Informed choice? Evidence of the persuasive power of professionals.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Biomedical subjects
Publications and source records attributed to R Johanson.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
BACKGROUND: The aim of the study was to evaluate the use of a democratic process for prioritizing the ASQUAM (Achieving Sustainable Quality in Maternity) clinical effectiveness programme. METHODS: Twenty-two improvements in the standards of maternity care were chosen as top-topic priorities at the 1996 and 1997 ASQUAM meetings. We wished to assess the relative priorities of local and national delegates, by comparing their voting patterns at the two meetings. The setting was North Staffordshire ASQUAM prioritization days, and the subjects were all the delegates at the 1996 and 1997 ASQUAM meetings. Main outcome measures were comparison of numbers of votes cast by local and national delegates for each of the 20 topics presented at the two ASQUAM meetings, and proportions of the 11 top-topics decided at each meeting that were chosen by local and national delegates. RESULTS: In 1996, significantly more local than national delegates voted for two topics related to maternal mortality or morbidity (incontinence and hypertensive diseases of pregnancy), but there were no statistically significant differences between the proportions of votes cast for any of the other 18 topics presented on the day. Indeed, local delegates had prioritized 11/11 of the final top-topics, and only one was omitted by the national delegates (10/11). In 1997, significantly more national than local delegates voted for three topics relating to professional stress levels, user involvement in working groups and antibiotic prophylaxis, but there were no statistically significant differences between the proportions of votes cast for any of the other 17 topics presented on the day. Again, local delegates had prioritized 11/11 of the final topics, with only one being omitted by the national delegates (10/11). CONCLUSION: There appeared to be a remarkable concordance between local and national delegates at both meetings, suggesting an underlying rationality to decision making. We believe this to be a reflection of the process of careful evaluation of outcome and intervention supported by the protection of a secret ballot, allowing free expression of individual's values.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
A placebo controlled trial of glyceryl trinitrate was carried out in women whose first attempt at external cephalic version without tocolysis had been unsuccessful. No significant differences between groups were found and no side effects were noted. It is recommended that a larger, possibly multicentre study, should be undertaken.
The objective of the study was to establish the frequency of depression during pregnancy and the puerperium, and its relationship to marital disharmony and sociodemographic variables. A prospective longitudinal study was carried out in a district general hospital in the West Midlands, UK. The cohort consisted of 417 women booked for confinement at the hospital. Depression was measured as a proportion of high scores (> 14) on the Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale (EPDS) and marital disharmony was determined by the Spanier Dyadic Adjustment Scale. Using recommended cut-offs, 41/417 (9.8%) of the women were depressed during pregnancy and 31/417 (7.4%) were depressed at 3 months postpartum. There was a significant association between antenatal and postnatal depression, seven of the 31 women who were depressed postpartum had also been depressed in the antenatal period. Only five of the 41 women with antenatal depression and eight of the 31 women with postnatal depression were identified by their general practitioners as depressed. Marital disharmony was sequentially associated with depression before and after delivery. We conclude that antenatal depression is more common than generally thought, and that both antenatal and postnatal depression are frequently missed during routine consultation. Pregnancy-associated depression is more common where marital disharmony exists. More widespread use of the EPDS during pregnancy may help to highlight these often unidentified mental health problems.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Operative vaginal delivery with the vacuum extractor or forceps is integral to the practice of obstetrics worldwide. The rates at which obstetricians in different countries intervene vary enormously. The wide range of operative vaginal delivery rates reported in the United Kingdom has been noted as a cause for concern. At a Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists consultants' conference, the participants of a discussion group were surveyed regarding their 'actual' and perceived 'optimal' operative vaginal delivery rate. The 'actual' operative vaginal delivery rate was 10.5% and the perceived 'optimal' was 8.7%. Given that there are approximately 600 000 births per annum in the UK, if the optimal delivery rate was achieved over 10 000 operative vaginal deliveries could be avoided, with significant reductions in maternal morbidity. Reductions could be achieved by examining practice at a number of points in the care pathway. Individual units should examine their practice to establish whether their guidelines and continuing education programmes reflect current knowledge of best practice.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the effectiveness of an educational visit to help obstetricians and midwives select and use evidence from a Cochrane database containing 600 systematic reviews. DESIGN: Randomised single blind controlled trial with obstetric units allocated to an educational visit or control group. SETTING: 25 of the 26 district general obstetric units in two former NHS regions. SUBJECTS: The senior obstetrician and midwife from each intervention unit participated in educational visits. Clinical practices of all staff were assessed in 4508 pregnancies. INTERVENTION: Single informal educational visit by a respected obstetrician including discussion of evidence based obstetrics, guidance on implementation, and donation of Cochrane database and other materials. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Rates of perineal suturing with polyglycolic acid, ventouse delivery, prophylactic antibiotics in caesarean section, and steroids in preterm delivery, before and 9 months after visits, and concordance of guidelines with review evidence for same marker practices before and after visits. RESULTS: Rates varied greatly, but the overall baseline mean of 43% (986/2312) increased to 54% (1189/2196) 9 months later. Rates of ventouse delivery increased significantly in intervention units but not in control units; there was no difference between the two types of units in uptake of other practices. Pooling rates from all 25 units, use of antibiotics in caesarean section and use of polyglycolic acid sutures increased significantly over the period, but use of steroids in preterm delivery was unchanged. Labour ward guidelines seldom agreed with evidence at baseline; this hardly improved after visits. Educational visits cost pound860 each (at 1995 prices). CONCLUSIONS: There was considerable uptake of evidence into practice in both control and intervention units between 1994 and 1995. Our educational visits added little to this, despite the informal setting, targeting of senior staff from two disciplines, and donation of educational materials. Further work is needed to define cost effective methods to enhance the uptake of evidence from systematic reviews and to clarify leadership and roles of senior obstetric staff in implementing the evidence.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
This review covers a selection of the important recently published papers that show enormous variations in obstetric intervention rates. It includes references to the forceps versus vacuum extractor controversy, discussing the controlled trial data as well as selected observational studies. Papers on new equipment and techniques of delivery are reviewed, although in the recent literature these are principally related to the vacuum extractor and not to forceps. Final discussion is made of methods of ensuring adequate training.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
OBJECTIVE: To establish the antihypertensive properties of intravenous nimodipine used to treat eclamptic patients. To assess the effects of intravenous nimodipine on oxygen delivery and consumption. DESIGN: A prospective observational study. SETTING: The Maternity Centre Obstetric Intensive Care Unit, Groote Schuur Hospital. PARTICIPANTS: Four unselected patients presenting with proteinuric hypertension and seizures. METHODS: Haemodynamic observations were obtained by a radial artery catheter and right heart catheterisation with a pulmonary artery flow directed thermodilution catheter. Observations were obtained prior to and after the administration of nimodipine. RESULTS: A significant reduction in mean arterial pressure occurred in all patients after administration of nimodipine. This was due to a significant reduction in systemic vascular resistance. Neither oxygen delivery to the tissues nor peripheral oxygen consumption changed significantly during nimodipine infusion. No adverse effects related to the use of nimodipine were documented. CONCLUSIONS: Nimodipine is an effective vasodilator. There may be a role for nimodipine as a single agent for the management of eclampsia.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
OBJECTIVE: Increased total body oxygen consumption requirements are usually met by increased oxygen delivery and increased oxygen extraction. In certain conditions (e.g., adult respiratory distress syndrome) the ability to increase oxygen extraction is lost, and any increase in oxygen consumption depends on increased oxygen delivery. The objective of this study was to investigate the oxygen delivery/oxygen consumption relationship in severe preeclampsia. STUDY DESIGN: Thirty-two patients with severe preeclampsia (blood pressure > 160/110 mm Hg; 3 to 4+ proteinuria) were monitored with a pulmonary artery catheter. Baseline oxygen consumption and delivery in a group without volume expansion or pharmacologic vasodilatation were compared with those in a group who had received a magnesium sulfate infusion. RESULTS: Oxygen consumption, oxygen delivery, arterial-venous-oxygen difference, and the oxygen extraction ratio were low when compared to that for normal 32 to 38 week pregnancy. The oxygen extraction ratio, defined as the ratio of oxygen consumption to oxygen delivery, was abnormally low for pregnancy, especially considering the low oxygen delivery levels in these patients. Oxygen consumption was dependent on oxygen delivery over the entire range of values seen. CONCLUSIONS: Severe preeclampsia is associated with an abnormality of tissue oxygen extraction, as evidenced by a low and unresponsive oxygen extraction ratio. Oxygen consumption increases proportionately with increases in oxygen delivery without reaching an oxygen delivery-independent state. Even at high oxygen delivery levels the oxygen consumption in preeclamptic patients is still abnormally low for pregnancy.