Search PubMed⌕ Search

Biomedical subjects

A W Evans

Publications and source records attributed to A W Evans.

At least 19 recordsLinked to original sources
PubMed2005

The influence of self-deception and impression management upon self-assessment in oral surgery.

OBJECTIVE: To see if poor self-assessment of surgical performance during removal of mandibular third molars is influenced by self-deception (lack of insight) and impression management (trying to convey a favourable impression). DESIGN: A prospective study of 50 surgeons, surgically removing a lower third molar tooth. SETTING: One UK dental school over a two year period. METHODS: The surgeons' surgical skills were assessed (by two assessors) and self-assessed using check-list and global rating scales. Post-operatively, surgeons completed validated deception questionnaires which measured both self-deception enhancement (lack of insight), and impression management (the tendency to deliberately convey a favourable impression). MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Reliability between assessors, and between assessors' and surgeons' self-assessments were calculated. Discrepancies between assessors' and surgeons' scores were correlated with surgeons' deception scores. RESULTS: Reliability between assessors was excellent for checklist (0.96) and global rating scales (0.89) and better than the reliability between assessors and surgeons (0.51 and 0.49). There was a statistically significant correlation (r=0.45 p=0.001 checklist, r= 0.48 p<0.001 global) between over/ under-rating of their surgical performance by surgeons and their impression management scores. No statistically significant correlation was found between this inaccuracy in self-assessment and surgeons' individual self-deception scores. CONCLUSION: The majority of surgeons scored themselves higher than their assessors did for surgical skill in removing a single mandibular third molar tooth. Impression management (the tendency to deliberately convey a favourable impression) may contribute to a surgeon's inaccurate self-reporting of performance. Lack of insight appears to be much less important as a contributing factor. The authors speculate that pressure to provide evidence of good performance may be encouraging surgeons to manage their image and over-score themselves.

Attitude of Health Personnel↗
PubMed2005

Correlation between a patient-centred outcome score and surgical skill in oral surgery.

Our aim was to find out whether scores derived from a patient-centred outcome questionnaire correlated with the skill of the surgeon as assessed by a trainer. We found a relatively poor correlation after removal of a third mandibular molar, probably because outcome scores incorporate other measures, including patients' perceptions, anaesthesia, clarity of explanations and instructions, apart from surgical skill. The experience of the surgeon and the length of operation also influenced the results. The correlation was closest (i.e. higher levels of skill produced milder symptoms) when the operation was under local anaesthesia, probably because the surgeon's skill, behaviour, and attitude were visible to the patient throughout, and other team members had a less prominent role. In future, it may be more appropriate to assess the performance of the whole surgical team, rather than the surgeon alone.

Anesthesia, Dental↗
PubMed2003

Measurement of nitric oxide in temporomandibular joint saline aspirates.

Temporomandibular joint (TMJ) saline aspirates, obtained from the upper joint space of 17 patients undergoing TMJ arthroscopy under general anaesthesia were assayed for the presence of nitrite, a stable metabolite of nitric oxide by a spectrophotographic method using the Griess reaction. Measurable levels of nitrites were found in the saline aspirates of both symptomatic and asymptomatic joints. There was no statistically significant difference between the two sides. The presence of nitric oxide metabolites in the asymptomatic joints has not been previously reported in the literature. This finding may represent a latent disease process in the symptomless joint.

Adult↗
PubMed2002

Assessment of surgeon competency to remove mandibular third molar teeth.

There is an increasing demand for methods to objectively assess a surgeon's competence. The purpose of this study is to test two evaluation methods that assess a surgeon's skills in the removal of mandibular third molar teeth. One method uses an objective checklist scale by which twenty components of the operation are judged as correct or incorrect. The second method is a global rating scale, that scores different aspects of performance, such as respect for tissue, number of manoeuvres, knowledge of procedure and instrument handling. Using these two methods, assessors judged the removal of 22 mandibular third molar teeth by 17 different surgeons. Good inter-rater reliability was achieved using both scales. A greater preference was expressed for the global rating scale for assessment and for the objective checklist scale for guiding feedback in training. Scales such as these need to be developed for, and tested on, different surgical procedures in order that credible assessment of surgical skills can be obtained.

Clinical Competence↗
PubMed2002

Are we really as good as we think we are?

Differences are examined in assessment and self-assessment scores, in oral and maxillofacial surgery trainees and MSc postgraduates, following the surgical removal of lower third molar teeth. This study found evidence of a surprising and worrying over-rating of their own surgical skills by many trainees and postgraduates.

Analysis of Variance↗
PubMed2001

Assessing competence in surgical dentistry.

The growing demand for assessment in all aspects of surgical competencies will inevitably embrace the whole of dental surgery. The aim of this paper is to review the literature and discuss some of the issues that will have to be addressed as objective assessment of the surgical dentists' skills is introduced. The paper reviews what is meant by competence and how we assess it, with particular emphasis on practical and technical skills. Specific methodologies for assessing competence are described including, as illustrations, two means of assessing the removal of lower wisdom teeth. The evaluation of competence in the workplace is discussed together with the difficulty in assessing important attributes such as attitude. It concludes that the assessment of competence is a valuable tool in its own right and a means of demonstrating to the public the continuing commitment of the profession to the highest possible standards. However assessment will be very time consuming and to be worth while we must ensure that it is done in a way that produces clear and unambiguous benefits and solves real problems.

Attitude of Health Personnel↗
PubMed2001

Gender challenge.

Explore the source record for details and available documents.

Dentists, Women↗
PubMed2000

Osteosarcoma of the jaws: a 30-year retrospective review.

OBJECTIVE: This article reviews osteosarcomas of the jaws referred to the Department of Oral Pathology, Eastman Dental Institute, for histologic diagnosis during the 30 years from 1968 to 1998, to compare the clinical behavior of the tumors, to assess how they differ from the reported characteristics of tumors from other sites, and to report on observations of clinical and diagnostic significance. STUDY DESIGN: The clinical, radiographic, and histopathologic records of 25 patients were obtained for retrospective review. Supportive and follow-up clinical and histopathologic material was obtained from the referring clinicians. RESULTS: The mean age of presentation of the primary lesions was 36. 9 years (range, 10-87 years) with a slight female predilection. The most common presenting features were swelling, pain, ulceration, or a neurologic deficit. The radiographic appearance of the lesions was mixed with areas of radiopacity and radiolucency. Histologically, the lesions ranged from those dominated by immature bony trabeculae separated by a cytologically bland stroma to high-grade, cellular lesions with regions of marked atypia and mitotic activity. Most had areas of chondroid formation, in addition to neoplastic osteoid. The main complication was local recurrence. Metastasis was rare and occurred as a solitary process or at a late stage in the disease progression. This was in contrast to lesions metastatic to the jaws, which were higher grade in appearance and had metastasized widely, early in the disease process. Primary osteosarcoma occurring in patients with a history of radiotherapy was typically more aggressive. CONCLUSION: Primary osteosarcomas of the jaws are a group of lesions distinct from those occurring in the long bones. Osteosarcomas of the jaw arising in a former radiation field may be a discrete group of lesions with a more aggressive behavior pattern.

Adolescent↗
PubMed2000

Identification of the secreted macromolecular immunogens of Staphylococcus aureus by analysis of serum.

The ability of sera to recognise secreted macromolecules of Staphylococcus aureus was examined by ELISA and Western immunoblotting. Individual secreted proteins were also studied using both human sera and sera from rabbits immunised with secreted macromolecules. Patients sera showed a wide range of IgG antibody titres to secreted macromolecules and whole bacteria. Controls showed a significantly lower IgG response. Western immunoblotting revealed that a significant number of secreted proteins were recognised by circulating IgG antibodies. Surprisingly, both the sera from controls and from patients recognised similar macromolecules including a number of potential virulence factors. The major difference was in the IgG binding to a 16-kDa component, which was recognised by the majority of the sera from infected individuals, but only by a small number of sera from healthy controls. The higher incidence of antibodies recognising the 16 kDa component may be related to our earlier finding that the major bone resorbing component of S. aureus is a heterodimeric protein containing a 16-kDa subunit, the activity of which could be blocked by sera.

Adult↗
PubMed1996

Estimating the consequences of accidents: the case of automatic train protection in Britain.

This paper considers estimates of the number of fatalities per year on rail lines operated by British Railways that could be expected to be saved by the installation of automatic train protection, based on historical data. The authors' preferred estimate is 3.66 fatalities per year, with an estimated 95% confidence interval of 1.44-5.89. It is possible to find orthodox probability distributions that fit the distribution of numbers of fatalities well. FN-graphs are not a suitable means of fitting such distributions.

Accidents, Traffic↗