Search PubMed⌕ Search

Biomedical subjects

D E Draper

Publications and source records attributed to D E Draper.

At least 55 records · Page 3Linked to original sources

Thermodynamics of RNA unfolding: stabilization of a ribosomal RNA tertiary structure by thiostrepton and ammonium ion.

RNAs with interesting secondary and tertiary structures tend to melt in several broad and overlapping transitions over a wide temperature range, and it has been consequently difficult to resolve the thermodynamics of individual unfolding steps. In the case that a ligand selectively binds a single folded state of the RNA, it is possible to obtain reliable thermodynamic parameters for both RNA unfolding and RNA-ligand binding simply from the hyperchromicity of RNA denaturation. The analysis procedure involves fitting a three-dimensional surface to absorbance data collected as a function of both temperature and ligand concentration. Analysis of the unfolding of a fragment of the large subunit ribosomal RNA (Escherichia coli sequence 1051 to 1109) is presented; both an antibiotic (thiostrepton) and ammonium ion specifically stabilize a tertiary structure within this RNA. A consistent set of thermodynamic parameters (delta H and tm) for the first two sequentially linked unfolding transitions is obtained from the experiments, and the binding constants obtained for the two ligands are consistent with other independent measurements. The approach is applicable to a variety of RNAs that specifically bind proteins, antibiotics, ions or other ligands.

Ammonia↗

Stabilization of a ribosomal RNA tertiary structure by ribosomal protein L11.

Interactions between ribosomal protein L11 and a domain of large subunit rRNA have been highly conserved and are essential for efficient protein synthesis. To study the effects of L11 on rRNA folding, a homolog of the Escherichia coli L11 gene has been amplified from Bacillus stearothermophilus DNA and cloned into a phage T7 polymerase-based expression system. The expressed protein is 93% homologous to the L11 homolog from Bacillus subtilis, denatures at temperatures above 72 degrees C, and has nearly identical rRNA binding properties as the Escherichia coli L11 in terms of RNA affinity constants and their dependences on temperature, Mg2+ concentration, monovalent cation, and RNA mutations. Mg2+ and NH4+ are specifically bound by the RNA-protein complex, with apparent ion-RNA affinities of 1.6 mM-1 and 19 M-1, respectively, at 0 degree C. The effect of the thermostable L11 on the unfolding of a 60 nucleotide rRNA fragment containing its binding domain has been examined in melting experiments. The lowest temperature RNA transition, which is attributed to tertiary structure unfolding, is stabilized by approximately 25 degrees C, and the interaction has an intrinsic enthalpy of approximately 13 kcal/mol. The thermal stability of the protein-RNA complex is enhanced by increasing Mg2+ concentration and by NH4+ relative to Na+. Thus L11, NH4+, and Mg2+ all bind and stabilize the same rRNA tertiary interactions, which are conserved and presumably important for ribosome function.

Amino Acid Sequence↗

Persistence length of RNA.

A set of 10 double-stranded RNAs ranging in length from 92 to 317 base pairs has been synthesized, and their rotational diffusion times were measured by transient electric birefringence. A hydrodynamic analysis of the birefringence decay data yields a helix persistence length of 720 +/- 70 A, based on a helix with an effective hydrodynamic diameter of 26 A and a rise per base pair of 2.7 A in the presence of Mg2+ ions. Thus, duplex RNA is somewhat stiffer than DNA, for which the persistence length is 450-500 A. The measurements also suggest that (i) current hydrodynamic theory for the rotational decay times is applicable to RNA molecules that are longer than 100 base pairs and (ii) weak Mg(2+)-RNA association decreases the rise per base pair slightly, by no more than 0.1 A.

Base Composition↗

Purine-purine mismatches in RNA helices: evidence for protonated G.A pairs and next-nearest neighbor effects.

Thermodynamic parameters are presented for 12 different RNA duplexes containing A.A, A.G, G.A and G.G mismatches flanked by C-G base pairs. UV melting studies were conducted under three different buffer conditions in order to evaluate the effects of salt concentration and pH on the stability of each mismatch-containing duplex. The main findings are: (i) the mismatches have a wide range of effects on duplex stability, decreasing delta G degrees 37 of denaturation by approximately 0-7 kcal/mol; (ii) the nearest-neighbor assumption commonly used to calculate helix stability breaks down for G.A mismatches; and (iii) G.A mismatches separated by 2 bp form a protonated structure.

Adenine↗

Protein-RNA recognition.

Specific interactions between RNAs and proteins are fundamental to many cellular processes, including the assembly and function of ribonucleoprotein particles (RNPs), such as ribosomes and spliceosomes and the post-transcriptional regulation of gene expression. Among the complexes studied to date are small RNAs bound to individual amino acids, tRNAs and tRNA fragments bound to their cognate aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases, and a variety of proteins bound to RNA single strands, hairpins, irregular helices, and tertiary structures stabilized by bound cations. Several proteins use a beta-sheet surface to bind RNAs, and others insert an alpha-helix into the widened major groove of a non-canonical RNA helix. Distortion or rearrangement of the RNA structure by bound protein is a common theme. The structural details of protein-RNA complexes are being resolved by nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) and X-ray crystallography, but thorough thermodynamic analyses of recognition mechanisms have yet to be performed.

Amino Acid Sequence↗

A conformational switch in a regulated mRNA involves tertiary structure.

The E. coli alpha operon mRNA is autogenously regulated by binding the repressor ribosomal protein S4. Repression occurs via a novel mechanism in which S4 traps the mRNA in a conformation that prevents formation of the complete initiation complex. The conformations have similar stabilities but separated by a high activation energy which is a criterion for a conformational switch. The conformation switch is likely to involve alteration in tertiary structure as indicated by gel electrophoresis and thermal denaturation experiments. It was found that Mg2+ stabilizes the repressed form and tertiary structure, and H+ stabilizes the translated form and have complicated effects on tertiary structure.

Bacterial Proteins↗

Protein recognition of a ribosomal RNA tertiary structure.

Ribosomal protein L11 recognizes a highly conserved, 58 nucleotide domain of large subunit ribosomal RNA. This domain has a set of tertiary interactions that are specifically stabilized by Mg2+ and NH4+ ions. The protein recognizes this tertiary structure, in the sense that ions stabilizing the tertiary structure also promote L11 binding, and a heat stable form of the protein (from Bacillus stearothermophilus) prevents RNA unfolding. We also find that these RNA-binding properties are confined to a approximately 75 amino acid domain of the protein. The larger issue of L11 function within the ribosome is discussed in light of these findings.

Bacterial Proteins↗

Bases defining an ammonium and magnesium ion-dependent tertiary structure within the large subunit ribosomal RNA.

A 58 nucleotide RNA derived from a highly conserved domain of the large subunit ribosomal RNA (Escherichia coli 1051 to 1108) has a set of tertiary interactions that is stabilized by NH4+ and Mg2+ in preference to other ions. We have mapped the nucleotides contributing to this structure by examining the thermal denaturation of 25 sequence variants. Where necessary compensatory mutations were made to preserve the phylogenetically conserved secondary structure. Substitutions of bases or base-pairs at eight positions specifically eliminate the ion-dependent tertiary structure without affecting the secondary structure stability; most of these positions are conserved among all large subunit RNA sequences. At two positions, substitutions of bases found in other organisms stabilize the E. coli tertiary structure by substantial amounts (delta G 37 degrees becomes more favorable by -1.8 to -4.5 kcal/mol). One of these variants disrupts a potential A.U base-pair within a helix, suggesting that the tertiary structure competes with alternative structures. The results show that this rRNA domain contains an extensive, highly conserved, and very stable set of tertiary interactions. The sequence in E. coli, and probably most other organisms, has not evolved to maximum stability. It is possible that natural selection has "tuned" the tertiary structure to an optimum stability, perhaps because the structure must open and close during the ribosome cycle.

Base Composition↗

Bend and helical twist associated with a symmetric internal loop from 5S ribosomal RNA.

We have used gel electrophoretic mobility measurements to investigate the conformation of the symmetric eubacterial loop E sequence of 5S rRNA (seven nucleotides in each strand). The loop strongly retarded the gel mobility of duplex RNAs containing it. In contrast, only asymmetric A5.An or U5.Un internal loops (n not equal to 5) strongly affected duplex RNA gel mobility. A phasing experiment, in which an A2 bulge and loop E were placed in the same duplex RNA and the number of base pairs between them varied, showed that loop E has a permanent bend and is torsionally stiff. A second phasing experiment substituting loop E for duplex sequences between two A2 bulges measured the helical twist associated with loop E; it is about 30 degrees (+/- 15 degrees) overwound compared to a duplex RNA of the same number of bases. Ribosomal protein L25 specifically recognizes loop E but had little or no effect on the twist of the loop. These results suggest that loop E adopts a specific, roughly helical structure.

Base Composition↗

Thermodynamics of folding a pseudoknotted mRNA fragment.

A sequence in the leader and first gene of the Escherichia coli alpha mRNA folds into a complex pseudoknot structure that is required for binding of a translational repressor. The thermal denaturation of a 112 nt RNA containing this structure has been followed by calorimetry and UV hyperchromicity. To determine the partially folded intermediates in unfolding, the denaturation of 13 mutants and of several fragments with successive deletions of helices were investigated as well. An unfolding pathway with seven states is proposed as the simplest mechanism that accounts for the data, and has several implications. (1) The lowest temperature transition appears only in the presence of moderate concentrations of Mg2+ or high concentrations of K+ (delta H approximately 45 kcal/mol), and is the unfolding of tertiary structures, rather than secondary structure. Under some conditions it is destabilized by increasing salt concentration. (2) Two of the intermediates unfolding at higher temperature must have non-canonical or tertiary interactions in addition to the known secondary structure. (3) Two alternative structures compete for formation of the complete pseudoknot, and form as the pseudoknot unfolds. Thus structures not present in the completely folded pseudoknot affect the overall thermodynamics, and probably the kinetics, of unfolding. (4) Approximately 16 kcal/mol of free energy is required to completely expose the coding region to ribosomes at 37 degrees C, though approximately 6.5 kcal/mol is regained by refolding of upstream regions after the pseudoknot is unfolded. The substantial energy needed to unfold the pseudoknot may affect the rate of translation from this ribosome binding site. A simple model of RNA folding in which an optimum secondary structure forms first, followed by tertiary interactions that further stabilize the secondary structure, does not hold in this RNA.

Base Sequence↗

Thermodynamics of RNA folding in a conserved ribosomal RNA domain.

A small, 58 nt domain of the large subunit ribosomal RNA (Escherichia coli sequence 1051 to 1108) is a highly conserved junction of three helices whose secondary structure has been established by phylogenetic comparisons. To detect any contributions of additional tertiary interactions, the thermal denaturation of the rRNA domain was followed by either UV hyperchromicity or calorimetry in buffers containing a wide range of Mg2+ concentrations. Several smaller fragments corresponding to two different hairpin stem-loop structures within the domain were also synthesized and melted for comparison with the larger molecule. A model of the secondary structure unfolding was devised, based on measured enthalpies and melting temperatures of the component hairpins and tabulated parameters of base-pair stacking and loop closure. The model closely simulates the observed melting data when three additional factors are included: two parameters to account for coaxial stackings within a junction of helices, and a set of undefined "tertiary" interactions that unfolds before the secondary structure and is preferentially stabilized by Mg2+. A critical feature of this model is a conserved pair, U1082/A1086, that is within the junction loop and hypothesized to stack with an adjacent helix. The model correctly predicts the effects of disrupting this pair in a U1086 sequence variant. Although the set of "tertiary" interactions contributes a significant fraction of the RNA unfolding enthalpy (delta H approximately 25 kcal/mol, out of 180 kcal/mol total), its overall stability is marginal at 37 degrees C.

Base Sequence↗

Stabilization of RNA structure by Mg ions. Specific and non-specific effects.

The stabilities of three different RNA fragments have been measured as a function of Mg2+ concentrations, and are interpreted in terms of two different models of Mg(2+)-RNA interaction. The models presume either tight binding of ions to specific site(s) in a folded RNA, or non-specific, electrostatic binding to both folded and unfolded forms; qualitatively different predictions are made for the melting temperature dependence on ion concentration. Three different modes of Mg2+ interactions with RNA structures are distinguished. Hairpins are stabilized by completely non-specific binding, with affinities the same as or weaker than those for single strand and duplex homopolymers binding Mg2+. In contrast, a ribosomal RNA tertiary structure is stabilized by specific binding of a single ion; since no other di- or trivalent ion is as effective as Mg2+, direct coordination of Mg2+ to the RNA structure is probably taking place. A third class of sites is best analyzed by the site-specific model, but any di- or trivalent ion is as effective as Mg2+; the ion(s) are probably localized in a region of unusually high charge density. The magnitude of a Mg(2+)-induced shift in RNAtm is itself not diagnostic of specific site binding or RNA tertiary structure, since large shifts can be observed for all three interaction modes.

Binding Sites↗

On the use of phasing experiments to measure helical repeat and bulge loop-associated twist in RNA.

In a phasing experiment, two bends are introduced into a long duplex RNA or DNA and the number of base pairs between them varied. When electrophoresed in a gel, the set of molecules may show a periodic variation in mobility that contains information about the twist associated with the bends and the intervening helix. We show how a set of three phasing experiments can be used to extract this information, and apply it to an RNA helix bend at the bulge sequence A2. The bulge introduces a negative (left-handed) twist of approximately 30 degrees; at low temperatures, it is mostly confined to the 5' side of the bulge. The apparent helical repeat of random sequence RNA measured in these experiments was 10.2 +/- 0.1 base pairs, an unexpectedly low value. It is likely that moderate curvative of the RNA helix axis (30-40 degrees over 80 bp) has affected the measurement.

Base Composition↗

Specific ammonium ion requirement for functional ribosomal RNA tertiary structure.

In compactly folded RNAs, coordination or hydrogen bonding of cations in specific sites is a potentially important aspect of the tertiary structure. NH4+ specifically stabilizes the tertiary structure of a conserved, 58-nt fragment of the large subunit ribosomal RNA, as judged in two ways: a melting transition associated with tertiary interactions is sharpened and stabilized more effectively by NH4+ than by any alkali metal cation, and the affinity of the RNA fragment for ribosomal protein L11 or the antibiotic thiostrepton is approximately 10-fold stronger when measured in NH4+ than in Na+. The dependence of the melting temperature on NH4+ concentration shows that a single bound ion is responsible for these effects. The requirement of different ribosome functions for NH4+ suggests that other such sites exist in ribosomal RNAs.

Cations, Monovalent↗

Allosteric mechanism for translational repression in the Escherichia coli alpha operon.

The ribosomal protein S4 is a translational repressor that binds to a complex mRNA pseudoknot structure containing the ribosome binding site for the first gene of the alpha operon. Either 30S subunits or S4 protein bound to the mRNA causes Moloney murine leukemia virus reverse transcriptase to pause near the 3' terminus of the pseudoknot. There is no competition between subunits and S4 for mRNA binding. The kinetics of forming S4-30S-mRNA complexes are biphasic, and the fraction of mRNA molecules reacting more rapidly decreases as the temperature is increased from 30 degrees C to 40 degrees C. The complex cannot be detected with mRNA mutants that cannot be repressed. We have previously shown similar kinetic behavior for the formation of tRNA(fMet) initiation complexes with tRNA(fMet), 30S subunits, and mRNA, except that the fraction reacting rapidly increases when the temperature is increased over the same 30-40 degrees C range. Thus the two sets of experiments show that there are two forms of 30S-mRNA complexes that differ in their abilities to bind S4 and tRNA(fMet). The results support an allosteric model for translational repression in which S4 traps the mRNA in a conformation able to bind 30S subunits but unable to form an initiation complex with tRNA(fMet).

Allosteric Regulation↗

Ribosome initiation complex formation with the pseudoknotted alpha operon messenger RNA.

The Escherichia coli alpha mRNA has a complex pseudoknot secondary structure that forms the recognition site for a translational repressor, ribosomal protein S4, and also encompasses the regulated ribosome binding site. To find out whether the pseudoknot is a stable structure under the conditions of ribosome initiation complex formation, thermal denaturation of the RNA was monitored by calorimetry and ultraviolet light hyperchromicity. The secondary structure formed by the coding region melts in a single transition and has a stability of -7.4 kcal/mol at 37 degrees C (5 mM-Mg2+, 100 mM-Na+, pH 7.0). A broad transition with tm approximately 38 degrees C may be a rearrangement of pseudoknot secondary or tertiary structure. Using reverse transcriptase primer extension assays ("toeprints") to measure the kinetics of ternary 30 S subunit-tRNAf(met)-alpha mRNA translational initiation complex formation, we find a fast and a slow phase in the reaction. The fraction reacting rapidly is sensitive to temperature and mutations in the mRNA. We interpret these results in terms of "active" and "inactive" mRNA conformations that are trapped by 30 S subunits and react rapidly or slowly with tRNAf(met), respectively; the active form is predominant above 37 degrees C. The binary 30 S-mRNA complex in the inactive form stops MMLV reverse transcriptase near the 3' edge of the pseudoknot structure, apparently by stabilizing the pseudoknot. We propose the following mechanism for translational initiation with the alpha mRNA. The intact pseudoknot stimulates 30 S subunit binding, at low temperatures, but prevents proper binding of tRNAf(met). The inactive to active transition of the pseudoknot, which may be related to the 38 degrees C transition seen in melting experiments, is required for tRNAf(met) to pair with the anticodon and is rate-limiting for initiation complex formation at lower temperatures. A novel feature of this proposal is that the mRNA structure affects a kinetic step in initiation complex formation, as well as ribosome binding affinity.

Base Sequence↗