An inverse relationship between the growth rate of human melanoma xenografts and their response to some cytostatic drugs.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
SEARCH · Search PubMed
Search indexed PubMed citations on genomics, clinical trials, systematic reviews and public health. Explore titles, authors and supplied subject terms, then open the PubMed record.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Results after an average follow-up of 3 years are presented on 485 patients in the 3rd MRC therapeutic trial in myelomatosis. The 353 non-azotaemic patients (199 now dead) were randomized between i.v. cyclophosphamide (CY) and oral melphalan with prednisone (M & P). THose treated with M & P fared slightly, but non-significantly, better. The 132 azotaemic patients (111 now dead) were randomized between i.v. CY and a 4-drug regimen, and both groups fared equally badly. Finally, after one year of the allocated treatment, 297 survivors (126 now dead) were randomized either to stop all treatment until evidence of relapse was obtained, or to continue treatment with azathioprine and vincristine, interrupted every 3 months for a course of the first-allocated treatment. The overall results suggested that maintenance therapy was beneficial, though the results were not statistically significant. Most of the difference was found among the few patients with unfavourable prognostic features who survived one year and were eligible for this randomization. In this, as in the two previous MRC trials, no striking differences have emerged between the therapeutic effects of different schedules of melphalan and/or CY. Consequently, a regimen of intermittent oral melphalan (with or without prednisone) seems satisfactory, because it is among the least toxic and most convenient. The 4th myeloma trial, now beginning, seeks to discover whether the addition of vincristine to the regimen can improve these results.
Two soft-agar methods for assaying chemosensitivity of human cancers in vitro were compared with respect to colony morphology, plating efficiency (PE) and chemosensitivity of human melanomas. In 9 xenografts and 9 patients' biopsy specimens Method A (essentially that of Courtenay & Mills, 1978) gave considerably higher PE that Method B (essentially that of Hamburger & Salmon, 1977) and, in contrast to Method B, the number of colonies was proportional to the number of cells plated. Evidence was obtained that the observed differences in PE could be attributed to the low O2 concentration and the presence of rat red blood cells in Method A. Colony morphology was similar in the 2 assays. When cells from 4 xenografted melanomas were treated in vitro with DTIC, CCNU, vinblastine and abrin, and the inhibition of colony formation was assayed concurrently in the 2 soft-agar methods, the tumour cells appeared to be more sensitive to 3 of the drugs in Method B than in A. The results demonstrate that chemosensitivity data obtained with the 2 assays cannot be directly compared.
Pre-treatment with the anabolic steroid nandrolone decanoate (ND) increases the LD50 of 1-(2-chloroethyl)-3-cyclohexyl-1-nitrosourea (CCNU) and 5-Fluorouracil (FU) in NMRI mice. Administration of ND did not affect the anti-tumour action of CCNU against a transplantable mouse adenocarcinoma of the colon (MAC 13) or the anti-tumour action of FU against MAC 26. In both tumour lines ND had no significant effect on tumour growth. These data suggest that an increase in the anti-tumour selectivity of these agents may be produced by pre-treatment with ND.
This report compares the results at 36 months for 121 patients treated with radiotherapy alone (R) and 115 with radiotherapy followed by 3-drug chemotherapy (RC) for small-cell carcinoma of the lung of "limited" extent. The RC patients had an increased survival (P = 0.009 by log-rank test). The median survival was 25 weeks for the R patients and 43 weeks for the RC patients, but at 36 months, only 4 (3%) of the R patients and 5 (4%) of the RC patients were still alive. There was evidence of recurrence of the primary cancer in 41 (35%) of the 117 R and 35 (32%) of the 110 RC patients who died. Distant metastases were more frequent in the R series, being reported in 99 (82%) compared with 82 (71%) of the RC patients (P less than 0.05 by log-rank test). The numbers of R patients alive and considered free of metastases were 10 (8%) at 12 months, 3 (2%) at 24 months and 3 (2%) at 36 months; the corresponding figures for the RC patients being 30 (26%), 9 (8%), and 4 (3%).
The response of intramuscularly growing KHT sarcomas to the chemotherapeutic agent (1-(2-cloroethyl)-3-cyclohexyl-1-nitrosourea (CCNU) alone or simultaneously with the chemical radio-sensitizer misonidazole (MISO) was assessed using either a tumour growth-delay assay or an in vivo-in vitro tumour-excision assay. Median tumour growth delay following the combination of 20 mg/kg CCNU and either 0.5 or 1.0 mg/g MISO was 19.5 and 21.5 days, compared to 10 days for this CCNU dose alone. A similar degree of enhanced tumour response by MISO (factor of approximately 2 in tumour growth delay) was seen in RIF-1 tumours treated with 20 mg/kg CCNU plus 1.0 mg/g MISO. Clonogenic cell-survival studies with KHT sarcomas demonstrated that MISO at doses of 0.25, 0.5 or 1.0 mg/g given simultaneously with a range of CCNU doses produced dose-modifying factors (DMFs) of 1.9, 2.1 and 2.4 respectively. Normal tissue toxicity assessed by an LD50/7 assay led to DMFs of 1.2 and 1.4 for CCNU doses combined with 0.5 and 1.0 mg/g MISO. Thus in this animal tumour model the combination of CCNU and MISO appears to lead to a potential gain by a factor of approximately 1.7.
A series of human bronchial-carcinoma xenografts (3 small-cell anaplastic, 2 large-cell anaplastic and 3 adenocarcinomas) established in immune-suppressed mice were treated with combination chemotherapy based on clinical regimes. Xenograft response was assessed by the in situ endpoint of growth delay in s.c. tumours. Dose-response relationships of 3 triple-drug combinations and their component agents were explored, allowing the relative contributions of single agents in each combination to be assessed. The results demonstrate that the effects produced in the xenografts were generally consistent with clinical experience. Procarbazine, cyclophosphamide and CCNU stood out as the most effective drugs in small cell carcinoma, but were ineffective in the other histological types. These was some evidence for individuality of therapeutic response among the grafts, supporting the case for incorporating panels of histologically similar xenografts into primary drug-screening programmes to complement existing syngeneic rodent tumour systems.
Enhancement of CCNU cytotoxicity by misonidazole (MISO) was studied in three tumours and two normal tissues in the mouse. The 3 experimental tumours (SCCVII/St, EMT6 and KHT) showed very different sensitivities to CCNU alone, but MISO enhanced the cell killing in ech case. The effect was not always dose-modifying, so that the CCNU dose range for the greatest enhancement was different in each of the tumours. In all 3 tumours, enhancement increased with dose of MISO. The effect on two normal tissues, marrow (CFU-S) and testis (spermatogonia), was also investigated. Enhancement of marrow toxicity could be demonstrated only at CCNU doses greater than 12.5 mg/kg, so that at lower CCNU doses there was a therapeutic gain equal to the tumour enhancement ratio. The spermatogonia effect, however, showed enhancement by MISO similar to that seen in the tumours at all CCNU doses up to 20 mg/kg.
The therapeutic value of sequential hemi-body irradiation (HBI) as a primary treatment for small-cell lung cancer (SCLC) was compared to 3-drug cyclic chemotherapy (CC) in a group of 64 patients with early and advanced disease. Thirty patients were randomized to receive sequential HBI and 34 to receive CC. All patients received a local radiation boost to the primary lesion. An overall response rate of 87% was obtained in patients treated with sequential HBI and 88% in patients treated with CC. In patients with early disease, the estimated median survival was 43 weeks when treated with HBI and 42 weeks when treated with CC, but in advanced disease the estimated median survival was 15 weeks and 44 weeks respectively. Of the patients with an initial complete response, the estimated median survival was 51 weeks for HBI and 62 weeks for CC. From these observations we suggest that sequential HBI treatment technique with local radiation boost is an efficient method of tumour control in patients with early small-cell lung cancer.
Using a regrowth-delay assay, we investigated structure/activity relationships for the enhancement by electron-affinic agents of the anti-tumour effect of the nitrosourea CCNU against the KHT sarcoma in C3H mice. A series of neutral 2-nitroimidazoles similar in electron affinity but varying in octanol/water partition coefficient (PC) over 4 orders of magnitude (0.016- greater than 200, Misonidazole = 0.43) were examined at a fixed dose of 2.5 mmol/kg. A parabolic (quadratic) dependence of activity on log PC was observed. Analogues more hydrophilic than misonidazole (MISO) were inactive as were those with very high PCs (greater than 20). Those with PC 0.43--20 were usually more active than MISO, some considerably so. The fairly lipophilic 5-nitroimidazoles nimorazole and metronidazole (METRO) had similar activity to MISO, despite their reduced electron affinity. Two basic 2-nitroimidazoles more efficient as radiosensitizers in vitro likewise showed activity comparable to MISO. We also investigated several agents more electron-affinic than MISO, including some non-nitro compounds. Most were inactive at maximum tolerated doses, but nitrofurazone showed reasonable activity. Sensitizer dose-response curves were obtained for MISO, METRO and two of the most effective agents, benznidazole (Ro 07-1051) and Ro 07-1902. The two latter agents were both considerably more active than MISO at low doses (0.1--0.9 mmol/kg). These studies indicate that the structural features of electron-affinic agents responsible for the enhancement of KHT tumour response to CCNU, are quite different from those affecting radiosensitization, lipophilicity being particularly important. The microsomal enzyme-inhibitor SKF 525A increased the anti-tumour effect of CCNU, suggesting inhibition of CCNU metabolism as one possible mechanism contributing to chemosensitization by lipophilic electron-affinic agents in mice.
Tumour cells from 7 patients with ovarian carcinoma and from 22 different human tumour xenografts representing a wide range of histological sub-types have been examined for multicellular spheroid forming ability. Spheroid formation was limited to cells derived from xenografts. Of the 22 lines tested, 5 formed spheroids capable of growth in isolation. There was no clear relationship between histological type and spheroid-forming ability. The plating efficiency of tumour cells obtained from spheroids was always greater than for the cells obtained from the dissociated tumour of origin and was in some cases as much as 6-fold greater. Spheroid growth was nearly exponential for 4 cell lines. Volume growth delay was used to investigate the activity of melphalan, adriamycin, the Vinca alkaloids, CCNU and cisplatin. Differences between lines in drug response broadly reflected patient and in vivo xenograft response.
The in vivo response of B16 melanoma and Lewis lung carcinoma to combinations of hyperthermia and graded doses of CCNU or Melphalan was studied. To obtain dose-response curves and quantitative comparisons of different treatments, an agar-colony assay was used to measure survival of cells from excised tumours. For heating experiments, the use of 2 tumours per animal, one heated and one not, allowed all other factors to be kept constant. When tumours were immersed in a water-bath at 43 degrees C for 1 h, Thermal Enhancement Ratios (TER) measured from the slopes of the dose-response curves were up to 1.6 for CCNU and 2.4 for Melphalan. Direct heat killing of about 1 decade was seen for 1 h at 43 degrees C. The anaesthetic Saffan also enhanced drug cell kill; the largest Dose Modifying Factor (2.7) was measured for Melphalan in the Lewis lung tumour. The duration of heating, and waterbath temperature, both influenced the enhancement of cell killing by CCNU, as did the time of excision of tumours between 0 and 3 1/2 h after treatment. There was no difference in effect between 3 1/2 and 24 h. The interaction between heat and CCNU varied if the interval between them was altered. The maximum effect was found if the heat and drug were given in close sequence.
The effect of combinations of the conventional chemotherapeutic agent 1-(2-chloroethyl)-3-cyclohexyl-1-nitrosourea (CCNU) and nitroimidazole radiation sensitizers was evaluated in female C3H mice. Tumour response to single-agent or combination therapy was assessed in a tumour growth-delay assay. In the KHT sarcoma the simultaneous addition of misonidazole (MISO) was found to increase significantly the tumour growth delay resulting from CCNU treatment. The observed enhancement ratios (ER) increased with MISO dose, and ranged from 1.3 to 1.9 for sensitizer doses of 0.25-1.0 mg/g. The combination of CCNU and 1.0 or 0.5 mg/g MISO in the RIF-1 tumour or the MT-1 tumour produced ERs of approximately 2.0 and approximately 1.5 respectively. In the KHT sarcoma a series of other nitroimidazole sensitizers, including Ro-05-9963, SR-2555, SR-2508 and metronidazole (METRO), were also evaluated at equimolar doses (5 mmol/kg) in combination with a 20mg/kg dose of CCNU. Unlike MISO, these compounds in general failed to enhance the CCNU cytotoxicity in this tumour model. However, SR-2508 did enhance the response of the RIF-1 tumour to large single doses of CCNU, though not as much as MISO. Normal-tissue toxicity was determined using peripheral white blood cell (WBC) counts 3 days after treatment. CCNU doses of 10-50 mg/kg given either alone or in simultaneous combination with 0.5 or 1.0 mg/g MISO were studied. WBC toxicity increased with CCNU dose, but the addition of MISO at either dose did not significantly enhance this normal-tissue toxicity.
The effect has been studied of adding either misonidazole (MISO) or metronidazole (METRO) to cytotoxic drug treatment of C3H mice bearing the RIF-1 sarcoma. The nitroimidazoles were injected 30 min before the cytotoxic drugs at a dose of 2 . 5 mmol/kg. Both clonogenic-cell survival and growth delay were measured as indicators of tumour response and depression in WBC count and acute lethality were used to indicate normal-tissue response. For melphalan, neither pretreatment agent produced any change in tumor response. For cyclophosphamide, no change was produced by METRO but a minimal increase in tumour response occurred with MISO. An enhancement of cell killing by CCNU was seen with MISO pretreatment, but there was no increase in tumour growth delay. METRO, however, did not enhance tumour response by either endpoint. WBC depression by CCNU was not enhanced by MISO pretreatment, and there was no significant reduction in the acute LD50. This indicates a therapeutic advantage from the addition of MISO to CCNU in this model system. For chlorambucil, considerable enhancement of tumour response followed either MISO or METRO pretreatment (dose-modifying factors of 2 . 0 and 1 . 4 respectively). However, the modification by MISO of normal-tissue response to chlorambucil was also enhanced by about a factor of 2, with no therapeutic gain.
We have investigated the effect of misonidazole (MISO) on the pharmacokinetics of 1-(2-chloroethyl)-3-cyclohexyl-1-nitrosourea (CCNU) in mice. CCNU and its monohydroxylated metabolites were measured using a high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) method. In the absence of MISO the plasma disappearance of CCNU was biphasic with a t 1/2 alpha of 2.3 min and a t 1/2 beta of 53 min. The monohydroxylated metabolites of CCNU also followed biphasic clearance kinetics. A large single dose of MISO (0.5 mg g-1), given i.p. 30 min prior to CCNU, prolonged the t 1/2 alpha by a factor of 2.6 but had no effect on t 1/2 beta. In addition, the apparent volume of distribution was decreased by a factor of 1.6. Consequently, the plasma area under the curve (AUC0 - infinity) was increased by a factor of 1.7 for CCNU and by a factor of 2.0 for total nitrosourea (CCNU + monohydroxylated metabolites). The effects of MISO on CCNU kinetics were dependent on MISO dose and plasma concentration and on the interval between MISO and CCNU administration. The concentration of CCNU was measured in 4 tumours: the KHT, RIF-1 and EMT6 mouse tumours, and the HT29 xenograft. For all 4 tumours, 0.5 mg g-1 MISO raised the tumour concentrations of CCNU and total nitrosourea by a considerable amount (2-2.5 times). More detailed studies in the KHT tumour demonstrated that there was a significant lag period before peak tumour CCNU concentrations were reached, and that MISO increased the peak concentrations by a factor of about 2.4. In contrast, there was no such lag period for the plasma and MISO did not increase the plasma peak CCNU concentrations. These data strongly suggest that modification of the pharmacokinetics may be a major contributory factor in the enhancement of CCNU cytotoxicity by large single doses of MISO in vivo.
Clonal subpopulations of different ploidy values and metastatic capacities, isolated from the RIF-1 mouse sarcoma, have been tested for in vitro X-radiation sensitivity, for in vitro sensitivity to adriamycin and for in vitro and in vivo sensitivity to melphalan and CCNU. Following X-radiation, no consistent differences in the survival curve characteristics (Do and n) of diploid, tetraploid and octoploid cells were observed. In addition no relationship between radiation response and metastatic capacity was observed. For drug response, no marked differences were found in the dose response curves of RIF-1 clones treated in vitro with adriamycin. However, a wide variation in the responses of RIF-1 clones to in vitro melphalan treatment was observed which was independent of both ploidy and metastatic capacity. Although the responses of RIF-1 clones to in vitro CCNU treatment were similarly independent of metastatic capacity, a clear relationship between CCNU sensitivity and ploidy was observed. Thus, all diploid RIF-1 clones were markedly more sensitive to CCNU treatment than either tetraploid or octoploid RIF-1 clones. For both melphalan and CCNU treatment the relative sensitivities in vitro correlated with in vivo sensitivities as assayed by clonogenic cell survival.
We have carried out experiments to determine the response of tumours and normal tissues in the C3H mouse to the combination of lipophilic nitroimidazoles and CCNU, cyclophosphamide or melphalan. The nitroimidazoles studied were Ro 07-1902 (1902) and benznidazole (Ro 07-1051, BENZO). Maximum enhancement of CCNU response in the KHT sarcoma by 2.5 mmol kg-1 1902 or 0.3 mmol kg-1 BENZO occurred at low doses of CCNU where dose modifying factors (DMF) of 2.5-3.0 and 1.5-2.0 respectively were found. The DMFs for depression of white cell count at day 3 were 1.6 and 1.2 respectively whilst the DMFs for LD50/30 were 1.5 and 1.3. There appears, therefore, to be a therapeutic gain at low doses of CCNU of about the same magnitude as produced by 2.5 mmol kg-1 misonidazole. The production of this gain at relatively low doses of BENZO is of possible clinical significance. Some sensitization of the KHT tumour to CCNU by 0.3 mmol kg-1 BENZO was maintained even with an interval of 25 h between BENZO and CCNU injection. A multiple injection regime of BENZO administration designed to maintain plasma concentrations for prolonged periods was, however, no more effective than a single dose. The response of the RIF-1 sarcoma to cyclophosphamide was not enhanced by the lipophilic sensitizers at the doses previously stated. Considerable enhancement of tumour response to melphalan (DMF 2.0) was produced by both lipophilic sensitizers. Enhancement of acute LD50 was similar in magnitude but no large enhancement by BENZO of melphalan induced white blood cell depression was observed. The evidence regarding the therapeutic potential of this combination is, therefore, equivocal.
The sulphydryl compound WR 2721 has been combined with a range of cytotoxic drugs in the mouse and the effects upon tumours and normal tissues determined. In the acute lethality (LD50/30) assay, mean protection factors produced by WR 2721 (200 or 400 mg kg-1) were generally less than 1.3 for cyclophosphamide (CTX), CCNU and chlorambucil (CHL) but a protection factor of 1.7 was obtained for cisplatinum (cis-P) in combination with 400 mg kg-1 of WR 2721. No protection against the depression of peripheral white cell count seen at 3 days after CTX, CCNU or cis-P was obtained with either 200 or 400 mg kg-1 of WR 2721. Significant protection of the RIF-1 sarcoma by WR 2721 against CTX and cis-P induced growth delay was seen. In the KHT sarcoma, WR 2721 produced small reductions in the growth delay caused by CCNU, melphalan and CHL but these were not statistically significant. These data show less differential normal tissue protection by WR 2721 than do a number of reports in the literature.