Search PubMed⌕ Search

Biomedical subjects

M F Shapiro

Publications and source records attributed to M F Shapiro.

124 records · Page 7Linked to original sources

Medical aid provided by American, Canadian and British Nationals to the Spanish Republic during the Civil War, 1936-1939.

During international or civil wars, private citizens of noncombatant nations often provide medical aid to one of the contending factions, particularly when they support a participant not favored by their own government. This paper details and analyzes the prominent campaign in the United States, Canada and Great Britain to provide medical aid to the Republicans during the Spanish Civil War (1936 to 1939). The substantial medical aid that was provided clearly alleviated some suffering, but one of the major objectives of the campaign was to arouse public opinion sufficiently to end the boycott of military aid to Republicans; this objective was never achieved. Whether it be in Republican Spain, Vietnam or El Salvador, even a successful medical aid campaign to people in a military conflict may save some lives but may not affect substantially the course of the conflict. Those who are primarily interested in influencing political or military developments, hoping to advance the cause of a particular contending faction, may find tactics other than medical aid campaigns more useful in accomplishing their goals.

Canada↗

Biases in the laboratory diagnosis of depression in medical practice.

Several studies, conducted in psychiatric settings, have reported that the dexamethasone suppression test (ST) is useful in the diagnosis of endogenous depression. To determine whether the test has clinical utility in internal medicine practice, data were reviewed and reanalyzed from all studies that evaluated the dexamethasone ST in the diagnosis of depression. In these 11 studies, the mean positive predictive value reported for the test was 84%, reflecting high prevalence of disease (50%), sensitivity (43%), and specificity (92%) in those specialized populations studied. When estimates of the prevalence and severity of conditions associated with depressed mood seen in internal medicine were used, the sensitivity dropped to 30%, and the specificity to 85%. Assuming a prevalence of 20%, a figure based on available epidemiologic data, the predictive value for a positive test would be 33%, too low to have value in most clinical settings. Data from studies currently available do not support the use of dexamethasone ST in internal medicine practice. More generally, before any test is adopted in a general medical setting, it should be studied in that setting, or available data should be reanalyzed to correct for biases affecting prevalence, sensitivity, and specificity that may inflate the test's value.

Clinical Laboratory Techniques↗

Treatment for a nondisease: the case of low blood pressure.

This paper documents diagnosis and treatment of hypotension among a sample of subjects visiting blood pressure screening booths as part of a hypertension screening survey in Montreal. Of 1019 subjects, over one quarter had been diagnosed as hypotensive. Though low blood pressure is harmless for the majority of people, almost 10% of the screened sample reported receiving treatment from their physicians for the condition. Treatment typically consisted of harmless, but ineffective placebo-like medications including veal liver extract capsules or injections, iron capsules, tonics and vitamin B12 liquid, injections or capsules. Additional analysis discovered little meaningful difference in systolic and diastolic readings among individuals treated for hypotension, those diagnosed but not treated, and an undiagnosed group. Subjects receiving the hypotensive label from practitioners were typically older women with less education and income. Findings are discussed in light of the overlap between statistical and pathological models of illness; presenting symptoms of patients and their demands for treatment; and assumptions of physicians in diagnostic decision-making. It is speculated that medical definition of a nondisease such as low blood pressure may serve to individualize discomfort when true etiology lies in the environment; legitimate neglect of responsibilities and obligations by assigning one to the sick role; or cause organization of vague impulses into symptoms. Hypotension should be included in utilization studies to determine prevalence of treatment, life history of those being treated and complaints offered for treatment.

Adult↗

Medical aid to the Spanish Republic during the Civil War (1936-1939).

During international or civil wars, private citizens of noncombatant nations often provide medical aid to one or the contending factions. To examine the role of such an aid campaign in a military conflict, I did a detailed historical analysis of the prominent campaign in the United States to provide medical aid to the Republicans during the Spanish Civil War (1936 to 1939). Substantial medical aid was provided that clearly alleviated some suffering, but one of the major objectives of the campaign was to arouse public opinion sufficiently to end the boycott of aid to Republican forces by the American government; this objective was never achieved. I conclude that even a successful medical aid campaign to people in a military conflict may save some lives but may not affect substantially the course of the conflict. Persons who are primarily interested in influencing political or military developments may find tactics other than medical aid campaigns more useful in accomplishing their goals.

Government↗

Variations in the care of HIV-infected adults in the United States: results from the HIV Cost and Services Utilization Study.

CONTEXT: Studies of selected populations suggest that not all persons infected with human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) receive adequate care. OBJECTIVE: To examine variations in the care received by a national sample representative of the adult US population infected with HIV. DESIGN: Cohort study that consisted of 3 interviews from January 1996 to January 1998 conducted by the HIV Cost and Services Utilization Consortium. PATIENTS AND SETTING: Multistage probability sample of 2864 respondents (68% of those targeted for sampling), who represent the 231400 persons at least 18 years old, with known HIV infection receiving medical care in the 48 contiguous United States in early 1996 in facilities other than emergency departments, the military, or prisons. The first follow-up consisted of 2466 respondents and the second had 2267 (65% of all surviving sampled subjects). MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Service utilization (<2 ambulatory visits, at least 1 emergency department visit that did not lead to hospitalization, at least 1 hospitalization) and medication utilization (receipt of antiretroviral therapy and prophylaxis against Pneumocystis carinii pneumonia). RESULTS: Inadequate HIV care was commonly reported at the time of interviews conducted from early 1996 to early 1997 but declined to varying degrees by late 1997. Twenty-three percent of patients initially and 15% of patients subsequently had emergency department visits that did not lead to hospitalization, 30% initially and 26% subsequently of those who had CD4 cell counts below 0.20 x 10(9)/L did not receive P carinii pneumonia prophylaxis, and 41% initially and 15% subsequently of those who had CD4 cell counts below 0.50 x 10(9)/L did not receive antiretroviral therapy (protease inhibitor or nonnucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitor). Inferior patterns of care were seen for many of these measures in blacks and Latinos compared with whites, the uninsured and Medicaid-insured compared with the privately insured, women compared with men, and other risk and/or exposure groups compared with men who had sex with men even after CD4 cell count adjustment. With multivariate adjustment, many differences remained statistically significant. Even by early 1998, fewer blacks, women, and uninsured and Medicaid-insured persons had started taking antiretroviral medication (CD4 cell count adjusted P values <.001 to <.005). CONCLUSIONS: Access to care improved from 1996 to 1998 but remained suboptimal. Blacks, Latinos, women, the uninsured, and Medicaid-insured all had less desirable patterns of care. Strategies to ensure optimal care for patients with HIV requires identifying the causes of deficiency and addressing these important shortcomings in care.

Adult↗

Funding for medical care research.

Funding for medical care research in the interrelated fields of health services research, clinical decision-making, clinical epidemiology, the medical humanities and social sciences, and medical education has been unstable, and relatively little is available in the form of investigator-initiated grants. Stable funding for these fields is important to society and critical to the healthy development of academic general internal medicine. Strategies to augment funding can include political interventions to increase support for the National Center for Health Services Research and Health Care Technology Assessment and to secure designated funds within the National Institutes of Health. Public funding is also needed for career development awards in these fields. Research support also could be enhanced by establishing a consortium of foundations interested in funding investigator-initiated grants through open competition, by developing a mechanism for reviewing proposals from small foundations, by developing consortia in the private sector to support focused research, and by developing endowments to support research.

Financing, Government↗

Program directors' attitudes towards residents' care of patients who have AIDS.

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the educational strategies and experiences of residency programs regarding the training of primary care providers in the care of patients who have AIDS. DESIGN: Cross-sectional, self-administered questionnaire survey. SETTING: Survey conducted November 1988-April 1989. PARTICIPANTS: All 771 non-military U.S. internal medicine and family medicine program directors were surveyed; 80% responded. INTERVENTIONS: None. MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: While 91% of the directors felt that primary care of AIDS patients was an important educational experience and 94% reported that their programs usually had AIDS inpatients, only 16% reported that the majority of trainees cared for AIDS patients in their continuity clinics. Even at programs that typically had six or more AIDS inpatients, only 26% of directors reported that most residents had cared for an AIDS patient in their continuity clinics. Among the 57% who did not believe or were unsure whether their residents were adequately trained in AIDS ambulatory care, only 38% reported improving resident education in this area to be a high priority. Among the 39% who did not encourage residents' assumption of primary care, 60% had at least one of the following concerns: AIDS care too stressful for residents (24%), AIDS care too complicated for generalists (31%), or clinic faculty not qualified to supervise residents' caring for AIDS patients (39%). CONCLUSION: Although program directors view education in AIDS ambulatory care as important, most do not believe that residents are adequately trained, many do not encourage residents' assumption of primary care of AIDS patients, and residents usually have not provided such care in their programs. Strategies to augment residents' ambulatory experience in AIDS care are needed.

Acquired Immunodeficiency Syndrome↗

Multi-city study of quality of care for HIV-related Pneumocystis carinii pneumonia: successfully collecting highly sensitive information.

Pneumocystis carinii pneumonia (PCP) has been the major cause of death and the most common opportunistic infection in patients with acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS), with in-hospital mortality rates as high as 60% in some hospitals. To investigate whether there were large variations in quality of care for hospitalized patients with PCP, researchers at RAND Corporation, in 1989, designed and initiated a multi-city study of patterns of care. Mounting a successful primary data collection effort in several cities requires a substantial effort from collaborators in many different settings. In addition, studies of persons with AIDS require careful consideration of issues related to the highly sensitive nature of data sources such as medical records of persons with AIDS, collection of reliable and accurate information, and protection of hospital and patient confidentiality and anonymity. The research team developed an interactive well-coordinated program to select hospitals and patients for evaluation, ensure confidentiality and anonymity, prepare materials, recruit collaborators, and obtain detailed clinical data about the care of patients with PCP. This paper summarizes major data collection and related project activities including design and sampling decisions, fieldwork preparation and implementation, and patient and hospital characteristics.

AIDS-Related Opportunistic Infections↗

Residents' experiences in, and attitudes toward, the care of persons with AIDS in Canada, France, and the United States.

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate resident physicians' experiences in, and attitudes toward, the care of persons with the acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS) in Canada, France, and the United States. DESIGN: Cross-sectional survey, using a self-administered, mailed questionnaire to residents in 10 American states, three French regions, and all 10 Canadian provinces, with follow-up surveys of nonresponders in France and the United States. SUBJECTS: Systematic samples of residents in the last year of internal medicine or family medicine residencies prior to subspecialization or entry into medical practice. RESULTS: While the majority of residents had provided inpatient and outpatient care to persons with AIDS, most believed that their training in ambulatory care of persons with AIDS had been deficient. The rate of blood-contaminated needle-sticks from human immunodeficiency virus-infected patients ranged from 4% for internal medicine residents in Canada to 14% in the United States (P less than .05). The majority recognized an ethical obligation to treat AIDS, but 4% in France, 14% in Canada, and 23% in the United States indicated that they would not care for persons with AIDS if they had a choice (P less than .001). A substantial minority of US physicians reported that a patient of theirs had been refused care by a medical specialist (19%) or a surgeon (39%), but less than 10% of French physicians reported such refusals (P less than .001). CONCLUSION: Concerns about caring for AIDS patients were common and many physicians reported that patients were refused care. While most residents acknowledged an obligation to treat human immunodeficiency virus infection, many did not, and viewpoints varied considerably across the countries studied. The lower level of reluctance to treat AIDS patients in France and Canada makes it clear that the higher rate in the United States is far from optimal and needs to be addressed.

Acquired Immunodeficiency Syndrome↗

Misunderstanding of 'safer sex' by heterosexually active adults.

To assess the understanding of safer sex among heterosexual adults, people enrolled in human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) education trials at a sexually transmitted disease (STD) clinic and a university student health service were surveyed concerning sexual behavior with their latest reported partner. Of 646 sexually active persons enrolled in the trials, 233 (36 percent) reported having had safer sex with their latest partner; 124 of them (53 percent) also reported having vaginal or anal intercourse without a condom during that sexual encounter. Among the 124 who reported safer sex despite having intercourse without a condom, only 23 percent reported asking partners about their HIV status, 46 percent had asked about intravenous drug use, and 47 percent had asked about the number of prior sexual partners. For 34 percent of those surveyed, the length of the sexual relationship with their latest partner was 1 month or less, and 18 percent estimated that this partner had had 11 or more prior sexual partners. STD clinic participants characterized intercourse without a condom as safer sex more often than student health service enrollees (76 percent versus 39 percent, P < 0.001). The concept of safer sex is often misunderstood by persons engaging in behavior at risk for HIV transmission, and the level of misunderstanding differs among samples. Interventions to reduce transmission of HIV must confront misconceptions about the risk of sexual intercourse without condoms and include specific instructions understood by the targeted group.

Adult↗