Epitope mapping by differential chemical modification of antigens.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Biomedical subjects
Publications and source records attributed to H R Bosshard.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Little is known about the extent to which protein flexibility contributes to antigen-antibody recognition and cross-reactivity. Using short coil peptides (leucine zippers) as model antigens, we demonstrate that a monoclonal antibody can force a noncognate peptide into a conformation that is similar to the conformation of the cognate peptide against which the monoclonal antibody is directed. Monoclonal antibodies 29AB and 13AD were raised against the 29-residue peptide LZ (Ac-EYEALEKKLAALEAKLQALEKKLEALEHG-amide) that forms a very stable coiled coil. The two antibodies cross-reacted strongly with the random coil analogue LZ(7P14P) that contains Lys-->Pro and Ala-->Pro substitutions in positions 7 and 14, respectively. The antibody-bound peptide LZ(7P14P) adopted an altered conformation that possibly was coiled coil-like, as shown by CD difference spectroscopy and fluorescence quenching experiments on coumarin-labeled peptides. Isothermal titration calorimetry revealed that the cross-reaction of antibodies 13AD and 29AB with the random coil peptide LZ(7P14P) exhibited a large unfavorable entropy. This, however, was strongly compensated by a more favorable enthalpy, resulting in only a small difference between the association constants for peptide LZ and LZ(7P14P), respectively. To investigate the opposite type of cross-reaction, monoclonal antibody 42PF was raised against the random coil peptide LZ(7P14P). 42PF cross-reacted with coiled coil peptide LZ by forcing it to dissociate into single chains. Enthalpy/entropy compensation again enabled the cross-reaction, which now was entropically favored and enthalpically disfavored. The rate of reaction of antibody 42PF with peptide LZ was controlled by the rate of dissociation of LZ into single chains. This observation, as well as the generally much slower reaction rate with the noncognate peptides, indicated that the cross-reactivity occurred because the antibody selected the conformer of the antigen that binds the strongest, a mechanism we call "induced fit by conformational selection."
Real-time monitoring of intermolecular interactions can provide a direct and rapid estimate of the affinity and kinetics of interactions between biomolecules. Optical methods based on the measurement of changes of refractive index in the immediate vicinity of a liquid-solid interface are particularly convenient because they require no radioactive, fluorescent or other labelling of the molecules under study. In the present work we have followed the specific interaction of protein molecules on a SiO2/TiO2 surface with the help of the optical grating coupler sensor instrument BIOS-1. This instrument allows the determination of the absolute mass of protein adsorbed to the sensor surface and, therefore, the calculation of the molar ratio of the components partaking in an intermolecular interaction. For example, about 3 ng avidin/mm2 surface area could be adsorbed. This amount closely corresponds to a monolayer composed of densely packed globular avidin molecules. A dimeric, biotinylated leucine zipper peptide was bound to this avidin layer at a molar ratio of 1:1 (1 peptide molecule/4 biotin binding sites of tetrameric avidin). An average of 1/2.6 peptides was recognized by a peptide-specific monoclonal antibody. Even though avidin was not covalently bound to the sensor surface, the avidin-coated chip could be used repeatedly to measure the time course of antibody binding as a function of the concentration of the antibody. From such measurements it was possible to calculate the association and dissociation rate constants assuming that the interaction of the antibody with the surface-bound antigen can be described by a simple Langmuir binding model. The limits of the Langmuir model are discussed. The same antigen-antibody reaction was also analyzed by a surface plasmon resonance biosensor (BIAcoreTM, Pharmacia). The results obtained with the two instruments, which register different optical phenomena and employ different surface chemistry, were in good agreement.
Leucine zippers are short coiled coils frequently found in transcription factors where they serve as dimerization domains. The basic features contributing to the thermodynamic stability of leucine zippers are well understood, but very little is known about their folding kinetics. Leucine zippers have a simple and well defined structure and are, therefore, excellent models for the study of the concerted folding and assembly of polypeptide chains. Here we report on a fluorescence stopped flow investigation of the kinetics of association and dissociation of a series of model leucine zippers based on the common sequence Xzero-EYEALEKKLAAX1EAKX2QALEKKLEALEHG-amide (Xzero = N alpha-acetyl, N alpha-fluorescein-GGG, or N alpha-dimethylaminocoumarin-GGG; Xl = Leu or Ala; X2 = Leu, Ala, or Asn). When Xzero is fluorescein, self-quenching between adjacent fluorophores leads to a decrease in fluorescence emission intensity whereas unfolding of the coiled coil leads to an increase. In a heteromeric coiled coil containing both fluorophores, resonance energy transfer between the donor coumarin and the acceptor fluorescein is observed, and the mixing of labeled and nonlabeled peptides allows the measurement of the rates of strand exchange between leucine zippers. Exchange rates do not depend on peptide concentration, indicating that strand exchange is governed by the rate of dissociation of the coiled coil. Strand exchange between leucine zippers with X1 and X2 = Leu occurs with a half-time of approximately 30 min. A single Leu/Ala substitution at X1 or X2 decreases the half-time to approximately 1 s. Folding was also studied in a relaxation experiment in which a preexisting equilibrium between monomeric chains and coiled coils was rapidly disturbed by dilution with buffer, and the relaxation to the new equilibrium was followed by the increase in fluorescence. In peptides with X1, X2 = Ala or X1 = Ala, X2 = Asn the folding process can be described by a simple two-state monomer<-->dimer equilibrium with k(on) approximately 4 x 10(6) M-1 s-1 and k(off) approximately 10 s-1. Kd = k(off)/k(on) approximately 2.5 microM is in good agreement with the value of Kd obtained from equilibrium measurements. The peptides with a single Ala at X1 or X2 exhibit biphasic folding kinetics. One phase is concentration dependent and the other apparently concentration independent. This behavior can be interpreted as a monomer<-->dimer equilibrium coupled to an equilibrium between different conformational isomers. Leu to Ala and Leu to Asn substitutions in the hydrophobic core alter the folding kinetics in a position-dependent manner.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)
The development of "soft" ionization methods has enabled the mass spectrometric analysis of higher-order structural features of proteins. We have applied electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) to the analysis of the number and composition of polypeptide chains in homomeric and heteromeric leucine zippers. In comparison with other methods that have been used to analyze leucine zippers, such as analytical ultracentrifugation, gel chromatography, or electrophoretic band shift assays, ESI-MS is very fast and highly sensitive and provides a straightforward way to distinguish between homomeric and heteromeric coiled-coil structures. ESI-MS analyses were carried out on the parallel dimeric leucine zipper domain GCN4-p1 of the yeast transcription factor GCN4 and on three synthetic peptides with the sequences Ac-EYEALEKKLAAX1EAKX2QALEKKLEALEHG-amide: peptide LZ (X1, X2 = Leu), peptide LZ(12A) (X1 = Ala, X2 = Leu), and peptide LZ(16N) (X1 = Leu, X2 = Asn). Equilibrium ultracentrifugation analysis showed that LZ forms a trimeric coiled coil and this could be confirmed unequivocally by ESI-MS as could the dimeric nature of GCN4-p1. The formation of heteromeric two- and three-stranded leucine zippers composed of chains from LZ and LZ(12A), or from GCN4-p1 and LZ, was demonstrated by ESI-MS and confirmed by fluorescence quenching experiments on fluorescein-labeled peptides. The results illustrate the adaptability and flexibility of the leucine zipper motif, properties that could be useful to the design of specific protein assemblies by way of coiled-coil domains.
The recent development of 'soft' ionization-desorption methods has lead to a breakthrough for the mass spectrometric analysis of biomacromolecules such as proteins and nucleic acids. In particular, the feasibility of electrospray-ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) for the direct characterization of non-covalent supramolecular complexes is opening new analytical perspectives. Examples hitherto analyzed by ESI-MS include enzyme-substrate and -inhibitor complexes, homo- and heterodimers/trimers of leucine zipper polypeptides, and several other DNA- and RNA-binding proteins. Furthermore, the characterization of double-stranded and higher-order oligo- and polynucleotide complexes by negative-ion ESI has been demonstrated. Ions specific of non-covalent protein and oligonucleotide complexes can be selectively dissociated by changing the solution conditions and by increasing the desolvation potential. These results form the basis for the molecular characterization of protein-nucleotide interactions, thus complementing protein-chemical approaches, and other methods of structure determination.
The association of ferredoxin with ferredoxin:NADP+ reductase (both proteins from spinach chloroplasts) was characterized by isothermal titration calorimetry and fluorescence quenching titration. The formation of the complex is mainly driven by a positive entropy change (delta S = 125 +/- 8 J mol-1 K-1). The calorimetric enthalpy of binding is small between 10 and 37 degrees C and either negative or positive, with an inversion temperature near 25 degrees C. The pH dependence of the association constant [Batie, C. J., & Kamin, H. (1981) J. Biol. Chem. 256, 7756-7763] was shown to correlate with the uptake of a single proton by a group exhibiting a heat of protonation of -26 kJ mol-1. This value agrees with the protonation of an imidazole group. Possible residues to become protonated in the complex are His-19 or His-90 of ferredoxin:NADP+ reductase. The temperature dependence of the free energy of binding, delta G, is weak because of the enthalpy-entropy compensation caused by a heat capacity change, delta Cp, of -680 +/- 44 J mol-1 K-1. The favorable binding entropy and the negative delta Cp indicate a large contribution to binding from hydrophobic effects, which seem to originate from dehydration of the protein-protein interface. Dehydration was demonstrated by osmotic stress experiments in which the association constant was found to increase by 2-4-fold in the presence of 52% (w/w) glycerol. The increase in the association constant with osmotic pressure points to the release of several water molecules from the complex interface.
Differential chemical modification of acidic residues was used to map the binding site of plant ferredoxin (Fd) for the chloroplast enzyme ferredoxin:thioredoxin reductase (FTR). Binding of FTR to Fd inhibits chemical modification of Fd residues D34, D65, E92, E93, E94 and C-terminal A97. The binding site demarcated by these residues differs from that for ferredoxin:NADP+ reductase (FNR). The FTR site includes C-terminal residues but not helix 24-31, which is part of the FNR site. Both sites enclose the [2Fe-2S] cluster.
Antiserum to a native protein may cross-react with the corresponding denatured protein or with peptides. The cross-reaction is either a genuine property of the antibodies or caused by antibodies produced against some unfolded protein contaminating the native protein used for immunization. Appropriate conformation-sensitive immunoassays must be employed to distinguish a genuine from an apparent cross-reaction. In the present study, we have analyzed critically the cross-reaction of rabbit antisera against proteins and peptides. We have distinguished between genuine and apparent cross-reaction with the help of the protein A antibody-capture ELISA, a new conformation-sensitive ELISA format. Three systems were analyzed: cross-reaction of antisera to native yeast and horse cytochrome c with unfolded apo-cytochrome c; cross-reaction of antisera to a coiled-coil leucine-zipper peptide with a homologous random-coil peptide obtained by introducing two proline residues into the leucine-zipper sequence; cross-reaction of antisera to two peptides that correspond to the N-terminal and an internal sequence of ferredoxin: NADP+ reductase (FNR), with the native enzyme. The reaction of the anti-(cytochrome c) sera was clearly due to antibodies produced against unfolded protein, it was an apparent and not a genuine cross-reaction. Furthermore, the apparently cross-reactive antibodies to horse cytochrome c did not discriminate against sequence-related proteins from dog, beef, rabbit and pigeon. In contrast, antibodies to the leucine-zipper peptide did cross-react in a genuine way with the homologous random-coil peptide, that is, the cross-reactive antibodies do not seem to have been produced against the unfolded form of the leucine-zipper peptide. Of the two anti-peptide sera the one against the unstructured and highly accessible N-terminal segment reacted strongly with the native protein. The second serum against a solvent-accessible turn-like sequence of FNR showed apparent cross-reactivity: antibodies recognizing the native protein were directed against a minor conformational isoform of the free peptide and did not react with the principal form(s) of the free peptide. The generation of cross-reactive antibodies depends on the conformational stability and integrity of the immunogen and on the molecular form of its application, i.e., free, polymerized or carrier-bound. The results clarify the different nature of cross-reactivity of antisera to proteins and peptides. This knowledge is crucial if antisera are to be used as conformation-specific probes.
It has long been known that antibodies to cytochrome c can distinguish between closely sequence-related cytochromes c. Because the 3-D-structure of the polypeptide chain is virtually identical among eukaryotic cytochromes c, antibody specificity is directed against amino acid substitutions within a common polypeptide folding pattern. The question arises if the specificity is observed at the level of the 3-D-structure (conformational epitopes) and/or at the level of the primary structure (sequential epitopes). Using rabbit sera to horse cytochrome c, we show that discrimination against the host's own cytochrome c (six amino acid changes) occurs exclusively at the 3-D-level and not between peptides with sequences typical for horse and rabbit cytochrome c. Furthermore, deliberate immunization with horse apo-cytochrome c produces antibodies that cannot discriminate efficiently between sequence-related apo-cytochromes c. B-cell tolerance to the host's own protein seems to be restricted to the intact, native cytochrome. These findings bear on the application of antisera to distinguish between closely related proteins.
The chloroplast enzyme ferredoxin: NADP+ reductase (FNR) catalyzes the reduction of NADP+ by ferredoxin (Fd). FNR and Fd form a 1:1 complex that is stabilized by electrostatic interactions between acidic residues of Fd and basic residues of FNR. To localize lysine residues at the Fd binding site of FNR, the FNR:Fd complex (both proteins from spinach) was studied by differential chemical modification. In a first set of experiments, free FNR and the FNR:Fd complex were reacted with the N-hydroxysuccinimidyl ester of biotin. Biotinylated peptides and non-biotinylated peptides were separated on monovalent avidin-Sepharose and purified by high-performance liquid chromatography. Two peptides containing Lys18 and Lys153, respectively, were less biotinylated in complexed FNR than in free FNR. In a second set of experiments, free and complexed FNR were treated with 4-N,N-dimethylaminoazobenzene-4'-isothiocyano-2'-sulfonic acid (S-DABITC) to obtain coloured lysine-modified FNR. Protection of Lys153 was again found by modification with S-DABITC. In addition, Lys33 and Lys35 were less labelled in the S-DABITC-modified. Fd-bound enzyme. FNR modified in the presence, but not in the absence, of Fd was still able to bind Fd, indicating that the Fd-protected residues are involved in the formation of the Fd:FNR complex. The lysine residues disclosed by differential modification surround the positive end of the molecular dipole moment (558 Debye approximately 1.85 x 10(-27) Cm) and are located in a domain of strong positive potential on the surface of the FNR molecule. This domain we had proposed to belong to the binding site of FNR for Fd [De Pascalis, A. R., Jelesarov, I., Ackermann, F., Koppenol, W. H., Hirasawa, M., Knaff, D. B. & Bosshard, H. R. (1993) Protein Science 2. 1126-1135]. The prediction was based on the complementarity of shape between positive and negative potential domains of FNR and Fd, respectively.
Adsorption to a polymeric surface may severely alter the antigenic structure of proteins through unfolding. A conventional capture ELISA in which a protein antigen is adsorbed to the microtiter plate may be unsuitable for testing the specificity of antibodies directed against native proteins (C. Schwab and H.R. Bosshard (1992) J. Immunol. Methods 147, 125). This problem can be overcome by PACE, a new ELISA procedure in which monoclonal or polyclonal antibodies are first allowed to equilibrate with biotinylated antigen in solution. Thereafter, the antigen-antibody complex (and free antibody) is bound to the microtiter plate through protein A. Captured antigen-antibody complex is detected by streptavidin-alkaline phosphatase and p-nitrophenylphosphate. A competition assay is accomplished by co-incubation of biotinylated and non-biotinylated antigens before capture to the protein A-coated plate. PACE combines the advantages of a solution-phase immunoassay (Farr assay) with the ease of a solid-phase ELISA. PACE has been used to test the conformational specificity of polyclonal and monoclonal antibodies against native and denatured cytochrome c, and of a polyclonal antiserum against a coiled coil leucine zipper peptide. Since a biotin group can be attached specifically to the N-terminal residue of synthetic peptides, PACE is also useful for assaying reactivity against peptide antigens which are difficult to adsorb to microtiter plates.
Crystallographic work on antigen-antibody complexes has revealed that extensive surface areas of proteins may interact with antibodies. On the other hand, most experimental approaches to locate and define antigenic determinants of protein antigens rely on the linear sequence of the polypeptide chain. Hence the question arises whether mapping of antibody binding sites by analysis of the reactivity of anti-protein antibodies with synthetic peptides can provide a representative picture of the antigenic structure of a protein antigen. We have addressed this question using yeast iso-1 cytochrome c as a protein antigen against which antisera were raised in rabbits. The reaction of the antisera with 103 synthetic hexapeptides covering the entire sequence of cytochrome c was tested by the pepscan procedure in which peptides are coupled to polyethylene rods and tested by ELISA. For the assay, anti-cytochrome c antibodies were fractionated by affinity chromatography on native yeast iso-1 cytochrome c and on apo-cytochrome c; the latter is a random coil. It was found that only antibodies retained by the apo-cytochrome c affinity column react with synthetic peptides. These antibodies comprise a small fraction, probably less than 2%, of all cytochrome c-specific antibodies. The majority of antigenic determinants, which seem to consist of strongly conformation-dependent topographic epitopes, could not be uncovered by the peptide approach. Epitope mapping with short peptides seems of limited usefulness in the case of small, globular, and conformationally stable proteins like cytochrome c.
The small, soluble, (2Fe-2S)-containing protein ferredoxin (Fd) mediates electron transfer from the chloroplast photosystem I to ferredoxin: NADP+ oxidoreductase (FNR), a flavoenzyme located on the stromal side of the thylakoid membrane. Ferredoxin and FNR form a 1:1 complex, which is stabilized by electrostatic interactions between acidic residues of Fd and basic residues of FNR. We have used differential chemical modification of Fd to locate aspartic and glutamic acid residues at the intermolecular interface of the Fd:FNR complex (both proteins from spinach). Carboxyl groups of free and FNR-bound Fd were amidated with carbodiimide/2-aminoethane sulfonic acid (taurine). The differential reactivity of carboxyl groups was assessed by double isotope labeling. Residues protected in the Fd:FNR complex were D-26, E-29, E-30, D-34, D-65, and D-66. The protected residues belong to two domains of negative electrostatic surface potential on either side of the iron-sulfur cluster. The negative end of the molecular dipole moment vector of Fd (377 Debye) is close to the iron-sulfur cluster, in the center of the area demarcated by the protected carboxyl groups. The molecular dipole moment and the asymmetric surface potential may help to orient Fd in the reaction with FNR. In support, we find complementary domains of positive electrostatic potential on either side of the FAD redox center of FNR. The results allow a binding model for the Fd:FNR complex to be constructed.
Rabbit antisera against apo-cytochrome c, which was prepared by removal of the covalently bound heme prosthetic group from yeast iso-1 cytochrome c, were tested for reactivity against native yeast iso-1-cytochrome c. When the antigen was adsorbed to a microtiter plate in a conventional enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA), the antisera were unable to distinguish between their cognate antigen apo-cytochrome c, a random coil protein, and native cytochrome c, a small globular protein of remarkable conformational stability in solution. However, when the assay was conducted under conditions where antigen and antibody were free to associate in solution, that is in a solution-phase radioimmunoassay (RIA), the antisera were highly specific for apo-cytochrome c. Similarly, antibodies induced by native cytochrome c and discriminating strongly between native and apo-cytochrome c in a solution-phase RIA, did not distinguish between native and apo-cytochrome c in a solid-phase ELISA. This discrepancy of results obtained by different immuno assay procedures clearly indicates that adsorption to plastic alters the antigenic structure of even a conformationally stable protein such as cytochrome c. A conventional solid-phase ELISA strongly selects for those antibodies that recognize the unfolded antigen. The results presented warrant serious thoughts about previous reports on anti-peptide antibodies reacting with native whole protein molecules, as tested by those ELISA procedures that have the protein antigen adsorbed to plastic.
Peptides synthesized onto polyethylene pins can be directly used to map the antigenic structure of proteins by ELISA (Geysen et al., 1987, J. Immunol. Methods 102, 259-274). The specificity of the reaction between anti-cytochrome c antibodies (IgG) and pin-bound hexapeptides of cytochrome c was tested using a competitive ELISA in which free and pin-bound peptides competed for the antibody. Competition was specific for many of the pin-bound peptides: only free peptides having the same sequence as the pin-bound peptides were able to compete for antibody-binding. However, non-specific reactivity was observed with pin-bound peptides whose sequence corresponded to the N terminal segment of cytochrome c. This segment is predicted to be particularly antigenic because of its high mobility and the nature of its amino acid sequence. In one case no competition by the free peptide could be observed even though the pin-bound peptide reacted strongly with anti-cytochrome c antibodies.
We describe two monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) against rat cytochrome P450IIB1 and investigate the mechanisms by which they influence P450IIB1-mediated catalysis. MAb ce9 partially inhibits the activities toward p-nitroanisole, 7-ethoxycoumarin, and benzphetamine as well as NADPH oxidation. These findings can be explained by the observation that ce9 cross-links P450 to form large aggregates resulting in the inhibition of the functional interaction with NADPH cytochrome P450 reductase. Binding of ce9 to P450IIB1 does not affect the spin state of the P450 heme, as revealed by comparing the magnetic circular dichroism (MCD) spectra of free and antibody-bound P450IIB1. On the other hand, the second antibody tested, MAb 14E10, induces a remarkable low to high spin transition upon binding to P450IIB1, as shown by MCD difference spectroscopy. This MAb stimulates activities toward p-nitroanisole and 7-ethoxycoumarin without affecting the rate of NADPH oxidation. This observation indicates that MAb 14E10 may increase the efficiency of electron utilization by P450IIB1. Benzphetamine metabolism remains unchanged in the presence of MAb 14E10.
The antigenic determinants for three monoclonal antibodies against cytochrome c2 from Rhodospirillum rubrum were partially characterized by differential chemical modification of free and antibody-bound cytochrome c2 and by cross-reactivity analysis with different antigens. Circular dichroism spectroscopy was used to probe the effect of antibody binding on the conformation of cytochrome c2. The binding of two antibodies was strongly dependent on the native folding of the antigen. The first antibody bound to a determinant around the exposed heme edge on the 'front side' of the molecule which is not antigenic in mitochondrial cytochrome c2. Binding of this antibody to cytochrome c increased the induced CD of the ferric heme in a manner similar to that observed previously when mitochondrial cytochrome-c oxidase bound to the front side of cytochrome c. This observation points to a subtle conformational adaptation of the antigen induced by the antibody. The determinant for the second antibody, which also affected the heme CD spectrum of the antigen, was on a polypeptide loop where cytochrome c2 differs from mitochondrial cytochrome c by an eight-residue insertion. The third antibody, which did not induce a change in CD, bound to a sequential determinant near the amino end of cytochrome c2. Only this antibody cross-reacted with isolated cytochrome-c-derived peptides and with apo-cytochrome c2. A preliminary analysis of the polyclonal immune response of five rats against cytochrome c2 indicates that, unlike in eukaryotic cytochrome c, antigenic determinants are distributed over the whole polypeptide chain of the prokaryotic immunogen.