Pursuit of a paradigm for professional progress.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Biomedical subjects
Publications and source records attributed to Ralph V Clayman.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
BACKGROUND: To assist practicing urologists incorporate laparoscopic urology into their practice, a 5-day mini-residency (M-R) program with a mentor, preceptor, and proctor experience was established at the University of California, Irvine, and we report the initial results. STUDY DESIGN: Thirty-two urologists underwent laparoscopic ablative (n=17) or laparoscopic reconstructive (n=15) training, including inanimate model skills training, animal laboratory, and operating room observation. A questionnaire was mailed 1 to 15 months (mean, 8 months) after their M-R program, and responses were reviewed. RESULTS: A 100% response rate was achieved. The mean M-R participant age was 49 years (range 31 to 70 years). The majority of the participants (72%) had laparoscopic experience during residency training and had performed between 5 and 15 laparoscopic cases before attending the M-R program. Within 8 months after M-R, 26 participants (81%) were practicing laparoscopic surgery. Participants were performing laparoscopic radical nephrectomy (p=0.008), nephroureterectomy (p<0.0005), and pyeloplasty (p=0.008) at substantially higher rates after training. At the same time, fewer of the M-R participants were performing hand-assisted laparoscopic surgery after training (p=0.008) compared with before the M-R. Ninety-two percent of the participants indicated that they would recommend this training program to a colleague. CONCLUSIONS: A 5-day intensive laparoscopic ablative and reconstructive surgery course seems to encourage postgraduate urologists, already familiar with laparoscopy, to successfully expand the scope of their procedures to include more complex laparoscopic techniques such as nephrectomy, nephroureterectomy, and pyeloplasty into their clinical practice.
BACKGROUND: We present initial data on the construct, content, and face validity of the LAPMentor (Simbionix), virtual reality laparoscopic surgical simulator. STUDY DESIGN: Medical students (MS), residents and fellows (R/F), and experienced laparoscopic surgeons (ES), with < 30 laparoscopic cases per year (ES<30) and those with > 30 laparoscopic cases per year (ES>30), were tested on 9 basic skill tasks (SK) including manipulation of 0-degree and 30-degree cameras (SK1, SK2), eye-hand coordination (SK3), clipping (SK4), grasping and clipping (SK5), two-handed maneuvers (SK6), cutting (SK7), fulguration (SK8), and object-translocation (SK9). RESULTS: Mean MS (n=23), R/F (n=24), ES<30 (n=26), and ES>30 (n=30) ages were 26 years (range 21 to 32 years), 31 years (range 27 to 39 years), 49 years (range 31 to 70 years) and 47 years (range 34 to 69 years), respectively. In the lower level skill tasks (SK3, SK4, SK5, and SK6) the ES>30, ES<30, and R/F had similar scores, but were all substantially better than the MS scores. In the higher level skill tasks (SK7, SK8, and SK9), the ES>30 scores tended to be better than the R/F and ES<30, which were similar, and these, in turn, were markedly better than the MS. The ES>30 had notably higher SK8 scores than the R/F and ES<30, who had similar scores, and these had notably better scores than the MS. CONCLUSIONS: The noncamera skills (SK3 to 9) of the LAPMentor surgical simulator can distinguish between laparoscopically naive and ES. SK8 showed the highest level of construct validity, by accurately differentiating among the MS, R/F, ES<30 and ES>30.
PURPOSE: We determined the current status of residency training in laparoscopic and robotic surgery in the United States and Canada. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A total of 1,188 surveys were sent via the Internet to all 1,056 current urology residents and 132 program directors with an Internet address registered with the American Urological Association. RESULTS: Responses were received from 372 residents (35%) and 56 program directors (42%). Of respondents 47% reported greater than 100 laparoscopic procedures performed yearly by 1 (36%) or more (51%) faculty members. Robotic procedures were performed at 54% of the institutions, mainly consisting of prostatectomy and pyeloplasty. At all institutions laparoscopic radical nephrectomy was performed and those at 69% of the institutions believed that it is the gold standard for renal tumors today. Urologists were involved in 87% of adrenal surgeries and 54% of respondents believed that is the gold standard approach. However, only 35% of respondents had participated in laparoscopic adrenalectomy. Of respondents 36%, 42% and 17% reported that laparoscopic donor nephrectomy was performed by only urologists, only a nonurology transplant team and shared equally, respectively. Of respondents 41% planned on performing laparoscopic donor nephrectomy in the next year. Laparoscopic needle ablation renal surgery was done in 51% of the programs and percutaneous needle ablation was done in 63%. None of the respondents (0%) believed that it is the gold standard but 51% believed that ablative procedures look promising for renal tumors. Of respondents 39% had participated in robotic radical prostatectomy and 53% thought that it looked promising but was not the gold standard. Of respondents 31% believed that they will be performing robotic surgery after residency, 30% were unsure and 29% will not be using the robot. Overall 38% of residents thought that their laparoscopic experience was at least average or acceptable. CONCLUSIONS: A large number of laparoscopic urological procedures are being performed at training institutions with robotic procedures being performed at 54% of respondent facilities. Residents are participating in most cases but only 38% consider their laparoscopic experience to be satisfactory. A need still exists for increased laparoscopic training for residents, which can be accomplished by expanding training facilities and increasing the number of faculty members performing laparoscopic procedures.
OBJECTIVES: To report our single institutional experience of laparoscopic partial nephrectomy (LPN) for enhancing renal masses and evaluate outcomes and histopathologic findings with respect to the location of the renal mass. METHODS: A retrospective review of LPN for 123 renal masses completed by 7 urologists was performed. Of these lesions, 49 (40%) were exophytic, 19 (15.5%) endophytic, 47 (38%) mesophytic, and 8 (6.5%) were hilar. We defined exophytic as more than 60%, mesophytic as 40% to 60%, and endophytic as less than 40% of the renal mass protruding off the surface of the kidney on radiologic imaging studies. Hilar lesions were those located within 5 mm of the renal hilar structures, regardless of the surface characteristics. RESULTS: The mean tumor size was 2.6 cm (range 1 to 9). Hilar vessel clamping was performed during 55 procedures (44.7%); the mean warm ischemia time was 27 minutes (range 12 to 52). On final histopathologic examination, 3 patients (2.5%) had positive tumor resection margins. Overall, 26 (20.6%) complications occurred. The complication rate was significantly less for patients who underwent LPN for an exophytic (10%) or a mesophytic (12.8%) mass than for those with an endophytic (47%) or a hilar (50%) mass. Histopathologic examination of the renal masses revealed malignant pathologic features in 86 (69%) and benign findings in 37 (31%). In our series, only 55% of exophytic tumors were malignant and, if malignant, were invariably low grade (96%). CONCLUSIONS: The complications of LPN and the malignancy rate of the renal lesions were related to the tumor location within the kidney.
Management of the small renal mass (< or = 3 cm) is a topic of significant debate among urologists worldwide. With the advent of needle-based therapies and, less frequently, reports of extracorporeal approaches, along with ongoing refinements in each technology, patients with such masses may have the option of being treated in a truly minimally invasive, or even noninvasive, manner. Herein we review the body of available clinical literature on these modalities with respect to patient selection, success and complication rates, follow-up information, energy delivery devices, and current probe configurations.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: An objective evaluation of innate ability and its ability to predict potential success as a surgical trainee is an appealing concept for the selection process of residency applications. The objective of this study was to evaluate whether basic elements of performance (BEP) could discriminate among resident applicants and urologists with various extents of surgical experience. SUBJECTS AND METHODS: One hundred forty-five participants were divided into four study groups: group A, 57 urology residency applicants to the 2002 and 2003 interview process; group B, 8 post-internship urology residents; group C, 19 urologists tested with BEP within 10 years of graduation from their residency training program; and group D, 61 urologists who had graduated from their residency training program more than 10 years prior to testing. The BEP measures consisted of 13 basic performance resources (BPR) including visual-information processing speed, visual-spatial immediate-recall capacity, and neuromotor channel capacity. RESULTS: The four study groups differed significantly in their mean age: group A=27.6 years, group B=29.1 years, group C=37.1 years, and group D=48.9 years (P<0.0005). There was essentially no significant difference between the groups with regard to immediate-recall memory, reaction time simple, or reaction time complicated. The younger participants (groups A and B) were faster than the older surgeons (groups C and D) (P<0.02). However, the older surgeons (groups C and D) were significantly more accurate than the younger groups (A and B) (P<0.0005). The only sex differences noted were in hand-grip strength and shoulder-strength scores, which were all higher in the men. CONCLUSIONS: There generally appears to be a lack of direct correlation between innate abilities and surgical experience. Urology resident applicants with no surgical experience and urology residents with limited surgical experience are faster but less accurate in innate skills testing than experienced practicing urologists.
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: The traditional method of acquiring surgical skills is by apprenticeship and involves an extensive period of training with patients. Model-based and virtual reality simulation is gaining interest as alternative training, allowing repetitive practice in a low-risk environment. The objective of this study was to determine if a materials, model-based training format and an interactive virtual-reality simulator could provide equivalent teaching of basic ureteroscopy skills to the inexperienced medical student. SUBJECTS AND METHODS: Sixteen first-year medical students received the same didactic session and video viewing on cystoscopy, guidewire access to the upper urinary tract, and ureteroscopy with intracorporeal laser lithotripsy and stone extraction by the same instructor. The participants were then randomized into two study groups: Group 1 was trained on the ureteroscopy training model (TMU) from Limbs & Things and Group 2 on the Simbionix UROMentor virtual-reality simulator (VRS) until the participants could perform the procedure independently. Two months later, the participants independently performed a ureteroscopic procedure on a pig kidney/ureter model and were graded from 1 to 5 on their ability to complete the steps of the procedure and the quality of their performance (handling of tissue, efficiency, instrument handling, knowledge of instruments, flow of operation, use of assistants, and knowledge of the specific procedure) for a possible total of 35 points. RESULTS: All participants were able to perform the steps of the procedure correctly. The TMU group and the VRS group received a mean of 22.9 +/- 4.8 and 23.6 +/- 5.4 points, respectively (P = 0.38) for their qualitative assessment. CONCLUSION: The medical students' skills and ability to perform a basic ureteroscopic stone-management procedure was independent of the training modality (VRS or TMU). Incorporating either of these devices into the preliminary training of urology residents may improve their initial clinical performance of these skills.
Ureteral obstruction caused by extrinsic compression by a malignancy generally can be overcome initially with a ureteral stent. However, the long-term failure rate is high, usually necessitating placement of a nephrostomy tube. Herein, we present the initial case, in this country, of intractable ureteral obstruction managed successfully with the newly developed all-metal Resonance stent (Cook Ireland Ltd., Limerick, Ireland) constructed of MP35N alloy, a composite of nonmagnetic nickel-cobalt-chromium-molybdenum. The patient is a 64-year-old woman with metastatic breast cancer causing retroperitoneal fibrosis and ureteral obstruction diagnosed laparoscopically. The obstruction failed to respond to placement of a single 7F double-J stent and then of two 6F double-J stents in the left ureter. As a last resort, in order to avoid nephrostomy-tube placement, the 6F metal stent was placed; this provided unobstructed flow of urine, as documented on a subsequent Whitaker test and, most recently, on a renal scan, 4 months after initial stent placement.
Image-guided percutaneous nephrostomy tube placement can be a challenging procedure, particularly in a nondilated system or in the morbidly obese patient. Herein, we report the routine use of ureteroscopy-guided percutaneous renal access. With this method, rapid, accurate creation and dilation of the nephrostomy tract is assured in all patients regardless of body habitus or stone burden.
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Advances in electro-optics continue to improve the urologist's ability to perform minimally invasive procedures. While the development of flexible fiberoptic cystoscopes more than 20 years ago greatly impacted the practice of urology, distal-sensor digital technology may represent the next step in the evolution of endoscopy. We compared a new distal-sensor digital flexible cystoscope with two standard fiberoptic flexible cystoscopes. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We evaluated the resolution, contrast, and color discrimination of a new ACMIICN distal-sensor digital cystoscope with >165,000 effective pixels in its clear aperture (viewing area), a new ACMI-ACN II fiberoptic cystoscope with <15,000 pixels in its clear aperture, and a Storz 1127 office fiberoptic cystoscope. Five subjects compared each cystoscope across 13 test parameters. RESULTS: There was no difference in the performance of the two fiberoptic cystoscopes. The ICN cystoscope was statistically superior to one or both fiberoptic cystoscopes across 12 of the 13 tests, including color differentiation between shades of dark red (P < 0.05), contrast discrimination along a 15-step grayscale gradient (P < 0.001 compared with the 1127 fiberoptic cystoscope only), resolution at 10 mm (7.52 line pairs/mm [lp/mm] (ICN) nu 3.58 lp/mm for both fiberoptic cystoscopes; (P < 0.001), and clear resolution of a 1-mm target at a distance of 6.1 cm (ICN) nu 3.3 cm (1127) and 3.8 cm (ACN II) (P < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: The ICM distal-sensor all-digital cystoscope was clearly superior to two representative fiberoptic cystoscopes in vitro in terms of resolution, contrast discrimination, and red color differentiation. In-vivo performance remains to be assessed.
Postoperative rhabdomyolysis is a rare but serious complication of laparoscopic renal urologic surgery. The early recognition and treatment of the condition are imperative to minimize the risk of acute renal failure (ARF) and to limit the associated physical debility. Between 1992 and 2003, > 700 laparoscopic renal procedures were performed at 2 institutions. Rhabdomyolysis occurred in 7 patients. Patient records were retrospectively analyzed for operative, postoperative, and convalescence data. Rhabdomyolysis presented in all patients as excessive, immediate postoperative muscular pain in the "downside" hip/flank. The average procedure time among these patients was 7.5 hours (range, 5.8 to 9.4 hours). In 6 of 7 cases, the kidney rest was elevated throughout the procedure. Two patients required emergency fasciotomy to treat a gluteal compartment syndrome. Four patients (57%) experienced ARF with an average peak creatinine of 533.8 micromol/L [7.0 mg/dL] (range, 160.1 to 739.6 micromol/L [2.1 to 9.7 mg/dL]). These patients had bicarbonate alkalinization and diuretic administration initiated at a mean of 24 hours (range, 4 to 48 hours). Two patients required hemodialysis for 1 month postoperatively but had stable serum creatinine (106.8 and 129.6 micromol/L [1.4 and 1.7 mg/dL]) within 2 months. The mean peak serum creatinine kinase (CK) for all patients was 33,912 U/L (range, 9350 to 99,193 U/L). All patients had extended recovery with difficulties including lower extremity weakness (n = 4), local pressure neuropathy (n = 1), long-term leg pain and numbness (n = 1), and disability requiring long-term wheelchair assistance (n = 1). Excessive, immediate postlaparoscopic gluteal muscular pain should prompt immediate evaluation of serum CK to assess for rhabdomyolysis. Aggressive hydration and diuresis are recommended to minimize renal injury. Minimizing operative times, attention to padding of the operative table, and eliminating or limiting the use of a kidney rest may help prevent this complication.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.