Introgression shapes the genomic conflict landscape of Malus, providing evidence for a reticulate backbone in a woody crop lineage.

Abstract

Phylogenomic discordance is widespread across plants, but its evolutionary significance is often obscured when conflict is treated primarily as analytical noise rather than as evidence of underlying processes. In woody lineages in particular, incomplete lineage sorting, introgression, and genome duplication can interact over long timescales to produce complex genomic histories that are not adequately summarized by a strictly bifurcating tree. Here, we use Malus as a model woody genus to investigate how these processes structure conflict across a genus-scale, accession-based phylogenomic framework. Using broad taxon sampling, hundreds of nuclear loci, plastid genomes, and genome-wide SNP summaries, we reconstruct a robust nuclear backbone for sampled Malus lineages and evaluate where discordance is concentrated and which processes best explain it. Nuclear analyses resolve eight major clades, whereas conflict is non-random and localized to recurrent hotspots rather than evenly distributed across the tree. Cytonuclear discordance is similarly concentrated, especially around Clade H, represented by sampled accessions of M. tschonoskii, where localized plastid-nuclear disagreement is consistent with candidate plastid capture or organellar introgression. Multiple complementary analyses further indicate that the strongest conflict is not explained by ILS alone, but instead reflects lineage-structured introgression, while polyploid complexes represent additional localized sources of evolutionary complexity. Together, these results provide evidence for a reticulate genomic backbone in Malus and show how integrating nuclear, plastid, and genome-wide conflict analyses can help distinguish background discordance from process-specific signals in woody plant radiations. Several lineage-level reticulation hypotheses identified here should now be tested with broader population-level sampling and curated reference accessions.