Biomedical subjects
L J Donaldson
Publications and source records attributed to L J Donaldson.
1969 revisited: reflections on Tomorrow's community physician.
This lecture focuses on a paper that Jerry Morris published in the Lancet of Saturday 18 October 1969 entitled Tomorrow's Community Physician. It was a seminal paper in which a vision of the role and potential of a new breed of public health practitioner was set out. The themes raised in the original paper which examined population health and health service issues, are revisited, by assessing how things have changed, and in particular examining the extent to which the vision set out in the paper has become reality over the last 30 years.
The first 500 days: renewal, reform, reflection.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Professional accountability in a changing world.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Safe high quality health care: investing in tomorrow's leaders.
The agenda for health care in developed countries in the 21st century will be dominated by a vision of quality which seeks to address the deep seated problems of the past. The ability to deliver safe, effective, high quality care within organisations with the right cultures, the best systems, and the most highly skilled and motivated work forces will be the key to meeting this challenge. This is an issue which should be a priority for education and training bodies. The need for health services to give priority to developing health professionals equipped to practise in a new way and thrive in new organisational environments requires a rapid response to reshape curricula and training programmes. Developing leadership and management skills will be essential in achieving this transformation in the quality of care delivered to patients.
125 years of public health in the UK.
This paper examines four themes in public health theory and practice: all are important for the future and are illuminated by the last 125 years. First, while definitions of public health may be stable, the rationale of public health practice--'why bother?'--has altered considerably over time. A second theme revolves around personal autonomy--can we compel individuals to take health promoting measures? Third, public health practice today pays attention as never before to the use of research-based evidence, helping to answer three questions: What are the problems? What are their causes? What are the solutions? The fourth theme is the changing character, locus and focus of public health. From being predominantly locally focused within Borough Councils, albeit operating within frameworks of national legislation and one eye on global threats, it has become much more complex with emerging levels of action which encompass the neighbourhood, the strategic district, the region, nation state, Europe and finally the ever more pressing globalisation agenda as it affects the human condition. Public health has been medically dominated for the last 125 years and this is now changing. Its ties with local government are being strengthened after a break of nearly 30 years. The focus of public health has recently been strongly on health services. This reached its apogee a few years ago but is also now rapidly changing. Looking back over the last 125 years can help us identify some of the mistakes to be avoided and opportunities to be seized at this time of change.
Sport and exercise: the public health challenge.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
International collaboration: harnessing differences to meet common needs in improving quality of care.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Clinical governance: a mission to improve.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Impact of clinical practice guidelines on clinicians' behaviour: tonsillectomy in children.
OBJECTIVE: This study was conducted to assess the extent to which developing and implementing clinical practice guidelines for listing children for tonsillectomy (with or without adenoidectomy) influenced the behaviour of participating ENT surgeons. METHOD: A before and after study in which the intervention (the development and dissemination of local practice guidelines) was introduced sequentially into different hospitals and surgical practice. The study was conducted in four ear, nose, and throat surgical services in the North of England, with 16 consultant ENT surgeons and their junior staff on 1190 children aged 0 to 14 years who were judged, prior to consultation with an ENT surgeon, to have been referred for throat-related problems for which tonsillectomy was one possible treatment option were included in the study. Decision reached by surgeons and proportion of decisions that complied with new guidelines. RESULTS: Of the clinical decisions to list children for tonsillectomy taken before introduction of locally agreed guidelines, 73% (486/660) conformed to the criteria in the subsequent guidelines, 15% (97/660) did not, and in 12% (77/660), it was impossible to judge. After the intervention, the corresponding figures were 73% (386/530), 14% (73/53), and 13% (71/530), respectively. When decisions were taken to break the guidelines, this was more often to list for tonsillectomy when it was not indicated--83% (141/170)--than to withhold tonsillectomy when it was indicated--17% (29/170). The aspects of guidelines that were breached in decisions to carry out tonsillectomy were: the age of the child was younger than the guidelines recommended--54% (75/141); there had been fever attacks of tonsillitis than the guidelines recommended--22% (32/141); and there were "significant" symptoms not included in the guidelines--20% (29/141). CONCLUSIONS: In spite of strong evidence to the contrary, local guidelines were formulated at a level that the majority of surgeons already attained. Guideline development and implementation, therefore, had very little impact on clinical practice. The process of local formulation of guidelines was not sufficient to achieve change toward evidence-based practice; clinical preference proved to be quite intractable. There is a need to enhance the ability of clinicians in the assessment and interpretation of research evidence. Previous work has emphasized the need to explore factors that influence clinical behaviour toward evidence-based practice. Our study suggests the need for more research into why clinicians continue to follow clinical preference even when invited to base agreed local clinical policies on evidence.
The NHS's 50 anniversary. Clinical governance and the drive for quality improvement in the new NHS in England.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Should we be frightened of bracken? A review of the evidence.
OBJECTIVE: To assess the risk to human health of the plant bracken (Pteridium sp). DESIGN: An evaluation of studies of human and animal populations exposed to bracken, together with a review of expert reports and advice to the public. MAIN RESULTS: Bracken induced disease has been demonstrated in animals in both laboratory and field studies. Depending on the species, diseases in animals associated with the plant have included; cancers of the alimentary and urogenital tract, lung and breast; haematuria; retinal degeneration; and, thiamine deficiency. Potential exposure of human populations is through: food either directly (people in some parts of the world eat bracken as a traditional dish) or indirectly by consuming animals fed on bracken; milk; water; inhalation and ingestion of spores; and insect vectors. Four studies of human populations (two analytical and two observational) failed to assess adequately confounding factors and other sources of bias, so that conclusions about a risk to human health from bracken cannot firmly be drawn. Establishing exposure is also extremely difficult in populations (such as the United Kingdom) where direct consumption of bracken is rare. CONCLUSION: Bracken is a common plant worldwide. It is toxic to many animal species and to several organ systems. There is no tumour (or other disease) that is pathognomic of exposure in animals, though cancers of the alimentary and urogenital tract seem to be the most commonly associated. It is not possible to extrapolate from animal models to humans. Studies of human populations, do not establish a clear risk of bracken to human health, largely because of methodological problems. Testing the evidence against traditional criteria of causality only fulfils the criterion of biological plausibility. Despite this, current public information implies a serious risk to human health from bracken, and increasing media coverage of the subject is likely to lead to greater public concern. Further epidemiological studies are required.
Clinical governance: a statutory duty for quality improvement.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Clinical governance: a quality duty for health organisations.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
The public health practitioner as investigator.
The history of public health began with the investigation of communicable diseases. Improved epidemiological methods have subsequently illuminated the causes and management of a wide range of health problems. The day-to-day challenges facing today's public health practitioners must be tackled rapidly and with limited resources, but must still subject to sound epidemiological principles.
Obstetric anaesthesia: an approach to improving the standards of services.
There has been considerable discussion about obstetric anaesthesia standards and about the role of peer review in quality improvement. We carried out two postal surveys in 1990 and 1991 in major obstetric departments in Northern England, in order to assess practice and facilities against professionally derived standards, with the aim of stimulating and reviewing change. The reference standards were a local adaptation of those produced by the Obstetric Anaesthetists Association, and covered operating facilities, anaesthetic equipment, management and manpower, training, and protocols. In 1990, considerable variation in practice and facilities was identified with deficiencies in all hospitals. After feedback of the results of the first survey, a further survey conducted in 1991 identified improvement in 23/26 standards. Reference to standards was widely included in business plans and contracts for services. Following further feedback of the second survey and some revision of standards, a third survey was carried out using site visits. This revealed further improvement in 8/26 standards, but apparent deterioration in 11/26. The overall change from the first to the third survey was of apparent improvement in 15/26 standards and deterioration in 6/26. Surveys of practice against professionally derived standards and the targeted feed back of results can lead to improvements in practice and facilities.
The dancing plague: a public health conundrum.
The phenomenon of mass, frenzied dancing affected large populations in various parts of Europe from the thirteenth century and lasted, on and off, for three centuries. The exact aetiology of the Dancing Plague (or Dancing Mania) is still unclear. Retrospective historical review of this public health problem reveals claims for causative factors including demonic possession, epilepsy, the bite of a tarantula, ergot poisoning and social adversity. It seems unlikely that Dancing Mania resulted from a single cause but rather resulted from multiple factors combining with a predisposing cultural background and triggered by adverse social circumstances. Dancing Mania remains one of the unresolved mysteries of public health.
A prescribing incentive scheme for non-fundholding general practices: an observational study.
OBJECTIVE: To examine the effects of a financial incentive scheme on prescribing in non-fundholding general practices. DESIGN: Observational study. SETTING: Non-fundholding general practices in former Northern region in 1993-4. INTERVENTION: Target savings were set for each group of practices; those that achieved them were paid a portion of the savings. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Financial performance; prescribing patterns in major therapeutic groups and some specific therapeutic areas; rates of generic prescribing; and performance against a measure of prescribing quality. SUBJECTS: 459 non-fundholding general practices, grouped into three bands according to the ratio of their indicative prescribing amount to the local average (band A > or = 10% above average, B between average and 10% above, C below average). RESULTS: 102 (23%) of 442 practices achieved their target savings (18%, 19%, and 27% of bands A, B, and C respectively). Band C practices that achieved their target had a lower per capita prescribing frequency for gastrointestinal drugs, inhaled steroids, antidepressants, and hormone replacement therapy. There were no other significant differences in prescribing frequency, and no reduction in the quality of prescribing in achieving practices. Total savings of pounds 1.54 m on indicative prescribing amounts were achieved. Payments from the incentive scheme and discretionary quality awards resulted in pounds 463,000 being returned to practices for investment in primary care. CONCLUSIONS: The prescribing behaviour of non-fundholding general practitioners responded to financial incentives in a similar way to that of fundholding practitioners. The incentive scheme did not seem to reduce the quality of prescribing.