Search PubMed⌕ Search

Biomedical subjects

G G Browning

Publications and source records attributed to G G Browning.

At least 37 records · Page 2Linked to original sources

Is otoscopy reliable? A structured teaching method to improve otoscopic accuracy in trainees.

Otoscopy is an important skill for primary care physicians and otologists. Until now, training has been by repeated exposure to patients with ear disease. Structured instruction in how to assess an ear has not previously been reported. Not-diseased ears and those with varying types of chronic (suppurative) otitis media were chosen to be photographed as this is an important condition to be able to diagnose and in which pneumatic otoscopy has no role. Two sets of 30 slides of equal difficulty were shown to 10 trainees, one before and one after structured teaching. The overall error rate fell from 44 to 21% (P < 0.001). Most importantly, the error rate in assessing ear activity fell from 35 to 17% (P < 0.05). In conclusion, a structured approach to otoscopy has been shown to improve the diagnostic ability of trainess tested with photographs of ears with chronic otitis media. Such a teaching approach is likely to be equally beneficial to other otological conditions and to live otoscopy.

Diagnostic Errors↗

A prospective evaluation of direct referral to audiology departments for hearing aids.

It has been suggested that a proportion of individuals with a hearing impairment can be fitted with a hearing aid without being otolaryngologically assessed. Such assessments are deemed advisable: (a) to identify otological pathology that might require management and (b) because surgery can be a viable alternative in those with a conductive impairment. The aim of this study was to prospectively study individuals referred to an Otolaryngology Department in a teaching hospital to assess how technicians, at a direct referral clinic for the provision of a hearing aid, could screen to identify those meriting an otolaryngological opinion. Two hundred and forty-eight patients were evaluated by technicians using strict audiometric and tympanometric criteria. One hundred and twenty-five patients (50 per cent) failed these criteria and were referred to an otologist. The remaining 123 (50 per cent) were managed by technicians but were subsequently reviewed for the purpose of this study by an otologist and their management assessed. In only two patients (one per cent) was it thought that the initial management would have been different if seen by an otologist. Alternative criteria for deciding suitability for management by technicians were applied. The inclusion of tympanometry was essential to avoid missing middle ear pathology.

Acoustic Impedance Tests↗

Estimation of the benefit of bone-anchored hearing aids.

Implantable bone conduction hearing aids are a valuable alternative to conventional aids for those who cannot use a conventional air conduction aid or find it difficult to use because of an aural discharge, most commonly due to chronic otitis media. Previously reported series of the use of a bone-anchored hearing aid (BAHA) come from the originators of this device, and an independent report of their benefit and use, especially in previous air conduction aid users, would be of value. Twenty-three patients were evaluated at least 6 months after implantation of a BAHA. All 7 previous bone conduction aid users were delighted with their BAHA, reporting increased comfort and hearing benefit that was backed by audiometric evidence. Of the 16 individuals who previously used an air conduction aid, 11 (69%) were delighted users of their BAHA. Unfortunately, the other 5 (31%) reverted to solely using their air conduction aid. There was no obvious predictor as to how these individuals might have been identified prior to implantation. In particular, their pure tone thresholds, especially the bone conduction thresholds, were no different from those of the 11 BAHA users. However, in free field audiometry, the users gained superior benefit from their BAHA compared to their air conduction aid, whereas the nonusers did not. In conclusion, in all series to date, previous users of a conventional bone conduction aid have been delighted users of a BAHA and have gained superior audiometric benefit. This is not necessarily the case with previous air conduction aid users.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Adult↗

A randomized study of the surgical management of children with persistent otitis media with effusion associated with a hearing impairment.

The object of this study was to compare the effect on the hearing of the insertion of a grommet, with or without adenoidectomy, against a non-surgically managed control ear in children with persistent hearing impairment due to otitis media with effusion. Seventy-eight children (44 boys, 34 girls, mean age 5.8 years) with documented bilateral otitis media with effusion associated with a bilateral hearing impairment (pure tone average air conduction thresholds over 0.5, 1 and 2 kHz of > or = 25 dB HL) over a three month period were admitted to a randomized, controlled trial. Each child was randomized to have or not to have an adenoidectomy. The ears in each child were then randomly allocated to have a grommet (tympanostomy tube) inserted. The children's hearing status was reviewed six and 12 months post-operatively. During follow-up, should a child redevelop a persistent bilateral hearing impairment (as defined above) for three months they were managed with a hearing aid. Thus no child had repeat insertion of a grommet. Surgery of each type had an effect on the hearing and the presence of otitis media with effusion at six months post-operatively but not at 12 months when it was no different from natural resolution. If resolution of the otitis media with effusion is the outcome measure, then adenoidectomy alone is significantly better than no surgery but only in boys rather than in girls. Even in boys it only resolves about 60 per cent of effusions. However, when combined with a grommet (one insertion) adenoidectomy gives no greater resolution (89 per cent compared with 86 per cent).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Adenoidectomy↗

Reporting the benefits from middle ear surgery using the Glasgow Benefit Plot.

In the past, otologists have reported the results of middle ear surgery to improve hearing, either by tympanoplasty or by stapes surgery, mainly in terms of closure of the air-bone gap. This is valid as a measure of the technical success of the operation provided any change in the bone conduction thresholds, particularly at the higher frequencies, is also reported. Unfortunately, technical success in surgery does not always equate with patient benefit, primarily because, in most conditions, listening is a binaural condition. Disability in such circumstances is dictated by the hearing in the better hearing ear, which, quite correctly, is usually the nonoperated ear. Hence, it is important to define the relationship, before and after surgery, between the hearing in the operated and that in the nonoperated ear. This is the basis of the Glasgow Benefit Plot, which is drawn up from pure-tone audiometric data before and after surgery.

Audiometry, Pure-Tone↗

The prevalence of middle ear disease in the adult British population.

The UK National Study of Hearing set out to ascertain the prevalence of hearing impairments of various magnitudes, the prevalence of ear disease and the associated risk factors, and to estimate the percentage of individuals requiring some form of management. A stratified sample of 2708 British adults, aged 18-80 years, was chosen from a sample of 48,313 adults, randomly selected from the electoral roll, for a full otological and audiological assessment. This paper deals primarily with the middle ear results. Otoscopically, 2.6% of British adults had inactive and 1.5% had active chronic otitis media. This condition was more common in older individuals and in those in manual occupations. For this purpose, presumptive otosclerosis was defined as a conductive component to the impairment (average air bone gap over 0.5, 1 and 2 kHz of 15 dB or greater) and with an intact tympanic membrane. The population prevalence for presumptive otosclerosis was 2.1%, for healed OM 1.7% and for Eustachian tube dysfunction 0.9%. This prevalence of otosclerosis was higher in those over 40 years, but only in those with air bone gaps of 30 dB or greater were women more likely to have the condition than men, by a factor of three. At most, 20% of individuals with any of the above middle ear conditions will have had ear surgery.

Adult↗

Randomized, cross over study to assess patient preference for an acoustically modified hearing aid system.

It seems reasonable to postulate that if a patient has a hearing impairment at particular frequencies, selective amplification at those frequencies would be an advantage. Attempts have been made in the laboratory to show that when this is done scores on various audiometric tasks will improve. Whether such laboratory benefit will be preferred by patients in their daily life is another matter. Despite a lack of knowledge on this subject, modifications are frequently made to a hearing aid system in the expectation that this will improve auditory performance and hence be preferred by the patient. The most common modifications made to an ear level aid in the British National Health Service are adjusting the tone control and venting the ear mould with the aim of emphasizing the higher frequencies. A randomized crossover study was carried out in 83 first time hearing aid users with a mild to moderate hearing impairment to assess whether a hearing aid at the 'H' tone setting and with a 2 mm vented mould would be preferred by those with a more marked high frequency impairment. BE series aids were used so that any findings could be directly translated to NHS practice. No consistent preference for the modified system was identified when patients were subgrouped according to the overall slope (0.5 to 4 kHz) of their audiogram. However, when the slope between 0.25 and 1 kHz, which corresponds to the real ear effect of these modifications, was analyzed patients with a slope at these frequencies preferred the high-tone emphasis system (p less than 0.005).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Adult↗

Characterization of severely and profoundly hearing impaired adults attending an audiology clinic.

Despite the fact that around 12 per cent of adult patients attending an audiology department will be severely hearing impaired (pure tone averages of 0.5, 1, 2 and 4 kHz of 70 dB HL or worse in the better hearing ear), their clinical and audiometric characteristics have not been well documented. These characteristics were collected prospectively in 132 adult patients attending a Severe Impairment Clinic, set up to manage their specific problems. The inability to provide sufficient masking makes audiometric assessment of the severity of the impairment uncertain in the poorer hearing ear in 52 per cent of these patients. In addition, the limited bone conduction output makes it almost invariably impossible to assess the masked bone conduction thresholds and hence the air-bone gap in the poorer ear. Hence, accurate characterization is only practical of the better hearing ear in such patients. In 67 per cent of the better hearing ears, there was a mixed hearing impairment, the air-bone gap being 20 dB or greater. The aetiology of the conductive component was almost equally otosclerosis and chronic otitis media. In only 19 per cent was the impairment of a pure sensorineural type, broken down as 6 per cent congenitally acquired, 5 per cent due to meningitis and 9 per cent being adult in onset. In the remaining 14 per cent of patients the type of impairment could not be classified as the bone conductive thresholds were off scale. Having had experience of managing these patients at a special clinic and knowing the workload involved, it is argued that consideration be given to setting up such clinics in most departments.

Adolescent↗

Can meta-analysis help uncertainty in surgery for otitis media in children.

While otitis media is perhaps the most common disease of childhood that receives medical attention, there is little agreement concerning the efficacy of the medical and surgical therapies employed to try to alleviate its symptoms or hasten its natural resolution. Because various surgeries including adenoidectomy, myringotomy, and insertion of tympanostomy tubes are frequently involved in the treatment of otitis media with effusion (OME), it is likely the most expensive condition being managed in national terms. In an attempt to elucidate the most appropriate management of this condition, a meta-analysis was attempted to the 12 randomized control trials of surgical treatments for OME in children, published between 1966 and 1990. Heterogeneity both in the populations and comparisons studied and in the outcomes presented made meta-analysis an inappropriate method for clarifying this area of clinical uncertainty. Important elements in the design of randomized control trials that should be included in future studies of treatment for OME are therefore discussed.

Adenoidectomy↗

The Glasgow Benefit Plot: a new method for reporting benefits from middle ear surgery.

Conventionally, the results of middle ear surgery are reported in terms of postoperative closure of the air-bone gap or the improvement in air-conduction thresholds. While these are relevant in that they assess the technical success of the procedure and the lessening of monaural disability, they do not necessarily assess whether the patient has benefited. This is determined by many factors, not least of which is the hearing in the nonoperated ear. In this paper, we suggest that preoperative and postoperative plots of the air-conduction thresholds in both ears be used as an additional method of presenting the results. First, the proportion of patients that fall into each of three main preoperative impairment groups are identified. This is important, as the potential benefits from surgery are not the same in each group. Thereafter, the percentages of patients that achieve various postoperative hearing categories can be calculated, allowing surgeons to audit their results and make comparisons between series.

Adult↗

Reliability of patient choice between hearing aid systems.

Various hearing aid provision strategies have been suggested but it is important to compare patient benefit from these, not only in the laboratory, but in everyday life. The latter can only be assessed by patient report. The false positive report rate of a difference between aids and the reproducibility of patient choice of aids was assessed in two groups of patients. The first received the same system on two occasions and were asked to report if they had any preference. The second group received two different systems on two occasions and the reproducibility of any preference was assessed. Of the 22 patients who were given the same hearing aid system on each visit, eight (36%) reported no differences, 10 (45%) a little and four (18%) a moderate or large difference between them when, in fact, there was none. Of the 34 patients who were asked to compare two acoustically different aids, 32 chose an aid on both occasions but only 22 (65%) chose the same aid, of whom 11 (32%) reported a moderate or large difference on both occasions. If reports of a little difference between aids are discounted and only moderate or large differences are accepted, it is concluded that the false positive report rate of a difference is approximately 20%. In addition, when patients are being asked to compare two NHS hearing aid systems, the rules of chance, order effect and reproducibility of patient choice have all to be controlled for, before decisions regarding patient preference can be made.

Aged↗

Risks of developing an otogenic intracranial abscess.

One-and-a-half per cent of adults have active chronic otitis media and its management to prevent complications is a considerable workload. The risks of developing these complications is relatively unknown but because of its mortality, intracranial abscess is the most relevant. A 10-year review of all otogenic intracranial absesses in Scotland was carried out. A 15 per cent allowance was made for missing records. The annual risk in an adult with active chronic otitis media of developing an abscess is about one in 10,000 but its development is three times more likely in males. This risk might appear low but the lifetime expectancy of an individual aged 30 years with active chronic otitis media developing an abscess is one in 200. However, as yet, there is no evidence that surgery reduces this risk. Unfortunately, because of the duration of follow-up needed and the size of the sample required, scientific evidence would be difficult to obtain. However, 5 per cent of abscesses currently occur in the immediate post-operative period following mastoid surgery.

Adolescent↗

The British experience of an implantable, subcutaneous bone conduction hearing aid (Xomed Audiant).

Implantable bone conduction aids are potentially an important advance for those with a conductive hearing impairment. One system (Xomed Audiant bone conductor), which uses electromagnetic induction to vibrate a subcutaneous implanted skull magnet, has now been implanted in sufficient patients in the United Kingdom, for enough time, for its indications to be evaluated. Seventeen of the total of 18 patients that have been implanted, satisfied the average threshold criterion for suitability for implantation (average bone conduction over 0.5, 1 and 2 kHz of 25 dB HL or better) yet only 10 of the 17 (59 per cent) currently use their Audiant aid. This was not because of technical reasons but was mainly influenced by the previous type of amplification. Current usage of a body level processor was 100 per cent) (6 of 6) in those that previously could only use a conventional bone conduction aid because of bilateral congenital or acquired atresia of their external auditory canals. In comparison, usage was only 36 per cent (4 of 11) in those that could potentially use a conventional ear level aid albeit with problems such as the discharge from active chronic otitis media. This relative non-use was considered due to a lack of power of the ear level processor and the general unwillingness of patients to change from an ear level to a body level device.

Adolescent↗

Hearing disability and hearing aid benefit related to type of hearing impairment.

This study was designed to investigate whether patients with a conductive hearing impairment derive more benefit from the provision of a hearing aid than comparable individuals with a sensorineural hearing impairment. A secondary aim was to assess the relative hearing disability of those with each type of impairment. Twenty-eight patients with a bilateral, symmetrical conductive impairment were selected. They were matched for age, sex and speech frequency average to individuals with a bilateral, symmetrical sensorineural hearing impairment. Each patient performed free-field audio and audio-visual tests in noise, both with and without a hearing aid, during which the non-test ear was acoustically occluded. When unaided, individuals with a conductive impairment were more disabled than those with a sensorineural impairment. On the other hand, those with a conductive impairment derived more benefit from an aid than those with a sensorineural impairment.

Adult↗