The needle biopsy should replace open excisional biopsy ... but will the surgeon's role in coordinating breast cancer treatment be diminished?
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Biomedical subjects
Publications and source records attributed to C M Balch.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
PURPOSE: To determine the prognostic significance of the size of the lymph node mass as measured by physical examination (PE) and of the size of the largest node measured by pathologic analysis (path) in patients with cutaneous melanoma and nodal metastases. PATIENTS AND METHODS: The medical records of all patients with nodal metastases seen at The University of Texas M.D. Anderson Cancer Center from January 1, 1973 to December 31, 1989 were reviewed. Patient eligibility criteria included the following: (1) availability of data describing the nodal size either by PE or by path and the number of positive nodes; (2) no history of preoperative chemotherapy or radiotherapy; and (3) no history or presence of in-transit, satellite, local, or distant metastases. Eleven variables, including largest diameter of the nodal mass by PE and diameter of the largest node by path, were examined as potential prognostic factors for disease-free survival (DFS) and overall survival (OS). RESULTS: Of 800 patients evaluated, 442 met the eligibility criteria and are the subjects of this study. In the univariate analysis, size of the nodal mass by PE was marginally significant for survival as a continuous variable (P = .045), but not as a categorical variable using a cutoff size of < or = 3 or more than 3 cm as indicated by the American Joint Committee on Cancer (AJCC) staging system (P = .61). Size of the largest node by path was not significant for survival. In the multivariate analysis, only the number of positive nodes (P < .001), age (P < .001), and tumor thickness (P < .001) were significant for survival. CONCLUSION: Size of the nodal mass by PE and size of the largest node by path are not useful prognostic factors for survival and should be eliminated from the current staging system. More powerful and well-established prognostic factors, such as the number of positive nodes, should be considered for inclusion in staging.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
The study of specific immunity in human cancers has been hampered by the elusive distribution and heterogeneity of effector cells. In this study, we have investigated the distribution of autologous melanoma-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) in 18 different distant metastases from melanomas (9 non-visceral and 9 visceral metastases). Uncultured cells from tumors were provided directly for the establishment of T-cell clones using limiting dilution analysis to avoid any possible effects of in vitro sensitization of T cells to coexisting tumor cells. Autologous tumor specific CTL clones were detected in 6 of 18 tumors (33%, 4 non-visceral and 2 visceral metastases). The majority of CTL clones (35 of 46 and 17 of 19) in 2 patients with HLA class-I A2 haplotype failed to lyse either A2+ or A2- allogeneic melanoma cells, although anti-class-I (monomorphic) MAb inhibited their cytotoxicity. The remaining 11 of 46 and 2 of 19 CTL clones showed A2-restricted cytotoxicity. Autologous tumor-specific cytotoxicity was also detected after polyclonal culture of these tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes (TILs) in 8 of 16 tumors (50%, 5 non-visceral and 3 visceral metastases). These results suggest that tumor-specific T cells exist at tumor sites in at least one-third of distant metastases of melanomas and could be induced by the addition of IL-2 in at least half of the tumors. Tumor-specific T cells were detectable more often in non-visceral than in visceral metastases.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
The role of uncultured melanoma cells in the proliferation of autologous tumor-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) was investigated. Uncultured autologous tumor cells by themselves induced modest, but significant, proliferation in 10 of 13 (77%) CTL clones and in only two of nine non-CTL clones. Uncultured allogenic melanoma cells mostly failed to induce CTL proliferation. Autologous tumor-induced CTL proliferation declined with increasing age of the culture. It did not correlate with IL-2 receptor-alpha expression or was not inhibited by addition of anti-IL-2 antibody to the culture. It was inhibited by pretreatment of tumor cells with anti-MHC class II, but not -MHC class I mAb. IL-2 alone was sufficient for the potent proliferation of five of nine CTL clones. In all these five CTL clones, autologous tumor cells suppressed IL-2-induced proliferation. The remaining four CTL clones, however, required both uncultured autologous melanoma cells and IL-2 for the proliferation. IL-4 or IL-6, in particular IL-6, facilitated IL-2-induced CTL proliferation, but not their cytotoxicity. In summary, uncultured melanoma cells by themselves induced modest levels of CTL proliferation in the context of MHC class II antigens, whereas they suppressed IL-2-induced CTL proliferation in more than half of the clones.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Alteration in interactions between tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes (TILs) and tumor cells after chemotherapy or immunotherapy was studied in metastatic melanoma patients. Tumors were harvested from surgical specimens 17 days after the end of chemotherapy with cisplatin, vinblastine, and dacarbazine (CVD). Tumors of nonlymph-node metastases from two responders yielded neither TILs nor tumor cells, whereas those from all four nonresponders had both TILs [(1.1-13.8) x 10(6) cells/g tumor] and tumor cells [(2.8-30.8) x 10(6) cells/g tumor). Tumors of lymph node metastases from nine patients yielded substantial numbers both of TILs and tumor cells, regardless of different clinical responses, except with one complete responder, whose tumor did not contain tumor cells. The mean increase of TILs from these tumors (n = 14) 3-4 weeks after incubation with 200 U/ml recombinant interleukin-2 (rIL-2) was 2.5-fold, whereas there was a 56-fold increase in TILs from untreated tumors (n = 3). CD3+ T cells predominated in TILs before and after expansion with IL-2. IL-2-activated TILs from five of six tumors tested displayed higher cytotoxicity against autologous tumor cells than against cells from any of three allogeneic tumors. Mean tumor cell numbers (10(6) cells/trial) obtained by serial needle biopsies for the same tumor in five patients decreased from 1.2 before therapy to 0.25 at day 4 of therapy (interferon alpha alone), and to 0.02 at day 8 (interferon alpha and IL-2). This decrease did not correlate with clinical responses. Yields (x 10(6) cells/g tumor) of TILs and tumor cells in subcutaneous melanomas obtained by excisional biopsies in one nonresponder under IL-2 therapy were respectively 0.2 and 1.1 before therapy (day 0), 0.1 and less than 0.01 during (day 7), 0.2 and less than 0.01 at the end of therapy (day 21), and 0.5 and 0.5 at the time of tumor progression (day 66). Yields of TILs and tumor cells in the other nonresponder were respectively 3 and 26 before (day 0), 16 and 3 during (day 7), and 0.4 and less than 0.01 at the end of IL-2 therapy (day 17), and 2.5 and 6 at the time of progression (day 62). TILs in these two patients before therapy proliferated well in culture with IL-2 (570- and 720-fold, respectively), and showed higher cytotoxicity against autologous tumor cells, whereas none of those from the five tumors biopsied during or at the end of IL-2 therapy proliferated. TILs at the time of progression showed modest proliferation (54- and 76-fold, respectively) and showed major-histocompatibility-complex-nonrestricted cytotoxicity. In summary, a decrease in the number of live tumor cells did not always correlate with clinical response in either therapy. CVD chemotherapy may simply impair IL-2-induced proliferation of TILs. IL-2 therapy may induce transient unresponsiveness of TILs to IL-2.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
The surgical morbidity associated with aggressive preoperative chemotherapy in 106 patients with advanced primary breast cancer who had chemotherapy followed by mastectomy was examined. These patients were compared with a group of 91 consecutive patients who had mastectomy without preoperative chemotherapy. Strict operative criteria were used to determine the timing of mastectomy following chemotherapy. Wound infection rates were no different in the preoperative chemotherapy group compared to the mastectomy-alone groups (7% versus 4%; p = 0.62). The incidence of wound necrosis was similar (11% versus 6%; p = 0.29). Seroma formation was decreased significantly in the preoperative chemotherapy group compared to the mastectomy-alone group (15% versus 28%; p = 0.04). Intensive preoperative chemotherapy did not delay the reinstitution of postoperative treatment (30% versus 20%; p = 0.27). However, when delay in instituting postoperative chemotherapy was more than 30 days, there was a significant decrease in overall survival rate (p = 0.04). This study provides evidence that intensive preoperative chemotherapy and mastectomy can be performed without increased morbidity. Furthermore it is important to institute systemic chemotherapy within 30 days of mastectomy to achieve maximum survival.
We investigated the immunological properties of interleukin-2 (IL-2)-activated tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes (TIL), which were used for adoptive therapy of renal cell carcinoma (RCC) (seven patients) by focusing on natural killer (NK) cells, and metastatic melanoma (six patients) by focusing on cytotoxic T lymphocytes. TIL from five of seven cases proliferated well in culture with AIM-V serum-free medium and 1000 U/ml rIL-2 in 3-L gas permeable bags, whereas TIL from two RCCs exhibited delayed proliferation. Proliferation of CD3-CD56+ NK cells with major histocompatibility complex-nonrestricted cytotoxicity in RCC-TIL (n = 6, mean = 651-fold, ranging from 39- to 3450-fold) for the first 2-4 weeks was 63 times higher than that of noncytotoxic CD3+ T cells (n = 6, 10.3-fold ranging from 0.8 to 35-fold). Thereafter, CD3+ T cells predominantly proliferated, and proliferation of CD3+ T cells (n = 5, 743-fold) for 5-6 weeks were 24 times higher than that of CD3-CD56+ NK cells (n = 5, 31-fold). Significant numbers of RCC-TIL became adherent to the surfaces of the bags several weeks after initiation of culture. These adherent TIL consisted of more CD3-CD56+ NK cells and exhibited higher cytotoxicity than did nonadherent TIL. Adherent RCC-TIL produced interferon (IFN)-gamma, while nonadherent TIL did not. These results suggest that initially cytotoxic CD3-CD56+ NK cells and, later, noncytotoxic CD3+ T cells proliferated in culture of RCC-TIL for adoptive therapy. These noncytotoxic TIL were primarily transferred to RCC patients, who also received cyclophosphamide, IL-2, and IFN-alpha. In contrast to RCC-TIL, IL-2-activated melanoma TIL consisting of all CD3+ T cells displayed modest levels of cytotoxicity, primarily restricted to autologous melanoma cells in all cases tested. The cytotoxic melanoma TIL were adoptively transferred to melanoma patients. Three of seven RCC patients responded to the adoptive therapy.
Two separate studies have been reported comparing Corynebacterium parvum and bacille Calmette-Guérin (BCG) as adjuvant immunotherapy for stage II melanoma patients (The Milton S. Hershey Medical Center, 48 patients; Southeastern Cancer Study Group [SECSG], 162 patients). As the criteria for patient selection and drugs used were similar, we have pooled the data to analyze the effects of these two treatments. Both studies used BCG (Tice, Chicago, IL) 3 x 10(8) live organisms per treatment by Tine technique and C parvum (Burroughs-Wellcome, Triangle Park, NC) subcutaneous at a dose of 4 mg/m2 (SECSG) or 5 micrograms/m2 (Hershey) per treatment. The only difference in these studies was the frequency of immunization, with patients in Hershey receiving 22 doses and the SECSG patients receiving 55 doses during the 2-year period of treatment. Kaplan-Meier life-table analysis for the 210 patients shows a prolonged disease-free interval for patients treated with C parvum (P = .02, two-sided Mantel procedure). In similar fashion, patients treated with C parvum had an improved survival rate (from all causes) when compared with BCG-treated patients (P = .012). An analysis of the results for the 170 patients for which the number of positive nodes was available was performed using Cox's model, with nodes as a stratification variable and with covariates of place, treatment, age, and sex. In this analysis, an observed benefit for C parvum on the disease-free interval had a P value of .37 while the benefit of C parvum on the survival times (from all causes) had a P value of .04. When the same analysis was performed using only patients aged younger than 60 years, the observed benefit of C parvum on disease-free interval had a P value of .08 and the benefit of C parvum on survival times (from all causes) had a P value of .008.
Theoretically ELND may be beneficial for the subset of patients who are likely to have occult metastases at the time of diagnosis. The natural history of melanoma, well described from large data bases, has identified a group of patients with "intermediate-thickness" melanomas as the potential beneficiaries. However, pathologic specimens obtained from ELND have demonstrated a much lower incidence of occult disease (15%) than what would be anticipated based on the estimated risk of developing clinically detectable metastasis, more than 50%. Possible explanations for this discrepancy are as follows: (1) routine pathologic examination fails to detect micrometastases accurately thus, grossly underestimating the true incidence of occult disease and/or (2) patients who are at high risk for metastases have not yet developed regional disease at the time of diagnosis and performance of the ELND. In the latter situation, ELND would provide expectant palliation by preventing regional node relapse but would not be expected to impact on survival. Clearly, however, at least three retrospective studies have demonstrated a survival benefit when using ELND for the treatment of patients in the subgroup with intermediate-thickness melanomas. Prospective studies have not confirmed these same results, but they have not targeted the study to the same group of patients. In order to resolve the differences, we have initiated a prospective randomized multi-institutional surgical trial to ascertain the efficacy of ELND in patients with tumor thickness between 1 and 4 mm. More than 700 patients have been entered on this study. Results should provide valuable insights as to the true incidence of occult regional disease and determine if the removal of this disease translates into a survival benefit. In the meantime, the practice of ELND should be a selective one. The decision should be individualized in an attempt to maximize the potential benefit and minimize the morbidity. Tumor thickness, presence or absence of ulceration, anatomical site of primary, and sex of the patient are all important criteria for estimating the risk of metastasis. The elderly and obese are more likely to suffer from long-term complications of lymphadenectomy, and therefore the risk and benefits must be meticulously evaluated before application of ELND in this patient population is undertaken.
Soluble inhibitors of lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cell induction were characterized and purified from serous fluids from healthy donors or from patients with advanced cancer. Inhibitory activity in sera from cancer patients was partially absorbed with protein A agarose or anti-human IgG agarose. Following absorption, residual inhibition varied with individual sera, suggesting the presence of IgG-related and non-IgG inhibitory factors, and the proportions varied in the patient population. IgG, purified by affinity chromatography from ascitic fluids, from plasma of cancer patients, and from plasma of healthy donors, significantly inhibited IL-2 induction of LAK cells in a dose-dependent manner. Irrespective of the sources, inhibitory activity resided in the high-molecular-weight IgG fraction composed of IgG aggregates and immune complexes, but not monomeric IgG. Commercially prepared human IgG in aggregated form, but not in monomeric form, inhibited LAK cell induction in a dose-dependent manner. In contrast, neither bovine IgG nor human albumin affected LAK cell induction, even at higher concentrations. Aggregated human IgG inhibited LAK cell induction in unfractionated peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) but not in monocyte-depleted peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL). Despite extensive (greater than 99%) depletion of IgG by protein-G affinity chromatography, the serous fluid from cancer patients displayed significant inhibitory activity. Fractionation of the IgG-depleted inhibitory materials by Sephacryl S-300, high-pressure ion-exchange column (HPIEC) or gel-permeation chromatography (HPGPC) demonstrated a 65-kDa inhibitor, distinct from IgG. Affigel-blue affinity chromatography of the 65-kDa fraction depleted albumin but did not remove the inhibitory activity, suggesting that the 65-kDa inhibitor is not serum albumin nor an albumin-bound component. These results suggest that serous fluids from patients with advanced-stage cancer contain 2 distinct regulators for LAK cell induction: (I) aggregated IgG and (2) a 65-kDa inhibitor, distinct from albumin.
Antitumor immunity requires (a) extravasation of lymphocytes from the blood stream to interstitium, (b) locomotion through extracellular matrix to the site of the tumor, (c) effector cell recognition of the tumor target with cell/cell contact and binding of adhesion receptors, (d) T-cell receptor binding to histocompatibility and tumor antigens, and (e) tumor cell lysis. We hypothesize that the tumor microenvironment inhibits lymphocyte locomotion through extracellular matrix as one mechanism by which tumors may avert host defense. Lymphocyte locomotion was investigated in vitro using a three-dimensional collagen gel model. Fresh tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes (TIL) were obtained by enzymatic digestion of melanomas and renal cell carcinoma, and mononuclear cells were isolated by discontinuous Ficoll-Hypaque gradient. The lymphocytes were analyzed for motility from a point of origin between basal and overlay layers of collagen gel. Results showed that TIL migration was almost completely inhibited, compared with migration of normal and cancer patient peripheral blood leukocytes and lymphocytes from lymph nodes. Short-term (24-h) exposure of lymphocytes to cytokines during the assay in the collagen gel matrix had no effect on locomotor ability. Long-term (19, 30, or 35 days) culture of TIL in 200 units/ml of interleukin 2 reinstated locomotor ability. Short-term exposure of any of the lymphocyte populations to interleukin 1-alpha, interleukin 1-beta, interleukin 2, interleukin 3, interleukin 4, alpha-interferon, or gamma-interferon had no effect on migration. Thus, TIL display a uniquely arrested ability to locomote through collagen gel. Inhibition of the locomotion of infiltrating effector cells is possibly a mechanism by which the tumor evades the host immune system.
The immunological properties of lymphocytes from tumor, peripheral blood (PBL), and nontumorous kidney from 16 patients with renal cell carcinoma were characterized at the clonal level with respect to their clonogenic efficiency, phenotypic expression, and cytotoxicity against autologous and allogenic tumor cells. The objectives were to delineate: (a) the quantitative differences in the immunological properties of tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes (TIL) from patient to patient; and (b) the qualitative differences in immunological properties between TIL and lymphocytes from peripheral blood or nontumorous kidney from a single patient. A total of 926 clones were characterized for phenotype expression, and 465 clones were characterized for cytotoxicity. The clonogenic efficiency of TIL varied with individuals: high in one patient; relatively high to moderate in seven patients; low in seven patients, and extremely low in the remaining one patient. The levels of autologous tumor cell lysis by TIL clones also varied with individuals. More than one-third of the TIL clones established in 4 of 13 patients displayed significant (greater than or equal to 10%) lysis against autologous tumor cells, and in each of the four patients the average percentage of lysis in the total TIL clones was higher than 10%. In two patients, 5 of 26 or 3 of 13 TIL clones were cytotoxic, but averages of percentage of lysis in the total clones were less than 10%. One 1 or 2 TIL clones of 10-27 total clones were cytotoxic in each of 4 patients, while no cytotoxic TIL clones were found in the remaining 3 patients. Clonogenic efficiency did not correlate with the level of cytotoxicity, and TIL from no tumors displayed both high proliferation and high cytotoxicity at the clonal level. In a majority of patients (12 of 13), most cytotoxic TIL clones against autologous tumor cells also lysed allogenic tumor cells. In contrast, TIL clones lysed only autologous tumor cells in the remaining one patient (patient 2). The clonogenic efficiency of TIL was lower than that of PBL in 6 of 12 patients, while the opposite was true in the remaining 6 patients. The level of cytotoxicity in the PBL clones of these 12 patients primarily correlated with that of the TIL clones. With one exception (patient 2), most cytotoxic PBL clones against autologous tumor cells also lysed allogenic targets in a majority of patients. CD4+CD8-T-cell clones (70-85%) predominated in all patients regardless of the different lymphocyte sources.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)
T expaanded role of the surgeon now integrates a range of multi-modality treatment options that address both local and regional and systemic disease control. This decision-making process requires an understanding of the natural history of cancer and those prognostic factors that predict the risk of clinically occult regional metastases and distant metastases. The goal in managing the surgical patient with cancer is a full implementation of multi-disciplinary cancer care to provide the highest quality of care with the maximum rehabilitation at the lowest possible cost.