Search PubMed⌕ Search

Biomedical subjects

D Ciliska

Publications and source records attributed to D Ciliska.

24 records · Page 2Linked to original sources

Changing nursing practice--trisectoral collaboration in decision making.

In an age of cost containment, agency partnerships have become an essential element for future planning and program implementation. This paper describes a trisectoral collaboration of a hospital, health department, university and school of nursing to compare the efficacy and efficiency of referral decisions of hospital staff nurses to those of the public health liaison nurses (LNs). A process to identify decision criteria was undertaken and an educational programme was designed to assist the staff nurses with the referral process and to assure consistency of decision making. The two groups were then compared. The results of the study found staff nurses, using the decision criteria, identified more patients who required public health nursing visits than did the liaison nurses, refusal rate of the patients to participate was no different, staff nurses cost less than LNs and job satisfaction was not significantly altered for either group. In addition to providing information to guide administrative and clinical decision making, the project also provided a learning experience for the staff of three agencies in conducting research and in using evidence-based practice to change traditional practice.

Decision Making, Organizational↗

A systematic overview of the effectiveness of home visiting as a delivery strategy for public health nursing interventions.

The purpose of this systematic overview was to assess the evidence for the effectiveness of public health nursing interventions when carried out by the strategy of home visiting. A search of published and unpublished literature resulted in retrieval of 108 articles; 77 articles were judged to be relevant. Validity criteria included method of allocation to the study groups, level of agreement to participate in the study, control for confounders, method of data collection (pretesting of data collection tools, blinding of data collectors to group allocation of study participants), quantitative measure of effect and percentage of participants available at follow-up. Using these criteria, 9 articles were judged to be strong, 5 moderate and 63 weak. There were no reported negative effects of home visiting in the 9 strong articles. Positive outcomes included improvement in children's mental development, mental health and physical growth; reduction in mother's anxiety, depression, and tobacco use; improvement in maternal employment, nutrition and other health habits; government cost saving; and reduced level of care required for the elderly.

Canada↗

A systematic overview of adolescent suicide prevention programs.

The purpose of this systematic overview was to summarize evidence about the effectiveness of adolescent suicide prevention curricula programs. A comprehensive search of published and unpublished literature resulted in retrieval of 11 relevant studies. The findings, of this overview indicate that there is currently insufficient evidence to support curriculum-based suicide prevention programs. The evidence suggests that there may be both beneficial and harmful effects of the programs on students. In most studies, knowledge related to suicide improved as a result of the programs. However, studies found both beneficial and harmful effects on attitudes related to suicide. One study found in increase in hopelessness and maladaptive coping for males following the intervention. The literature suggests that more broadly based comprehensive school health programs should be evaluated for their effectiveness in addressing the determinants of adolescent risk behaviour.

Adaptation, Psychological↗

Evaluation research in public health: barriers to the production and dissemination of outcomes data.

Health outcomes are becoming the currency of health care exchange, and a call for evidence dominates decision making at all levels. This discussion paper reviews methodological and sociopolitical barriers that impede the production and dissemination of outcome research in public health, with particular reference to nursing. Barriers to the production of high-quality research evidence include inaccessible graduate education and inadequate research funding. Also, randomized controlled trials (the ideal design for interventions studies) are uniquely difficult to implement for public health services. Practical and ethical difficulties arise in defining the intervention, implementing random allocation methods, selecting and measuring outcomes, and articulating adequate theoretical frameworks. When health care activity is defined as output, there is a tendency to exclude the ethical standing of preventive, supportive and communitarian functions. The production and interpretation of research results must remain part of a social, political and ethical debate, not a purely scientific one.

Canada↗