Search PubMed⌕ Search

Biomedical subjects

D M Levi

Publications and source records attributed to D M Levi.

At least 37 records · Page 2Linked to original sources

A new illusion demonstrates long-range processing.

In the Fraser phase-illusion [Popple & Sagi. Vision Research, 40 (2000) 873-878] rows of Gabor patches appear tilted because successive elements are shifted in phase. We measured this bias in global orientation judgment, while varying the number of patches in each row, and their separation. We found that illusory tilt increases with the number of patches, at least up to ten patches for a separation of four carrier periods. This finding implies that the visual system is able to integrate information over large (>10 degrees ) strips of the central visual field. Our model shows that the tilt illusion might be the result of averaging the activity of oriented filters.

Humans↗

Amblyopic deficits in detecting a dotted line in noise.

We compared detectability of a dotted line masked by random-dot noise for the amblyopic versus non-amblyopic eye of two strabismic amblyopes. Small but consistent deficits in the amblyopic eye of these observers were found, and shown to be limited to dotted-line targets composed of greater than seven dots (with performance being normal for targets of less than seven dots). These deficits were unrelated to impaired visual acuity, impaired sensitivity to dot density, and differential positional uncertainty between the eyes of our observers. The deficits were also unlikely to be due to CSF losses due to abnormal low-spatial-frequency filters involved in detecting long chains of collinear dots. Instead, the results of simulations indicate that the inefficiency in utilising large numbers of dots is due to deficits of global, integrative processes in strabismic amblyopes. These simulations also show that while neither undersampling nor positional uncertainty of inputs into integrative processes can themselves account for the amblyopic deficits, if such abnormal inputs lead to the development of stunted integrative processes then impaired sensitivity to long chains of collinear dots is indeed predicted.

Adult↗

Spatial scale of visual analysis for vernier acuity does not vary over time.

The visual system filters spatial pattern through a range of narrowly tuned spatial mechanisms, but the rules by which the outputs of these mechanisms are combined across time to extract precise geometrical information are not yet clear. One hypothesis is that spatial analysis shifts over time from coarse to finer spatial scales, in order to extract fine spatial information. An alternative hypothesis is that thresholds are determined by the signal-to-noise ratio within an optimal spatial scale. In this study, we measured vernier acuity across exposure duration for equally visible long lines and short lines and found no improvement in spatial precision with time. Using a simultaneous spatial-masking paradigm, we determined the active spatial scales at 100 and 1000 ms. The results show no significant changes in spatial scale, or in the size-range of active scales, for the two exposure durations. Furthermore, whereas vernier thresholds vary markedly with line contrast, we find only modest shifts in spatial scale. Taken together, our results suggest that for vernier acuity, spatial scale is selected very early, and that vernier thresholds are predominantly limited by signal strength within that spatial scale.

Humans↗

Dynamic random noise shrinks the twinkling aftereffect induced by artificial scotomas.

Physiological alterations in cortical neurons are induced during adaptation to an artificial scotoma, a small homogeneous patch within a dynamic random noise or patterned background. When the dynamic noise is replaced by an equiluminant gray background, a twinkling aftereffect can be seen in the location of the artificial scotoma. Following binocular adaptation, we discovered that the perceived size of the twinkling aftereffect was dramatically smaller than the inducing artificial scotoma. Dichoptic adaptation induced shrinkage in the twinkling aftereffect that was similar to that found after binocular adaptation, suggesting that the twinkling aftereffect and its shrinkage both have cortical origins. We speculate that this perceptual shrinkage may reflect the interaction between two cortical mechanisms: a twinkling aftereffect mechanism that spreads throughout the artificial scotoma, and a filling-in mechanism that has a greater influence at the edges of the artificial scotoma and spreads inwards.

Adaptation, Ocular↗

Unmasking the mechanisms for Vernier acuity: evidence for a template model for Vernier acuity.

The goal of this study was to evaluate the mechanisms underlying Vernier acuity, over a range of spatial scales using narrow-band Vernier stimuli and oblique masking. Specifically, the test stimuli consisted of a pair of vertical ribbons of horizontal cosine grating with a vertical Vernier offset between the ribbons. These stimuli have two important advantages for studying Vernier acuity: (1) they are relatively well localized in vertical spatial frequency, and (2) they are localized in their horizontal extent (width). We measured the orientation, spatial frequency and width tuning of Vernier acuity over a wide range of ribbon spatial frequencies, using a simultaneous oblique masking paradigm. Our masking results suggest that the mechanisms underlying Vernier acuity are tuned to the orientation, spatial frequency and width of the ribbon stimuli. The peak of the bimodal orientation tuning function varies systematically with the spatial frequency of the ribbon. The peak of the spatial frequency tuning function varies systematically with both the ribbon spatial frequency, and the ribbon width (i.e. the grating length). A 'template' model, in which the 'mechanism' is a windowed version of the stimulus is able to account for many features of the data, including results which cannot be easily accounted for by standard multi-scale filter models. Specifically, the template model can account for: (i) the bimodal orientation tuning function, (ii) the systematic variation in the peak of the orientation and spatial frequency tuning functions with spatial frequency, and (iii) the systematic effect of ribbon width on spatial frequency tuning.

Contrast Sensitivity↗

Vernier and contrast discrimination in central and peripheral vision.

The present paper asks whether Vernier offset discrimination is limited by the observer's sensitivity to local contrast change in both central and peripheral vision. To answer this question we compared Vernier discrimination and contrast discrimination thresholds (specified in the same units) for a pair of narrow ribbons of cosine gratings. Because the ribbons are narrow, both the offset information (for Vernier discrimination) and the contrast information (for contrast discrimination) are highly localized. We found that when the stimuli are narrow ribbons, the local contrast cue is the limiting factor in Vernier discrimination. However, our results also show that integration of information along the length of the gratings (the ribbon width) is: (i) different for Vernier and contrast discrimination, and (ii) for Vernier discrimination the integration of information along the length of the gratings differs qualitatively in central and peripheral vision. For narrow ribbons, the peripheral 'template' for ribbon Vernier acuity is not as well matched to the stimulus (in two-dimensional spatial frequency space) as the foveal 'template'.

Contrast Sensitivity↗

Undercounting features and missing features: evidence for a high-level deficit in strabismic amblyopia.

Abnormal visual development in strabismic amblyopia drastically affects visual perception and properties of neurons in primary visual cortex (V1). To test the notion that amblyopia also has consequences for higher visual areas, we asked humans with amblyopia to count briefly presented features. Using the amblyopic eye, strabismic amblyopes counted inaccurately, markedly underestimating the number of features. This inaccuracy was not due to low-level considerations (blur, visibility, crowding, undersampling or topographical jitter), as they also underestimated the number of features missing from a uniform grid. Rather, counting deficits in strabismic amblyopes reflected a higher-level limitation in the number of features the amblyopic visual system can individuate.

Adult↗

Surround modulation in human vision unmasked by masking experiments.

The responses of neurons in cat and monkey primary visual cortex are modulated by stimuli outside the classical receptive field. Here we report psychophysical evidence from masking experiments for two distinct types of surround modulation, one narrowly tuned to iso-orientation (stimuli with center and surround at the same orientation) and the other broadly tuned to cross-orientation (center and surround at perpendicular orientations). Surround modulation at iso- and cross-orientations showed distinct contrast dependencies, and high-contrast cross-oriented surrounds were able to completely eliminate masking. Surround modulation was modeled by subtracting divisive inhibition that raised the gain of spatial filters.

Adult↗

Alignment of separated patches: multiple location tags.

Gaussian and Gabor patches can be accurately localized; however, it is not yet clear which cues (or location tags) the visual system utilizes for localization. To determine the cues used in spatial alignment, we measured and modelled the perceived shifts for asymmetric Gaussian and Gabor patches over a wide range of separations, patch sizes and orientations. For Gaussian patches we observed perceived shifts that were generally consistent with that of the centroid of the envelope. For Gabor patches we found that the perceived shift depends on the carrier orientation (whether co-axial or orthoaxial with the patch arrangement), separation (in units of carrier wavelength) and patch size (number of cycles per standard deviation). Gabor patches with the carrier orthoaxial (horizontal) to the three vertically arranged patches, were similar to Gaussian patches. However, Gabor patches with the carrier coaxial (vertical) to the three vertically arranged patches resulted in perceived shifts that were consistent with a number of alternate localization primitives. The selection of primitives was dependent on mainly the separation and patch size. Our results support the suggestion that the visual system can use multiple tags for location (Hess et al., Vis Res 1994;34:2439-2451; Badcock et al., Vis Res 1996;36:1467-1472).

Cues↗

Position jitter and undersampling in pattern perception.

The present paper addresses whether topographical jitter or undersampling might limit pattern perception in foveal, peripheral and strabismic amblyopic vision. In the first experiment, we measured contrast thresholds for detecting and identifying the orientation (up, down, left, right) of E-like patterns comprised of Gabor samples. We found that detection and identification thresholds were both degraded in peripheral and amblyopic vision; however, the orientation identification/detection threshold ratio was approximately the same in foveal, peripheral and amblyopic vision. This result is somewhat surprising, because we anticipated that a high degree of uncalibrated topographical jitter in peripheral and amblyopic vision would have affected orientation identification to a greater extent than detection. In the second experiment, we investigated the tolerance of human and model observers to perturbation of the positions of the samples defining the pattern when its contrast was suprathreshold, by measuring a 'jitter threshold' (the amount of jitter required to reduce performance from near perfect to 62.5% correct). The results and modeling of our jitter experiments suggest that pattern identification is highly robust to positional jitter. The positional tolerance of foveal, peripheral and amblyopic vision is equal to about half the separation of the features and the close similarity between the three visual systems argues against extreme topographical jitter. The effects of jitter on human performance are consistent with the predictions of a 'template' model. In the third experiment we determined what fraction of the 17 Gabor samples are needed to reliably identify the orientation of the E-patterns by measuring a 'sample threshold' (the proportion of samples required for 62.5% correct performance). In foveal vision, human observers are highly efficient requiring only about half the samples for reliable pattern identification. Relative to an ideal observer model, humans perform this task with 85% efficiency. In contrast, in both peripheral vision and strabismic amblyopia more samples are required. The increased number of features required in peripheral vision and strabismic amblyopia suggests that in these visual systems, the stimulus is underrepresented at the stage of feature integration.

Adult↗

Orientation-based texture segmentation in strabismic amblyopia.

Texture segmentation of 'target' Gabors from an array of 'background' Gabors was measured in terms of the difference in orientation between the two regions, as well as the difference in orientation within each region. Segmentation was shown to occur on the basis of local orientation differences at the boundary between the target and background regions (Nothdurft, H.C. (1992). Feature analysis and the role of similarity in preattentive vision. Perception and Psychophysics, 52, 355-375.). We obtained similar results for both the amblyopic and non-amblyopic eye of three strabismic amblyopes, and showed also that the effects of texture undersampling and positional jitter were similar for the two eyes. This pattern of results is consistent with intact mechanisms of texture perception in amblyopic cortex, and suggests also that any amblyopic deficits in first-order cortical units (undersampling and/or positional uncertainty) do not limit higher-order texture segmentation processes. Therefore, first- and second-order processes involved in perceptual grouping of oriented elements (that appear to be abnormal in amblyopic cortex; Kovács, I., Polat, U., Norcia, A.M. (1996). Breakdown of binding mechanisms in amblyopia. Association for Research in Vision and Ophthalmology Abstracts; Mussap, A.J., Levi, D.M. (1995). Amblyopic deficits in perception of second-order orientation. Investigative Ophthalmology and Visual Science (Supplement), 36, S634; Mussap, A.J., Levi, D.M. (1998). Amblyopic deficits in perceptual grouping. Vision Research, submitted) do not contribute to texture perception based on orientation contrast.

Adult↗

Looking behind a pathological blind spot in human retina.

Recent work suggests that dichoptic lateral interactions occur in the region of the visual field of one eye that corresponds to the physiological blind spot in the other eye (Tripathy, S. P., & Levi, D. M. (1994). The two-dimensional shape of spatial interaction zones in the parafovea. Vision Research, 34, 1127-1138.) Here we ask whether dichoptic lateral interactions occur in the region of the visual field of one eye that corresponds to a pathological blind spot, a retinal coloboma in the other eye. To address this question we had the observer report the orientation of a letter 'T' presented within this region in the presence of flanking 'T's presented to the other eye around the coloboma. A large drop in performance was seen due to the flanks, showing the existence of dichoptic lateral interactions in this monocular region. The presence of these dichoptic interactions in a region lacking direct retinal afferents from one eye is consistent with the proposition that long-range horizontal connections of the primary visual cortex mediate these interactions.

Coloboma↗

The time course of psychophysical end-stopping.

This study measured the time course of psychophysical end-stopping and compared it with the time course of masking. For a 10' D6 target on an 18' D6 pedestal, two abutting end-zone masks (each 13.5' long) covering the filter end-zones reduce masking. This facilitatory 'end-stopping' effect was measured over a range of exposure durations and stimulus onset asynchronies (SOAs). We found that psychophysical end-stopping has a delayed onset which is around 70-100 ms after stimulus onset, in contrast to masking which is robust immediately after stimulus onset, suggesting intracortical feedback processes in the generation of psychophysical end-stopping. The development course of psychophysical end-stopping is relatively long and lasts for approximately 150-200 ms after stimulus onset, in contrast to that of masking which lasts for approximately 100-150 ms. Our results also showed that end-stopping occurs only when the center mask and the end-zone masks have sufficient temporal overlap, possibly indicating that the feedback process for generating end-stopping is triggered by the activation of the spatial filter center by the center mask. These results are in tune with current knowledge of intracortical feedback modulating activities of receptive fields, and have been incorporated into our model to describe the temporal dynamics within end-stopped spatial filters.

Adult↗

Sparse-sampling of gratings in the visual cortex of strabismic amblyopes.

Strabismic amblyopes show losses in positional acuity that cannot be explained by their resolution or contrast sensitivities. One hypothesis for these losses is a reduction in the density of cortical neurons that are driven by the amblyopic eye (cortical undersampling). The question this study addressed was whether the foveal representation of the amblyopic eye is undersampled in the cortex of strabismic amblyopes. In order to assess spatial sampling psychophysically, we recorded the perceived orientation of a stationary grating as a function of grating orientation and frequency in three strabismic amblyopes. To ensure high retinal contrast, the grating was imaged on the fovea of each observer using a laser interferometer. We found that the strabismic amblyopes misperceived the orientation of the grating at spatial frequencies that are a factor of two to six lower than the sampling frequency of the foveal cones. Since the retina and LGN in strabismic amblyopes are presumably normal, this result suggests sparse cortical sampling in the foveal representation of the amblyopic eye. Undersampling by cortical neurons may contribute to the spatial distortions present in strabismic amblyopic eyes.

Amblyopia↗

Spatial characteristics of the second-order visual pathway revealed by positional adaptation.

The visual system is thought to process luminance (first-order) and contrast (second-order) information by dedicated cortical streams. To explore the spatial characteristics of the second-order pathway, we examined the effect of adaptation on spatial localization in human subjects. We show that, unlike first-order adaptation, second-order positional adaptation via cortical mechanisms transfers across orientations but not across spatial frequencies. These results support physiological evidence that these two processing streams are distinct and suggest that the cortical mechanism mediating second-order positional adaptation maintains spatial frequency information but sums signals across orientations.

Adaptation, Ocular↗

Progress and paradigm shifts in spatial vision over the 20 years of ECVP.

In the beginning there was light, and form, and visual mechanisms. This paper traces developments in research on spatial vision over the 20 years of ECVP, with particular emphasis on (1) hyperacuity, (2) peripheral vision, (3) amblyopia and development, and (4) learning and plasticity.

Amblyopia↗