Search PubMedSearch

Biomedical subjects

B T Collopy

Publications and source records attributed to B T Collopy.

5 recordsLinked to original sources

Correlation between injury severity scores and subjective ratings of injury severity: a basis for trauma audit.

A retrospective review of 1900 road accident victims attending the emergency departments of two Melbourne hospitals was undertaken to identify Injury Severity Score levels which could distinguish between minor, moderate, severe and critical injury. Injuries scoring ISS 6 or below were designated 'minor' because they were associated with a low risk of requiring admission to hospital. Case notes of patients scoring above ISS 6 were then reviewed by a panel of clinicians, who independently rated each patient's overall injury severity as moderate, severe or critical according to what was recorded in the notes and their 'clinical' judgement. ISS values were compared with clinicians' ratings. Measures of each clinician's individual rating consistency, and correlation between pairs of clinicians with respect to inter-rater consistency, were made. By combining data from both hospitals it emerged that 'moderate' injury corresponded to ISS 8-13, 'severe' to ISS 14-20 and 'critical' to ISS 21 and above. These ISS breakpoints will be useful in selecting groups of injured patients for future trauma audit studies.

Accidents, Traffic

Use of the Injury Severity Score to monitor diagnostic accuracy in the early assessment of road trauma.

A retrospective review of 279 hospital admissions at two Melbourne hospitals was conducted to develop a method for identifying diagnostic error using the Injury Severity Score (ISS) as a model for clinical audit. Two scores were calculated for each patient, the first according to injuries diagnosed on initial assessment in the Emergency Department and the second according to final, confirmed diagnoses upon discharge from hospital. Diagnostic errors were identified as discrepancies between the initial and final scores. ISS discrepancies were found in 48 cases (17.2%). Some were clinically significant errors of diagnosis while others reflected inaccurate injury description or record keeping. Abdominal injuries were the most frequently missed, followed in decreasing order by spinal, thoracic, extremities (limbs), head/face and external injuries (skin and subcutaneous tissues). The frequency and pattern of injury misdiagnosis concurs with the findings of other studies. The diagnostic error rate was found to increase with injury severity and with the number of anatomic body regions involved. The authors suggest that comparing initial and final ISS provides a convenient mechanism for the audit of early diagnosis in trauma cases.

Accidents, Traffic

Experimental replacement of the cervical oesophagus with a free transverse colon autograft using microvascular anastomoses.

Microsurgical revascularization in the neck has improved the survival rate of free small-bowel grafts used to replace the cervical oesophagus. Colon vessels are larger than those in the jejunum, and even with naked-eye technique good results have been reported following free colon grafting of the oesophagus. The authors thought it might be possible to achieve even better results using microvascular anastomoses in the neck, and in this way replaced the cervical oesophagus in each of 15 dogs with a free transverse colon autotransplant. Four dogs died during operation and four within three days, two of the latter with graft necrosis. The next seven dogs survived eight days or more, and all their colon grafts were viable. Where patent arteries were demonstrated (three cases) the mucosa and myenteric plexuses of the graft survived. In all four dogs where the arteries were thrombosed or not demonstrated, the mucosa was absent, myenteric plexuses were absent in three, and one graft was grossly stenosed. Among these seven dogs there were three fistulae, one where graft arteries were patent and two where they were not; immediate anastomotic healing was not guaranteed by graft survival or arterial patency.

Animals

Lincomycin-clindamycin-associated psuedomembranous colitis.

Five cases of lincomycin-clindamycin-associated acute pseudomembranous colitis, demonstrating a spectrum of clinical, histological and radiological severity, were encountered over a five-months period. All patients presented with watery diarrhoea without the passage of macroscopic blood or pus. Two patients were seriously ill with fulminant colitis, but responded rapidly to corticosteroids given parenterally and supportive therapy. The diagnosis of acute colitis should be considered in all patients developing diarrhoea during or up to three weeks after beginning therapy with lincomycin or clindamycin and can be confirmed by sigmoidoscopic examination. Withdrawal of the antibiotic and symptomatic treatment is appropriate for mild cases of colitis, but our experience suggests that corticosteroid therapy is safe and effective in severe cases. Indiscriminate use of these antibiotics should be avoided.

Acute Disease