Search PubMed⌕ Search

Biomedical subjects

D Stannard

Publications and source records attributed to D Stannard.

15 recordsLinked to original sources

End-of-life issues in intensive care units: a national random survey of nurses' knowledge and beliefs.

OBJECTIVE: To investigate the knowledge, beliefs, and ethical concerns of nurses caring for patients dying in intensive care units. METHODS: A survey was mailed to 3000 members of the American Association of Critical-Care Nurses. The survey contained various scenarios depicting end-of-life actions for patients: pain management, withholding or withdrawing life support, assisted suicide, and voluntary and nonvoluntary euthanasia. RESULTS: Most of the respondents (N = 906) correctly identified the distinctions among the end-of-life actions depicted in the scenarios. Almost all (99%-100%) agreed with the actions of pain management and withholding or withdrawing life support. A total of 83% disagreed with assisted suicide, 95% disagreed with voluntary euthanasia, and 89% to 98% disagreed with nonvoluntary euthanasia. Most (78%) thought that dying patients frequently (31%) or sometimes (47%) received inadequate pain medicine, and almost all agreed with the double-effect principle. Communication between nurses and physicians was generally effective, but unit-level conferences that focused on grief counseling and debriefing staff rarely (38%) or never (49%) occurred. Among the respondents, 37% had been asked to assist in hastening a patient's death. Although 59% reported that they seldom acted against their consciences in caring for dying patients, 34% indicated that they sometimes had acted against their conscience, and 6% had done so to a great extent. CONCLUSIONS: Intensive care unit nurses strongly support good pain management for dying patients and withholding or withdrawing life-sustaining therapies to allow unavoidable death. The vast majority oppose assisted suicide and euthanasia. Wider professional and public dialogue on end-of-life care in intensive care units is warranted.

Adult↗

Relationship between behavioral and physiological indicators of pain, critical care patients' self-reports of pain, and opioid administration.

OBJECTIVES: To examine the accuracy of inferences about critical care patients' pain based on physiological and behavioral indicators and to assess the relationship between registered nurse and patient pain scores and doses of opioids administered. DESIGN: Descriptive, comparative analysis. SETTING: Three intensive care units and two postanesthesia care units in two hospitals. SUBJECTS: Fourteen critical care nurses who conducted 114 pain assessments on 31 surgical patients. INTERVENTIONS: Nurses used a pain assessment and intervention notation algorithm that contained lists of behavioral and physiological indicators of pain to make inferences about a patient's pain intensity. Fourteen registered nurses completed up to five pain assessments on each patient over a 4-hr period. Following both the physiological and behavioral ratings, nurses rated the patients' pain intensity, using a 0 to 10 numeric rating scale, and they asked patients to provide a self-report of pain intensity, using a similar numeric rating scale. Nurses then administered an intravenous dose of an opioid from a sliding scale prescription. MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: Moderate-to-strong correlations were found between the number of behavioral indicators at times 1 through 5 and between the number of physiological indicators and nurses' ratings of the patients' pain intensity at times 1 through 4 (p < .05). Although nurses' pain ratings were consistently lower than patients' pain ratings across the five time points, these differences were not significant. The amount of opioid analgesic administered by the nurse correlated more frequently with nurses' pain ratings than with patients' self-reports of pain intensity. CONCLUSIONS: The use of a detailed, standardized pain assessment and intervention notation algorithm that incorporates behavioral and physiological indicators may assist healthcare professionals in making relatively accurate assessments of a patient's pain intensity. Further research is needed to determine the specific decision-making processes and criteria that healthcare professionals use to choose doses of analgesics to administer to critically ill patients.

Adult↗

Breakdown in the nursing care of families in the ICU.

BACKGROUND: Factors that can lead to breakdown in the care of the families of patients in the ICU include gaps in the healthcare providers' education and skill in working with families, unclear lines of responsibility for various aspects of family care, and insufficient support or supervision for the difficult emotional work of family care. OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to highlight instances in which negative or difficult aspects of nursing care of family members of ICU patients were evident, so that needed changes in caring for the families could be emphasized. METHOD: Interpretive phenomenology was used to analyze transcribed audiotape recordings of interviews with 130 nurse participants and clinical observations of 48 nurse participants. The interpretive account is based on more than 100 narratives of patient care relayed in interviews and on observational notes that focused on care of the family. RESULTS: The five general nursing approaches that constrained family care in ICUs were nurses' efforts to (1) distance the family physically from the patient and the patient's bedside, (2) distance themselves from the patient and the patient's family, (3) characterize the family's perspective as pathological, (4) dissipate responsibility for family care, and (5) take an elemental rather than a systemic perspective. CONCLUSIONS: The breakdowns in family care observed in this study were neither new nor unique. In order to truly realize a patient- and family-focused healthcare system, an infusion of knowledge and skill must occur at the bedside with individual nurses.

Critical Care↗

Comparison of mortality with home hemodialysis and center hemodialysis: a national study.

We sought to determine whether lower mortality rates reported with hemodialysis (HD) at home compared to hemodialysis in dialysis centers (center HD) could be explained by patient selection. Data are from the United States Renal Data System (USRDS) Special Study Of Case Mix Severity, a random national sample of 4,892 patients who started renal replacement therapy in 1986 to 1987. Intent-to-treat analyses compared mortality between home HD (N = 70) and center HD patients (N = 3,102) using the Cox proportional hazards model. Home HD patients were younger and had a lower frequency of comorbid conditions. The unadjusted relative risk (RR) of death for home HD patients compared to center HD was 0.37 (P < 0.001). The RR adjusted for age, sex, race and diabetes, was 44% lower in home HD patients (RR = 0.56, P = 0.02). When additionally adjusted for comorbid conditions, this RR increased marginally (RR = 0.58, P = 0.03). A different analysis using national USRDS data from 1986/7 and without comorbid adjustment showed patients with training for self care hemodialysis at home or in a center (N = 418) had a lower mortality risk (RR = 0.78, P = 0.001) than center HD patients (N = 43,122). Statistical adjustment for comorbid conditions in addition to age, sex, race, and diabetes explains only a small amount of the lower mortality with home HD.

Adolescent↗

ESRD patient mortality with adjustment for comorbid conditions in Lombardy (Italy) versus the United States.

The present study evaluated end-stage renal disease (ESRD) patient survival in Lombardy, Italy, and the United States (U.S.) using data from two registries, the Lombardy Dialysis and Transplant Registry (RLDT) and the U.S. Renal Data System (USRDS), respectively. For this purpose, 4,196 white patients (2,900 from the USRDS Case Mix Severity Study and all 1296 from RLDT) who started renal replacement therapy in 1986 and 1987 were studied. Compared to Lombardy patients, those in the USA were significantly older (mean age 59.9 +/- 16.4 vs. 55.9 +/- 14.7 years), had a lower proportion of males (53.7 vs. 62.1%), a greater proportion with diabetic nephropathy (29.9 vs. 9.7%) and a significantly greater proportion of patients with the recorded comorbid conditions (heart disease, peripheral vascular disease, cirrhosis, cachexia, malignancy). U.S. patients were less frequently treated with peritoneal dialysis (PD) by day 30 of ESRD (21.2 vs. 30.7). Survival was compared in the Cox proportional hazard regression model, using age, sex, comorbid conditions and early modality of treatment as explanatory covariates. Overall, 48% of the 4196 patients died during the 48 to 72 months follow-up to 12/31/91. Per 100 patient-years the gross death rate for USRDS patients was 28.7 compared to 13.0 of RLDT patients. The unadjusted death relative risk for RLDT was 0.439, that is, 56% lower death rate compared to USRDS patients. Age, sex, diabetic status, each of the recorded comorbid conditions and treatment modality were significantly related to survival and included in the model. The Cox cumulative survival adjusted for all these explanatory covariates survival was for U.S. patients 84.4% at one year, 67.0% at two years and 33.4% at five years, and for RLDT patients 88.3% at one year, 75.9% at two years and 45.9% at five years. The relative mortality risk (RR) for the patients treated in Lombardy adjusted for all the reported covariates was 29% lower than for US patients (RR = 0.71; P < 0.0001). This comparative risk varied significantly by age (P < 0.0001) and was 65 percent lower for Lombardy compared to U.S. patients in the age range 25 to 44 years (RR = 0.35) and about 20% lower for patients over age 65 years (RR = 0.80). This relative risk was mainly related to hemodialysis and was not statistically significant for PD patients. The observed lower mortality risk in Lombardy was less pronounced when adjusted for demographic and comorbid covariates, but was still large and therefore suggests the need for further studies regarding treatment related factors and unmeasured patient factors, particularly in hemodialysis patients.

Adult↗

Clinical judgment and management of postoperative pain in critical care patients.

BACKGROUND: Acute pain is a significant problem in critical care patients. Although many barriers to successful assessment and management of pain in critical care patients have been noted, little is known about how critical care nurses make clinical judgments when assessing and managing patients' pain. OBJECTIVE: This qualitative analysis is part of a pilot study evaluating nurses' use of a pain assessment and intervention notation algorithm in patients in critical care areas who have limited communication abilities after abdominal or thoracic surgery. METHOD: Transcribed audiotapes of nurse participants' "thinking aloud" while using the pain assessment and intervention notation algorithm were analyzed by using interpretive phenomenology. The interpretive account is based on 31 tape recordings of 14 nurses caring for 41 patients (12 patients in the ICU and 29 patients in the postanesthesia care unit). FINDINGS: The two domains of clinical judgment found were (1) assessing the patient and (2) balancing interventions. CONCLUSIONS: Many nurses' reports showed that they accurately assessed their patients' needs for analgesics. Through testing of and learning from their patients' responses, nurses were able to give amounts of analgesics that diminished patients' postoperative pain. Additionally, nurses had to balance analgesic administration against the patients' hemodynamic and respiratory conditions, medical plan and prescriptions, and the desires of the patients and the patients' families.

Adult↗

A "thinking-in-action" approach to teaching clinical judgment: a classroom innovation for acute care advanced practice nurses.

The complexity of the evolving advanced practice nurse (APN) role demands new teaching strategies. Based on the challenges that clinicians face daily, we have developed a teaching-learning strategy that addresses five central issues: (a) learning to perceive or identify relevant clinical problems; (b) learning to address the limits of formalism by situating clinical problem solving according to the most relevant goals and intents; (c) learning to reason in transition about the particular clinical situation; (d) learning the ethical skill of problem engagement and interpersonal involvement; and (e) learning to take a stand as a responsible agent by making clinical judgments, acting on them, and advocating for the patient/family. Although these five central issues are typically excluded from classic academic approaches, they are addressed in the "Thinking-in-Action" approach. This teaching-learning strategy offers a different way of teaching clinical judgment that closely resembles the way in which expert nurses actually think and reason in patient situations as they unfold.

Decision Making↗

Entry: a new approach.

Despite all of the protections promised through grandfathering and pathways to educational mobility, the entry movement tends to be perceived by many to be "demoting" the lives and livelihoods of hundreds of thousands of RNs who do not possess the education to meet the proposed standard. Here is a proposal for a way out of the quagmire.

American Nurses' Association↗