Voices from Roslin: the creators of Dolly discuss science, ethics, and social responsibility. Interview by Arlene Judith Klotzko.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Biomedical subjects
Publications and source records attributed to I Wilmut.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Ovine primary fetal fibroblasts were cotransfected with a neomycin resistance marker gene (neo) and a human coagulation factor IX genomic construct designed for expression of the encoded protein in sheep milk. Two cloned transfectants and a population of neomycin (G418)-resistant cells were used as donors for nuclear transfer to enucleated oocytes. Six transgenic lambs were liveborn: Three produced from cloned cells contained factor IX and neo transgenes, whereas three produced from the uncloned population contained the marker gene only. Somatic cells can therefore be subjected to genetic manipulation in vitro and produce viable animals by nuclear transfer. Production of transgenic sheep by nuclear transfer requires fewer than half the animals needed for pronuclear microinjection.
We summarize here the procedures for nuclear transfer using S-phase cytoplasts and describe a new method for avoiding loss of reconstructed embryos from the oviducts during in vivo culture. We obtained 2 clones of 5 genetically identical animals following the transfer of blastomeres from 16-cell embryos into enucleated preactivated cytoplasts. Metaphase II oocytes and embryos were surgically collected from superovulated Sarda breed ewes 54 and 120 h after sponge removal, respectively. Oocytes were exposed for 15 min to 5 mug/ml of Hoechst 33342 and were micromanipulated at room temperature. Efficiency in embryo reconstruction was 100% for enucleation and 98% for fusion. Embryos were embedded in agar as separate clones and transferred into the oviducts of temporary recipients. The fimbriae were closed with glass-nylon made filters. Embryo recovery from the temporary recipients was 97.3%, with a cleavage rate of 81.4%; development to morula-blastocyst stage was 70.6%. A total of 29 Grade 1 blastocysts corresponding to 5 clones were transferred into 13 naturally synchronous ewes, and scanning was performed at 30 and 90 d. Ten ewes were pregnant at the first scanning and nine at the second for a final pregnancy rate of 71.4%; the survival rate at term was 48%. Overall, we obtained 4 clones of identical lambs: two sets of 5 (one male set and one female set) and two sets of twins (both sets male). Pregnancy length in recipients carrying clones was longer than the standard period in Sarda breed (153 vs 150 d, respectively). Weight at birth was higher for male lambs obtained from nuclear transfer than for normal males (4.1 vs 3.6 kg), while the weight for females was normal.
Fertilization of mammalian eggs is followed by successive cell divisions and progressive differentiation, first into the early embryo and subsequently into all of the cell types that make up the adult animal. Transfer of a single nucleus at a specific stage of development, to an enucleated unfertilized egg, provided an opportunity to investigate whether cellular differentiation to that stage involved irreversible genetic modification. The first offspring to develop from a differentiated cell were born after nuclear transfer from an embryo-derived cell line that had been induced to become quiescent. Using the same procedure, we now report the birth of live lambs from three new cell populations established from adult mammary gland, fetus and embryo. The fact that a lamb was derived from an adult cell confirms that differentiation of that cell did not involve the irreversible modification of genetic material required for development to term. The birth of lambs from differentiated fetal and adult cells also reinforces previous speculation that by inducing donor cells to become quiescent it will be possible to obtain normal development from a wide variety of differentiated cells.
Nuclear transfer has been used in mammals as both a valuable tool in embryological studies and as a method for the multiplication of 'elite' embryos. Offspring have only been reported when early embryos, or embryo-derived cells during primary culture, were used as nuclear donors. Here we provide the first report, to our knowledge, of live mammalian offspring following nuclear transfer from an established cell line. Lambs were born after cells derived from sheep embryos, which had been cultured for 6 to 13 passages, were induced to quiesce by serum starvation before transfer of their nuclei into enucleated oocytes. Induction of quiescence in the donor cells may modify the donor chromatin structure to help nuclear reprogramming and allow development. This approach will provide the same powerful opportunities for analysis and modification of gene function in livestock species that are available in the mouse through the use of embryonic stem cells.
One of the primary limiting factors to superovulation and embryo transfer in cattle has been the large variability in response, both between and within animals. It appears that the primary source of this problem is the variability in the population of gonadotropin-responsive follicles present in ovaries at the time of stimulation. We have shown that treatment of heifers with recombinant bovine somatotropin (rbGH) increases the number of small antral follicles (2 to 5 mm) and, therefore, enhances the subsequent superovulatory response to eCG. To investigate further the potential of using this approach to improve superovulatory regimens in cattle, the effect of rbGH pretreatment on the response to pituitary FSH was studied. The estrous cycles of 16 heifers were synchronized using PGF2alpha. On Day 7 of the synchronized cycle, half of the animals were injected with 320 mg sustained-release formulated rbGH, while the other half received 10 ml saline. Five days later, all heifers were given a decreasing-dose regimen of twice daily injections of oFSH for 4 d, incorporating an injection of PGF2alpha with the fifth FSH treatment, to induce superovulation. All animals were artificially inseminated twice with semen from the same bull during estrus. Ova/embryos were recovered nonsurgically on Days 6 to 8 of the following estrous cycle, and the ovulation rate assessed on Day 9 by laparoscopy. Using the same animals as described above, the experiment was repeated twice, 3 and 6 mo later, with no laparoscopy in the third experiment. The animals were randomized both between experiments and for the day of ova/embryo collection. Pretreatment of heifers with rbGH significantly (P < 0.01) increased the number of ovulations, total number of ova/embryos recovered and the number of transferable embryos. The percentage of transferable embryos was significantly (P < 0.05) increased by rbGH pretreatment. In addition, the incidence (2/16) of follicular cysts with a poor ovulatory response (< 6 ovulations) for the rbGH-pretreated heifers was significantly lower (P < 0.05) when compared with the incidence (7/16) in the control animals. It is concluded that pretreatment with rbGH may provide a useful approach for improving superovulatory response in cattle.
Exciting new opportunities in embryo cloning have been made possible by recent studies on the interaction of the donor nucleus with the recipient cytoplasm after embryo reconstruction. This article reviews information regarding the co-ordination of nuclear and cytoplasmic events during embryo reconstruction, in particular the direct and indirect effects of maturation/ meiosis/mitosis-promoting factor (MPF), upon the transferred nucleus. This will be discussed in relation to DNA replication, the maintenance of correct ploidy, the occurrence of chromosomal abnormalities and development of reconstructed embryos. Although this review is primarily concerned with the reconstruction of mammalian embryos, specific examples from amphibians will also be cited.
Communication between the oocyte and its somatic cells has been shown to be important in oocyte development. Here we examined how the oocyte may be involved in bovine cumulus cell expansion. Intact bovine cumulus oocyte complexes (COC) were obtained by puncturing antral follicles. From the intact COC, oocytectomised complexes (OOX) were produced by micro surgical removal of the oocyte. Clumps of cumulus cells (CC) were obtained by micro-dissection. Intact or OOX complexes or CC were matured in the presence of fetal calf serum and hFSH (6 mlU/ml) for 24 hr and the degree of expansion measured. The presence of the oocyte is not essential to allow bovine cumulus expansion to occur as expansion occurred in all groups. Murine OOX complexes from eCG primed 35-40-day-old C57BL6/CBA F1 hybrids (known to require the presence of an oocyte secreted factor for cumulus expansion) were cultured with or without denuded bovine oocytes (1 oocyte/microliter). Murine OOX complexes expanded only in the presence of denuded bovine oocytes. Thus some factor produced by bovine oocytes enabled expansion of murine OOX complexes. To determine whether the factor is secreted by bovine oocytes, murine OOX were cultured with or without media conditioned by bovine oocytes (1 oocyte/microliter for 4 hr). Significant expansion of murine OOX occurred in media conditioned by bovine oocytes. This shows that the cumulus expansion enabling effect of bovine oocytes is released into the surrounding media. Media conditioned by bovine oocytes and then frozen for up to 1 month showed that the activity by the factor can withstand freezing.
The transition from maternal to zygotic gene expression in the mouse occurs in the 2-cell embryo. Previous studies in which DNA was injected into 2-cell embryos revealed that transcription promoters and origins of DNA replication are strongly repressed in cleavage stage embryos unless linked to an embryo-responsive enhancer. Repression also occurs when DNA is injected into the paternal pronucleus of a 1-cell embryo and the injected embryo subsequently undergoes mitosis, except that repression is no longer relieved by enhancers. Here we extend this observation to maternal pronuclei in 1-cell embryos and show that this repression could not be relieved either by linking the promoter to an embryo-responsive enhancer or by inducing hyperacetylation of chromatin inorder to increase its accessibility to transcription factors. However, repression could be relieved by transplanting the injected pronucleus to a 2-cell embryo, even when the recipient cell subsequently underwent mitosis. Both the extent of promoter repression and the ability of enhancers to stimulate promoter activity increased as development proceeded from the early 2-cell stage to the 4-cell stage. Once repression was established in late 2-cell embryos, transplanting an injected 2-cell embryo nucleus back to an early 1-cell embryo failed to restore activity to the injected promoter, even when it was linked to an enhancer. These and other data demonstrate that cytoplasmic factors appear during formation of a 2-cell embryo that can repress promoter activity and activate enhancer activity. These factors are absent from the paternal pronucleus and cytoplasm of early (S-phase arrested) 1-cell embryos. Moreover, the cytoplasm of early 1-cell embryos appears to lack the ability to reprogram expression of genes once they have progressed to the late 2-cell stage in mouse development.
Mouse 2-, 4-, 8-, and 16-cell embryos were exposed to nocodazole in M16 culture medium. The effect of different concentrations and exposure times on the efficiency of cell cycle synchronization and the development of the treated embryos after release from the drug was determined. The minimum effective concentration (> 95% of arrested nuclei) for 4-, 8-, and 16-cell embryos was 5 microM nocodazole. The effect upon subsequent development of mouse embryos depended upon both the stage of development of the embryo at treatment (P < 0.001) and the length of exposure to nocodazole (P < 0.001). Exposure to any concentration of nocodazole within the range 2.5-10 microM for 12 hr caused a reduction in the proportion of embryos that formed blastocysts. As the period of exposure to 5 microM nocodazole increased from 12 to 24 hr, the proportion of embryos developing to the blastocyst stage decreased. The lower proportion of embryos developing to the blastocyst stage and to term (P < 0.01) suggests that the more advanced stages were more susceptible to damage as a result of exposure to nocodazole. The rate of development of 4-cell embryos to blastocysts was not affected when an exposure time of 9 hr was used. Together these results show that it is possible to use nocodazole to arrest mouse embryonic cells in mitosis but that it is not appropriate to culture the embryos in the presence of this drug for prolonged periods. Individual blastomeres completed mitosis at 60-90 min and started DNA synthesis at 120-150 min after release from nocodazole.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
The production of transgenic animals from ungulate species is an inefficient and expensive procedure. The development of selection methods to identify the small number of transgenic preimplantation embryos produced following DNA microinjection of one-cell embryos would greatly reduce both the cost and effort of these procedures. This study has examined the fate of the ovine beta-lactoglobulin-human alpha 1-antitrypsin (AATB) minigene construct or a subfragment of this following microinjection into one-cell mouse embryos. It has examined two PCR-based methods that were designed to identify a biochemical difference between microinjected DNA constructs to select preimplantation stage embryos in which chromosomal integration of exogenous DNA has occurred. The two methods involved the modification of the AATB DNA construct either by dam methylation or the substitution of dTTP by dUTP. The dam-sensitive DNA endonuclease DpnI, that was used to digest nonintegrated AATB sequences at sites located between PCR oligonucleotide sequences, was found to interfere with the activity of the subsequent PCR reaction. Analyses of the fate of dUTP-DNA indicated that either repair or replication of microinjected DNA interfered with the ability to distinguish between integrated and nonintegrated DNA constructs in the mid-preimplantation stage embryo. The distribution of microinjected AATB DNA between the blastomeres of individual four and eight-cell stage embryos was also examined by the PCR reaction. Microinjected DNA was not found to be evenly distributed between all the blastomeres of individual embryos.
Although it is only a decade since the use of transgenic livestock for the production of pharmaceutical proteins in milk was first suggested, great progress has been made. There is every reason to expect that, as methods for the transfer of genomic clones are applied with efficient regulatory elements, many proteins will be produced at high concentrations in the milk of livestock species. In most cases, these proteins will be biologically active, however, it remains to be shown whether they will be identical in structure and function to the natural product.
The timing of pronuclear formation and the initiation and duration of the DNA synthetic period (S-phase) were determined during the first cell cycle of electrically activated ovine oocytes matured in vivo. Reconstructed embryos were produced by electro-fusion-mediated nuclear transfer of unsynchronized single blastomeres. These were derived from embryos produced in vivo at the 16-cell stage (Day 4) and transferred to enucleated metaphase II oocytes at the time of activation or to enucleated activated oocytes during early, mid, and late stages of the presumptive S-phase. The frequency of development to blastocyst was greatest in embryos reconstructed during the presumptive S-phase of enucleated activated oocytes than in embryos reconstructed at the time of activation (mean 55.4% vs. 21.3%). No significant differences were observed when embryos were reconstructed during early, mid, or late stages of the presumptive S-phase (61.3%, 45.7%, and 57.7%, respectively). The results indicate that the use of enucleated activated oocytes as cytoplasts for embryo reconstruction can increase the frequency of development to blastocyst of embryos reconstructed from unsynchronized donor blastomeres.
Nuclear-cytoplasmic interactions during the second cell cycle of mouse embryos were examined by assessing the timing of cleavage in reconstituted two-cell embryos and their ability to develop further to the blastocyst stage in vitro. Nuclear transplantations were performed either within or across the cell cycle and at different stages of the cell cycle to assess the effect of 'asynchrony' on development. In most cases, cleavage occurred at an intermediate time between nuclear and cytoplasmic controls indicating an interaction in their mechanisms for controlling the timing of cleavage. Early nuclei extended the cleavage timing of late cytoplasm for a short period, possibly to allow for completion of DNA synthesis, while early cytoplasm delayed the expected cleavage time of late nuclei, possibly to enable proper maturation of cytoplasmic components. However, a block of cleavage was observed in most across cell cycle transplantations and also when fusing early two-cell karyoplasts to enucleated late two-cell blastomeres. It is suggested that this incompatibility is caused by major changes in the transcriptional status of donor and recipient cells. Although the development of reconstituted embryos to the blastocyst stage was clearly affected by cell cycle 'asynchrony' in within cell cycle transplantations, independent effects of cytoplast stage and, to a lesser extent, of karyoplast cell cycle stage were predominant in transplantations using eight-cell karyoplasts.
Treatment of mature heifers with recombinant bovine somatotropin (BST) increases the number of ovarian follicles of 2-5 mm in diameter. This study was carried out to investigate whether the increase in the number of small follicles induced by BST treatment can enhance the superovulatory response. In the first experiment, 24 heifers were assigned, in a randomized block design, to four treatment groups: 1) control; 2) BST; 3) pregnant mare serum gonadotropin (PMSG); 4) BST+PMSG. On Day 7 of the estrous cycle, animals in groups 2 and 4 received injections of 320 mg BST (in a sustained release formulation), while heifers in groups 1 and 3 received 10 ml saline. Five days later heifers in groups 3 and 4 were treated with a single dose of 2000 IU PMSG to induce superovulation. Embryos were recovered nonsurgically on Days 6-8 of the following cycle, and all heifers underwent laparoscopy on Day 9 to assess ovulation rate. In a second experiment, 24 heifers were assigned randomly to four treatment groups: 1) PMSG (1000 IU); 2) BST (320 mg) + PMSG (1000 IU); 3) PMSG (2000 IU); 4) BST (320 mg) + PMSG (2000 IU), and then treated as for experiment I. In both experiments, all heifers were scanned daily using real-time ultrasound from the day before BST injection until the day of ovulation to monitor dynamics of ovarian follicular growth and development, and blood samples were collected daily throughout the experimental period for measurement of peripheral progesterone, estradiol-17 beta, growth hormone (GH), and insulin-like growth factor-I (IGF-I).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
The present study investigated the decay of maturation-promoting factor (MPF) activity in electrically activated in vitro-matured bovine oocytes and examined the influence of the cell cycle stage of both the donor nucleus and the recipient cytoplasm upon the morphology and DNA synthesis potential of the donor nucleus in reconstructed embryos. The decay of MPF activity was studied both biochemically in electrically activated in vitro-matured oocytes and by morphological examination of nuclear structure in reconstructed bovine embryos. As measured by H1 kinase activity in groups of 10 oocytes, the level of MPF declined rapidly to 30 +/- 4% (of the maximum level in unactivated control oocytes) at 60 min and reached a basal level of 20 +/- 6% at 120 min. This level of activity was then maintained until at least 9 h postactivation. In contrast, when MPF activity was assayed by morphological examination of nuclei in individual reconstructed embryos, the decline in activity occurred over a period of 9 h postactivation. DNA synthesis of nuclei arrested at the G1/S border and in G2 phases of the cell cycle was examined in embryos reconstructed at the time of oocyte activation, i.e., when MPF levels were maximal, and by fusion 10 h postactivation, when no MPF activity could be detected. All nuclei transferred at the time of oocyte activation underwent nuclear envelope breakdown (NEBD) and subsequent DNA synthesis. However, when nuclei were transferred 10 h after activation, no NEBD was observed in any nuclei. Nuclei arrested at the G1/S border or nuclei in S phase when transferred in the absence of NEBD underwent DNA synthesis, while no DNA synthesis was observed in G2 nuclei transferred into this cytoplasmic environment. The results presented show that all nuclei, regardless of cell cycle stage, undergo DNA replication when transplanted into metaphase II (MeII) cytoplasts in which MPF activity is high. From these observations we would suggest that one factor that may contribute to the present low frequency of development of bovine nuclear transfer embryos is the ploidy of the reconstructed embryo after the first cell cycle. In order to maintain correct ploidy of the reconstructed embryo, only G1 nuclei should be transferred at the time of activation, when MPF levels are high. In contrast, when the integrity of the nuclear membrane is maintained by transfer at 10 h postactivation, when MPF activity is absent, the rereplication of G2 nuclei is prevented and correct ploidy of the reconstructed embryo may be maintained.
Previous studies have shown that females of the Chinese Meishan breed and of their F1 cross with European Large White pigs are very prolific, producing about four more piglets per litter than control Large White females. The main cause of this prolificacy is enhanced prenatal survival for a given ovulation rate in Meishan and F1 females and this is controlled by genes of the mother, not those of the conceptus. The objectives of this study were to determine whether genotypic differences in embryo survival were apparent in the period immediately after attachment and to compare embryonic and uterine development at this time. Sows in their third parity (20 Large White, 14 Meishan, 25 Large White x Meishan F1 and 25 Meishan x Large White F1) were killed 20-22 days after mating and their reproductive tracts recovered for further study. There were significant differences between the purebred sows, and crossbred sows were approximately intermediate for the number of corpora lutea (20.7 +/- 0.9, 27.8 +/- 1.1, 22.4 +/- 0.8 and 23.3 +/- 0.8 for the four genotypes, respectively), the number of embryos (15.2 +/- 0.9, 23.4 +/- 1.1, 17.2 +/- 0.8 and 18.8 +/- 0.8, respectively) and the proportionate embryo survival (0.74 +/- 0.04, 0.84 +/- 0.04, 0.78 +/- 0.03 and 0.82 +/- 0.03, respectively). There was a negative association within genotype between embryo survival and the number of corpora lutea. Adjusting for the genotypic difference in the number of corpora lutea increased the genotypic differences in embryo survival.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)