Search PubMed⌕ Search

Biomedical subjects

R C Fraser

Publications and source records attributed to R C Fraser.

At least 19 recordsLinked to original sources

Strengths and weaknesses in the consultation skills of senior medical students: identification, enhancement and curricular change.

INTRODUCTION: This paper seeks to describe the consultation strengths and weaknesses of senior medical students, the explicit and prioritised strategies for improvement utilised in student feedback, and curriculum developments informed by this work. METHODS: Prospective, descriptive study of students on clinical placements in general practice. All were observed directly by 2 assessors in consultation with 5 patients in a general practice setting. Performance was judged against 5 categories of consultation competence and 35 component competences as contained in a modified version of the Leicester Assessment Package. Specific strategies for improvement were selected from a list of 69 previously formulated strategies. RESULTS: Data from 1116 students were included. The consultation competences identified most frequently as strengths related to interpersonal skills, while weaknesses were mainly in the domain of clinical problem-solving. The median number of key strengths identified per student was 5, with 5 additional but lesser strengths. A median of 3 key and lesser weaknesses were identified. The average number of strategies selected to address an identified weakness was 1.2. Students rated the assessment process and its impact very positively. CONCLUSION: The systematic assessment of the consultation competence of medical students by direct observation involving real patients is feasible and facilitates the 'educational diagnosis' of individuals and of their peer group. It has informed development of teaching and generated research hypotheses.

Clinical Competence↗

The relationship between measures of patient satisfaction and enablement and professional assessments of consultation competence.

The authors examined the extent of the relationship between a Consultation satisfaction questionnaire and Patient enablement instrument scores and professionally assessed consultation competence scores of senior medical students. Three analyses were performed: (i) linear regression with mean overall competence score as response variable; (ii) sensitivity and specificity calculations using patient scores to classify competence; (iii) a repeated measures model with consultation-specific competence score as response variable. One hundred and nineteen students and 388 patients took part. Consultation satisfaction and enablement scores were weakly correlated with overall and consultation specific competence scores (correlation coefficient 0.16 to 0.44). 'Satisfaction with professional care' had a sensitivity of 0.68, specificity of 0.72 and positive and negative predictive values of 0.32 and 0.92 respectively. It is concluded that patient and professional assessments may complement, but do not replace, each other. Levels of patient satisfaction should not be used as proxy measures of the quality of consultation competence.

Adolescent↗

Student perceptions of a new integrated course in clinical methods for medical undergraduates.

CONTEXT: In line with recent General Medical Council recommendations a new, 8-week integrated course in clinical methods has been introduced into the undergraduate curriculum at Leicester University. OBJECTIVES: To describe student perceptions of the course and to identify areas for improvement. DESIGN: A questionnaire survey. SETTINGS: These were 50 general practices, three teaching hospitals and the academic Department of General Practice and Primary Health Care. SUBJECTS: A total of 180 third- and fourth-year medical students. RESULTS: The questionnaires were completed by 93% of students. The latter expressed higher satisfaction with practice teaching compared with hospital teaching, on a 5-point scale, with regard to questions on 'teaching content' (4.0 vs. 2.7, P < 0.0001) and 'teaching process' (4.1 vs. 2.7 P < 0.0001), which was reinforced by free text comments. Of the respondents, 92% agreed that their teaching practice had satisfied the required teaching timetable and 87% of students found their departmental tutor enthusiastic and stimulating. CONCLUSION: It is possible to deliver an integrated course in clinical methods, teaching generic clinical skills, in a mix of hospital and practice settings. Nevertheless there were substantial differences in student perceptions of the relative quality and impact of teaching in the two settings. This may be related to the more detailed programme of preparation of practice teachers and the greater extent to which practice teachers were required, and able, to create protected time for the teaching task. These differences should be minimized if hospital teachers undergo similar preparation for the teaching task and have similar levels of protected teaching time.

Attitude of Health Personnel↗

Formative assessment of the consultation performance of medical students in the setting of general practice using a modified version of the leicester assessment package.

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the use of a modified version of the Leicester Assessment Package (LAP) in the formative assessment of the consultation performance of medical students with particular reference to validity, inter-assessor reliability, acceptability, feasibility and educational impact. DESIGN: 180 third and fourth year Leicester medical students were directly observed consulting with six general practice patients and independently assessed by a pair of assessors. A total of 70 practice and 16 departmental assessors took part. Performance scores were subjected to generalizability analysis and students' views of the assessment were gathered by questionnaire. RESULTS: Four of the five categories of consultation performance (Interviewing and history taking, Patient management, Problem solving and Behaviour and relationship with patients) were assessed in over 99% of consultations and Physical examination was assessed in 94%. Seventy-six percent of assessors reported that the case mix was 'satisfactory' and 20% that it was 'borderline'; 85% of students believed it to have been satisfactory. Generalizability analysis indicates that two independent assessors assessing the performance of students across six consultations would achieve a reliability of 0.94 in making pass or fail decisions. Ninety-eight percent of students perceived that their particular strengths and weaknesses were correctly identified, 99% that they were given specific advice on how to improve their performance and 98% believed that the feedback they had received would have long-term benefit. CONCLUSIONS: The modified version of the LAP is valid, reliable and feasible in formative assessment of the consultation performance of medical students. Furthermore, almost all students found the process fair and believed it was likely to lead to improvements in their consultation performance. This approach may also be applicable to regulatory assessment as it accurately identifies students at the pass/fail margin.

Clinical Competence↗

Simulated surgery.

Explore the source record for details and available documents.

Clinical Competence↗

Is ownership more important than the scientific credibility of audit protocols? A survey of medical audit advisory groups.

BACKGROUND: It is commonly accepted that ownership is an important factor in determining the acceptability and use of protocols or guidelines. OBJECTIVES: We aimed to determine whether Medical Audit Advisory Groups (MAAGs) are prepared to accept and use audit protocols developed systematically by an external agency. METHOD: A postal questionnaire was sent to all 105 MAAG chairmen in England and Wales to seek their views on the external development of protocols, the inclusion of evidence-based prioritized criteria, the general design of the protocols issued by the Lilly Audit Centre and the numbers of practices reported by MAAGs as making use of at least one of the first four protocols issued. RESULTS: Ninety-five MAAGs (90%) responded. Of these, 86% were in favour of the external development of protocols, and 98% and 94%, respectively, found evidence-based and prioritized criteria valuable; 98% felt the overall design and content of the Audit Centre protocols were excellent or good. A total of 1018 practices was known to have made use of one of these protocols, 261 taking part in multi-practice audits organized by their MAAGs. CONCLUSION: Ownership is not necessarily more important than scientific credibility and/or perceived utility. Externally developed audit protocols containing evidence-based, prioritized review criteria are acceptable to MAAGs, which are prepared to recommend their use in practice. Accordingly, such systematically developed protocols offer a promising and practical method for improving clinical effectiveness. Further research is needed, however, to determine the comparative impact on standards of care of protocols and other methods such as clinical guidelines.

Attitude of Health Personnel↗

Effective audit in general practice: a method for systematically developing audit protocols containing evidence-based review criteria.

Though many general practitioners (GPs) now take part in audit, there is still concern about the extent to which participation in audit leads to improvements in practice. Improved methods are needed for the incorporation of research evidence into criteria for use in audit. In this paper, a six-stage systematic method is described for developing audit protocols containing prioritized evidence-based criteria. The stages are: selection of a topic, identification of key elements of care, focused literature reviews, prioritization of the criteria on the strength of the evidence and impact on outcome, preparation of full documentation, and peer review.

Clinical Protocols↗

Development of review criteria: linking guidelines and assessment of quality.

Review criteria are designed to enable clinicians and others to assess care. However, there is no established method for developing criteria, and they are often confused with guidelines. Criteria should comprise measurable activities that are appropriate for the setting in which they are to be used. They should also be based on research evidence and prioritised according to the strength of that evidence and effect on outcome. Good criteria can be used to aid implementation of guidelines by providing a standard against which to monitor performance and enabling clinical audit.

Decision Making↗

Use of vitamin B-12 in Leicestershire practices: a single topic audit led by a medical audit advisory group.

OBJECTIVE: To encourage active participation of Leicestershire general practitioners and their staff in audit; to examine the use of vitamin B-12 injections and to achieve a more appropriate use. DESIGN: Implementation of an agreed audit protocol, with central analysis and feedback of anonymous and aggregated data by a medical audit advisory group. SETTING: All 147 Leicestershire practices. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Participation in the complete audit cycle, comparison of actual use of vitamin B-12 injections with agreed criteria of use, and assessment of improvement in use. RESULTS: 264 general practitioners (55% of all doctors from 49% of all Leicestershire practices) completed both phases of the audit cycle, and 321 (67%) completed phase 1 only. Twenty four (16%) practices failed to participate from the outset, and a further 58 (35%) dropped out at various stages. Only 10 of the 37 singlehanded practices completed the audit, although 34 initially agreed to participate. If singlehanded practices were excluded, 56% (61) of practices completed both phases of the audit cycle. In total 1714 patients received B-12 injections. Appropriate use increased from 62% in phase 1 to 72% in phase 2 of the audit; there was a 32% reduction in the number of patients inappropriately receiving B-12 (521 to 352), and the proportion of patients receiving B-12 at the correct frequency rose from 58% to 72%. The proportion of patients in whom all the diagnostic criteria for pernicious anaemia were established before treatment with B-12 was 27% in phase 1 and 28% in phase 2. CONCLUSION: Our study suggests that single topic audits organised by a medical audit advisory group can encourage large numbers of general practitioners to participate and can bring about changes in behaviour resulting in improvements in standards of care. Nevertheless, advisory groups will need to devise strategies to encourage even higher levels of involvement, most particularly from singlehanded practices.

Anemia, Pernicious↗