Search PubMed⌕ Search
Home/Archive/PubMed

PubMed · 42517628

No phenotypic resistance observed for most group-3 and -4 variants in Mycobacterium tuberculosis genes related to bedaquiline, clofazimine, delamanid, and pretomanid in a Central and West African context.

Faridath Massou·Klaas Dewaele·Anderson Gnamy·Ramata Balde·Wim Mulders·Conor J Mehan·Bouke C de Jong·Dissou Affolabi·Oren Tzfadia·Leen Rigouts
View original source ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

The interpretation of genetic variants' association (or not) with phenotypic resistance to newly introduced and repurposed antituberculosis drugs remains challenging, as many mutations detected by whole-genome sequencing (WGS) are classified as of uncertain significance (group 3) or not associated with resistance-interim (group 4) by the World Health Organization (WHO) mutation catalog v2. We evaluated the phenotypic impact of such variants on minimum inhibitory concentrations (MICs) for bedaquiline (BDQ), clofazimine (CFZ), delamanid (DLM), and pretomanid (PA) in Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex isolates from the multi-country DIAMA cohort in sub-Saharan Africa (SSA), which recruited RR/RS-TB patients naïve to these drugs. Among 1,475 isolates with available WGS data, 163 variants met eligibility criteria; due to viable strain unavailability, 89 isolates carrying 29 unique BDQ/CFZ-related and 60 unique DLM/PA-related variants were tested for MIC determination using broth microdilution. Additional structural modeling was performed to explore potential effects of amino-acid substitutions on protein stability. Among BDQ/CFZ-related variants, MICs above the critical concentrations (CCs) were consistently associated with mmpR5 variants, whereas variants in atpE, pepQ, and Rv1979c were not. DLM/PA variants (ddn, fbiA-D, and fgd1) were frequently detected as non-fixed populations, yet rarely yielding MIC values above the CC. Predicted structural destabilization showed no consistent association with MIC values or variant fixation status. Under the conditions tested, phenotypic resistance was not detected for most group 3 and 4 variants detected by WGS. Our data provide evidence from SSA to support improved interpretation of resistance-associated mutations for new and repurposed antituberculosis drugs.IMPORTANCEWhole-genome sequencing increasingly detects Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex mutations classified by the World Health Organization (WHO) mutation catalog v2 as group 3 variants of uncertain significance or group 4 variants not associated with resistance-interim, limiting reliable prediction of resistance to new and repurposed antituberculosis drugs. By generating minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC) data for such variants identified in a multi-country sub-Saharan African cohort, this study provides phenotypic evidence to support future refinement and expansion of the WHO mutation catalog v2. Notably, mmpR5 variants associated with elevated bedaquiline/clofazimine MICs were identified in eight isolates, suggesting that some patients in this cohort may have harbored pre-existing resistance-associated variants yet remained potentially eligible for bedaquiline-containing regimens. These findings contribute to improving the interpretation of genomic resistance data and strengthening surveillance of resistance to bedaquiline, clofazimine, delamanid, and pretomanid.

Explore related subjects

Mycobacterium tuberculosisAntitubercular AgentsMicrobial Sensitivity TestsNitroimidazolesHumansDiarylquinolinesClofazimineOxazolesWhole Genome SequencingAfrica, WesternMutationAfrica, CentralPhenotypeDrug Resistance, Bacterialminimum inhibitory concentrationwhole-genome sequencingJournal Article

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Faridath Massou, Klaas Dewaele, Anderson Gnamy, Ramata Balde, Wim Mulders, Conor J Mehan, Bouke C de Jong, Dissou Affolabi, Oren Tzfadia, Leen Rigouts. 2026-07-28. No phenotypic resistance observed for most group-3 and -4 variants in Mycobacterium tuberculosis genes related to bedaquiline, clofazimine, delamanid, and pretomanid in a Central and West African context.. https://doi.org/10.1128/spectrum.02005-26

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related citations

PubMed2026

Patterns of Drug Resistance, Drug Resistance Conferring Mutations and Genomic DNA Methylation Revealed in Mycobacterium tuberculosis From South Africa.

Tuberculosis remains a major public health threat globally, with drug-resistant strains undermining treatment efficacy. We analyzed 126 Mycobacterium tuberculosis (M. tuberculosis) isolates with diverse drug resistance spectra and selected 35 for whole genome sequencing (WGS) using Illumina NextSeq, SMRT PacBio Onso and SMRT PacBio Revio sequencing platforms. The study aimed to characterize drug resistance profiles, compare short- and long-read sequencing performance, identify lineages among South African isolates, detect known drug resistance mutations and their lineage-specific patterns, and utilize long-read SMRT platforms for epigenetic profiling. Multiple drug resistance mutations were identified, some lineage-specific, and notably, East-African-Indian (EAI) Lineage 1 isolates often considered less pathogenic, showed significant potential for multidrug-resistance development, including higher fluoroquinolone resistance as compared to other lineages. Three DNA motifs with methylated adenines, namely CACGCaG, CtCCaG and GaTNNNNRtAC, were detected, with methylation patterns varying by lineage and strain due to mutations in the corresponding methyltransferases (MTases). A particularly notable finding was the stable maintenance of a genetic heterogeneity in the mamB MTase, performing methylation at CACGCaG motifs. These results highlight the combined role of genetic and epigenetic variation in M. tuberculosis adaptive evolution and underscore the value of integrating long-read sequencing into TB surveillance and research.

Mycobacterium tuberculosis↗
PubMed2026

Phylogenetic inconsistency of pairwise SNP clustering for inferring tuberculosis transmission in a high-burden, endemic setting: a case study from Thailand.

Whole-genome sequence analysis is now widely used to delineate tuberculosis transmission clusters. A standard practice is to cluster bacterial isolates based on a fixed maximum genome-wide pairwise single nucleotide polymorphism (pwSNP) distance threshold. In this study, we evaluated the phylogenetic consistency of pwSNP-distance clustering with thresholds ranging between 1 and 25 single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) using two contrasting data sets: (i) a data set from the UK (N = 390) published by T. M. Walker, C. L. C. Ip, R. H. Harrell, J. T. Evans, et al. (Lancet Infect Dis 13:137-146, 2013, https://doi.org/10.1016/S1473-3099(12)70277-3), which was foundational to the establishment of this method, and (ii) a data set from Thailand (N = 3,341), characterized by persistent transmission and sparse, non-systematic sampling. For the UK data set, the standard pwSNP-distance clustering using thresholds of &#x2265;12 SNPs yielded entirely monophyletic clusters and showed high concordance with a comparative monophyly constrained, tree-based method. In contrast, for the Thai data set, pwSNP-distance clustering often generated non-monophyletic clusters, even by the 25-SNP threshold. The pwSNP-distance and comparative tree-based clustering methods only showed large consistency at thresholds of &#x2265;22 SNPs. This suggests that SNP clusters defined by low distance thresholds (i.e., <12 SNPs for the UK data set, and <22 SNPs for the Thai data set) may lack robustness, and the problem is particularly severe for data sets characterized by persistent transmission, likely due to poorer cluster separation. Moreover, our findings indicate that large cluster sizes, high maximum intra-cluster genetic distances, and broad sample collection time spans may serve as useful indicators of potentially non-monophyletic clusters. We also demonstrate that mixed infections can produce spurious, phylogenetically long-range SNP linkages, underscoring the necessity of strict sequence quality control.IMPORTANCEFixed-threshold pairwise single nucleotide polymorphism (pwSNP)-distance clustering is commonly used to delineate tuberculosis transmission clusters. From an epidemiological perspective, a genuine transmission cluster must be monophyletic, originating from a single source. However, pwSNP-distance clustering is inherently simplistic and can therefore violate this principle, making the assessment of its phylogenetic consistency critical. Our results demonstrate that while this method effectively delineated complete transmission clusters for the data set from the UK, a low-burden and non-persistent transmission setting, it frequently generated non-monophyletic clusters when applied to the Thai data set, characterized by persistent transmission alongside sparse and non-systematic sampling. Furthermore, we found that clusters derived using low distance thresholds could notably vary between the pwSNP-distance and comparative tree-based clustering methods, suggesting limited reliability and robustness. To accurately delineate tuberculosis transmission clusters, especially for complex data from high-burden, endemic settings, we recommend transitioning from pwSNP-distance clustering toward more robust, phylogenetic clustering that respects evolutionary descent.

Mycobacterium tuberculosis↗
PubMed2026

Clinical performance of the Abbott RealTime Mycobacterium tuberculosis (MTB) PCR on bronchoscopic specimens for diagnosing pulmonary tuberculosis.

PURPOSE: We evaluated the performance of the Abbott RealTime Mycobacterium tuberculosis (MTB) PCR (RT MTB) on bronchoscopic specimens using conventional culture as the reference standard in a low-Tuberculosis (TB) prevalence setting. METHODS: A total of 6,988 specimens (4,682 bronchial aspirates [BAS] and 2,306 bronchoalveolar lavages [BAL]) from 4,118 patients with suspected pulmonary TB were included. When BAS and BAL specimens from the same bronchoscopy procedure were available, these were mixed 1:1 prior to culture inoculation and PCR testing. Following processing, specimens were inoculated into a L&#xf6;wenstein-Jensen and a Bactec MGIT 960 tube and incubated at 37&#xa0;&#xb0;C for 3 months and at 35&#xa0;&#xb0;C for 8 weeks, respectively. RT MTB was performed as indicated by the manufacturer. RT MTB targets the insertion sequence IS6110 and the protein antigen B (PAB) gene, both highly conserved within the Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex. Whole genome Next generation sequencing of clinical MTBC isolates was performed when indicated. RESULTS: Among the 104 culture-positive specimens, 84 (1.2%) were detected by PCR. Additionally, 16 specimens (0.3% of all samples), from 16 patients, were PCR-positive despite negative culture results. Conversely, 20 specimens (0.4% of all samples), from 19 patients, were culture-positive but not detected by PCR. No significant differences were found between PCR-positive and PCR-negative specimens with respect to the number of IS6110 copies per isolate or PAB gene sequences (P&#x2009;=&#x2009;0.69). Finally, there were 4,683 specimens (97.4%) from the remaining 4,014 patients tested PCR-negative/Culture-negative. Following the resolution of discrepancies based on clinical grounds the sensitivity and specificity of RT MTB were 83.9% (CI 95%, 76.0-90.0) and 99.9% (CI 95%, 99.9-99.9), respectively. These results exceed the minimum performance requirements defined in the WHO Target Product Profiles for molecular TB diagnostics. Although RT MTB is not a point-of-care test but rather a moderate-complexity automated NAAT, it is recommended by WHO as part of the Abbott RealTime MTB/MTB RIF-INH testing algorithm, in which MTBC detection by RT MTB is followed by reflex testing with the MTB RIF/INH assay for detection of rifampicin and isoniazid resistance. CONCLUSION: RT MTB shows a good performance on bronchoscopic specimens.

Mycobacterium tuberculosis↗