[From science to clinical practice. Risk assessment in relation to treatment and prevention].
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Biomedical subjects
Publications and source records attributed to J Mainz.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Randomized trials were performed in Denmark and The Netherlands to determine the effect of mailed reminders on the response rate in surveys among patients in general practice. In both countries, general practitioners handed out questionnaires to 200 adult patients who came to visit them. An intervention group of 100 patients received reminders at 3 weeks after the visit, whereas a control group of the remaining 100 patients did not receive reminders. The response rate was significantly higher in the intervention groups than in the control group in The Netherlands (86% versus 55%, respectively) but not in Denmark (87% versus 81%, respectively). Mailed reminders can improve the response rate in surveys related to a general practice, but they are not effective in all situations.
This paper focuses on problems attached to using scientific results in everyday clinical practice. Based on examples we raise the question: Are research results obtained under ideal scientific conditions, presented to health professionals and the public in a way that creates unrealistic expectations of the health services? We suggest that the clinical researcher, when reporting scientific results, should be obliged to consider technological aspects, i.e. the human and monetary cost, effectiveness, compliance, the expected consequence for the patient, professionals and society, and resources needed to accomplish it. Presented with these considerations, actors of the health care scene in terms of professionals, administrators, politicians and patients should be better suited to decide if implementation of a new treatment should take place. Such procedures will give the population and the politicians more realistic expectations of the contributions of medical science and the health services in general.
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Improving the sensitivity of general practice to patients' needs demands a good understanding of patients' expectations and priorities in care provision. Insight into differences in expectations of patients in different cultures and health care systems may support decision-making on desirable models for care provision in general practice. An international study was conducted to determine priorities of patients in general practice care: which views do patients in different countries have in common and which views differ? METHODS: Written surveys in general practices in the UK, Norway, Sweden, Denmark, The Netherlands, Germany, Portugal and Israel were performed. Samples of patients from at least 12 practices per country, stratified according to area and type of practice, were included. Patients rated the importance of 38 different aspects of general practice care, selected on the basis of literature analysis, qualitative studies and consensus discussions. Rankings between countries were compared. RESULTS: A total number of 3540 patients (response rate on average 55%) completed the questionnaire. Patients in different countries had many opinions in common. Aspects that got the highest ranking were: getting enough time during the consultation; quick services in case of emergencies; confidentiality of information on patients; telling patients all they want to know about their illness; making patients feel free to talk about their problems; GPs going to courses regularly; and offering preventive services. However, differences between opinions of patients in different countries were also found for some of the selected aspects. A confounding effect of patients' characteristics may have played a role in these differences. DISCUSSION: The study provides information on what patients expect of and value in general practice care. It shows that patients in different cultures and health care systems may have different views on some aspects of care, but most of all that they have many views in common, particularly as far as doctor-patient communication and accessibility of services are concerned.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
This study aims to identify and explain which aspects of medical care patients valued and expected from the general practitioner. A questionnaire was given to a sample of 774 patients (86% response rate) from 15 practices. Patients rated the importance and ranked 40 different questions relating to their medical care. Aspects related to technical care were ranked highest. Patients gave low priority to aspects of care related to practice organisation. Enough time during consultations and quick services in case of emergencies got top rank in the study. The study provides information on patients' priorities regarding their general practitioner.
Insight into patients' priorities with respect to health care should complement the views of professionals and policy makers on what is thought to be appropriate health care. To determine the strengths and weaknesses of general practice care from patients' perspectives written surveys were performed among patients in Denmark, Germany, Israel, Netherlands, Norway, Portugal, Sweden and United Kingdom (n = 3540). The potential quality problems identified were spread over the different countries: the low involvement of general practitioners in out-of-hours services in Portugal; the low provision of routine screening in Sweden, Norway and The Netherlands; the lack of a defined patient population in Germany; the lack of a formal gatekeeper role to secondary care in general practice in Germany and Sweden; and the low number of home visits in Sweden.
To make health care more responsive to patient needs, insight into patient priorities is needed. A systematic literature review, using electronic and manual searches, was made of studies on patient priorities with regard to primary health care. Data-extraction was performed by two researchers, followed by systematic analyses of study features. 57 studies were included. The aspects of care and methods used showed a wide variation. Aspects most often included were "informativeness", "humaneness" and "competence/accuracy". Based on an analysis of 19 studies, the following aspects were seen by patients as most important in more than 50% of the studies that included them: "humaneness", "competence/accuracy", "patients' involvement in decisions", "time for care", "other aspects of availability/accessibility", "informativeness", "exploring patients' needs", "other aspects of relation and communication" and "availability of special services".
For use in a different cultural background, translated questionnaires need to be validated in the new context. International guidelines are needed for such validation, as precision in translation is an important methodological issue. The article consists in a review of the issue and recommended guidelines for the translation and validation of questionnaires, based on the authors' experience and international literature in the field. The authors participate in a European research programme (EU/BIOMED-Europep), set up to develop a questionnaire for exploring patients' priorities and their evaluations of important aspects of general practice.
The aim of this study was to evaluate the informative content of referrals and discharge summary letters concerning patients admitted acutely to the Department of Internal Medicine in a Danish district hospital, and to estimate the delivery time for discharge summary letters. A total of 132 patients were consecutively enrolled from May 2nd to May 30th 1995. The receiving doctor in the hospital on the day of admission as well as the general practitioner who received the discharge summary letter were asked to complete a specific designed questionnaire. The referrals were often insufficient regarding patient history (in particular data on psychosocial aspects and prescribed medicine) and physical examination. Every fifth referral was never received by the hospital. The delivery time for discharge summary letters was 13 days (0-87 days). In every fifth case the information was needed earlier. The discharge summary letters often lacked information concerning what the patients had been told, prognosis and suggestions concerning social medicine. This study indicates that the collaboration between general practitioners and doctors in hospital can be improved by of enhancing the informative content of referrals and discharge summary letters and the expedition time of discharge summary letters.
OBJECTIVE: To describe a method to handle data in qualitative research. DESIGN: Description of the data handling process in a personal computer database. SETTING: The method was used in a Danish qualitative study with more than 100 interviews on quality of care. OUTCOME MEASURES: The author's own description and assessment of the system. RESULTS: Storing information in a database makes it possible to store and retrieve information from qualitative research divided in themes and subthemes. The themes and subthemes are based on an interview guide and the succeeding development of theory and new themes. The comprehensive sorting systems in a database enable the researcher to keep an overview of his data while analysing and reporting. CONCLUSION: Storing, analysing, and retrieving data from qualitative research demands careful planning. A computer database may be a good help in this process if the researcher will not use more complex and comprehensive software for his analysis.
This article describes how hospitals in Denmark have tried to meet the quality challenge. How to improve health care has been a topic of debate in Denmark in the last decade, and various authorities and professional organizations have implemented quality improvement initiatives. A 1991 survey of Danish hospitals showed that methods of quality improvement and the responsibility for quality management were still issues in need of further clarification. This article illustrates the process of quality improvement using hospitals in the city of Copenhagen as examples.
Quality assurance (QA) has been a main topic of debate within the Danish health care system over the last few years. In order to study the effects of this debate we conducted a survey of QA activities in all hospitals. This article is concerned with the role of the central hospital management in QA. Thirty-nine percent (forty-one) of hospital managements returned the questionnaire. Thirty-two managements had initiated QA work in their hospitals, especially on topics concerning health care personnel, administration and organisation. Twenty-four managements had created goals for quality, only rarely were the goals followed up by quantitative methods. Seven managements had a special budget for QA-activities. Those hospital managements who have initiated QA in their hospitals have selected key topics in order to facilitate the implementation of QA.
Over the last few years there has been considerable activity concerning quality assurance (QA) in health care. In order to investigate the actual consequences, we mailed a questionnaire to all Danish hospital managements, asking them to distribute it to leading doctors and nurses. 349 questionnaires from 51 hospitals were returned. The questionnaire was concerned with QA-activities, topics and methods, organisational aspects and attitudes amongst the professionals. Forty-eight percent of all hospitals, evenly distributed over all hospital and department categories, were represented in the survey. Fifty percent of respondents were doctors, 40% nurses. Eighty-seven percent had started quality assurance activities, typically clinically oriented research where doctors were concerned, and typically projects concerning communication with patients when initiated by nurses. Both groups had many projects concerning personnel policy, especially educational aspects. 3% of the activities were concerned with patient satisfaction. Knowledge of quality assurance principles was not yet widespread among the professionals, but 87% expressed positive attitudes. There is a need to define the concept of QA and to spread knowledge of QA-methods, if a systematic approach to QA is to be implemented.