[Penal, civil, administrative and disciplinary medical responsibility. Definitions and basic ideas].
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Biomedical subjects
Publications and source records attributed to D Malicier.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
OBJECTIVE: The validity of French cause of death statistics largely depends on the transmission of the medical information reported on the dedicated part of the death certificate. Data referring to death causes are collected and analyzed at the Information Department on the cause of death (INSERM SC8). In major urban areas with one or more forensic institutions, it has been observed that the proportion of death certificates indicating ìno particular cause of deathî is higher than the national average. We therefore examined deaths occurring in 1996 in the Lyons region. METHODS: This retrospective study involved 5,208 deaths recorded in Lyons France in 1996. Complementary information on these deaths was obtained from INSERM SC8 and Lyons Medicolegal Institute. RESULTS: It was observed that a large portion of violent deaths occurring in this city in 1996 (more than 30%) were not recorded appropriately in the national statistics due to a lack of communication after autopsy. CONCLUSION: Considering the importance of epidemiology and suicide prevention in the national public health strategy, improved information transmission must be developed in the near future.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
The retrospective analysis of 1700 forensic autopsies over 17 years (1981-97) following unexpected sudden cardiac death revealed a group of 50 cases that could have been related to surgery and/or anaesthesia. Patients were young with no history of cardiac disease. Surgery was performed for uncomplicated disorders, all classified as ASA 1. Cardiac arrest took place at induction of anaesthesia in 16% of cases, during surgery in 64% and at the end of surgery in 20%. Investigation and expertise reports ordered by the public prosecutor revealed none of the typical causes of death usually associated with surgery or anaesthesia. Pathological examination showed cardiac lesions in 47 cases: arrhythmogenic right ventricular cardiomyopathy in 18 cases, coronary artery disease in 10 cases, cardiomyopathy in eight cases, structural abnormalities of the His bundle in nine cases, mitral valve prolapse in one case, and acute myocarditis in one case. Identification of the cause of death of patients at low risk may provide major relief to the family of the patient and the medical staff.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
A 16-year-old girl was admitted to the emergency department for sexual assault. The forensic examination revealed genital lesions of an age that were incompatible with her statements. She also presented extragenital lesions that resembled self-inflicted lesions. The reports of false rape allegations in the literature have all dealt with the motivations of the false victims. This case report is a reminder that an allegation of rape can be considered only on the basis of proof and not on speculation.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
The aim of this investigation was to study the distribution of arsenic species in human organs following fatal acute intoxication by arsenic trioxide. The collected autopsy samples of most organs were ground and dried, and the total arsenic was measured by electrothermal atomic absorption spectrometry (ETAAS). The arsenic species--inorganic arsenic, in the form of arsenite [As(III)] and arsenate [As(V)], and its metabolites [monomethylarsonic acid (MMA) and dimethylarsinic acid (DMA)]--were quantified by ETAAS after extraction with methanol/water (1:1, by volume) and separation by HPLC. The results indicate that after acute intoxication, the liver and kidneys show the highest concentrations of total arsenic and that the total concentration in blood is 7- to 350-fold less concentrated than in organs. In all organs, As(III) is the predominant species, and MMA is more concentrated than DMA. MMA and DMA are more prevalent in lipidic organs (49% of total arsenic) compared with other organs (25% of total arsenic). As(V) was found in small quantities in the liver, kidneys, and blood.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
The primum movens of a forensic autopsy is to track down the crime. The perfect crime can be defined as one which will never be suspected and/or one for which the criminal will never be arrested. We have reported several cases that have been adjudicated or are being adjudicated, and we show how actual homicides could have been taken for accidental deaths, suicides, or even natural deaths.
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Although new, large, double-blind, randomized studies are needed to establish the efficiency of intravenous thrombolysis, open trials of sufficient size may also provide novel data concerning specific outcomes after thrombolysis. METHODS: An open study of intravenous rtPA in 100 patients with internal carotid artery (ICA) territory strokes between 20 and 81 years of age, with a baseline Scandinavian Stroke Scale (SSS) score of <48 at entry was conducted. Inclusion time was within 7 hours after stroke onset. rtPA (0.8 mg/kg) was infused for 90 minutes, with an initial 10% bolus. Heparin was given according to 3 consecutive protocols. The SSS evaluation was done on days 0, 1, 7, 30, and 90. CT scan was performed before treatment, on days 1 and 7. Etiological investigations included echocardiography and carotid Doppler sonography and/or angiography. Outcome at 1 year was documented by SSS score, the modified Rankin Scale (mRS) score, and a 10-point invalidity scale. Multivariate logistic regression was used to identify predictors of poor versus good outcome. RESULTS: At day 90, 45 patients (45%) had a good result, defined as complete regression or slight neurological sequelae (mRS score of 0-1), 18 patients had a moderate outcome (mRS 2-3), and 31 patients had serious neurological sequelae (mRS 4-5). Six patients died, 2 with intracerebral hematoma after immediate heparin. Five of 11 patients (45.5%) treated between 6 and 7 hours had a good result. The overall intracerebral hematoma rate was 7%. Higher values of fibrin degradation products at 2 hours were observed in the subgroup with intracerebral hematomas. Significant predictors of poor outcome on multivariate logistic regression analysis were baseline SSS score of <15 (odds ratio [OR], 3.38; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.07 to 10. 74; P=0.04), indistinction between white and gray matter on CT scan (OR, 6.59; 95% CI, 2.19 to 19.79; P=0.0008), and proximal internal carotid thrombosis (OR, 3.29; 95% CI, 0.99 to 10.95; P=0.05). CONCLUSIONS: Our study confirms the safety of intravenous rtPA at a dose of 0.8 mg/kg and suggests efficacy for this drug even within 7 hours. Outcome and hematoma rates were at least as favorable as for trials of therapy with a 3-hour time window. Subgroups with a poor prognosis include low baseline neurological score, baseline CT changes, and proximal ICA thrombosis. However, approximately 30% of patients with each of these characteristics show a good outcome, so their inclusion in future routine rtPA protocols is still justified.
Patients can take action against physicians in front of different courts: Penal or Administrative Courts. Most of the time, the counsel chooses the legal proceedings. In the past, it was always necessary to prove the existence of malpractice; today, since 1990, the Administrative Court admits that it is no more necessary to find a malpractice, a damage and a link between the both. The medical expert valuation takes an important place in this matter. Nevertheless, the magistrate is not bound by the expert's report. In the last ten years several decisions have changed the usual rules in the matter of medical liability. Actually, in some special cases the Administrative Court admit a medical responsibility without malpractice, and so judges speak of medical risk.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Fraternity among humans is a social trait as old as the world. Among primitive men and in antiquity the most favoured came to the aid of the least favoured. Through the ages, this assistance has taken on various forms: food, money, and free medical care. With the Christian era, such aid became a charitable duty. The throne also came to the assistance of the poor, but here such actions alternated with those of the police, for poverty, engendered delinquency. The French Revolution opened a new era. Thereafter, the poor had certain rights upon society. This immense change led to our present social legislation.
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Pilot studies using early thrombolytic therapy in stroke have suggested that recombinant tissue plasminogen activator (rTPA) might be effective. While large, double-blind, randomized studies are needed, open trials could generate hypotheses concerning (1) the clinical correlations of outcome, (2) the significance of CT scan data during the first week, and (3) the use of adjunctive therapies. METHODS: We performed an open trial of intravenous rTPA on patients referred to our emergency service with all types of ischemic stroke in the carotid territory. All patients between 20 and 81 years hospitalized during 1994 with completed stroke in the internal carotid artery territory and a baseline Scandinavian Stroke Scale score lower than 48, even with severe disturbances of consciousness, were included. The inclusion time was within 7 hours after stroke onset. A 0.8-mg/kg dose of rTPA was infused for 90 minutes. Intravenous heparin was given either immediately at efficient dosage or after 24 hours. Mannitol was used in patients with severe presentation. The Scandinavian Stroke Scale evaluation was done at baseline, 3 hours, and 1, 7, 30, and 90 days. The CT scan was performed before the treatment and at days 1 (24 +/- 6 hours) and 7. RESULTS: Forty-three consecutive patients met the criteria of the protocol. The mean age at inclusion was 65 +/- 10.4 years, and the mean interval to treatment was 232 +/- 79 minutes. At day 90, 25 patients (58.1%) exhibited a complete regression of symptoms, and 3 had moderate neurological sequelae. Thirteen patients had severe neurological sequelae, 11 with infarcts and 2 with secondary parenchymal hematomas. Two patients died (4.6%), 1 with hematoma. The overall hematoma rate was 6.9%. Excellent outcome at day 90 was significantly correlated with major neurological improvement at day 1. Intravenous immediate heparin versus delayed heparin after 24 hours improved the ischemic outcome but not the overall outcome. Reinfarction syndromes after major neurological improvement, likely to be rethrombosis syndromes, were observed in 3 patients (6.9%). For the day 1 CT scan, poor outcome was associated with the presence of structured and homogeneous hypodensities likely to represent classic infarcts, as confirmed by day 7 CT scan. Conversely, total recovery was significantly associated with the absence of any image or with unstructured hypodensities, a particular type of image characterized by its heterogeneous darkness and often polylobar shape. This type of image disappeared at day 7 in 17.6% of the cases and is likely to represent reperfusion images and/or incomplete ischemic damage. CONCLUSIONS: The results obtained in this open, small study suggest safety and effectiveness of rTPA thrombolysis at the dose of 0.8 mg/kg within 7 hours in acute strokes of the carotid territory, including highly serious baseline neurological presentations, until age 81 years and under special therapeutic conditions. Complete recovery is significantly associated with major neurological improvement during the first 24 hours and the presence of a particular type of image at day 1 CT scan characterized by an unstructured hypodensity, often polylobar and heterogeneous, which is likely to correspond to reperfusion images.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
The aim of the present study was to investigate the functional and/or pathological significance of the hemispherical lateralization of TRH using radioimmunoassay to determine the TRH concentration of nuclei and areas within the hypothalamus of suicide patients, with matching measurement being carried out on control subjects. In suicide patients, we found no significant difference in TRH concentration between the left and right intrahypothalamic structures, while the group used as control subjects (see Borson-Chazot, 1986) showed a significant left side predominance in the ventromedial nucleus, paraventricular nucleus and area dorsalis. As regards the TRH concentration in the right intrahypothalamic structures, no significant difference was found between the suicide patients and the control subjects. The absence of the left TRH predominance for the three intra-hypothalamic structures in question may be of pathological significance.