Search PubMedSearch

Biomedical subjects

E K Harris

Publications and source records attributed to E K Harris.

At least 19 recordsLinked to original sources

Focal liver disease: comparison of breath-hold T1-weighted MP-GRE MR imaging and contrast-enhanced CT--lesion detection, localization, and characterization.

PURPOSE: To compare breath-hold T1-weighted magnetization-prepared gradient-echo (MP-GRE) magnetic resonance (MR) imaging with contrast material-enhanced computed tomography (CT) in the assessment of focal liver disease. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The MR and CT images obtained in 64 patients with focal liver disease were reviewed by six independent reviewers in a randomized, blinded fashion. Sets of axial T1-weighted MP-GRE images, three-plane (a compilation of axial, sagittal, and coronal) T1-weighted MP-GRE images, and contrast-enhanced CT scans were analyzed. T2-weighted spin-echo (SE) MR images were also compared with CT scans. RESULTS: Lesions were detected, localized, and characterized more accurately and generally with greater confidence with three-plane T1-weighted MP-GRE imaging than with CT (P < .01). Axial T1-weighted MP-GRE imaging was also superior (P < .05) to CT (although slightly less superior than three-plane imaging) except in the characterization of specific lesions, where both techniques were equal. T2-weighted SE MR imaging and CT were about equal. CONCLUSION: Lesion detection, localization, and characterization are performed more accurately and confidently with breath-hold T1-weighted MP-GRE imaging than with contrast-enhanced CT, particularly when breath-hold images are obtained in three planes.

Contrast Media

MR imaging of the liver: breath-hold T1-weighted MP-GRE compared with conventional T2-weighted SE imaging--lesion detection, localization, and characterization.

PURPOSE: To compare breath-hold T1-weighted magnetization-prepared gradient-echo (MP-GRE) imaging with conventional T2-weighted spin-echo (SE) imaging in evaluation of focal liver disease. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Images of 68 patients evaluated for focal liver disease were reviewed. Five sets of images were analyzed: axial, sagittal, and coronal breath-hold T1-weighted MP-GRE images, axial T2-weighted SE images, and a compilation of axial, sagittal, and coronal (three-plane) T1-weighted MP-GRE images. Lesion signal intensity (SI) and signal difference-to-noise (SD/N) ratios were calculated. RESULTS: Lesions were detected, localized, and characterize more accurately (P < .05-.001) and with greater confidence on three-plane T1-weighted MP-GRE images than on almost all single-plane images. Mean SI ratios of nonsolid and solid lesions on MP-GRE and SE images were significantly different at all lesion sizes; mean SD/N ratio was significantly different only for large lesions. CONCLUSION: Lesion detection, localization, and characterization can be accurately and confidently performed with three-plane T1-weighted MP-GRE breath-hold imaging, potentially obviating conventional T2-weighted SE imaging.

Artifacts

On the calculation of reference change values, with examples from a long-term study.

Reference change values (sometimes called critical differences) indicate statistically important changes between test values obtained on two occasions. They are commonly computed from the median (or mean) within-subject variance observed in repeated test measurements on a number of subjects. With this computational approach, all observed within-subject variances are assumed to be estimates of a constant true variance, the same for all individuals. Moreover, any possible correlation between successive values is almost always ignored. This simplified methodology differs from the method originally proposed for computing reference change values, which accounts for variability in true variances and for serial correlation. From data obtained from repeated measurements over 2 to 5 years in 72 physically healthy subjects, we computed and compared reference change values in 18 serum analytes, using the simplified method and the originally proposed procedure. Although the original method is more complicated and requires a computer program, we believe that it produces more-reliable reference change values than those obtained by the simplified approach. The former are generally larger, but remain sensitive to clinically important changes in the individual.

Adolescent

Statistical criteria for separate reference intervals: race and gender groups in creatine kinase.

Previously published data confirming differences in creatine kinase (EC 2.7.3.2) among various race and gender subgroups in the Los Angeles area have been re-examined with use of recently proposed statistical criteria for defining separate reference intervals. Results indicate that one criterion may be too lenient, whereas another is clearly too restrictive in suggesting the need for separate intervals. Further experience with other analytes in both large and small population samples would be helpful.

Creatine Kinase

On dividing reference data into subgroups to produce separate reference ranges.

We consider statistical criteria for partitioning a reference database to obtain separate reference ranges for different subpopulations. Using general formulas relating population variances, sample sizes, and the normal deviate test for the significance of the difference between two subgroup means, we show that partitioning into separate ranges produces little reduction in between-person variability, even when the differences between means are highly significant statistically. However, when there is a clear physiological basis for distinguishing between certain subgroups, simulation studies show that partitioning may be necessary to obtain reference limits that cut off the desired proportions of low and high values in each subgroup. Guidelines based on these results are provided to help decide whether separate ranges should be obtained for a given analyte.

Analysis of Variance

Generation and application of data on biological variation in clinical chemistry.

Most clinical chemical analytes vary in a random manner around a homeostatic set point. Replicate analyses of a series of specimens collected from a group of subjects allows estimation of analytical, within and between subject components of variation. The preferred experimental procedures and statistical methods for evaluation of data and analysis of variance are described; a detailed example is provided in the Appendix. The many uses of data on biological variation in clinical chemistry are reviewed, including setting analytical goals, deciding the significance of changes in serial results from an individual, evaluating the utility of conventional population-based reference values in patient management, and other applications.

Analysis of Variance

Proposed goals for analytical precision and accuracy in single-point diagnostic testing. Theoretical basis and comparison with data from College of American Pathologists proficiency surveys.

Expressing total analytic variance as the sum of the squares of imprecision and inaccuracy, or bias, and applying the Cotlove rule recommended by the 1976 College of American Pathologists Conference on Analytical Goals in Clinical Chemistry, namely, that analytic variance should be less than one fourth of the appropriate biological variance, I derive a rule for maximum allowable imprecision in the context of single-point diagnostic testing that takes into account the bias of the test procedure. This rule may be expressed in terms of a population-based reference range (in particular, the range of test results shown in a group of healthy individuals) and the bias of the test method. The latter is required not to exceed one eighth (0.125) of the reference range. These concepts are applied to eight common analytes for which estimates of the biases of specific methods and of within-laboratory imprecision have been published for large numbers of laboratories participating in recent College of American Pathologists proficiency surveys. Results indicate that some methods widely used in 1978 fail to meet the minimum accuracy criterion, while others show negligible bias. Even neglecting bias, more recent data show that average within-laboratory imprecision is still too high for sodium, chloride, and calcium but acceptable for potassium, glucose, cholesterol, urea, and uric acid.

Academies and Institutes

On the interpretation of serial laboratory measurements in acute myocardial infarction.

Serial laboratory determinations are now routinely performed on patients admitted to intensive-care units. Adequate interpretation of such cumulative information for clinical decision-making purposes is a challenging problem. We describe a statistical method for predicting--sequentially as the data become available--the patient's outcome, death or survival. Thus, the method goes beyond previously reported techniques that base such prediction on only a single multivariate observation. The method has been applied to daily measurements of serum urea and lactate dehydrogenase, performed during one week on patients hospitalized in the coronary-care unit with acute myocardial infarction. Two baseline variables were also included in the dynamic risk index so derived: the age of the patient and the number of previous myocardial infarctions recorded on admission. We also discuss the problems of selecting the most-predictive laboratory tests and of determining for each test the amount of past data needed to achieve satisfactory prediction. We distinguish between global evaluation of the dynamic risk index obtained (in terms of specificity and sensitivity) and individual interpretation (in terms of posterior/prior probability ratio) of a given risk score for a particular patient. The approach described may contribute to more effective use of results of repeated laboratory tests on critically ill patients.

Acute Disease

On the calculation of a "reference change" for comparing two consecutive measurements.

We describe a statistical method for calculating a "reference change," defined as that difference between two consecutive test results in an individual that is statistically significant in a given proportion of all similar persons. By allowing for variation in within-person variances, this procedure computes a reference change that is more specific (i.e., less prone to false positives) than that obtained directly from the distribution of observed differences between measurements. Moreover, the method may easily be extended to a test for trend in three successive measurements. The method has been applied to semi-annual measurements of serum calcium and alkaline phosphatase in 698 men and women enrolled in a large health-maintenance program. We believe that these ideas may also be usefully applied to successive laboratory tests in carefully defined patient populations--but this introduces special problems, which are discussed briefly.

Alkaline Phosphatase

Comparing multivariate and univariate subject-specific reference regions for blood constituents in healthy persons.

We examined the comparative behavior of subject-specific multivariate and univariate reference regions, using both computer-generated data and serial (semi-annual) measurements of selected analytes in subjects from a large health-maintenance program. Univariate studies under both homeostatic and random-walk time-series models were helpful in defining expected results, but only the homeostatic model was used in multivariate as well as univariate forms. Analysis of the computer-generated data and the real biochemical series produced similar findings, which showed the multivariate subject-specific reference region to be much more conservative than corresponding univariate intervals. That is, a multidimensional point of p correlated observations is quite likely to lie within the individual's multivariate reference region (based on past observation vectors), even when one or more of the observations lie outside their separate reference intervals for that individual. One consequence of this high specificity against univariate false positives in a large surveillance program is a higher than expected proportion of positive multivariate vectors in which none of the values lie outside their univariate ranges. Thus, although the development of multivariate reference regions should be encouraged, they should be used in conjunction with, not instead of, univariate ranges.

Analysis of Variance

Temporal changes in the concentrations of serum constituents in healthy men. Distributions of within-person variances and their relevance to the interpretation of differences between successive measurements.

The distributions of within-person variances in the concentrations of 10 commonly assayed serum constituents have been derived from data on 37 healthy male subjects studied at weekly intervals over a period of five months. All 10 distributions appear to be of log-normal form. The relevance of the findings to the interpretation of differences between serial measurements in a given individual is discussed. Examples are given to show how the information on within-person variances for a particular analyte, organised into a simple graph, may be used to test medical opinions on threshold values for serial changes in the concentration of this analyte in a given individual. In this way, biological variability as well as analytical error may be taken into account quantitatively when assessing the significance of a difference between two serial measurements.

Adult