Undergraduate medical education: the challenge of change.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Biomedical subjects
Publications and source records attributed to J D Knox.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
When murine cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) are heated at 42 degrees C for 30 min their ability to lyse their target cells (TC) is severely impaired. When the CTL are allowed to recover at 37 degrees C, a partial recovery of cytolytic activity that peaks within 6 h is observed. A dye exclusion assay demonstrated that such a heat shock does not affect the viability of the CTL and direct microscopic observations established that their ability to bind to TC is not impaired. Therefore, the step or steps inhibited by hyperthermia are subsequent to TC recognition and binding. Kupfer et al. ((1983) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 80, 7224-7228) demonstrated that upon binding to an appropriate TC, a rapid orientation of the Golgi apparatus and the microtubule organizing center (MTOC) occurred within the CTL so that the two organelles face the TC. This orientation is a prerequisite for efficient TC lysis. We have shown by immunofluorescence and confocal microscopy, using a monoclonal antibody to tubulin and a rabbit autoimmune serum that binds a centriole-associated protein, that the organization of the MTOC-microtubule array is disrupted by hyperthermia. EM suggests that this disorganization of the microtubules may result from an aggregation of the pericentriolar material. The recovery of cytolytic activity is coincident with the reorganization of the microtubules about the MTOC. These findings suggest that the initial inhibitory effect of hyperthermia on CTL function results from the disruption of microtubule organization.
Analytic, within-subject, and between-subject biologic variations were estimated for leukocytes, erythrocytes, hemoglobin, hematocrit, mean cell volume (MCV), mean cell hemoglobin (MCH), mean cell hemoglobin content (MCHC), platelets, and a three-component differential count (lymphocytes, monocytes, and granulocytes in terms of both concentration and percentage of leukocytes) in cohorts of 12 male and 12 female healthy elderly subjects. The assays were performed with an Ortho ELT-800 automated analyzer. The estimates of within-subject biologic variation were similar to published data on young subjects, indicating that this aspect of homeostasis is not compromised in the elderly. The data were used to derive objective analytic goals; goals were surpassed except for assays of erythrocytes, hematocrit, and the derived MCV, MCH, and MCHC. The changes required for serial results to be significantly different were determined and found to be generally valid because most quantities have no heterogeneity of within-subject variation. All quantities had significant individuality; in consequence, conventional population-based reference values are of limited utility, and screening using reference limits will not detect latent or early disease in many subjects.
Teaching on the theme of 'breaking bad news' was selected for special development as part of an introductory course on communication skills for preclinical medial students in 1987. Eight parents of handicapped children and three patients terminally ill with neoplastic diseases cooperated in a series of semi-structured group discussions in which students were encouraged to interact with patients and children. The patients/parents readily assumed the role of teachers and where it was possible, they participated in similar sessions the following year. Analysis of questionnaires indicated that the plan had proved acceptable to patients, relatives and students. Follow-up of student opinion one year later indicated that students felt they had derived benefit from these opportunities to learn first-hand from patients and parents of handicapped children.
Medical education is moving to a more problem-orientated basis than was the case formerly. The Modified Essay Question has its origins in this movement, being introduced in the late 1960s as one assessment technique more suited to general practice than other traditional assessment methods. In its original form it is a paper exercise based on an evolving situation presented by a patient in primary care. Experience with the technique in different countries is briefly summarised, and its applications to assessment and to teaching are discussed. Despite shortcomings this method appears to be standing up to the test of time.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Analytical, within-subject, and between-subject components of variation were estimated for 26 clinical chemistry analytes from duplicate analyses of 10 specimens collected from 27 healthy elderly subjects over a period of 20 weeks. Within-subject variations were similar to those generated previously by us in younger subjects. We conclude, therefore, that homeostasis is not compromised by age alone, and biological variability does not increase simply with age. All analytes except serum water had marked individuality, showing that conventional population-based reference values are of limited utility. The critical differences required for two results to be significantly (P less than or equal to 0.05) changed are not the same as those that prompt action by clinicians. Although heterogeneity of within-subject variation does exist, we believe that the critical differences generated will be useful in routine clinical decision making.
This pilot study examined how closely general practitioners and employment medical advisors agreed when jointly investigating occupational dermatitis. The criterion for admitting a patient to the study was dermatitis on one or both hands. This presented most commonly among men aged 41-60 years and women aged 21-40 years. There was some reluctance among general practitioners to take part in the study, probably owing to the medico-legal problems associated with this condition. General practitioners and employment medical advisors were equally likely to attribute a case of dermatitis to occupational factors if the patient was employed in industry; but if the patient was in nonindustrial employment, general practitioners were more likely to consider the possibility of an occupational origin than employment medical advisors. These differences suggest that before initiating a wider study more information is required concerning the trigger mechanisms for dermatitis on the hands in order to reduce the diagnostic variability.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
This paper describes a recent change in the practical component of the Behavioural Sciences course at Dundee Medical School. Results obtained from an evaluation of the change appear to show that students' learning was enhanced by the new form of practical work.
This paper reports some aspects of teaching communication skills based on experience with over 100 pre-clinical students in each of two years. Students interviewed patients selected by general practitioner tutors from their practices and 214 interviews, recorded on videotape, were subsequently analysed. Without having been given detailed instruction, approximately two-thirds of each class of second year students (mean age 19 1/2 years) sustained a consultation for 5 minutes or more. Over one half of the students elicited the salient features of the patients' problems within this short time. Anxiety exhibited by the majority of students could be seen to influence the interviews in several ways. These manifestations and the ways in which the interview was affected are briefly described. When some of the patients were subsequently interviewed by postgraduate trainees in general practice, the consultations differed in a number of respects. These differences are described, and the possible significance of the observations is discussed in relation to medical education.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Three hundred and forty-two general practitioners in Scotland presented their views on content and training in relation to consulting with patients. Differences in responses from trainers, non-trainers, and trainees are examined and possible reasons for the divergences are discussed.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
General-practitioner trainers in Scotland responded to a questionnaire on difficulties in consultation significantly more readily than did non-trainers. Their answers to some questions were significantly different.Trainer and trainee views of difficulties in communication with different types of patients and situations are broadly similar. Because of this similarity of views, the experienced doctor can plan an approach to training which is valid for the inexperienced trainee. He may, however, modify his estimate of the degree of difficulty for the trainee of consultation by involving some categories, for example, adolescents (easier for the trainee), dying patients (more difficult), patients of socioeconomic status which is different to that of the doctor (more difficult).SOME ASPECTS OF THE CONSULTATION MERIT SPECIAL ATTENTION: techniques such as those appropriate to ending the interview and discovering the patient's reasons for seeking medical help.While trainees' problems associated with lack of familiarity with patients and their circumstances are likely to decrease with time spent in the teaching practice, adequate records can help to diminish the trainees' insecurity.This survey confirms the need to continue to focus attention on patient management as a component of training as relevant as the detailed diagnosis and treatment of disease.
A short, intensive, teacher training course for general practitioners is described. The assessment techniques used indicate that it went some way towards achieving predetermined goals. Set alongside the limited time available to practitioners for attending training courses, and the logistic problems of training an adequate supply of teachers, this experience suggests that short intensive courses may have an important role in professional education.