Search PubMed⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search PubMed

Results for “Subtilisin”

Search indexed PubMed citations on genomics, clinical trials, systematic reviews and public health. Explore titles, authors and supplied subject terms, then open the PubMed record.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 613 records · Page 34Linked to original sources

Silyl protection in the solid-phase synthesis of N-linked glycopeptides. Preparation of glycosylated fluorogenic substrates for subtilisins.

The trimethylsilyl (TMS) group was used for protection of the hydroxy groups of three disaccharide 1-amino-alditols and of the glycosylamines of glucose, maltotriose and maltoheptose. The per-O-trimethylsilylated derivatives were coupled with N alpha-Fmoc-Asp(Cl)-OPfp 7 to give six glycosylated building blocks for the solid-phase synthesis of N-linked glycopeptides. Building block 8 was used in the synthesis of five internally quenched fluorescent substrates which were studied by enzymatic hydrolysis with savinase, a subtilisin-type enzyme.

Amino Acid Sequence↗

Probing the altered specificity and catalytic properties of mutant subtilisin chemically modified at position S156C and S166C in the S1 pocket.

A series of chemically modified mutants (CMMs) of subtilisin B. lentus (SBL) were generated employing the combination of site-directed mutagenesis and chemical modification. This strategy entails the mutation of a selected active site residue to cysteine and its subsequent modification with a methanethiosulfonate reagent CH3SO2S-R, where R may be infinitely variable. The present study was undertaken to evaluate the changes in specificity and pH-activity profiles that could be induced by modification of S156C and S166C in the S1 pocket of SBL with a representative range of side chain modifications, namely R=-CH3, -CH2C6H5, -CH2CH2NH3+ and CH2CH2SO3 . The side chain of S156C is surface exposed and well solvated while that of S166C points into the pocket. Kinetic evaluation of the CMMs with suc-AAPF-pNA as substrate showed that the kcat/K(M)s changed very little for the S156C CMMs, but varied by up to 11-fold for the S166C CMMs. pH-Activity profiles were also determined, and showed that a negatively or positively charged side chain modification increased or decreased respectively, the pKa of the catalytic triad histidine for both modification sites but with more dramatic changes for the interior pointing S166C than for the solvent exposed S156C site. As an additional probe of altered specificity, inhibition of the CMMs by a representative series of 5 boronic acid transition state analogue inhibitors was determined. The K(I)s observed ranged from a 3.5-fold improvement over the WT value, to a 12-fold decrease in binding. Overall, greater variability in all the parameters measured, activity, pKa, and boronic acid binding resulted from modification at the inward pointing 166 site than at the solvent-exposed 156 site.

Binding Sites↗

The controlled introduction of multiple negative charge at single amino acid sites in subtilisin Bacillus lentus.

The use of methanethiosulfonates as thiol-specific modifying reagents in the strategy of combined site-directed mutagenesis and chemical modification allows virtually unlimited opportunities for creating new protein surface environments. As a consequence of our interest in electrostatic manipulation as a means of tailoring enzyme activity and specificity, we have adopted this approach for the controlled incorporation of multiple negative charges at single sites in the representative serine protease, subtilisin Bacillus lentus (SBL). A series of mono-, di- and triacidic acid methanethiosulfonates were synthesized and used to modify cysteine mutants of SBL at positions 62 in the S2 site, 156 and 166 in the S1 site and 217 in the S1' site. Kinetic parameters for these chemically modified mutant (CMM) enzymes were determined at pH 8.6 under conditions which ensured complete ionization of the unnatural amino acid side-chains introduced. The presence of up to three negative charges in the S1, S1' and S2 subsites of SBL resulted in up to 11-fold lowered activity, possibly due to interference with oxyanion stabilization of the transition state of the hydrolytic reactions catalyzed. Each unit increase in negative charge resulted in a raising of K(M) and a reduction of k(cat). However, no upper limit was observed for increases in K(M), whereas decreases in k(cat) reached a limiting value. Comparison with sterically similar but uncharged CMMs revealed that electrostatic effects of negative charges at positions 62, 156 and 217 are detrimental, but are beneficial at position 166. These results indicate that the ground-state binding of SBL to the standard substrate, Suc-AAPF-pNA, to SBL is reduced, but without drastic attenuation of catalytic efficiency, and show that SBL tolerates high levels of charge at single sites.

Amino Acids↗

Altering the specificity of subtilisin Bacillus lentus through the introduction of positive charge at single amino acid sites.

The use of methanethiosulfonates as thiol-specific modifying reagents in the strategy of combined site-directed mutagenesis and chemical modification allows virtually unlimited opportunities for creating new protein surface environments. As a consequence of our interest in electrostatic manipulation as a means of tailoring enzyme activity and specificity, we have recently adopted this approach for the controlled incorporation of multiple negative charges at single sites in the representative serine protease, subtilisin Bacillus lentus (SBL). We now describe the use of this strategy to introduce multiple positive charges. A series of mono-, di- and triammonium methanethiosulfonates were synthesized and used to modify cysteine mutants of SBL at positions 62 in the S2 site, 156 and 166 in the S1 site and 217 in the S1' site. Kinetic parameters for these chemically modified mutants (CMM) enzymes were determined at pH 8.6. The presence of up to three positive charges in the S1, S1' and S2 subsites of SBL resulted in up to 77-fold lowered activity, possibly due to interference with the histidinium ion formed in the transition state of the hydrolytic reactions catalyzed.

Amino Acids↗

Benzophenone boronic acid photoaffinity labeling of subtilisin CMMs to probe altered specificity.

A transition state analogue inhibitor, boronic acid benzophenone (BBP) photoprobe, was used to study the differences in the topology of the S1 pocket of chemically modified mutant enzymes (CMMs). The BBP proved to be an effective competitive inhibitor and a revealing active site directed photoprobe of the CMMs of the serine protease subtilisin Bacillus lentus (SBL) which were chemically modified with the hydrophobic, negatively charged and positively charged moieties at the S1 pocket S166C residue. As expected, in all cases BBP bound best to WT-SBL. BBP binding to S166C-SCH2C6H5 and S166C-CH2-c-C6H11, with their large hydrophobic side chains, was reduced by 86-fold and 9-fold, respectively, compared to WT. Relative to WT, BBP binding to the charged CMMs, S166C-S-CH2CH2SO3- or S166C-S-CH2CH2NH3+, was reduced 170-fold and 4-fold respectively. Photolysis of the WT-SBL-BBP enzyme inhibitor (EI) complex, inactivated the enzyme and effected the formation of a covalent crosslink between WT and BBP. The crosslink was identified at Gly127 by peptide mapping analysis and Edman sequencing. Gly127 is located in the S1 hydrophobic pocket of SBL and its modification thus established binding of the benzophenone moiety in S1. Photolysis of the EI complex of S166C-SCH2C6H5, S166C-S-CH2CH2SO3-, or S166C-S-CH2CH2NH3+ and BBP under the same conditions did not inactivate these enzymes, nor effect the formation of a crosslink. These results corroborated the kinetic evidence that the active site topology of these CMMs is dramatically altered from that of WT. In contrast, while photolysis of the S166C-CH2-c-C6H11-BBP EI complex only inactivated 50% of the enzyme after 12 h, it still effected the formation of a covalent crosslink between the CMM and BBP, again at Gly127. However, this photolytic reaction was less efficient than with WT, demonstrating that the S1 pocket of S166C-CH2-c-C6H11 is significantly restricted compared to WT, but not as completely as for the other CMMs.

Amino Acid Sequence↗

Up-regulation of Prl, a subtilisin-like protease, during conidiation in the insect pathogen Metarhizium anisopliae.

Metarhizium anisopliae exhibits two different developmental patterns under nutrient-deprived conditions: appressorium formation in early stages and conidiation in late stages of pathogenesis in its insect hosts. In this study we isolated genes enriched during mature conidial production under nutrient-deprived conditions in M. anisopliae by using the method of suppression subtractive hybridization. We sequence-identified seven conidiation-associated genes (cag) in M. anisopliae. One of the genes, cag7, encoded an extracellular subtilisin-like protease, Pr1, that plays a fundamental role in cuticular protein degradation. Reverse-transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) analysis confirmed that cag cDNAs are expressed during the development of mature conidia under nutrient-deprived conditions. RT-PCR analysis was also performed for Pr1 during infection of greater wax moth larvae (Galleria mellonella). Results showed up-regulation of Pr1 in the infected insect as the mycelia emerge and produce conidia on the surface of the cadaver. It is well documented that Pr1 is produced during the initial stages of transcuticular penetration by M. anisopliae. Here we show that Pr1 is also up-regulated during the final stages of pathogenesis as the fungus emerges from the dead host and subsequently conidiates on the cadaver.

Animals↗

Immobilized-metal affinity and hydroxyapatite chromatography of genetically engineered subtilisin.

High-performance immobilized-metal affinity and hydroxyapatite chromatography were employed to investigate the engineered subtilisin S1 binding site microenvironment. Although these methods are classified as affinity techniques, unlike traditional affinity columns, both are capable of probing the entire surface of a molecule. The metal chelate study employed gradient elution to assemble retention maps for a wide range of mobile-phase pH. Resolution of single substitution variants was achieved at the optimum mobile-phase pH. A total of four metals were applied separately to the metal chelate column to investigate ligand specificity with respect to protein retention. Hydroxyapatite chromatography, albeit an established technique, has only recently been developed as a high-performance chromatographic method. Gradient elution separations were performed to determine selectivity. Immobilized-metal affinity chromatography was found to be the more effective method for the separation of site-specific variants.

Chromatography, Affinity↗

Single amino acid contributions to protein retention in cation-exchange chromatography: resolution of genetically engineered subtilisin variants.

Genetically engineered proteins were used to determine the amino acid contributions of surface residues to subtilisin retention in cation-exchange chromatography. Crystallographic data were used to correlate the observed chromatographic behavior with enzymatic structure. Retention times of variants in gradient elution varied by as much as 33% compared to the wild type. The role of both charged and uncharged residues was investigated in isocratic separations and found to significantly influence protein retention in this electrostatically dominant separation method. This study demonstrates the ability of ion-exchange chromatography to discriminate between protein variants differing by a single residue in 275 amino acids.

Amino Acid Sequence↗

Context dependence of protein secondary structure formation: the three-dimensional structure and stability of a hybrid between chymotrypsin inhibitor 2 and helix E from subtilisin Carlsberg.

The loop region of chymotrypsin inhibitor 2 from barley has been employed as a scaffold for testing the intrinsic propensity of a peptide fragment to form a secondary structure. The helix formation of the nine amino acid residue segment Lys-Gln-Ala-Val-Asp-Asn-Ala-Tyr-Ala of helix E from subtilisin Carlsberg has been studied by the construction of a hybrid consisting of chymotrypsin inhibitor 2 (CI2) where part of the active loop has been replaced by the nonapeptide. An expression system for a truncated form of CI2 where the 19 structureless residues of the N-terminus have been removed and Leu20 replaced by methionyl was constructed from the entire 83-residue wild-type CI2 gene by polymerase chain reaction methodology. The gene encoding the hybrid was constructed from the truncated inhibitor gene. The stability of the truncated inhibitor and of the hybrid toward guanidinium chloride denaturation was examined. From these measurements, the energy of unfolding in pure water was extrapolated to 30.5 +/- 1.0 kJ/mol for the truncated inhibitor and 10.9 +/- 0.3 kJ/mol for the hybrid. These energies show that the stability of CI2 is unaffected by the N-terminal truncation but severely decreased by the loop mutations. The three-dimensional structure of the hybrid protein has been determined in solution by nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy using 893 distance restraints and 84 torsional angle restraints. The average root-mean-square deviation (rmsd) of 15 structures compared to their geometrical average was 0.8 +/- 0.2 A for heavy backbone atoms and 1.3 +/- 0.2 A for all heavy atoms.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Amino Acid Sequence↗

A covalently trapped folding intermediate of subtilisin E: spontaneous dimerization of a prosubtilisin E Ser49Cys mutant in vivo and its autoprocessing in vitro.

The propeptide of subtilisin E (the N-terminal 77 amino acid extension) is required for the proper folding of the nascent mature protein and is also a potent and specific inhibitor of the active enzyme. Previous studies have demonstrated that the propeptide can renature denatured mature sequence either in cis or in trans and can be considered an intramolecular chaperone, since it is not required for activity of the mature enzyme. In this paper it is shown that a prosubtilisin-S49C mutant can be expressed in Escherichia coli either as a monomer or as a disulfide-linked dimer, (prosubtilisin-S49C)2, depending on the vector selected. Interconversion between (prosubtilisin-S49C)2 and prosubtilisin-S49C could be readily achieved by reduction and oxidation in denaturing solutions, such as guanidine hydrochloride or urea. While the monomer can undergo autoprocessing in vitro under refolding conditions, the dimer is trapped in an intermediate state which could not be processed into active enzyme. Remarkably, the autoprocessing of this trapped intermediate could be induced readily upon reduction by dithiothreitol. This disulfide-linked (prosubtilisin-S49C)2 is fairly stable, but does tend to aggregate when the ionic strength of the solution is reduced below 0.1 M. The disulfide-linked (prosubtilisin-S49C)2 has far- and near-UV CD spectra revealing the presence of both secondary and tertiary structures, respectively, similar to those of the active mature monomer. Hence this autoprocessing-competent state appears to be a "late" folding intermediate, arising after the "molten globule" state formed in the absence of the prosequence, that has no discernible tertiary structure.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Amino Acid Sequence↗

Characterization of cDNA for human tripeptidyl peptidase II: the N-terminal part of the enzyme is similar to subtilisin.

Tripeptidyl peptidase II is a high molecular weight serine exopeptidase, which has been purified from rat liver and human erythrocytes. Four clones, representing 4453 bp, or 90% of the mRNA of the human enzyme, have been isolated from two different cDNA libraries. One clone, designated A2, was obtained after screening a human B-lymphocyte cDNA library with a degenerated oligonucleotide mixture. The B-lymphocyte cDNA library and a cDNA library, obtained from human fibroblasts, were rescreened with a 147 bp fragment from the 5' part of the A2 clone, whereby three different overlapping cDNA clones could be isolated. The deduced amino acid sequence, 1196 amino acid residues, corresponding to the longest open reading frame of the assembled nucleotide sequence, was compared to sequences of current databases. This revealed a 56% similarity between the bacterial enzyme subtilisin and the N-terminal part of tripeptidyl peptidase II. The enzyme was found to be represented by two different mRNAs of 4.2 and 5.0 kilobases, respectively, which probably result from the utilization of two different polyadenylation sites. Furthermore, cDNA corresponding to both the N-terminal and C-terminal part of tripeptidyl peptidase II hybridized with genomic DNA from mouse, horse, calf, and hen, even under fairly high stringency conditions, indicating that tripeptidyl peptidase II is highly conserved.

Amino Acid Sequence↗

Effect of an intersubunit disulfide bond on the stability of Streptomyces subtilisin inhibitor.

The effect of an engineered disulfide bond between two identical subunits of a dimeric protein, Streptomyces subtilisin inhibitor, on the stability of the protein was studied by differential scanning calorimetry. The introduction of the linkage caused a large stabilization without changing the cooperativity of unfolding, with the denaturation temperature of a 2 mg/mL solution being increased by 14.3 degrees C to 95.0 degrees C at pH 9.5 and by 16.4 degrees C to 63.0 degrees C at pH 3.0. The stabilization was caused by a loss of denaturational entropy, i.e., -40 and -98 cal K-1 mol-1 at pH 3.0 and 9.5, respectively, which more than compensated for the loss in the denaturational enthalpy.

Bacterial Proteins↗

Limited proteolysis of thermolysin by subtilisin: isolation and characterization of a partially active enzyme derivative.

Incubation of the neutral metalloendopeptidase thermolysin at pH 9-10 in the presence of 10 mM CaCl2 for 2 days at room temperature with subtilisin at a 50:1 molar ratio leads to a derivative possessing lower (approximately 3%) but intrinsic catalytic activity. This derivative, called thermolysin S, was isolated by gel filtration in approximately 80% yield and then separated from some residual intact thermolysin by an affinity chromatographic step on Sepharose-Gly-D-Phe. It was found that thermolysin S results from a tight association of two polypeptide fragments of apparent Mr of 24000 and 10000. Dissociation of the complex was achieved under strong denaturing conditions, such as gel filtration on a column equilibrated and eluted with 5 M guanidine hydrochloride. The positions of the clip sites were defined by amino acid analysis, end-group determination, and amino acid sequencing of the isolated fragments and shown to lie between Thr-4 and Ser-5, between Thr-224 and Gln-225, and also between Gln-225 and Asp-226. Thermolysin S, which is therefore a stable complex of fragments 5-224(225) and 225(226)-316, shows a shift in optimum pH of about 1 unit toward the acid range with respect to intact thermolysin and a Km essentially unchanged, with furylacryloyl-Gly-Leu-NH2 as substrate. Inhibitors of thermolysin such as ethoxyformic anhydride and Zn2+ ions inactivate also the nicked enzyme.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Binding Sites↗

Hydrogen exchange kinetics of core peptide protons in Streptomyces subtilisin inhibitor.

The hydrogen isotope exchange kinetics of the 10 slowest exchanging resonances in the 1H NMR spectrum of Streptomyces subtilisin inhibitor (SSI) have been determined at pH 7-11 and 30-60 degrees C. These resonances are assigned to peptide amide protons in the beta-sheet core that comprises the extensive protein-protein interface of the tightly bound SSI dimer. The core protons are atypical in that their exchange rates are orders of magnitude slower than those for all other SSI protons. When they do exchange at temperatures greater than 50 degrees C, they do so as a set and with a very high temperature coefficient. The pH dependence of the exchange rate constants is also atypical. Exchange rates are approximately first order in hydroxyl ion dependence at pH less than 8.5 and greater than 9.5 and pH independent between pH 8.5 and 9.5. The pH dependence and temperature dependence of the SSI proton exchange rates are interpreted by the two-process model [Woodward, C. K., & Hilton, B. D. (1980) Biophys. J. 32, 561-575]. The results suggest that in the average solution structure of SSI, an unusual mobility of secondary structural elements at the protein surface is, in a sense, compensated by an unusual rigidity and inaccessibility of the beta-sheet core at the dimer interface.

Bacterial Proteins↗

Acylation of subtilisin A by aryl esters: contribution to rate limitation by a physical step preceding general acid-base catalysis.

The specificity ratios kc/Km = k for subtilisin A catalyzed hydrolysis of five aryl esters of N-(methoxycarbonyl)-L-Phe (McPhe) were determined at pH 7.03 and its pD equivalent. The ratios are independent of the electronic properties of the leaving group substituent. Kinetic solvent isotope effects, Dk, increase from about 0.9 to 1.3 as leaving group ability decreases from p-nitrophenolate to p-methoxyphenolate. The k of N-(methoxycarbonyl)-L-phenylalanine p-nitrophenyl ester (NPE) with native enzyme exhibits a strong temperature dependence; delta H* = 87 +/- 3 kJ mol-1 and delta S* = 148 +/- 14 J K-1 mol-1 at 25 degrees C (H2O). The Dk with this substrate is 1.36 at 13.6 degrees C, declines to 0.89 at 25 degrees C, and then increases to 1.04 at 39.4 degrees C. Above neutral pH(D), with McPhe NPE as substrate, the dependence of k is for the dissociated form of a single base of pKapp = 7.38 +/- 0.03 in H2O and 7.67 +/- 0.03 in D2O. The pKapp values are apparently those of the uncomplexed native protein. By contrast, k of 3-phenylpropanoic acid (Prop) p-nitrophenyl ester exhibits a weaker temperature dependence; delta H* = 20 kJ mol-1 and delta S* = -90 J K-1 mol-1 (H2O) at 25 degrees C. The Dk are larger than those for McPhe NPE, decreasing from 1.99 at 20.5 degrees C to 1.74 at 46.1 degrees C. These results, combined with those of previous studies, are consistent with limitation of k by at least two processes.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Acylation↗

Catalytic and conformational changes induced by limited subtilisin cleavage of bovine carboxypeptidase A.

Limited proteolysis of carboxypeptidase A from bovine pancreas with subtilisin Carlsberg generates a stable intermediate, carboxypeptidase S, whose esterase and peptidase activities are increased and decreased, respectively, under standard assay conditions. Carboxypeptidase S was isolated by affinity chromatography. Sequence analysis shows that it is cleaved solely at the Ala154-Gly155 bond. Its enzymatic properties were determined under stopped-flow conditions with Dns-Gly-Ala-Phe and its ester analogue Dns-Gly-Ala-OPhe. For both substrates, the Km values are increased 30-40-fold. The kcat value for peptide hydrolysis is virtually unaffected whereas that for ester hydrolysis is increased 10-fold. The magnitude of the Km effect is equivalent to a loss of 9 kJ/mol of binding energy and likely reflects a disruption of the network of hydrogen bonds that links Tyr-248 and Arg-145 to the backbone carbonyls of Ala-154 and Gly-155. The difference in kcat effects for the two substrate classes is related to differences in the chemical nature of the rate-determining step. Product release is rate determining for catalytic hydrolysis of ester substrates, and hence, the increase in kcat indicates that dissociation of products is facilitated as a result of the Ala154-Gly155 bond scission. The changes in enzymatic activity accompanying limited proteolysis are due to conformational alterations in the vicinity of the active center of the molecule. The affinity of a monoclonal antibody, mAb 100, directed toward the antigenic determinant located between residues 209 and 218 in carboxypeptidase A is diminished considerably for carboxypeptidase S.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Amino Acid Sequence↗

Proton magnetic resonance study of Streptomyces subtilisin inhibitor. pH titration and assignments of individual tyrosyl resonances.

This paper reports the pH titration at 25 degrees C and the assignment of aromatic proton resonances of three tyrosyl residues of each identical subunit of Streptomyces subtilisin inhibitor (Mr 23000) by high-resolution 1H NMR spectroscopy. The complete assignments of the specific tyrosyl resonances were made based on the results of the differential chemical modification of the tyrosyl residues with tetranitromethane followed by peptide analysis, independently of the knowledge of the crystal structure. pKa values of Tyr-7, -75, and -93 were determined in a 2H2O solution to be 10.95, 11.8, and greater than or equal to 12.6, respectively, at 25 degrees C, whereas pKa values of nitrated Tyr-7 and -75 were determined to be 7.3 and 7.9, respectively. Tyr-93 was not nitratable under normal conditions. The strong resistance to nitration, together with the extremely high pKa value and the high-field shifted positions of the ring proton resonances of Tyr-93 at neutral pH, strongly suggests that Tyr-93 takes part in a hydrogen bonding as a proton donor. Tyr-7 is more easily modified with tetranitromethane than Tyr-75, although in the crystal Tyr-75 is more exposed than Tyr-7. The result, together with the pKa value of Tyr-75 significantly higher than that of a normal tyrosine, indicates that the microenvironment of Tyr-75 is more restricted in solution than in solid. These results imply that structural details of a protein may be quite similar in solution to those in the crystal in the rigid hydrophobic region of the protein but that in the surface region of the protein local structures may well differ between the solution and the crystal.

Amino Acids↗

Proton nuclear magnetic resonance evidence for the absence of a stable hydrogen bond between the active site aspartate and histidine residues of native subtilisins and for its presence in thiolsubtilisins.

The very low field proton nuclear magnetic resonance (1H NMR) found in aqueous solutions of serine proteases and their zymogens is characteristic of the hydrogen bond between the imidazolium and aspartate groups of the catalytic triad: Ser-His-Asp [Robillard, G., & Shulman, R. G. (1972) J. Mol. Biol. 71, 507--511]. According to 1H correlation NMR spectroscopic studies performed in 80/20 (v/v) H2O/2H2O, no such resonance is found in native subtilisins (even at -2 degrees C and pH 6.0), but it is present in thiolsubtilisins and in the phenylboronic acid derivatives of the serine enzymes. The resonance was not visible in the mercuric or carboxamidomethyl derivatives of the thiol enzymes or in the phenylboronic acid--serine enzyme complex if the serine enzyme was first acylated with phenylmethanesulfonyl fluoride. The histidine at the catalytic site of thiolsubtilisin carries a positive charge between pH 5.6 and 8.4, in accord with previous data in favor of a mercaptide--imidazolium ion pair at the catalytic site. The charge distribution (- + -) at the active site of thiolsubtilisin and in the phenylboronic acid derivatives of the serine enzymes resembles that in the tetrahedral transition state formed between a serine enzyme and its substrate. Therefore, the stable hydrogen bond (found in the thiol enzyme and in the phenylboronic acid derivative of the serine enzyme) should be more important during catalysis than in the substrate-free enzyme.

Aspartic Acid↗