanogaster Schneider L2 cells and germ-line transformed adult flies. Mutations that disrupt the putative hairpin structure right upstream of the intron branch point were found to cause a significant reduction in both splicing efficiency and ADH protein production. In contrast, the compensatory double mutant that restores the putative hairpin structure was indistinguishable from the WT in both splicing efficiency and ADH level. It was also observed by mutational analysis that a more stable secondary structure (with a longer stem) in this intron decreases both splicing efficiency and ADH protein production. Implications for RNA secondary structure and intron evolution are discussed.
Alcohol Dehydrogenase↗
Compensatory evolution in response to a novel RNA polymerase: orthologous replacement of a central network gene.
A bacteriophage genome was forced to evolve a new system of regulation by replacing its RNA polymerase (RNAP) gene, a central component of the phage developmental pathway, with that of a relative. The experiment used the obligate lytic phage T7 and the RNAP gene of phage T3. T7 RNAP uses 17 phage promoters, which are responsible for all middle and late gene expression, DNA replication, and progeny maturation, but the enzyme has known physical contacts with only 2 other phage proteins. T3 RNAP was supplied in trans by the bacterial host to a T7 genome lacking its own RNAP gene and the phage population was continually propagated on naive bacteria throughout the adaptation. Evolution of the T3 RNAP gene was thereby prevented, and selection was for the evolution of regulatory signals throughout the phage genome. T3 RNAP transcribes from T7 promoters only at low levels, but a single mutation in the promoter confers high expression, providing a ready mechanism for reevolution of gene expression in this system. When selected for rapid growth, fitness of the engineered phage evolved from a low of 5 doublings/h to 33 doublings/h, close to the expected maximum of 37 doublings/h. However, the experiment was terminated before it could be determined accurately that fitness had reached an obvious plateau, and it is not known whether further adaptation could have resulted in complete recovery of fitness. More than 30 mutations were observed in the evolved genome, but changes were found in only 9 of the 16 promoters, and several coding changes occurred in genes with no known contacts with the RNAP. Surprisingly, the T7 genome adapted to T3 RNAP also maintained high fitness when using T7 RNAP, suggesting that the extreme incompatibility of T7 elements with T3 RNAP is not an invariant property of divergence in these expression systems.
Bacteriophage T3↗
Sex, mutation and fitness: asymmetric costs and routes to recovery through compensatory evolution.
A wild-type population of Drosophila melanogaster was used to assess the impact of a known deleterious mutation, nub(1), when it had (1) evolved for up to 180 generations with the mutation or (2) recently had the same mutant allele introgressed into it. Relative to this benchmark, we observed much stronger initial fitness depression in males (-74%) than in females (-38%) and also relatively greater fitness recovery by evolved males (+55%) than females (+17%). Experimental assays revealed amelioration in both juvenile and adult fitness and suggested that the greater relative recovery of male fitness was from gains through sexual selection. These evolutionary changes in male fertility depended on pairing with their coevolved mates for both mate choice and post-copulatory components of sexual selection. Without replication at the population level, these results are used to motivate a general hypothesis rather than definitively test it: Differences in reproductive optima may generally skew mutational effects towards the more strongly sexually-selected sex due to genic capture and condition dependence.
Analysis of Variance↗
Comparative sequence analysis and patterns of covariation in RNA secondary structures.
A novel method of RNA secondary structure prediction based on a comparison of nucleotide sequences is described. This method correctly predicts nearly all evolutionarily conserved secondary structures of five different RNAs: tRNA, 5S rRNA, bacterial ribonuclease P (RNase P) RNA, eukaryotic small subunit rRNA, and the 3' untranslated region (UTR) of the Drosophila bicoid (bcd) mRNA. Furthermore, covariations occurring in the helices of these conserved RNA structures are analyzed. Two physical parameters are found to be important determinants of the evolution of compensatory mutations: the length of a helix and the distance between base-pairing nucleotides. For the helices of bcd 3' UTR mRNA and RNase P RNA, a positive correlation between the rate of compensatory evolution and helix length is found. The analysis of Drosophila bcd 3' UTR mRNA further revealed that the rate of compensatory evolution decreases with the physical distance between base-pairing residues. This result is in qualitative agreement with Kimura's model of compensatory fitness interactions, which assumes that mutations occurring in RNA helices are individually deleterious but become neutral in appropriate combinations.
Analysis of Variance↗