PubMed · 6705756
The source did not provide an abstract. Follow the original record for more information.
Explore connections, maps & timelines
D M DeMarini, M D Shelby. 1984. Test data--how much is not enough?. https://doi.org/10.1002/em.2860060202
Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.
KEEP EXPLORING
The ability of a TA7000 series of Salmonella his- mutant tester strains to detect mutagens as classified by the traditional tester strains (TA100, TA98, TA1535, TA1537, TA97, TA102 and TA104) was evaluated using 30 coded chemicals, 5 of which were duplicates with different code numbers. The TA7000 series of tester strains were TA7001, TA7002, TA7003, TA7004, TA7005 and TA7006, each of which reverts by a specific base substitution. In addition, each chemical was tested in a mixture of the base-specific strains (the Mix), plus the traditional strains, TA98 and TA1537. A liquid version of the Salmonella mutagenicity assay was performed in microtiter plates to allow partial automation for increased throughput. The results were compared to those in the National Toxicology Program (NTP) database, which were obtained from the traditional strains in the preincubation assay. In the two strains common to both protocols, TA98 and TA1537, the agreement was 80% and 85%, respectively. When compared to the NTP results for TA100, the Mix gave a 72% concordance, while the addition of the frameshift tester strain, TA98, increased the agreement to 76%. The overall agreement on positive or negative classifications of mutagenicity was 88% for the 25 chemicals tested. There were three notable exceptions to the overall agreement. Benzaldehyde was detected as a mutagen in TA7005 in contrast to its classification as a non-mutagen in the NTP database. This does not necessarily contradict the NTP results because the base-specific strains may respond to different mutagens. Two weak mutagens in the NTP database, 1-chloro-2-propanol and isobutyl nitrite, were not detected as mutagens in the base-specific new strains in the liquid protocol. While there are a number of major differences in the two assays, it was concluded that the results from each procedure are comparable.
The present study documents the mutagenicity of a new National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) standard reference material (SRM) in the Salmonella plate incorporation assay. This study is in response to a previous recommendation by the World Health Organization to develop large batches of new SRMs for biological and chemical research. SRM 1975 is a dichloromethane (DCM) extract of 5.6 kg of filter-collected combustion particulate matter (SRM 2975) from operating forklifts with diesel engines. The mutagenicity and a summary of the related chemical analysis of mutagens in SRM 1975 is presented in this paper, and are available from the NIST. Mutagenicity test conditions were: Salmonella typhimurium TA98, TA100 (standard strains); TA98NR, TA100NR (nitroreductase (NR) gene deficient); and YG1021 and YG1026 (NR gene addition); 10 dose levels in the linear portion of the dose-response curve; duplicate plates per dose; and S9 at 6.4% or 1.1 mg of protein/plate. Four rounds of testing were conducted. Rounds were conducted at least 1 week apart. Slopes (revertants/microg) were calculated by the linear regression rejection model of Bernstein and by the Stead and Krewski models which analyze non-linear data. The GeneTox Manager software package developed at the EPA was used to record the data and calculate the slopes. Results demonstrated: (1) the ranking of slopes without S9 was: YG1021 > TA98 > TA98NR > YG1026 > TA100 > TA100NR in all three statistical models; (2) the mutagenic activity of SRM 1975 was significantly increased by the presence of the NR gene; (3) the slope values for the TA100 series were significantly less than for the TA98 series; (4) in general, the addition of the S9 significantly reduced mutagenic activity; (5) the mutagenic activity of the SRM 1975 was stable over time and variability was low (generally less than 20% in slope values over the 4 rounds); and (6) agreement of the slope values among the three models was excellent due to the linear nature of the data. These data will be useful in ranking other diesel and air samples for mutagenic activity, for quality assurance of data generated in different laboratories, for quality control within a laboratory, and as positive control values for future air and automotive emission studies.
ts1 is a mutation which causes a general increase in permeability of Sacharomyces cerevisiae cells in an unspecific manner. The introduction of the ts1 mutation under homozygous conditions into the D7 diploid strain enhanced the sensitivity of the test system described by Zimmermann et al. (1975). The newly constructed strain D7ts1 responded with a four to six times higher frequency compared to the D7 strain for all genetic end-points induced with chemical mutagens (ethyl methanesulfonate, methyl methanesulfonate, hydroxyurea, benzpyrene). The increased sensitivity of D7ts1 is specific only for mutagens active in yeast, since treatment of D7ts1 cells with 5-bromouracil or 5-bromouridine, known to be non-mutagenic in yeast, did not result in the induction of any of the measured genetic alterations. Five out of 14 water samples taken from the environment induced recombinogenic events in D7ts1, whereas all 14 water samples were without effect in the D7 test system. We concluded that D7ts1 cells show a higher sensitivity in the detection of mutagenic or carcinogenic action because of their generally enhanced permeability due to the ts1 mutation.