Smoking Cue Reactivity in Relation to Uncertain-Threat and Reward-Anticipation Networks: A Coordinate-Based fMRI Meta-Analysis.

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Smoking is a concerning medical and social problem, yet how the brain links stress to continued smoking is still not well understood. This coordinate-based meta-analysis identified convergent activations for smoking cues, uncertain threat, and reward anticipation, and examined co-activation patterns to clarify whether smoking-cue activity in smokers relates to threat and reward activity in non-addicted controls. METHODS: We conducted a coordinate-based activation likelihood estimation (ALE) meta-analysis of 102 fMRI studies (N = 3,068), including 30 studies on smoking cue reactivity (n = 945), 48 on reward anticipation (n = 1,413), and 24 on uncertain threat processing (n = 1,621). We performed single, conjunction, and contrast analyses, followed by meta-analytic connectivity modeling (MACM) of key regions. RESULTS: Single analysis revealed smoking engaged bilateral ACC (-1.1, 46.2, -1.1), uncertain threat engaged bilateral insula (left = -33.6, 22, 4.3, right = 41.3, 22, 1), reward anticipation activated thalamus (0.9, 1.3, -3.1) and medial frontal gyrus (2.7, 6.6, 52.1). Conjunction and contrast analyses showed shared or unique activation for each task in its respective regions. MACM showed ACC co-activation with thalamus and medial frontal gyrus, while insula co-activated with ACC and inferior frontal gyrus. CONCLUSIONS: Each process converged in a separate region, with no overlap between the smoking-cue map and either the threat or reward map. The ACC nonetheless co-activated with reward-related regions and shared network membership with the threat-related insula. On this basis we hypothesize a shift in motivation from stress-driven reward toward cue-driven craving, to be tested within subjects, and identify candidate neuromodulation targets for preventing stress-precipitated relapse.