Search PubMed⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search PubMed

Results for “Uncertainty”

Search indexed PubMed citations on genomics, clinical trials, systematic reviews and public health. Explore titles, authors and supplied subject terms, then open the PubMed record.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 1,441 records · Page 80Linked to original sources

Managing and treating risk and uncertainty for health: a case study of diabetes among First Nation's people in Ontario, Canada.

'Risk' has become a key concept for understanding health care policies that are focused on prevention. Intervention no longer depends on the presence of an illness but rather an individual's risk of developing an illness. Through 'risk factors' individuals are subject to medical examination and surveillance to determine the real presence of danger, based on this abstract notion of risk. This paper explores 'risk' and its consequences for medical intervention by focusing on biomedical practices surrounding diabetes care among First Nations on Manitoulin Island, Ontario. The first section explores the process of diagnosing diabetes. The second section outlines the treatment regimens resulting from membership in this category. The theme linking these two processes is that both diagnosis and management of diabetes depend on inclusion into categories of 'risk'. Practices surrounding diagnosis focus on a population described 'at risk' for diabetes. First Nation's people. Similarly, practices surrounding management of diabetes focus on a population 'at risk' for secondary complications, referring to individuals with diabetes. As the following discussion outlines, it is through the quantitative assessment of risk that scientific uncertainty is translated into definitive therapy and the need for constant surveillance.

Case-Control Studies↗

Uncertainty factors for chemical risk assessment: interspecies differences in glucuronidation.

For the risk assessment of effects other than cancer, a safe daily intake in humans is generally derived from a surrogate threshold dose (e.g. NOAEL) in an animal species to which an uncertainty factor of 100 is usually applied. This 100-fold is to allow for possible interspecies (10-fold) and interindividual (10-fold) differences in response to a toxicant, and incorporates toxicodynamic and toxicokinetic aspects of variability. The current study determined the magnitude of the interspecies differences in the internal dose of compounds for which glucuronidation is the major pathway of metabolism in either humans or in the test species. The results showed that there are major interspecies differences in the nature of the biological processes which influence the internal dose, including the route of metabolism, the extent of presystemic metabolism and enterohepatic recirculation. The work presented does not support the refinement of the interspecies toxicokinetic default to species- and pathway-specific values, but demonstrates the necessity for risk assessments to be carried out using quantitative chemical-specific data which define the fundamental processes which will influence the internal dose of a chemical (toxicokinetics), or the interaction of toxicant with its target site (toxicodynamics).

Animals↗

Maternity hospitals ranking on prophylactic caesarean section rates: uncertainty associated with ranks.

OBJECTIVE: Ranking maternity hospitals on prophylactic caesarean section rates. STUDY DESIGN: The study population was a sample of 8470 women having delivered in the 86 maternity hospitals of the Rhône-Alpes region (France) in 1990. A two-level logistic model and the Gibbs sampling method were used to estimate the adjusted rate and rank of each maternity hospital with their 95% credible interval. RESULTS: Ranking of maternity hospitals was substantially modified after adjusting for differences in case-mix. The 95% credible intervals of the ranks were generally wide and overlapping. No maternity hospital could be confidently placed in the upper quarter nor in the lower quarter of the league table. CONCLUSION: The use of ranks based on rates to compare hospitals may be seriously misleading; thus, league tables need an accompanying reading guide. Furthermore, some rules should be respected, including the need to make accurate case-mix adjustments, to reduce the rate instability in smaller hospitals, and to highlight the uncertainty associated with ranks.

Cesarean Section↗

Limits of uncertainty in measured values of embolus-to-blood ratio due to Doppler sample volume shape and location.

Measurements of the relative Doppler power scattered by an embolus and the surrounding blood are widely used to infer the composition of the embolus. For a given embolus, measured embolus-to-blood ratio (MEBR) is affected by the Doppler sample volume shape, the geometrical relationship between the sample volume and the vessel, and the embolus trajectory through the blood vessel. The likely magnitudes of such effects were quantified using a model that allowed calculation of theoretical values of MEBR as a function of the geometrical relationship between a blood vessel and a defined sample volume. Overall, the effects of embolus trajectory, likely insonation angles, and plausible vessel misalignments introduced uncertainties in MEBR values of approximately 10 to 12 dB for a given vessel size. In practice, the only operator-controlled factors are the position and orientation of the transcranial Doppler probe on the patients' heads. Probe positioning can significantly affect MEBR and suboptimal positioning may result in the reduced detection of emboli.

Embolism↗

Temporal uncertainty in reading the neural code (proportional noise).

It is widely accepted that neural information is encoded in the timing of action potentials. However, such information can only be transmitted if the receiver (soma, muscle fibre) can measure time precisely. We argue that such timing is inevitably imprecise due to biological fluctuations in receiver function. We show that this leads to a receiver output, where the standard deviation of receiver output noise is proportional to the mean level of the receiver output. Proportional noise is fundamentally distinct from the common assumption of square-root relationship seen in renewal processes (e.g. Poisson noise), which is usually assumed in neural firing patterns. We show that proportional noise may be the limiting constraint in receiver function, and that it could account for such diverse perceptual and motor behaviours encompassed by Weber's and Fitt's laws, as well as the dynamic trajectories of rapid feed-forward motor behaviours such as arm reaching and saccades. We conclude that temporal uncertainty should be potentially a fundamental stochastic constraint on network function and behaviour.

Action Potentials↗

Democracy and the governance of uncertainty. The case of agricultural gene technologies.

The use of genetically modified organisms (GMOs) in agriculture and food production is the object of an intense and divisive debate. Drawing on a study on the public perception of agricultural gene technologies carried out in five European countries, the article deals with the policy aspects of the issue, and more precisely on the relation between institutions, experts and the public in a context of deep uncertainty. A theoretical framework is developed and compared with the study findings, suggesting that issues like the GMOs one represent a strong case for a more participatory policy-making. My conclusions suggest a style of governance based on the principles of deliberative democracy, as a suitable approach to the confrontation of different viewpoints and forms of knowledge. This appears to be the best way to improve the overall quality of policy-making: in this I include its legitimacy, the degree of public trust, and also the actual quality of its products. Strengthening the role of the public sphere seems more effective than simply increasing direct decision-making by the populace, and it offers an alternative to the 'elitist' solutions to the crisis of representative democracy.

Agriculture↗

Toxic fear: the management of uncertainty in the wake of the Amsterdam air crash.

This paper examines the management of uncertainty among emergency responders, the media, and the public following the crash of an Israeli cargo plane carrying apparently hazardous cargo in Amsterdam's Bijlmermeer area. While the authorities' management of the emergency created by the initial crash was effective, the long-term crisis management performance was considerably less effective. It is argued that, particularly in hazardous materials emergencies, considerable management attention is required in the long-term aftermath rather than seeking a quick declaration of "all clear" or determination that the crisis is over. This paper examines the roles of all actors in the crisis and addresses the nature of communications in the "disaster after the disaster". The evolution of a "toxic fear" among citizens is documented and the social psychology of crisis management in the aftermath is examined.

Accidents, Aviation↗

Use of the most likely failure point method for risk estimation and risk uncertainty analysis.

The most likely failure point (MLFP) method, developed within the field of structural reliability analysis (where it is known as the FORM/SORM method) is a technique for estimating the risk (probability) that a calculated quantity Q exceeds a set limit Q(lim) when some or all of the inputs to the calculation are uncertain. It can be used as an efficient stand-alone method for this type of risk calculation. However, for application within the field of toxic hazards, it is proposed as a means for performing sensitivity analyses, possibly in parallel with a risk calculation carried out by conventional methods. The basis of the method is outlined and its use is demonstrated by means of an example calculation of the risk arising from an installation containing chlorine. The calculation uses, as a consequence model, commercial software for the prediction of dense gas transport. The risk estimate is shown to be acceptably close to that obtained by the Monte Carlo method. The use of a proposed screening procedure utilising the sensitivity formulas that the method provides, in order to identify the most significant uncertainties, is demonstrated. The identification of a single set of input values containing sufficient information to summarise (at least approximately) the entire risk analysis is considered to be an important feature of the method and is proposed as the basis of a means for assessing the validity of the consequence model.

Forecasting↗

Uncertainties in CT-based radiation therapy treatment planning associated with patient breathing.

PURPOSE: To evaluate uncertainties associated with treatment-planning computed tomography (CT) data obtained with the patient breathing freely. METHODS AND MATERIALS: Patients with thoracic or abdominal tumors underwent a standard treatment-planning CT study while breathing quietly and freely, followed by CT scans while holding their breath at normal inhalation and normal exhalation. Identical treatment plans on all three CT data sets for each patient pointed out differences in: (a) radiation path lengths; (b) positions of the organs; (c) physical volumes of the lung, liver, and kidneys; (d) the interpretation of plan evaluation tools such as dose-volume histograms and normal tissue complication probability (NTCP) models; and (e) how well the planning CT data set represented the average of the inhalation and exhalation studies. RESULTS: Inhalation and exhalation data differ in terms of radiation path length (nearly one quarter of the cases had path-length differences > 1 cm), although the free breathing and average path lengths do not exhibit large differences (0-9 mm). Liver and kidney movements averaged 2 cm, whereas differences between the free breathing and average positions averaged 0.6 cm. The physical volume of the liver between the free breathing and static studies varied by as much as 12%. The NTCP calculations on exhale and inhale studies varied from 3 to 43% for doses that resulted in a 15% NTCP on the free-breathing studies. CONCLUSION: Free-breathing CT studies may improperly estimate the position and volume of critical structures, and thus may mislead evaluation of plans based on such volume dependent criteria such as dose-volume histograms and NTCP calculations.

Abdominal Neoplasms↗

Computerized design of target margins for treatment uncertainties in conformal radiotherapy.

PURPOSE: We describe a computerized method of determining target margins for beam aperture design in conformal radiotherapy plans. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The method uses previously measured data from a population of patients to simulate setup error and organ motion in the patient currently being planned. Starting with a clinical target volume (CTV) and nontarget organs from the patient's planning CT scan, the simulation is repeated many times to produce a spatial probability distribution for each organ in the treatment machine coordinate system. This is used to determine a prescribed dose volume (PDV), defined as the volume to receive the prescribed dose, which encompasses the CTV while restricting the volume of nontarget organs within it, according to planner-specified values. The PDV is used to design beam apertures using a conventional margin for beam penumbra. RESULTS: The method is applied to 6-field prostate conformal treatment plans, in which the PDV encloses the prostate and seminal vesicles while limiting the enclosed rectal wall volume. The effect of organ motion is assessed by applying the plans on subsequent CT scans of the same patients, calculating probabilities for tumor control (TCP) and normal tissue complication (NTCP), and comparing with plans designed from a physician-drawn planning target volume (PTV). Although prostate TCP and rectal wall NTCP are found to be similar in the two sets of plans, TCP for the seminal vesicles is significantly higher in the PDV-based plans. CONCLUSIONS: The method can improve the dose conformality of treatment plans by incorporating population-based measurements of treatment uncertainties and consideration of nontarget tissues in the design of nonuniform target margins.

Computer Simulation↗

Free-choice preference under uncertainty.

Preferences in pigeons for free choice over forced choice under uncertain contingencies were compared with the one under certain contingencies in multiple concurrent-chain schedules of reinforcement. The uncertain condition examined the preference for two alternatives over one alternative when reinforcement probability at the end of the terminal link equalled 0.5, and with all keys in each terminal link lit green (two mixed fixed-interval extinction keys versus one mixed fixed-interval extinction key). Key and schedule arrangement in the certain condition was the same except that a peck on any terminal-link key after the FI interval always produced food. When naive pigeons were first exposed to uncertain contingencies, preference for two lit keys over one lit key was observed, and the preference was confirmed by sequential reversals of the terminal-link contingencies. However, no consistent preference was observed when uncertain condition followed the certain condition. Under certain contingencies, unlike the earlier experiments, very small and inconsistent preferences for free choice were demonstrated. A possible reason for the different preferences in the uncertain conditions was that pigeons may lessen their sensitivity to the circumstances with uncertainty by any history or carry-over effect of the prior contingency.

Journal Article↗

Science, uncertainty and policy: food for thought.

The organisation and work of the Food Standards Agency are described. The Agency is a new non-Ministerial Government department with responsibility for protecting the health of the public and other interests of consumers in relation to food. Its roles encompass assessment of risk (through scientific expert committees) as well as risk communication and management. Among the many changes that the Agency has brought about is a new commitment to openness. All policy discussions and decisions take place in public. Diet and bovine spongiform encephalopathy are used as examples to illustrate the Agency's approaches to dealing with risk and uncertainty.

Animals↗

Uncertainties relating to the health effects of particulate air pollution: the US EPA's particle standard.

Although the epidemiologic associations between urban particulate air pollution and human mortality and morbidity have been accumulating for several years, the causal agents (a specific chemical component, a specific particle size range, one or more pollutant combinations, etc.), and the physiological mechanisms behind the associations have yet to be identified. Significant questions regarding confounding effects due to weather, indoor air pollutant exposures and co-pollutants (that accompany particulate matter) stubbornly remain. The events in the United States began with recent epidemiological associations, followed by a lawsuit forcing the US EPA to accelerate the standard-setting process, and finally controversy over the scientific basis of the new standard. In contrast to the potential risks posed by particulate air pollution, many of the sources of such particles are positive contributors to human health; control measures to meet the proposed standard may therefore produce offsetting enhanced mortality and morbidity. In order to establish the information required for well-informed public health policies, a substantial research program is needed because of uncertainties relating to, the affected individuals, the potential causal agents, and the consequences of particle-control activities. Not only are the remaining scientific questions significant, but the particle exposure/health effects associations also call into question some of the current scientific assumptions relating to the nature of effects of population exposures to low concentrations of pollutants.

Air Pollutants↗

Measurements of coronary blood flow and degree of stenosis: current clinical implications and continuing uncertainties.

Initial measurements of coronary blood flow in human beings were limited by methodologic inadequacies causing clinically important areas of reduced perfusion to be incompletely represented or overlooked. More recent measurements have provided insight into clinically relevant pathophysiology. There has been increasing appreciation of the need for values of flow to be related to concomitant myocardial oxygen demand, and of the importance of evaluating perfusion in relation to coronary vascular reserve. Regional flow measurement techniques have progressed significantly during the past decade and have provided better insight into perfusion deficits in ischemic heart disease. A greatly improved understanding of the relation between the arteriographic degree of stenosis and perfusion limitation also has developed. In reviewing studies addressing these points, the present article attempts to highlight their current clinical implications and address continuing uncertainties meriting further attention.

Collateral Circulation↗

Relations governed by uncertainty: part of life of families of a child with asthma.

This study identifies what influences and characterizes family relations in families of a child with asthma. Seventeen mothers of children aged between 6 and 16 years participated in audio-taped in-depth interviews. The researchers were inspired by grounded theory in data collection and data analysis. The core category that developed was being governed by disease-engendered uncertainty. The category mothers' availability was seen in two dimensions. The first dimension, mothers' being available for the child with asthma, created two subcategories: 1. control and 2. tight bonds. The second dimension, mothers' being less available for other family members, also created two subcategories: 3. being forsaken and 4. lack of understanding. Nursing implications are discussed in relation to the findings.

Adolescent↗

Parenting of at-risk infants in the face of uncertainty: home apnea monitoring of subsibs.

This article describes the experiences of a group of parents in New Zealand who lost infants to sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) and who monitored their subsequent infants or subsibs (infants born after the death of an infant due to SIDS) at home for signs of apnea. Their caregiving experiences are explored within the framework of the substantive theory developed by Cohen (1993) that describes how another group of parents, those caring for children with chronic life-threatening illnesses, copes with living under conditions of sustained uncertainty. Attention is drawn to the similarities in both the grieving processes and coping strategies used by both groups of parents in these parallel situations.

Adult↗

Uncertainty and opposition of medical students toward assisted death practices.

To explore medical students' views of assisted death practices in patient cases that describe different degrees and types of physical and mental suffering, an anonymous survey was administered to all students at one medical school. Respondents were asked about the acceptability of assisted death activities in five patient vignettes and withdrawal of life support in a sixth vignette. In the vignettes, actions were performed by four possible agents: the medical student personally; a referral physician; physicians in general; or non-physicians. Of 306 medical students, 166 (54%) participated. Respondents expressed opposition or uncertainty about assisted death practices in the five patient cases that illustrated severe forms of suffering which were secondary to amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, treatment-resistant depressive and somatoform disorders, antisocial and sexually violent behavior, or AIDS. Students supported the withdrawal of life support in the sixth vignette depicting exceptional futility secondary to AIDS. Students were especially opposed to their own involvement and to the participation of non-physicians in assisted death activities. Differences in views related to sex, religious beliefs, and personal philosophy were found. Medical students do not embrace assisted death practices, although they exhibit tolerance regarding the choices of medical colleagues. How these attributes of medical students will translate into future behaviors toward patients and peers remains uncertain. Medical educators must strive to understand the perspectives of physicians-in-training. Expanded, empirically informed education that is attuned to the attitudes of medical students may be helpful in fulfilling the responsibility of imparting optimal clinical care skills.

Adult↗

Applying statistical, uncertainty-based and connectionist approaches to the prediction of fetal outcome: a comparative study.

A common situation in the field of medicine is the availability of a huge quantity of data and knowledge relevant to a problem which is nevertheless, to a greater or lesser degree, incomplete or imprecise. This kind of problem occurs, for example, with respect to the information available for the prognostic tasks required for pregnancy monitoring, where decision-making by physicians calls for the incorporation of predictive skills. There are available however, several knowledge discovery methods that can be applied to data resulting from the performance of one or several of the non-stress tests (NSTs) that are used to evaluate a pregnant patient's antenatal status. This paper presents, discusses and compares the results obtained as a consequence of the application of different prediction methods, namely the Bayes' model, discriminant analysis, artificial neural networks (ANNs) and the Shortliffe and Buchanan uncertainty-based model.

Computer Simulation↗