Weight-bearing locomotion mitigates the progression of post-traumatic knee osteoarthritis in male rodents: A systematic review and meta-analysis.

Abstract

OBJECTIVE: Although knee post-traumatic osteoarthritis (PTOA) has been associated with altered loading, how weight-bearing (WB) activities should be modulated post-injury to preserve knee health remains unknown. This systematic review and meta-analysis examined the effects of WB locomotion on knee PTOA in rodents to provide insight into potential clinical implications. DESIGN: Studies published in PubMed, Cochrane Library, Embase, and CINAHL through 02/2025 and meeting the following criteria were included: 1) rodents with knee PTOA, 2) compared locomotor exercises (treadmill/wheel) to no exercise, 3) outcome measures of PTOA (OARSI/Mankin OA scores, bone quality, osteophyte condition, cartilage quality/morphology). If significant heterogeneity across studies was observed, locomotion speed, time/number of intervention sessions, frequency and duration of intervention, exercise initiation, follow-up time, animal species, PTOA model were analyzed as potential moderator variables that may influence findings. RESULTS: Twenty-two studies met the criteria, resulting in a total of 156 effect sizes (ESs) for meta-analysis (all males). A positive ES denotes less PTOA. Based on the CAMARADES checklist, 5 studies were ranked low risk of bias and 14 studies were ranked moderate risk of bias. Locomotion significantly reduced PTOA severity evaluated using OARSI/Mankin scores (ES=0.927, 95% CI: [0.590, 1.264]) and improved bone quality (ES=0.379, 95% CI: [-0.023, 0.780]) with substantial heterogeneity across studies. Follow-up analyses indicated that greater ESs for reducing OA scores were associated with a shorter duration of each training session, more training sessions, longer intervention duration, and longer follow-up time (all P≤0.004). Greater ESs for improving bone quality were associated with a longer follow-up time and later exercise initiation post-injury (both P≤0.014). Locomotion resulted in small to moderate but non-significant positive effects for isolated measures assessing osteophyte condition (ES=0.379, 95% CI: [-0.023, 0.780]), cartilage quality (ES=0.430, 95% CI: [-0.034, 0.893]), and cartilage morphology (ES=0.464, 95% CI: [-0.006, 0.934]). CONCLUSION: WB locomotion reduced the overall degree of knee PTOA in male rodents. Composite knee OA scores may be more responsive to exercise interventions than isolated cartilage/osteophyte measures. The benefits of locomotion may be more prominent with a longer follow-up time or with exercise protocols consisting of shorter but more individual sessions and longer overall intervention durations.