Search PubMed⌕ Search

Biomedical subjects

F Holloway

Publications and source records attributed to F Holloway.

At least 19 recordsLinked to original sources

Case management and assertive community treatment in Europe.

OBJECTIVE: Case management studies from Europe and the United States continue to yield conflicting results. At a symposium at the World Psychiatric Conference in Hamburg in 1999, researchers from four European countries explored the possible reasons for differences in outcome. They also examined reasons for the differing foci of case management studies across the different cultures. The authors summarize the symposium's findings. METHODS: Individual case presentations were given of studies and services from the United Kingdom (three studies), Sweden (two studies), Germany, and Italy (one each). Outcomes, methodologies, and national service context were examined. RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS: A significant influence of national culture is evident both in the acceptability of case management and in approaches to researching it. Case management is perceived as an "Anglophone import" in Italy but is now national policy for persons with severe mental illness in the other three countries. Studies from the United Kingdom emphasized methodological rigor, with little attention to treatment content, whereas those from Sweden accepted a less disruptive research approach but with a more prescriptive stipulation of treatment content. Studies from Italy and Germany emphasized the importance of differing descriptive methodologies. Marked differences in the range of social care provision were noted across Europe. Overall, European researchers are less concerned than U.S. researchers with studying the impact of case management on hospital use.

Case Management↗

Case management: an update.

BACKGROUND: Case management in its various forms represents a major innovation in mental health care. Its efficacy remains controversial. AIMS: To update after a decade a previous review article (Holloway, 1991). METHODS: Descriptive literature and controlled trials of case management and its derivative Assertive Community Treatment (ACT) was accessed through four comprehensive and systematic reviews of the literature, repeated Medline and Embase searches and personal contacts. RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS: The concept of case management has continued to evolve over the past decade. No controlled trial has been published exploring the model of the case manager as a service broker without responsibility for the provision of care. Basic case management principles have frequently been incorporated within routine clinical practice. Published controlled trials of ACT, which were almost exclusively carried out in North America, have shown markedly positive results. However caution is required in extrapolating these findings to routine clinical practice within different systems of health and social care. Case management is not in itself an effective treatment for severe mental illness.

Case Management↗

The new long stay in an inner city service: a tale of two cohorts.

We assessed the long-stay inpatients (length of stay > 6 months) from a deprived inner-city catchment area with a population of 210,000 in 1993 and 1995 on a variety of measures, following up both cohorts after 24 months. Total numbers of long-stay inpatients were reduced from 56 (26.7 per 100,000 total population) to 35 (16.7 per 100,000) between 1993 and 1995, in line with the closure of dedicated long-stay beds. The 1995 cohort were more symptomatic according to the BPRS (t = 2.8, p = 0.007, 95% confidence interval 18.1, 3.0), more commonly detained under the Mental Health Act (chi 2 = 6.07 p = 0.05) and more commonly from an ethnic minority (chi 2 = 3.7 p = 0.05). At 2 year follow-up 57% of the 1993 cohort were living out of hospital, compared with 60% of the 1995 cohort. Patients were discharged to a variety of settings, some highly supported. For the combined sample the presence of certain challenging behaviours (absconding, disturbance at night, noncompliance with treatment and violence) predicted continuing inpatient status as did three items on the Social Behaviour Schedule (bizarre behaviour, laughing to oneself and violence). Only five (9%) of the original sample remained inpatients for the entire four year follow-up.

Adolescent↗

Subjective quality of life, psychopathology, satisfaction with care and insight: an exploratory study.

We have investigated the determinants of global subjective quality of life (GSQOL) using data from a controlled trial of intensive case management for the severely mentally ill. In a multiple regression analysis depression, age, objective quality of life and domain-specific quality of life together explained 59% of the variance in GSQOL. GSQOL was not significantly correlated with measures of positive psychotic symptomatology, insight or attitudes to treatment but was correlated with satisfaction with care (r = .21, p = .011). Change in GSQOL over 18 months was correlated with change in domain-specific quality of life (r = -.45, p = .002) and depression (r = -.43, p = .01): multiple regression analysis confirmed that both variables had an independent effect on change in GSQOL.

Adult↗

Intensive case management for the severely mentally ill. Controlled trial.

BACKGROUND: The aim was to compare the efficacy of intensive clinical case management (ICM) with standard community care in the management of 'hard to treat' patients with a severe mental illness. METHOD: A randomised controlled trial was carried out in East Lambeth, a deprived area of inner London. Seventy people with psychosis designated as 'hard to treat' by referring teams were included; 35 were randomised to ICM (case load eight patients per worker), and 35 to standard care, which offered follow-up by a community psychiatric nursing service (30 patients per worker). Outcome measures were admissions and hospital bed utilisation; contact with services; symptomatology; social behaviour; social functioning; quality of life; patients' satisfaction with care at 9 and 18 months. RESULTS: There were no differences in patients' symptoms, social behaviour or social functioning. Quality of life was significantly improved in patients receiving ICM at 9 months. Satisfaction with care was significantly greater among case-managed patients. All ICM patients remained in contact with services throughout the study, while six control patients were refusing all contact with services at 18 months. CONCLUSIONS: ICM failed to improve the clinical outcome of 'hard to treat' patients. The service was successful in maintaining contact with patients, was greatly appreciated and had a positive effect on their perceived quality of life.

Adolescent↗

Rationale and design. PRiSM Psychosis Study I.

BACKGROUND: This paper sets out the rationale for the PRiSM Psychosis Study, and the research design used. Nine accompanying papers present the main results. The questions addressed by the PRiSM Psychosis Study are: can the gains of experimental studies which have demonstrated benefits arising from treatment by community mental health teams be translated to routine settings? If so, are the benefits diluted in ordinary clinical practice? What are the costs? METHOD: A prospective nonrandomised controlled trial of two types of community mental health service, in two phases: case identification followed by patient interviews. For the case identification the research team conducted the complete ascertainment of all prevalent cases of psychosis in the two study catchment areas in the index year (1991-1992). From all 514 patients with psychotic disorders thus identified, 302 were randomly allocated for interview, along with a key informant clinician and a carer. Interviews were under taken at two time points, two years apart. RESULTS: This paper presents the socio-demographic, clinical and ethnic characteristics of the patients. CONCLUSIONS: The people with psychosis interviewed for the PRiSM Psychosis Study are representative of the whole epidemiologically based patient population identified.

Adult↗

Evolving service interventions in Nunhead and Norwood. PRiSM Psychosis Study. 2.

BACKGROUND: Service evaluation requires a detailed understanding of the services studied. METHOD: Community mental health services evaluated in the PRiSM Psychosis Study in south London are described. The intensive sector and standard sector services are contrasted. RESULTS: The intensive sector had two teams with extended opening hours: a psychiatric acute care and emergency (PACE) team, and a psychiatric assertive continuing care (PACT) team focusing on care for people with chronic illness. In the standard sector there was a generic community team providing office-hour assessments, case management of the severely mentally ill and close liaison with in-patient services. The team made use of the local psychiatric emergency clinic and of other local resources. The intensive sector was characterised by: more admissions to fewer beds, more nonhospital residential places, extended hours, on-call rota, wider range of interventions, more medical and nursing staff, a lower nursing grade mix and higher staff turnover. The standard sector had a less highly resourced generic community psychiatric service. CONCLUSIONS: Change in services has been more marked in the intensive sector.

Bed Occupancy↗

Frequency and predictors of adverse events. PRiSM Psychosis Study. 3.

BACKGROUND: Community care has been criticised as a hazardous policy associated with high rates of adverse events. There is little research evidence as to the truth of this claim. METHOD: Best available evidence from public records, interviews, case notes, key workers and general practitioners was assembled to establish: (a) which of the 514 subjects initially identified as having psychotic illnesses had died during an average follow-up of 4.9 years; (b) care currently received by all 286 subjects originally selected for interview; and (c) rates of major adverse events and of admission for these 286 individuals. RESULTS: Twenty-eight natural and II unnatural deaths had occurred. Among subjects still living at the end of the follow-up, 84% were in contact with specialist mental health services and 11% only with primary care services. Rates of serious violence, imprisonment and homelessness were relatively low. Forty-one per cent had been admitted at least once during a mean follow-up of 3.2 years and 20% at least once under the Mental Health Act. After adjustment, there were no significant differences between standard and intensive care sectors. CONCLUSIONS: Rates of adverse events and 'slipping through the net' are relatively low among individuals receiving community-based services, whether intensive or standard care.

Cause of Death↗

Utilisation and costs of community mental health services. PRiSM Psychosis Study. 5.

BACKGROUND: The costs and the effectiveness of mental health services need to be evaluated if provision is to be efficient. Service use and costs are described for two geographical areas in south London. METHOD: Service use was measured comprehensively for clients in both sectors for two six-month time periods using the Client Service Receipt Interview. This information was combined with unit costs to calculate service costs. The 'hidden' costs of informal care and unsupported accommodation were also calculated. RESULTS: At baseline significantly more intensive sector clients had in-patient stays but by the follow-up this difference had disappeared. There was significantly more use of supported accommodation in the intensive sector during both time periods. Baseline and follow-up total service costs were significantly higher for the intensive sector. Costs were spread disproportionately and a small number of services accounted for a large proportion of cost. CONCLUSIONS: While the cost at Time 2 was significantly greater in the intensive sector, this was largely due to the high use of supported accommodation. There was some convergence in cost between the sectors over time.

Community Mental Health Services↗

Quality of life outcomes for intensive versus standard community mental health services. PRiSM Psychosis Study. 9.

BACKGROUND: We report the impact on the quality of life (QOL) of people with psychosis of an intensive compared with a standard model of community care. METHOD: People with psychosis, in two sectors in south London, were interviewed with a variety of measures at baseline, and at two-year follow-up (n = 138). After baseline, services within one sector were reorganised, and a more intensive model of community care was introduced. QOL was measured using the Lancashire Quality of Life Profile. RESULTS: The two overall QOL measures, global QOL and the average of the domain-specific scores, were remarkably stable over time. There was weak evidence for an improvement in living situation domain in the intensive sector; this may be accounted for by a large drop in in-patient admissions. In both sectors objective QOL was poor, and there was little change in any of the objective indicators except in-patient admissions, and a suggestion of increased social activity in the intensive sector. CONCLUSIONS: We failed to find an effect of intensive community care on QOL in people with psychosis. This may indicate an insensitivity to change in QOL measures, or that the intervention failed to produce the kind of changes in mental health and functioning which would be reflected in improved QOL.

Adult↗

From efficacy to effectiveness in community mental health services. PRiSM Psychosis Study. 10.

BACKGROUND: The PRiSM Psychosis Study investigated the outcomes of community mental health services for epidemiologically representative cases of psychosis in London. METHOD: The results presented in the preceding nine papers are interpreted. RESULTS: (a) The health and social gains reported in experimental studies of community health services are replicable in ordinary clinical settings, and are more effective than hospital-oriented services which they replace. (b) Dilution does occur--these gains are less pronounced than in experimental (efficacy) studies. (c) Both models of community services produced a range of improved outcomes. (d) Some limited extra advantages (in terms of met needs, improved quality of life, and social networks) were found in the intensive sector. (e) There is no consistent evidence that community-oriented services (which include in-patient beds) fail service users, their families or the wider public. On balance the results weigh slightly in favour of the two-team model (for acute and continuing care) in terms of clinical effectiveness, but the general model is almost as effective and is less expensive. CONCLUSIONS: The evidence supports a community-oriented rather than a hospital-oriented approach and there is little difference between the community mental health team models.

Community Mental Health Services↗