Biomedical subjects
Publications and source records attributed to A Wittinghofer.
Recent three-dimensional structures of phosphoryl transfer enzymes in their aluminum fluoride bound state and corresponding biochemical data have shown how diverse biological problems can be investigated using this small inorganic molecule.
Ran, a small nuclear GTP-binding protein, is one of the most abundant Ras-related proteins in eucaryotic cells. Ran is essential for nucleo-cytoplasmatic transport and is primarily localized in the nucleus and at the nuclear pore complex. Here, we characterize the kinetics and equilibrium of the interaction between Ran and RanBP1 by two independent biophysical approaches: fluorescence spectroscopy using analogues of guanine nucleotides and surface plasmon resonance in the BIAcore system. Both approaches result in kinetic and equilibrium data which are in good agreement with each other. Affinities of RanBP1 for Ran in the GTP-bound state were in the nanomolar range, while Ran.GDP bound RanBP1 with a dissociation constant around 10 microM. Interestingly, the difference in affinity of RanBP1 for Ran.GDP was mostly due to a dramatic increase of the dissociation rate constant. Mutant Ran protein lacking the last five amino acids of the C-terminus (RanDeltaC) is unable to facilitate nuclear import in vitro and does not bind to RanBP1. Here, we show that RanBP1 binds RanDeltaC.mGppNHp with KD values around 10 microM, as is the case for its association with full-length Ran.GDP. The loss of affinity of RanBP1 for the triphosphate form of RanDeltaC was a result of both a decrease of the association rate and a moderately increased dissociation of the RanDeltaC.RanBP1 complex. Circular dichroism spectra indicate significant changes in the secondary structure of either Ran.GppNHp, RanBP1, or both proteins upon forming a stable complex with each other.
A catalytically active fragment of the Rap-specific guanine-nucleotide exchange factor C3G was expressed in E coli. It was purified and its interaction with GTP-binding proteins was investigated using fluorescence spectroscopy. C3G stimulates GDP dissociation from Rap1, but not from Rap2, neither from Bud1, which is believed to be the yeast homologue of Rap1 nor from all other proteins of the human Ras-subfamily. Like the corresponding fragment from CDC25Mm, the increase in the GDP dissociation rate is linear with increasing concentration of Rap1A x GDP up to 100 microM, indicating an apparent K(M) higher than 100 microM. Unlike the Ras-CDC25Mm system, the Rap1A(S17N) mutant does not inhibit the C3G-activated guanine nucleotide dissociation from wild-type Rap1A in vitro. These data suggest that Rap1A(S17N) is unlikely to titrate away C3G in vivo, the proposed mechanism by which S17N-mutants exert their dominant negative effects.
The three-dimensional structure of the complex between human H-Ras bound to guanosine diphosphate and the guanosine triphosphatase (GTPase)-activating domain of the human GTPase-activating protein p120GAP (GAP-334) in the presence of aluminum fluoride was solved at a resolution of 2.5 angstroms. The structure shows the partly hydrophilic and partly hydrophobic nature of the communication between the two molecules, which explains the sensitivity of the interaction toward both salts and lipids. An arginine side chain (arginine-789) of GAP-334 is supplied into the active site of Ras to neutralize developing charges in the transition state. The switch II region of Ras is stabilized by GAP-334, thus allowing glutamine-61 of Ras, mutation of which activates the oncogenic potential, to participate in catalysis. The structural arrangement in the active site is consistent with a mostly associative mechanism of phosphoryl transfer and provides an explanation for the activation of Ras by glycine-12 and glutamine-61 mutations. Glycine-12 in the transition state mimic is within van der Waals distance of both arginine-789 of GAP-334 and glutamine-61 of Ras, and even its mutation to alanine would disturb the arrangements of residues in the transition state.
Ras plays a major role as a molecular switch in many signal transduction pathways which lead to cell growth and differentiation. The GTPase reaction of Ras is of central importance in the function of the switch since it terminates Ras-effector interactions. GTPase-activating proteins (GAPs) accelerate the very slow intrinsic hydrolysis reaction of the GTP-bound Ras by several orders of magnitude and thereby act as presumably negative regulators of Ras action. The GTP hydrolysis of oncogenic mutants of Ras remains unaltered. In this review we discuss recent biochemical and structural findings relating to the mechanism of GAP action, which strengthen the hypothesis that GAP accelerates the actual cleavage step by stabilizing the transition state of the phosphoryl transfer reaction.
AlF4- has long been known to associate with and activate the GDP-bound alpha subunits of heterotrimeric G-proteins. Recently the small guanine nucleotide binding protein Ras has also been shown to associate with AlF4- in the presence of stoichiometric amounts of its GTPase activating protein (GAP). Here we present the isolation of a stable Ras x GDP- x AlF4- x GAP ternary complex by gel filtration. In addition, we generalise the association of AlF4- with the small GTP-binding proteins by demonstrating ternary complex formation for the Cdc42, Rap and Ran proteins in the presence of their respective GAP proteins.
Individual rate constants for the interaction of H-, K-, and N-Ras with GAP-334 and NF1-333 were determined using fluorescent derivatives of guanine nucleotides at the active site of the Ras proteins. Stopped-flow experiments with NF1-333 show a fast concentration-dependent initial phase corresponding to the binding reaction followed by a slower phase, which corresponds to the hydrolysis reaction. With Ras bound to the nonhydrolyzable analogue mant-GppNHp, only the concentration-dependent first phase was observed. The Ras x mant-GppNHp x NF1-333 complexes were also used to measure dissociation rate constants of the Ras-GAP complexes. Using GAP-334 as the catalyst, the concentration-dependent first phase was too fast to be measured by the stopped-flow method, but the subsequent chemical cleavage reaction occurred at a similar rate (5-10 s(-1)) to that seen with NF1-333. With both GAP-334 and NF1-333, after rapidly reaching the initial equilibrium, there was no further time-dependent change on mixing GAPs with Ras x mant-GppNHp. The results obtained provide new insights into the individual steps of the GAP-catalyzed GTPase reaction on Ras. They do not require the postulation of a rate-limiting step occurring before GTP hydrolysis.
GTP and ATP hydrolysing proteins have an absolute requirement for a divalent cation, which is usually Mg2+, as a cofactor in the enzymatic reaction. Other phosphoryl transfer enzymes employ more than one divalent ion for the enzymatic reaction. It is shown here for p21ras, a well studied example of GTP hydrolysing proteins, that the GTP-hydrolysis rate is significantly faster if Mg2+ is replaced by Mn2+, both in the presence or absence of its GTPase-activating protein Ras-GAP. This effect is not due to a different stoichiometry of metal ion binding, since one metal ion is sufficient for full enzymatic activity. To determine the role of the metal ion, the crystal structure of p21(G12P). GppCp complexed with Mn2+ was determined and shown to be very similar to the corresponding p21(G12P). GppCp.Mg2+ structure. Especially the coordination sphere around the metal ions is very similar, and no second metal ion binding site could be detected, consistent with the assumption that one metal ion is sufficient for GTP hydrolysis. In order to explain the biochemical differences, we analysed the GTPase reaction mechanism with a linear free energy relationships approach. The result suggests that the reaction mechanism is not changed with Mn2+ but that the transition metal ion Mn2+ shifts the pKa of the gamma-phosphate by almost half a unit and increases the reaction rate due to an increase in the basicity of GTP acting as the general base. This suggests that the intrinsic GTPase reaction could be an attractive target for anti-cancer drug design. By using Rap1A and Ran, we show that the acceleration of the GTPase by Mn2+ appears to be a general phenomenon of GTP-binding proteins.
Ras-GTPase-activating proteins (Ras-GAPs) are important regulators of the biological activity of Ras within the framework of intracellular communication where GTP-bound Ras (Ras:GTP) is a key signal transducing molecule (Trahey and McCormick, Science 238:542-545, 1987; Boguski and McCormick, Nature 366:643-654, 1993). By accelerating Ras-mediated GTP hydrolysis, Ras-GAPs provide an efficient means to reset the Ras-GTPase cycle to the GDP-bound 'OFF'-state and terminate the Ras-mediated signal. Here we report the crystallization of the GTPase-activating domain of the human p120GAP. The crystals-belong to the orthorhombic space group symmetry P2(1)2(1)2(1) with unit cell dimensions of a = 42.2 A, b = 55.6 A, c = 142.2 A, alpha = beta = gamma = 90 degrees. Assuming a Matthews parameter of 2.2 A3/Da, there is one molecule per asymmetric unit. Applying micro-seeding techniques, we grew large single crystals that could not be obtained by other routine methods for crystal improvement. They diffracted to a resolution of approximately 3 A using X-rays from a rotating anode generator and to better than 1.8 A in a synchrotron beam. Chemical cross-linking led to reduction of the maximum resolution but to significantly increased stability against mechanical and heavy atom stress.
Cell biology depends on the interactions of macromolecules, such as protein-DNA, protein-protein or protein-nucleotide interactions. GTP-binding proteins are no exception to the rule. They regulate cellular processes as diverse as protein biosynthesis and intracellular membrane trafficking. Recently, a large number of genes encoding GTP-binding proteins and the proteins that interact with these molecular switches have been cloned and expressed. The 3D structures of some of these have also been elucidated.
RasGAPs supply a catalytic residue, termed the arginine finger,into the active site of Ras thereby stabilizing the transition state of the GTPase reaction and increasing the reaction rate by more than one thousand-fold, in good agreement with the structure of the Ras.RasGAP complex.
The solution structure of the Ras-binding domain (RBD) of Ral guanine-nucleotide exchange factor RalGEF was solved by NMR spectroscopy. The overall structure is similar to that of Raf-RBD, another effector of Ras, although the sequence identity is only 13%. 15N chemical shifts changes in the complex of RalGEF-RBD with Ras indicate an interaction similar to the intermolecular beta-sheet observed for the complex between Ras and Raf-RBD.
Ras-related GTP-binding proteins function as molecular switches which cycle between GTP-bound 'on'- and GDP-bound 'off'-states. GTP hydrolysis is the common timing mechanism that mediates the return from the 'on' to the 'off'-state. It is usually slow but can be accelerated by orders of magnitude upon interaction with GTPase-activating proteins (GAPs). In the case of Ras, a major regulator of cellular growth, point mutations are found in approximately 30% of human tumours which render the protein unable to hydrolyse GTP, even in the presence of Ras-GAPs. The first structure determination of a GTPase-activating protein reveals the catalytically active fragment of the Ras-specific p120GAP (ref. 2), GAP-334, as an elongated, exclusively helical protein which appears to represent a novel protein fold. The molecule consists of two domains, one of which contains all the residues conserved among different GAPs for Ras. From the location of conserved residues around a shallow groove in the central domain we can identify the site of interaction with Ras x GTP. This leads to a model for the interaction between Ras and GAP that satisfies numerous biochemical and genetic data on this important regulatory process.
Controlling the hydrolysis rate of GTP bound to guanine nucleotide binding proteins is crucial for the right timing of many biological processes. Theoretical, structural, and functional studies have demonstrated that in p21ras the substrate of the reaction, GTP itself, plays a central role by acting as the base catalyst. This substrate-assisted reaction mechanism was analyzed with the help of linear free energy relationships (LFERs). Here we present experimental data that further support the proposed mechanism. We extend the LFER analysis to a wide range of oncogenic as well as nontransforming Ras mutants. It is illustrated that almost all Ras variants follow the observed LFER and thus also the same reaction path. Further, the reduced GTPase reaction rate that characterizes the oncogenic effect of many of the p21 mutants found in human tumors seems to be a consequence of a slightly reduced pKa of the gamma-phosphate group of bound GTP. Factors causing a pKa deviation of just 0.5 unit are enough to slow the intrinsic GTPase reaction rate significantly, and the system may exhibit as a consequence of this an oncogenic potential. Interestingly, we also found oncogenic mutations that do not follow the regular LFER. This suggests that the oncogenic effect of distinct Ras mutants has a different physical origin. The results presented might aid in the design of drugs aimed at reactivating the GTPase reaction of many oncogenic p21ras mutants. We also analyzed the stimulated GTPase reaction of p21ras by the GTPase activating protein (GAP) and the GTPase reaction of Rap1A, a Ras-related GTP binding protein, with similar approaches. The corresponding results indicate that the GAP-stimulated GTPase as well as the Rap1A-catalyzed reaction seem to follow the same substrate-assisted reaction mechanism. However, the correlation coefficient for the GAP-catalyzed reaction is different from the corresponding coefficient for the intrinsic reaction. While the intrinsic reaction exhibits a Brønsted slope of beta = 2.1, the corresponding value for the GAP-activated reaction is beta = 4.9.
31P NMR revealed that the complex of p21ras with the GTP analog GppNHp.Mg2+ exists in two conformational states, states 1 and 2. In wild-type p21ras the equilibrium constant K1(12) between the two states is 1.09. The population of these states is different for various mutants but independent of temperature. The activation enthalpy delta H ++ and activation entropy delta S ++ for the conformational transitions were determined by full-exchange matrix analysis for wild-type p21ras and p21ras(S65P). For the wild-type protein one obtains delta H ++ = 89 +/- 2 kJ mol-1 and delta S ++ = 102 +/- 20 J mol-1 K-1 and for the mutant protein delta H ++ = 93 +/- 7 kJ mol-1 and delta S ++ = 138 +/- 30 J mol-1 K-1. The study of various p21ras mutants suggests that the two states correspond to different conformations of loop L2, with Tyr-32 in two different positions relative to the bound nucleotide. High-field EPR at 95 GHz suggest that the observed conformational transition does not directly influence the coordination sphere of the protein-bound metal ion. The influence of this transition on loop L4 was studied by 1H NMR with mutants E62H and E63H. There was no indication that L4 takes part in the transition described in L2, although a reversible conformational change could be induced by decreasing the pH value. The exchange between the two states is slow on the NMR time scale (< 10 s-1): at approximately pH 5 the population of the two states is equal. The interaction of p21ras-triphosphate complexes with the Ras-binding domain (RBD) of the effector protein c-Raf-1, Raf-RBD, and with the GTPase activating protein GAP was studied by 31P NMR spectroscopy. In complex with Raf-RBD the second conformation of p21ras (state 2) is stabilized. In this conformation Tyr-32 is located in close proximity to the phosphate groups of the nucleotide, and the beta-phosphate resonance is shifted upfield by 0.7 ppm. Spectra obtained in the presence of GAP suggest that in the ground state GAP does not interact directly with the nucleotide bound to p21ras and does not induce larger conformational changes in the neighborhood of the nucleotide. The experimental data are consistent with a picture where GAP accelerates the exchange process between the two states and simultaneously increases the population of state 1 at higher temperature.
The small GTPase Rap 1A is a close relative of Ras that, when overexpressed, is able to revert oncogenic transformation induced by active Ras. We screened a mouse embryonic cDNA library using the yeast two-hybrid system and isolated the cDNA of a novel Rap 1A-interacting protein. The open reading frame encodes for an 84 kDa protein with a Cdc25-homology domain which shares approximately 30% identity with Ral guanine nucleotide dissociation stimulator (RalGDS) and RalGDS-like (Rg1). The C-terminal region reveals a striking conservation of sequences with the Ras-binding domain of RalGDS. We designated this protein Rlf, for RalGDS-like factor. In the yeast system, Rlf interacts with Rap 1A, H-Ras and R-Ras, but not with Rac and Rho. In addition, we found that Rlf interacts with Rap 1Aval12 but not with Rap 1AAsn17. In vitro binding studies revealed that a C-terminally located 91 amino acid region of Rlf is sufficient for direct association with the GTP-bound form of Ras and Rap 1A. The observed dissociation constants are 0.6 microM and 0.4 microM, respectively. No significant association with Ras-GDP or Rap 1A-GDP could be detected. These binding characteristics indicate that Rlf is a putative effector for Ras and Rap 1A.
The kinetic properties for the enzymatic stimulation of the GTPase reaction of p21(ras) by the two GTPase-activating proteins (GAPs) p120(GAP) and neurofibromin are different. In order to understand these differences and since crystallization attempts have only been successful with truncated fragments, structure/function requirements of the catalytic core of these proteins were investigated. Differences in size of the minimal catalytic domains of these two proteins were found as determined by limited proteolysis. The minimal catalytic domain has a molecular mass of 30 kDa in the case of p120(GAP) and of 26 kDa in the case of neurofibromin. Both catalytic domains contain the homology boxes as well as the residues perfectly conserved among all Ras GAPs. The C termini of these fragments are identical, whereas the N-terminal part of the minimal p120(GAP) domain is 47 amino acids longer. These newly identified minimal catalytic fragments were as active in stimulating GTPase activity toward p21(ras) as the corresponding larger fragments GAP-334 and NF1-333 from which they had been generated via proteolytic digestion. Recently it was postulated that a fragment of 91 amino acids from neurofibromin located outside the conserved domain contains catalytic activity. In our hands this protein is unstable and has no catalytic activity. Thus, we believe that we have defined the true minimal domains of p120(GAP) (GAP-273, residues Met714-His986) and neurofibromin (NF1-230, residues Asp1248-Phe1477), which can be expressed via LMM fusion vectors in Escherichia coli and isolated in high purity.
Unlike the alpha subunits of heterotrimeric guanosine triphosphate (GTP)-binding proteins, Ras-related GTP-binding proteins have hitherto been considered not to bind or become activated by tetrafluoroaluminate (AIF4-). However, the product of the proto-oncogene ras in its guanosine diphosphate (GDP)-bound form interacted with AIF4 - in the presence of stoichiometric amounts of either of the guanosine triphosphatase (GTPase)-activating proteins (GAPs) p120GAP and neurofibromin. Neither oncogenic Ras nor a GAP mutant without catalytic activity produced such a complex. Together with the finding that the Ras-binding domain of the protein kinase c-Raf, whose binding site on Ras overlaps that of the GAPs, did not induce formation of such a complex, this result suggests that GAP and neurofibromin stabilize the transition state of the GTPase reaction of Ras.