Defining alarm thresholds for the load of pathogenic viruses in wastewater for decision making: An application to three French cities.

Olivier Schlosser; Sophie Courtois; Philippe Bryche; Clotilde Fressinet; Nicolas Revel; Jean-Fran&#xe7;ois Loret

doi:10.1016/j.ijheh.2025.114563

Home/Archive/PubMed

PubMed · 40090160

Defining alarm thresholds for the load of pathogenic viruses in wastewater for decision making: An application to three French cities.

Olivier Schlosser·Sophie Courtois·Philippe Bryche·Clotilde Fressinet·Nicolas Revel·Jean-François Loret

View original source ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

Wastewater monitoring has the potential to complement infectious disease surveillance systems. However, the absence of predefined viral signal thresholds in wastewater is often presented as a limiting factor in triggering public health action. To overcome this issue, the feasibility of defining alarm threshold for viral loads in wastewater samples was assessed by quantifying genome fragments of SARS-CoV-2, influenza A virus (IAV), respiratory syncytial virus (RSV), norovirus (NoV), and rotavirus (RoV) by RT-digital PCR (dPCR) in untreated wastewater samples from three treatment plants. Cut-point values were calculated for periods with a high rate of visits to emergency rooms or at-home visits by SOS Médecins for the related diseases. ROC curves were constructed, and the values of alarm threshold in wastewater were defined using the Youden index. For each targeted virus, alarm thresholds were close to each other across the three WWTPs. As indicated by likelihood ratios, evidence to rule in the diagnosis of high rate of visits when the alarm threshold was exceeded ranged from weak to strong and was highest for RSV and SARS-CoV-2. Evidence to rule out the diagnosis when the alarm threshold was not exceeded was strong or moderate for IAV, SARS-CoV-2 and RSV. Diagnostic performance of the test was not as high for NoV and RoV. Positive predictive value was highest for SARS-CoV-2 and RSV. For SARS-CoV-2 and RSV, the definition of an alarm threshold in wastewater could substantially inform the diagnosis of a period with a high rate of medical visits for COVID-19 and bronchiolitis, respectively.

Explore related subjects

Wastewater SARS-CoV-2 France Humans Viral Load COVID-19 Cities Decision Making Environmental Monitoring Norovirus Influenza A virus Alarm threshold Early warning Enteric viruses Public health Respiratory viruses Surveillance Journal Article Research Support, Non-U.S. Gov't

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeX RIS

Olivier Schlosser, Sophie Courtois, Philippe Bryche, Clotilde Fressinet, Nicolas Revel, Jean-François Loret. 2025-03-15. Defining alarm thresholds for the load of pathogenic viruses in wastewater for decision making: An application to three French cities.. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijheh.2025.114563

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related citations

PubMed2026

The COVID-19 pandemic influenced the temporal dynamics of antimicrobial resistance markers and bacterial community across urban wastewater treatment plants.

Urban wastewater systems represent important interfaces between human activity and the environmental occurrence of antimicrobial resistance (AMR) markers. We assessed the temporal dynamics of intI1, ermB, and the 16 S rRNA gene by quantitative PCR across three wastewater systems (EPC, CJC, and JW) in Fortaleza, Brazil, from November 2021 to November 2023. Bacterial communities were additionally characterized by 16 S rRNA gene metabarcoding in 18 samples collected in December 2021 and January 2022. A synchronized decline in 16 S rRNA gene and intI1 concentrations beginning in late 2022 was observed across all three wastewater systems, suggesting a shift toward lower microbial abundance. The ermB gene showed higher and more variable concentrations during part of the pandemic period, followed by convergence toward lower levels; however, the absence of antimicrobial-consumption data precluded attribution of this pattern to changes in macrolide selective pressure. Normalized antimicrobial resistance marker abundances were comparatively stable at EPC and JW but more variable at CJC. EPC exhibited the highest ASV richness, whereas CJC and JW showed greater diversity according to Shannon and inverse Simpson indices. Beta-diversity analyses identified wastewater system as the principal factor associated with bacterial community structure, while the effect of sampling period was smaller and metric-dependent. Neither ermB nor intI1 was individually associated with community composition, although intI1 showed a limited effect after adjustment for wastewater system in one model. Physicochemical parameters were not significantly associated with normalized marker abundances in the exploratory paired analysis. Arcobacter, Acinetobacter, and other potentially relevant genera were detected, but no direct associations between these taxa and the monitored AMR markers could be established. These findings highlight the value of integrating longitudinal qPCR, microbiome profiling, and environmental characterization to improve the interpretation of targeted AMR markers in One Health wastewater surveillance.

Wastewater↗

PubMed2026

Whole-genome sequencing of adenovirus 41 directly from wastewater using nested overlapping PCR and MinION.

Human adenovirus F41 (HAdV-F41) is one of the leading causes of children's acute gastroenteritis and was recently linked to an outbreak of severe acute hepatitis of unknown etiology among children during 2021 to 2022. While most evidence is based on clinical data, wastewater-based epidemiology offers a community-level approach to monitoring circulating strains and enhancing outbreak preparedness. In this study, we developed an overlapping amplicon-based whole-genome sequencing approach to directly detect HAdV-F41 from archived wastewater samples, using nested PCR with 13 primer sets. Archived wastewater samples were collected between 2021 and 2022 from three treatment plants in Seattle, USA. The viral load ranged from 1.2 × 103 to 8.4 × 103 genome copies per liter. The Oxford Nanopore platform was used for whole-genome sequencing. Complete or partial (>84%) HAdV-F41 genomes were recovered from wastewater samples, with mean coverage depths ranging from 10³ to 10⁵. The consensus sequences showed more than 99% similarity to reference genomes in the NCBI database. The phylogenetic analysis revealed that 2 sequences clustered within lineage 2a and 11 within lineage 2b, reflecting that at least two sub-lineages were circulating in the community at that time. Our results demonstrate that the overlapping amplicon-based whole-genome sequencing approach using the Oxford Nanopore platform reliably recovers HAdV-F41 genomes from wastewater. This method offers high-resolution genomic surveillance of circulating, clinically relevant HAdV-F41, supporting wastewater-based epidemiology as a valuable tool for detecting emerging variants and strengthening the early warning system for future disease outbreaks.IMPORTANCEHuman adenovirus F41 is a primary cause of childhood gastroenteritis and has been linked to recent outbreaks of severe acute hepatitis in children, yet community-level genomic surveillance of this virus remains limited. This study shows that wastewater can be used to recover nearly complete HAdV-F41 genomes through a targeted overlapping-amplicon sequencing strategy on the Oxford Nanopore platform. By applying this method to archived wastewater samples, we detected the simultaneous circulation of multiple viral lineages in a large city. These findings extend wastewater-based epidemiology beyond SARS-CoV-2 and emphasize its importance for monitoring clinically significant enteric viruses. The method described here offers a scalable tool for tracking viral evolution in communities and enhancing early warning systems for future outbreaks.

Wastewater↗

PubMed2026

Wastewater viromics reveals host-structured viral signals and non-human pathogens.

Wastewater represents a powerful platform for human virus surveillance. However, the entry of animal- and plant-associated viruses into sewage is heterogeneous and incompletely understood, creating uncertainty about how reliably wastewater reflects non-human virus circulation. Here, we address this by analysing monthly wastewater metagenomic data from two distinct periods (2020-2021 and 2024-2025) across five major Finnish wastewater treatment plant catchments using a targeted hybrid-capture approach to characterise the composition, host range, and spatial distribution of the non-human wastewater virome. Nearly half of the detected viral accessions were non-human, indicating substantial diversity, despite human-associated viruses accounting for 83% of normalised viral reads. Rodent-, livestock-, and bird-associated viruses showed spatial structuring consistent with regional host populations. The wastewater viromics also detected four EU-regulated plant pathogens, including tomato brown rugose fruit virus, which was highly prevalent in wastewater two years before its first official detection in Finland. Together, these results show that wastewater contains structured, host-linked viral signals, supporting its use as an ecological proxy for non-human virus circulation.

Wastewater↗