Deviations from receptor theory?
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Animals↗
Biomedical subjects
I G Dougall
Publications and source records attributed to I G Dougall.
Estimation of the efficacy and affinity of the beta 2-adrenoceptor agonist salmeterol in guinea-pig trachea.
1. We have attempted to estimate the affinity and efficacy of the new beta 2-adrenoceptor agonist salmeterol in the guinea-pig isolated trachea and to compare these estimates with those obtained for salbutamol. 2. The kinetics of the relaxation to salmeterol were considerably slower than those to salbutamol and the responses were poorly defined. Nevertheless, in experiments employing a cumulative curve design both salmeterol and salbutamol exhibited partial agonist behaviour. Operational model-fitting of these data indicated that the intrinsic efficacies of the two agonists were indistinguishable but that salmeterol had an affinity (pKA = 7.4) some 30 fold greater than salbutamol (pKA = 5.9). 3. Single dose experiments, using maximally effective concentrations of salmeterol or salbutamol were carried out in an attempt to quantify more reliably the relative efficacies of the two agonists. In these experiments salbutamol was found to have an efficacy (2.5) approximately 3 fold greater than that of salmeterol (0.8). 4. Full/partial agonist interaction studies were carried out to provide another estimate of the affinity of salmeterol. Isoprenaline and adrenaline were employed as full agonists in these experiments and the affinity (pKB) estimates obtained for salmeterol against these agonists were 7.3 and 7.4 respectively. These affinity estimates were similar to the pKA value (7.4) obtained by operational model-fitting. 5. Salmeterol has slightly lower efficacy (3 fold) but markedly greater affinity (30 fold) than salbutamol at beta 2-receptors. The slightly lower efficacy of salmeterol is unlikely to have clinical implications for this drug as a bronchodilator beta 2-adrenoceptor agonist in asthma.
Adrenergic beta-Agonists↗
Errors in agonist affinity estimation: do they and should they occur in isolated tissue experiments?
Two plausible theories of agonist action - the isomerization and ternary complex mechanisms - predict that agonist affinity measured using the inactivation method may be subject to overestimation. Moreover, the greater the intrinsic efficacy, the greater the predicted error. But are these predictions correct, and are they borne out by experimental data? Paul Leff and colleagues argue that accurate agonist affinity constants can be measured despite these predictions, but that effort must be made to detect any potential errors that might be anticipated from theory.
Animals↗
Pharmacological estimation of agonist affinity: detection of errors that may be caused by the operation of receptor isomerisation or ternary complex mechanisms.
1. Recent theoretical studies have questioned the pharmacological estimation of agonist affinity. They showed that when receptor isomerisation or ternary complex mechanisms operate, the receptor inactivation method can substantially overestimate affinity, whereas methods for partial agonist analysis are more accurate. We previously suggested that the operation of such mechanisms and therefore the presence of errors could be detected by analysing the same partial agonist by the receptor inactivation and comparative methods. This paper describes the practical application of this test. 2. The ternary complex mechanism was simulated for a partial agonist under various conditions relating receptor (R) and transducer (T) concentrations, one of which also corresponds to the receptor isomerisation mechanism. The theoretical data so generated were then analysed by the inactivation and comparative methods to quantify the magnitude of error of affinity estimation that could occur. 3. This analysis showed that for a partial agonist with approximately 85% of the activity of a full agonist, the inactivation method could produce an affinity (pKA) estimate up to 0.7 log10 units higher than that produced by the comparative method. This difference would occur when the total receptor concentration ([R0]) is less than or equal to the total transducer concentration ([T0]). It also showed that the overestimation of affinity by the inactivation method was accompanied by drastic overestimation of Em, the maximal effect parameter. 4. The test was then exemplified using the muscarinic receptor system in the guinea-pig isolated left atrial preparation, where there is evidence that a ternary complex mechanism operates. The test agonist was pilocarpine, which produced on average 83% of the activity of the full agonist, carbachol. Pilocarpine was analysed in comparison with carbachol and by receptor inactivation in the same tissue resulting in small and statistically insignificant differences in Em (96.7% and 97.3% respectively) and pKA (5.03 and 4.95 respectively). 5. In conclusion, in this experimental system, there was no evidence for the errors in agonist affinity estimation predicted by theory. Although this conclusion only applies to this system and application of the test to others is necessary to establish the generality of the present results, further examination of the theoretical basis for the predicted errors is required.
Animals↗
Estimation of affinities and efficacies for kappa-receptor agonists in guinea-pig ileum.
1. Ethylketocyclazocine (EKC) and U50,488H have been employed widely as kappa-receptor agonists in the study of opioid receptor systems. However, the quantification of their agonism in terms of affinities and relative efficacies has not been investigated. 2. In this study, operational model-fitting was used to analyse the effects of irreversible receptor alkylation by beta-chlornaltrexamine (beta-CNA) on the kappa-receptor mediated effects of EKC and U50,488H in the isolated, coaxially stimulated ileum of the guinea-pig. 3. EKC produced monophasic inhibitory concentration-effect curves which were readily amenable to analysis. In contrast U50,488H produced biphasic curves characterized by a higher potency phase of agonism that was susceptible to antagonism by 16-methylcyprenorphine (RX8008M) and a lower potency phase that was apparently non-opioid in nature. 4. Analysis of the kappa-receptor-mediated effects of both agonists indicated that EKC has fifteen fold higher affinity than U50,488H and that the two agonists possess similar intrinsic efficacies.
3,4-Dichloro-N-methyl-N-(2-(1-pyrrolidinyl)-cycloh↗
Estimation of opioid receptor agonist dissociation constants with beta-chlornaltrexamine, an irreversible ligand which also displays agonism.
1. The irreversible opioid receptor antagonist beta-chlornaltrexamine (beta-CNA) has been shown previously to have agonist activity in the guinea-pig ileum preparation. However, the receptor type or types mediating this effect have not been established. 2. In this study, the agonism of beta-CNA was investigated by use of the competitive antagonist 16-methylcyprenorphine (RX8008M). Non-cumulative concentration-effect curves for beta-CNA were displaced in a non-parallel fashion indicating that the agonism was mediated by both mu- and kappa-receptors. 3. In principle, expression of agonism by an irreversible receptor antagonist could compromise its use in estimating agonist dissociation constants (pKAs) due to desensitization operating in addition to receptor inactivation. For kappa-receptors, this possibility was checked by use of ethylketocyclazocine (EKC) to mimic the agonist effects of beta-CNA and test whether subsequent EKC concentration-effect curves were displaced. For mu-receptors it was necessary to perform more involved experiments in which [D-Ala2, MePhe4, Gly-ol5]enkephalin (DAGOL) was used as a standard agonist and its pKA was estimated under different conditions of beta-CNA incubation. 4. These analyses indicated that neither the mu- nor the kappa-receptor-mediated agonism of beta-CNA was associated with appreciable receptor desensitization. In turn it was concluded that the usefulness of beta-CNA as a pharmacological tool for the estimation of mu- and kappa-opioid receptor agonist dissociation constants is not compromised by the agonist effects that the compound demonstrates at these receptors.
Animals↗
A critical review of the classification of opioid receptors.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Humans↗
Pharmacological analysis of the calcium-dependence of mu-receptor agonism.
1 A number of studies in isolated tissues have shown that mu-opioid-receptor-mediated agonism can be augmented or potentiated with reduction in extracellular calcium concentration [( Ca2+]o). These effects have been ascribed to alterations in post-receptor coupling but the nature of the changes involved have not been quantitatively elucidated. 2 In this paper, logistic curve-fitting and operational model-fitting (Black & Leff, 1983) were used to analyse the effects of variations in [Ca2+]o on the mu-receptor-mediated effects of [D-Ala2, MePhe4, Gly-ol5]enkephalin (DAGOL) in the isolated, coaxially-stimulated ileum of the guinea-pig. At each value of [Ca2+]o, the effects of irreversible receptor alkylation by beta-chlornaltrexamine (beta-CNA) were also investigated. 3 From these analyses it is concluded that with reduction in [Ca2+]o the efficacy of DAGOL in this system is increased and the sensitivity of the transducer relation is also enhanced, the latter indicating a trend towards positive co-operativity. Reduction of [Ca2+]o also appeared to produce a reduction in agonist affinity. 4 Experimental manipulation of [Ca2+]o may provide a useful means of enhancing mu-agonist efficacy, allowing detection of agonism in compounds with low intrinsic efficacies. However, the accompanying change in co-operativity of the transducer relation must be considered when quantifying agonism under these conditions.
Animals↗