Search PubMed⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search PubMed

Results for “Uncertainty”

Search indexed PubMed citations on genomics, clinical trials, systematic reviews and public health. Explore titles, authors and supplied subject terms, then open the PubMed record.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 1,495 records · Page 83Linked to original sources

Working memory, metacognitive uncertainty, and belief bias in syllogistic reasoning.

Studies of syllogistic reasoning have shown that the size of the belief bias effect varies with manipulations of logical validity and problem form. This paper presents a mental models-based account, which explains these findings in terms of variations in the working-memory demands of different problem types. We propose that belief bias may reflect the use of a heuristic that is applied when a threshold of uncertainty in one's processing--attributable to working-memory overload--is exceeded during reasoning. Three experiments are reported, which tested predictions deriving from this account. In Experiment 1, conclusions of neutral believability were presented for evaluation, and a predicted dissociation was observed in confidence ratings for responses to valid and invalid arguments, with participants being more confident in the former. In Experiment 2, an attempt to manipulate working-memory loads indirectly by varying syllogistic figure failed to produce predicted effects upon the size of the belief bias effect. It is argued that the employment of a conclusion evaluation methodology minimized the effect of the figural manipulation in this experiment. In Experiment 3, participants' articulatory and spatial recall capacities were calibrated as a direct test of working-memory involvement in belief bias. Predicted differences in the pattern of belief bias observed between high and low spatial recall groups supported the view that limited working memory plays a key role in belief bias.

Concept Formation↗

Reproductive uncertainty and the relative competitiveness of simultaneous hermaphroditism versus dioecy.

Hermaphroditism is typically associated with a sedentary existence, whereas dioecy is associated with mobility. This pattern is reflected within flowering plants, as dioecious species commonly possess traits that promote high dispersal. We investigated these associations with three population dynamics models (an individual-based simulation and two mathematical models, one deterministic and the other stochastic) that allowed us to examine competition for space between a hermaphroditic and dioecious species from different perspectives. The competing species are identical in every way but their sexual system. Separation of the sexes increases the variances of pollen import and seed dispersal for the dioecious species. These variances propagate through subsequent reproductive processes and ultimately reduce mean recruitment as a result of nonlinear averaging (Jensen's inequality). A dioecious species could overcome this disadvantage simply by producing more gametes than hermaphrodites; however, in line with the association with mobility, selection on dioecious species should also favor traits that reduce reproductive uncertainty, such as extensive dispersal.

Biological Evolution↗

A new fast algorithm for the evaluation of regions of interest and statistical uncertainty in computed tomography.

A new algorithm for region of interest evaluation in computed tomography has been developed. Region of interest evaluation is a technique used to improve quantitation of the tomographic imaging process by summing (or averaging) the reconstructed quantity throughout a volume of particular significance. An important application of this procedure arises in the analysis of dynamic emission computed tomographic data, in which the uptake and clearance of radiotracers are used to determine the blood flow and/or physiologic function of tissue within the significant volume. The new algorithm replaces the conventional technique of repeated image reconstructions with one in which projected regions are convolved and then used to form multiple vector inner products with the raw tomographic data sets. Quantitation of regions of interest is made without the need for reconstruction of tomographic images. The computational advantage of the new algorithm over conventional methods is between a factor of 20 and a factor of 500 for typical applications encountered in medical science studies. The greatest benefit of the new algorithm (and the motivation for its development) is the ease with which the statistical uncertainty of the result is computed. The entire covariance matrix for the evaluation of regions of interest can be calculated with relatively few operations.

Computers↗

Stochastic optimization of intensity modulated radiotherapy to account for uncertainties in patient sensitivity.

The aim of the present work is to better account for the known uncertainties in radiobiological response parameters when optimizing radiation therapy. The radiation sensitivity of a specific patient is usually unknown beyond the expectation value and possibly the standard deviation that may be derived from studies on groups of patients. Instead of trying to find the treatment with the highest possible probability of a desirable outcome for a patient of average sensitivity, it is more desirable to maximize the expectation value of the probability for the desirable outcome over the possible range of variation of the radiation sensitivity of the patient. Such a stochastic optimization will also have to consider the distribution function of the radiation sensitivity and the larger steepness of the response for the individual patient. The results of stochastic optimization are also compared with simpler methods such as using biological response 'margins' to account for the range of sensitivity variation. By using stochastic optimization, the absolute gain will typically be of the order of a few per cent and the relative improvement compared with non-stochastic optimization is generally less than about 10 per cent. The extent of this gain varies with the level of interpatient variability as well as with the difficulty and complexity of the case studied. Although the dose changes are rather small (<5 Gy) there is a strong desire to make treatment plans more robust, and tolerant of the likely range of variation of the radiation sensitivity of each individual patient. When more accurate predictive assays of the radiation sensitivity for each patient become available, the need to consider the range of variations can be reduced considerably.

Dose-Response Relationship, Radiation↗

Uncertainty, low-dose extrapolation and the threshold hypothesis.

Risk-based radiation protection policy is influenced by estimated risk and by the uncertainty of that estimate. Thus, if the upper limit, at (say) 95% probability, of risk associated with a given radiation dose is at an 'acceptable' level, it is unlikely (or not credible) that the true level of risk associated with the dose is at an unacceptable level. Central estimates presented alone, in the absence of probability limits, lack this safety factor. Estimating cancer risks from low doses of ionising radiation involves extrapolation of risk estimates based on high-dose data to the much lower dose levels that characterize the vast majority of exposures of regulatory concern. Proof of a universal low-dose threshold, below which there is no radiation-related risk, would revolutionise radiation protection. Available data fail to provide such proof and, in fact, leave considerable room for the possibility that DNA damage from a single photon can contribute to the carcinogenic process. Allowing for the possibility of a threshold would, however, remove very little of the regulatory burden associated with the so-called linear, no-threshold hypothesis, unless that possibility were a virtual certainty.

Humans↗

Uncertainty in estimating probability of causation in a cross-sectional study: joint effects of radiation and hepatitis-C virus on chronic liver disease.

Exposure to other risk factors is an important consideration in assessing the role played by radiation in producing disease. A cross-sectional study of atomic-bomb survivors suggested an interaction between whole-body radiation exposure and chronic hepatitis-C viral (HCV) infection in the etiology of chronic liver disease (chronic hepatitis and cirrhosis), but did not allow determination of the joint-effect mechanism. Different estimates of probability of causation (POC) conditional on HCV status resulted from additive and multiplicative models. We therefore estimated the risk for radiation conditional on HCV status using a more general, mixture model that does not require choosing between additivity or multiplicativity, or deciding whether there is interaction, in the face of the large uncertainty. The results support the conclusion that POC increases with radiation dose in persons without HCV infection, but are inconclusive regarding individuals with HCV infection, the lower confidence bound on estimated POC for radiation with HCV infection being zero over the entire dose range. Although the mixture model may not reflect the true joint-effect mechanism, it avoids restrictive model assumptions that cannot be validated using the available data yet have a profound influence on estimated POC. These considerations apply more generally, given that the additive and multiplicative models are often used in POC related work. We therefore consider that an empirical approach may be preferable to assuming a specific mechanistic model for estimating POC in epidemiological studies where the joint-effect mechanism is in doubt.

Cross-Sectional Studies↗

Analysis of uncertainty in theoretical methods of cardiac output measurement using the "Monte Carlo" technique.

We have developed three models which describe the relationship between cardiac output and the uptake of volatile anaesthetic agents, based on the Fick equation, and determined if these models could provide useful methods of cardiac output measurement. Because many variables are involved in the calculation of cardiac output using these methods, a "Monte Carlo" simulation was performed to investigate the combined effect of uncertainties in several variables on the resultant cardiac output estimate. We found that the single-breath model was most accurate when the inspired concentration was large, while the rebreathing model was better with smaller inspired concentrations. The three-breath model was the least accurate under all conditions studied. Volatile anaesthetics were generally more accurate than nitrous oxide, with both enflurane and halothane more accurate than isoflurane. The "Monte Carlo" technique provides a valuable tool for analysis of errors in measurement methods.

Anesthetics↗

Surrogate markers in AIDS clinical trials: conceptual basis, validation, and uncertainties.

The identification of surrogate markers for clinical end points has important implications for the conduct of AIDS clinical trials, the approval of drugs for the treatment of infection with human immunodeficiency virus (HIV), and the management of HIV infection. In this paper, the concept of a surrogate marker and the properties of an ideal marker are discussed. The steps required for the empirical verification of a potential marker are then addressed, and current information on surrogate markers for AIDS is reviewed. Studies conducted to date indicate that the effects of a new drug on numbers of CD4 lymphocytes account only partly for its ultimate impact on the clinical progression of HIV infection. Consequently, the potential benefits of early approval of a drug based on its effect on CD4 lymphocytes must be weighed against the uncertainty about its ability to actually delay clinical progression.

Acquired Immunodeficiency Syndrome↗

Age-related differences in response preparation: the role of time uncertainty.

This study explored the ability of younger and older participants to use a variable preparatory interval (PI) to enhance reaction time (RT) performance. In Experiment 1, 30 seniors and 15 young adults completed simple and choice RT tasks with short and long variable PIs. RT decreased with increasing PI duration in both younger and older adults, but the PI effect was larger in elderly individuals. The results of Experiment 2 (20 seniors and 20 young adults) showed an equivalent preparatory effect in older and younger adults when the probability of the shortest PI was increased. These findings suggest that older adults do not prepare as well as younger adults for unlikely events and that time uncertainty affects age-related differences in response preparation.

Adult↗

Uncertainty in the diagnosis of histologically confirmed pancreatic cancer cases.

In doing a case-control study of cancer of the exocrine pancreas, a set of criteria was developed to classify cancer of the exocrine pancreas by pathological and diagnostic data as to the probability that the tumor arose in the pancreas. We applied these criteria to the records of 125 consecutive patients between the ages of 40-79 years who were identified as having adenocarcinomas of the exocrine pancreas from a population-based cancer registry. We found that histological confirmation by a cancer registry does not guarantee the site of origin is the pancreas. Of the histologically confirmed cases meeting our study criteria, 28.7% may not have arisen in the pancreas. Forty-seven per cent of non-histologically confirmed cases, which most studies exclude, were almost certainly of pancreatic origin based on computerized tomogram (CT) scan and/or surgical palpation and subsequent clinical course. These figures may underestimate the full extent of diagnostic misclassification, especially in older age groups. We conclude that epidemiological studies of cancer of the exocrine pancreas need more uniform criteria for defining cases, and these criteria should take into account uncertainty as to site of origin. Sufficient detail of our scheme is presented so it can be applied in other studies.

Adult↗

Predicting coronary heart disease mortality--assessing uncertainties in population forecasts and death probabilities by using Bayesian inference.

BACKGROUND: Predictions concerning people and their health are influenced by many factors and have many sources of uncertainty. Even so predictions can give useful guidelines for health care planning. We present a Bayesian model based on past observations and prior knowledge to predict coronary heart disease (CHD) mortality in selected areas of Finland until the year 2030. METHODS: CHD mortality data are based on official statistics. The study area consists of one western and two eastern parts of Finland. The modelling of the probability of death follows a Bayesian age-period-cohort model. Two models are used, one assuming that the trend from 1970 to 2002 will continue and the other that mortality will stay at the attained level. RESULTS: If the observed trend in CHD mortality were to continue, death probabilities would decrease significantly among men aged 50-69 and women aged 50-59. In the older age groups (men aged 70 and women 60 years or more) the changes were found to be negligible. If the trend continues, the number of CHD deaths will decrease from 2002 to 2030 significantly among men [81% decrease; 95% credible interval (95% CI) 54-96%] and women (90%; 67-100%) aged 50-59. In the age group 60-79 the changes will be smaller and non-significant. In the oldest age group (80-99 years) the predicted increase in the number of deaths will be great, from 284 to 1297 (95% CI 474-2620) in men and from 722 to 1970 (717-4017) in women. CONCLUSIONS: Our predictions emphasize the significance of maintaining the recent decline of CHD mortality among middle-aged adults. Special attention should be paid to CHD mortality among men and women aged 80 and over. Considerable improvements in prevention and treatment are needed to compensate for the effects of ageing of the population.

Age Factors↗

Biological exposure and/or effect limits, facts, fallacies and uncertainties: general principles.

When looking for facts, fallacies and uncertainties of the use of biological exposure limits one has at first to discuss the general principles of biological monitoring (BM) and biological effect monitoring (BEM) because they determine the validity of the data that underpin the biological exposure limits. A difference between countries in preferred BM-methods can be observed. The terminology is still confusing: in addition to BM and BEM, biomonitoring and biological markers also are used. There are a number of problems in respect of the inter- and intra-individual variability in internal exposure and effect at similar exposure levels due to differences in for example, physical workload, body composition and genetics. Toxicokinetic models based on data from individual workers should be developed in order to get information on the variability and the cause of this. Both kinetics and dynamics may be sex-dependent. To date, BM methods have been tentatively suggested for only about 10 per cent of the regulated industrial chemicals. BM and BEM programmes yield important extra information on exposure and health risk, not to be gained by environmental monitoring alone.

Environmental Monitoring↗

Effect of uncertainty in transfer rates for the ICPR publication 67 biokinetic model on dose estimation for 239Pu from results of individual monitoring. International Commission on Radiological Protection.

The radiation dose due to internal exposures from 239Pu is mainly estimated by measuring actual urinary or faecal excretion of activity and comparing those values with the standard excretion rates calculated from the models of the International Commission on Radiological Protection (ICRP). Recently, on the other hand, uncertainties in the ICRP's models and parameters are under consideration because of the paucity of human data. In addition, there is a possibility of variation between individuals. A code has been developed to reproduce the ICRP's dose coefficients and excretion rates for 239Pu, which is one of the most important elements for occupational exposure. By using this code, the respective transfer rates for the ICRP Publication 67 biokinetic model were modified, and the effect owing to these changes on present hazard assessment was investigated. As a result, it was shown that dose estimates for workers exposed to 239Pu were not very sensitive to changes in these transfer rates.

Evaluation Studies as Topic↗

In vivo measurement of Pu dissolution parameters of MOX aerosols and related uncertainties in the values of the dose per unit intake.

The aim of this study was to compare dissolution parameter values for Pu from industrial MOX with different Pu contents. For this purpose, preliminary results obtained after inhalation exposure of rats to MOX containing 2.5% Pu are reported and compared to those obtained previously with MOX containing 5% Pu. Dissolution parameter values appear to increase when the amount of Pu decreases. Rapid fractions, f(r), of 4 x 10(-3) (s.d. = 2 x 10(-3)) and 1 x 10(-3) (s.d. = 6 x 10(-4)) and slow dissolution rates, s(s) of 2 x 10(-4) d(-1) (standard deviation, sigma = 5 x 10(-5)) and 5 x 10(-5) d(-1) (sigma = 1 x 10(-5)) were derived for MOX containing 2.5 and 5% of Pu, respectively. Simulations were performed to assess uncertainties on dose due to experimental errors. The relative standard deviations of the dose per unit intake (DPUI) due to f(r) (4-8%), are far less than those due to s(s) (about 20%), which is the main parameter altering the dose. Although quite different dissolution parameter values were derived, similar DPUIs were obtained for MOX aerosols containing 2.5 and 5% Pu which appear close to that for default Type S values.

Absorption↗

Uncertainty analysis of the urinary excretion of plutonium.

A quantitative estimate of the uncertainty of the urinary excretion of plutonium predicted by available biokinetic models is provided. Urinary excretion is primarily considered here because the monitoring of internal contamination of plutonium mainly relies on measurements of activity in urine samples. A previous paper has identified the most significant transfer rates for urinary plutonium excretion following an acute intake. That analysis is used here as a screening method to reduce the number of model parameters to be considered. A log-normal distribution was assumed for the probability distribution of the model parameters. The spread of the values, represented by the geometric standard deviation (GSD), is explicitly calculated, as few indications of the range of variation of systemic transfer rates are available. Different values for the GSD were considered. Assuming a certain GSD for all the systemic rate constants, random values of the rates were generated (by means of a Monte Carlo simulation with a Latin hypercube sampling scheme) and the resulting predictions of urine bioassay measurements were calculated. The comparison of the mean and variance of the predictions with the available data from several studies performed on different subjects provides information about the GSD of model parameters that represents the intersubject variation of transfer parameters.

Animals↗

Presenting statistical uncertainty on cytogenetic dose estimates.

Cytogenetic dosimetry results are customarily accompanied by 95% confidence limits and the derivation of these limits is discussed. Simply presenting values of the best estimate of dose and 95% limits assumes that recipients of dosimetry reports, possibly the patients themselves, have a sufficient grasp of statistics to comprehend the concept of uncertainty. Two further methods have been developed to aid improved understanding for the lay person. The first method, particularly useful for suspected low doses, presents a simple odds ratio indicating that the results favour either zero dose or that suspected; for example, from an unexpected dose recorded on a badge. The second method, described fully here for the first time, uses a graphical illustration of a normalised distribution of dose so that one may visualise the area beneath a curve that represents the probability that the dose lies within various bounds.

Cytogenetic Analysis↗

Bayesian synthesis for quantifying uncertainty in predictions from process models.

The Bayesian synthesis method is reviewed and judged to be useful for determining posterior distributions and interval estimates for inputs and outputs of process-based forest models. The method furnishes posterior distributions of the values of a model's parameters and response variables. The method also provides estimates of correlation among the parameters and output variables. Bayesian synthesis is the only type of uncertainty analysis that affords incorporation of all the information available to the investigator, in addition to the information contained in the model itself.

Journal Article↗