Search PubMed⌕ Search

Biomedical subjects

J Ashby

Publications and source records attributed to J Ashby.

At least 127 records · Page 7Linked to original sources

Alternatives to the 2-species bioassay for the identification of potential human carcinogens.

It is proposed that the standard 2-species rodent cancer bioassay protocol, as perfected by the US National Toxicology Program (NTP), has already fulfilled its most useful role by providing an unequalled carcinogenicity database by which to re-assess the type of carcinogen worthy of definition. Continued use of this resource and time consuming protocol can no longer be justified, except in rare circumstances of high and protracted human exposure to a chemical of unknown carcinogenicity. In those rare instances an enlarged bioassay of three or four test species should perhaps be considered, there being nothing fundamental about the rat/mouse combination. In the large majority of cases, however, a practical estimation of the carcinogenic potential of a chemical can be formed in the absence of lifetime carcinogenicity bioassay data. This can be achieved by its sequential study, starting with an appreciation of its chemical structure and anticipated reactivity and mammalian metabolism. After the shortterm evaluation of a range of additional properties of the agent, including its genetic toxicity, rodent toxicity and tissue-specific toxicity, confident predictions of the genotoxic and/or non-genotoxic carcinogenic potential of the agent can be made. In most situations these predictions will be suitable for framing hazard reduction measures among exposed humans. In some situations it may be necessary to evaluate these predicted activities using limited bioassays, a range of which are considered. Extensions of these limited carcinogenicity bioassays to a standard 2-year/2-species bioassay can only be supported in cases where the non-carcinogenicity of the agent becomes the important thing to define. The US NTP have evaluated the carcinogenicity of approximately 400 chemicals over the past 20 years, at a cost of hundreds of millions of US dollars. The experience gained by that and related initiatives, worldwide, can now be harnessed to classify thousands of priority chemicals as being either probable carcinogens or probable noncarcinogens. That can now be achieved using a fraction of the earlier resources and in a fraction of the time that would be required for the conduct of 2-species bioassays. The comfort factor for one group of people of the order of the present system, coupled to the comfort factor for another group of the delay in carcinogenicity assessment enforced by the present council of perfection, are the two main factors delaying transfer to a streamlined system for assessing the carcinogenic potential of chemicals to humans. A third delaying factor in the need for new and focused test data. Coordinated acquisition of such data could rapidly remove the first two obstacles.

Animals↗

Evaluation of the potential carcinogenicity and genetic toxicity to humans of the herbicide acetochlor.

Comprehensive toxicological studies of the herbicide acetochlor are presented and discussed. Although it gave a negative profile of responses in the many toxicity tests conducted there were some findings that prompted further investigation. First, although non-mutagenic in the Salmonella assay, acetochlor was clastogenic to mammalian cells treated in vitro. This clastogenic potential was not expressed in vivo in four rodent cytogenetic assays (bone marrow and germ cells). Second, although acetochlor gave a negative response in rat liver UDS assays when tested at the acute MTD, gavage administration of a single, supra-MTD dose (2000 mg/kg) gave a weak positive assay response. This dose-level (2000 mg/kg) was necrotic to the liver, depressed hepatic glutathione levels by up to approximately 80%, altered the metabolism of acetochlor, and was associated with up to 33% lethality. In contrast, reference liver genotoxins such as DMN, DMH and 2AAF were shown to elicit UDS in the absence of such effects, and at approximately 400 x lower dose-levels. Finally, microscopic nasal polypoid adenomas were induced in the rat when acetochlor was administered for two years at the maximum tolerated dose (MTD). The tumours were not life-threatening, they did not metastasize, and no DNA damage was induced in the nasal cells of rats maintained on a diet containing the MTD of acetochlor for either 1 or 18 weeks (comet assay). In order to probe the mechanism of action of these high dose toxicities a series of chemical and genetic toxicity studies was conducted on acetochlor and a range of structural analogues. These revealed the chloroacetyl substructure to be the clastogenic species in vitro. Although relatively inert, this substituent is preferentially reactive to sulphydryl groupings, most evidently, to glutathione (GSH). Similar chemical reactivity and clastogenicity in vitro was observed for two related chemicals bearing a chloroacetyl group, both of which have been defined as non-carcinogens in studies reported by the US.NTP. These collective observations indicate that the source of the clastogenicity of acetochlor in vitro is also the source of its rapid detoxification in the rat in vivo, via reaction with GSH. Metabolic studies of acetochlor are described which reveal the formation of a series of GSH-associated biliary metabolites in the rat that were not produced in the mouse. The metabolism of acetochlor in the rat changes with increasing dose-levels, probably because of depletion of hepatic GSH. It is most likely that a rat-specific metabolite is responsible for the rat nasal tumours observed uniquely at elevated dose-levels. The absence of genetic toxicity to the nasal epithelium of rats exposed acutely or subchronically to acetochlor favours a non-genotoxic mechanism for the induction of these adenomas. The observation of a time- and dose-related increase in S-phase cells in the nasal epithelium is consistent with this conclusion. Despite some confusion caused by the early use of perilethal gavage administrations of acetochlor to rodents, and supra-MTD dietary concentrations in some of the chronic studies, the available MTD data are consistent with acetochlor not posing a genetic or carcinogenic hazard to humans.

Adenomatous Polyps↗

Prediction of rodent carcinogenicity for 30 chemicals.

Predictions of carcinogenic activity are made for 30 chemicals currently being assessed for rodent carcinogenicity by the U.S. National Toxicology Program. The predictions are based upon the chemical structure, the anticipated or reported mutagenicity, and the reported sub-chronic toxicity of each chemical. It is predicted that 13 chemicals will be noncarcinogenic to rodents, that 7 will be genotoxic carcinogens, and that 10 may show some evidence of presumed nongenotoxic rodent carcinogenesis.

Animals↗

Structure activity relationships in skin sensitization using the murine local lymph node assay.

Murine local lymph assay node data for 106 chemicals are listed. Among these, 73 are active in the assay indicating their potential as skin sensitizing agents. Broad structure activity relationships (SAR) are suggested based on the electrophilic theory of skin sensitization suggested by Landsteiner and Jacobs in 1936, and elaborated by Dupuis and Benezra in 1982. Eight classes of agent are discerned; electrophiles, potential electrophiles after metabolism, Michael-reactive agents, benzoylating agents, ionic chemicals and miscellaneous agents. The electrophilic theory cannot at present fully explain the activity of agents in the last two classes. That fact will hopefully focus research into their mode of action. Some chemicals fit equally into more than one class, and such agents are entered into the several classes in order not to bias the analysis. Attention is given to why not all chemicals of a class are active in the assay. It is concluded that a combination of inappropriate lipophilicity, molecular size and metabolic detoxification are responsible for these inactivities. Given a sufficient number of analogues tested within each class it should be possible eventually to predict with accuracy the skin sensitizing potential of new members of the class. However, the present analysis is qualitative, not quantitative. Finally, the parallelism between sensitizing potential and mutagenic potential for chemicals is explored further.

Allergens↗

Enhanced hepatocyte colony growth in soft agar after in vivo treatment with a genotoxic carcinogen: a potential assay for hepatocarcinogens?

We have shown previously that approximately 1 in 10,000 primary hepatocytes isolated from untreated rats undergo clonal growth in soft agar in vitro in response to the synergistic action of nafenopin, a peroxisome proliferator (PP) and epidermal growth factor (EGF), a naturally occurring liver growth regulator. Here, we demonstrate that prior treatment of the animals with the genotoxic hepatocarcinogen diethylnitrosamine (DEN) caused a dose-dependent increase in soft agar colony numbers formed in vitro. These data suggest that the colony assay may offer a method of detecting in vitro hepatocytes transformed in vivo by DEN. It is known that rats treated with DEN develop enzyme altered foci prior to the development of tumours. The majority of these foci express high levels of gamma-glutamyl transpeptidase (GGT). However, foci promoted by PPs do not show this increased enzyme activity. In the present study, the colonies we have generated in vitro mimicked this pattern since the majority (approximately 80%) of the spontaneous colonies expressed GGT whereas colonies promoted by the synergistic action of nafenopin and EGF were mainly (75%) GGT negative. The proportion of colonies positive for GGT were similar using either hepatocytes isolated from control or from DEN-initiated rats. Further studies are required to assess if the hepatocytes selected for clonal expansion by this EGF/nafenopin regime reflect the presumed pre-neoplastic cells induced by genotoxin in vivo and associated with an increased propensity to cancer.

Agar↗

Consideration of the liver of embryonic lacZ transgenic mice as an analogue of the mouse coat colour spot test: preliminary data and technical problems.

Pregnant lacZ+ transgenic mice (Muta Mouse) were treated with ENU (25 mg/kg) by oral gavage on day 10.5 of pregnancy. This dose of ENU is the optimal dose observed by other investigators for activity in the mouse coat colour spot test. Day 10.5 of pregnancy represents the stage when the embryonic liver first becomes visually discernable. By day 15.5, when the maternal and embryonic livers were analysed for lacZ- mutation frequency, the embryonic liver is the largest tissue in the embryo (approximately 25 mg). These experiments therefore represent treatment of a small pool of progenitor hepatocytes just as they are entering into an intense wave of cell division--optimum conditions for the fixation of mutations. Exposure to ENU led to an average fourfold, and a maximum tenfold increase in mutation frequency in the embryonic livers. This relatively weak response is consistent with lacZ- mutants not having a growth advantage; unlike in the mouse spot test, clonal amplification of lacZ- mutants cannot be separately scored. The level of mutation in the control embryonic livers was lower than that of the maternal control livers, but the group sizes were too small to conclude this definitively. Embryonic livers from each individual mother showed a range of mutation frequencies that were not obviously related to that of the maternal liver. On a treatment group basis, ENU was non-mutagenic to maternal livers. Half of the embryonic livers yielded DNA that failed to package, despite repeated attempts and re-isolation of the DNA from the liver. The cause of this unexpected finding is not clear. What is clear is that it was not due to the ENU treatment because eight of 22 control embryonic livers behaved similarly. These preliminary results suggest that further research is required in order to establish a practical transgenic analogue of the mouse coat colour spot test.

Animals↗

The rodent dominant lethal assay: a proposed format for data presentation that alerts to pseudo-dominant lethal effects.

The rodent dominant lethal (DL) germ cell mutagenicity assay is the primary test for possible human germ cell mutagens. As such, it occupies a critical regulatory position. DL assay data are often difficult to assess because of the quantity of data involved, and because several related assay parameters require to be considered simultaneously. To reduce this difficulty a schematic method of data presentation is proposed and illustrated. This method enables the most pertinent assay data and parameters to be viewed and considered simultaneously. Using this format of data presentation, existing DL studies on cyclophosphamide, methylnitrosourea, diethylhexylphthalate, divinyl sulphone, methyl methanesulphonate, 6-mercaptopurine and ethylenethiourea are re-analysed.

Animals↗