Search PubMedSearch

Biomedical subjects

A S Shiu

Publications and source records attributed to A S Shiu.

10 recordsLinked to original sources

Dosimetric evaluation of a two-dimensional, arc electron, pencil-beam algorithm in water and PMMA.

The accuracy of dose calculations from a pencil-beam algorithm developed specifically for arc electron beam therapy was evaluated at 10 and 15 MeV. Mid-arc depth-doses were measured for 0 degrees and 90 degrees arcs using 12 and 15 cm radius cylindrical water phantoms. Calculated depth-doses for the 90 degrees arced beams in the build-up region were as much as 3% less than measured values; the maximum dose was similar in magnitude but at a greater depth; and the therapeutic depth, R80, was 2-4 mm deeper. Calculated values of output (dose per monitor unit) at the depth of the maximum calculated dose were compared with measured values; for arcs ranging from 0-90 degrees, 12 and 15 cm radius water phantoms, and collimator widths of 4, 5 and 6 cm, results showed differences as great as 7%. Isodose countours for a 90 degrees arc were also measured in a 15 cm radius PMMA phantom. At the depth of maximum dose the algorithm predicted doses in the penumbral regions, both with and without collimation, which agreed within a few per cent of measured values. The largest discrepancies were 5%, which occurred in the penumbral portion of the depth-dose fall-off region. Differences between measurement and calculation are not believed to be clinically significant and are believed to be primarily due to the fact that the algorithm models neither large-angle scattering nor the effects of range straggling on the pencil-beam dose distribution.

Algorithms

Dose in bone and tissue near bone-tissue interface from electron beam.

This work has quantitatively studied the variation of dose both within bone and in unit density tissue near bone-tissue interfaces. Dose upstream of a bone-tissue interface is increased because of an increase in the backscattered electrons from the bone. The magnitude of this effect was measured using a thin parallel-plate ionization chamber upstream of a polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA)-hard bone interface. The electron backscatter factor (EBF) increased rapidly with bone thickness until a full EBF was achieved. This occurred at approximately 3.5 mm at 2 MeV and 6 mm at 13.1 MeV. The full EBF at the interface ranged from approximately 1.018 at 13.1 MeV to 1.05 at 2 MeV. It was also observed that the EBF had a dependence on the energy spectrum at the interface. The penetration of the backscattered electrons in the upstream direction of PMMA was also measured. The dose penetration fell off rapidly in the upstream direction of the interface. Dose enhancement to unit density tissue in bone was measured for an electron beam by placing thermoluminescent dosimeters (TLDs) in a PMMA-bone-PMMA phantom. The maximum dose enhancement in bone was approximately 7% of the maximum dose in water. However, the pencil-beam algorithm of Hogstrom et al. predicted an increase of only 1%, primarily owing to the inverse-square correction. Film was also used to measure the dose enhancement in bone. The film plane was aligned either perpendicular or parallel to the central axis of the beam. The film data indicated that the maximum dose enhancement in bone was approximately 8% for the former film alignment (which was similarly predicted by the TLD measurements) and 13% for the latter film alignment. These results confirm that the X ray film is not suitable to be irritated "edge on" in an inhomogeneous phantom without making perturbation corrections resulting from the film acting as a long narrow inhomogeneous cavity within the bone. In addition, the results give the radiotherapist a basis for clinical judgment when electron beams are used to treat lesions behind bone or near bony structures. We feel these data enhance the ability to recognize the shortcomings of the current dose calculation algorithm used clinically.

Bone and Bones

Effect of dimensionality of heterogeneity corrections on the implementation of a three-dimensional electron pencil-beam algorithm.

Electron beam dose distributions were calculated on a three-dimensional grid using three pencil-beam algorithms, each taking into account irregularities in field shape. The algorithms differ in that patient anatomy in either one, two, or three dimensions is used in the calculation of dose to a point. Algorithms were optimized for speed by such techniques as precalculation and storage of several quantities, reordering of pencil-beam and grid-point loops, selection of cut-off values for some calculated quantities, and invoking error function symmetries. Execution times for optimized versions of each of the algorithms as implemented on a three-dimensional treatment planning system were comparable for both the one- and two-dimensional heterogeneity correction requires an additional calculational loop over fan lines. Execution times for the three-dimensional heterogeneity correction were approximately a factor of four longer than those for the two-dimensional correction. For certain geometries, three-dimensional heterogeneity corrections were necessary to calculate dose distributions accurately, in spite of the additional cost in calculation times.

Algorithms

Design of metallic electron beam cones for an intraoperative therapy linear accelerator.

A set of circular collimators and treatment cones from 5 to 12 cm diameter has been designed for an intraoperative accelerator (6-18 MeV) that has an optical docking system. Electron beam scattering theory has been used to minimize their weight while minimizing leakage radiation. Both acrylic and brass were evaluated as possible materials; however, because of substantial electron leakage through the lateral cone wall for acrylic, we have concluded that 2 mm thick brass walls are more desirable than acrylic walls. At 18 MeV, isodose measurements beneath the cones showed hot spots as great as 120% for both materials. The placement and dimension of an internal trimmer ring inside the brass cone was studied as a method for reducing the hot spots, and it was found this could only be accomplished at the expense of decreasing coverage of the 90% isodose surface. The effects of 1 degree cone misalignment on the dose distribution has been studied and found to generate changes of less than 5% in the dose and 3 mm in position of the 90% isodose surface. In a study of the contribution of the cone and its matching collimator assembly to x-ray room leakage, it was noted that although the treatment cone had a negligible contribution, the upper annuli of the upper collimator assembly contributed as much as 80% of the leakage at 16 MeV for the 5-cm cone.

Humans

A two-dimensional pencil-beam algorithm for calculation of arc electron dose distributions.

A two-dimensional pencil-beam algorithm is presented for the calculation of arc electron dose distributions in any plane that is perpendicular to the axis of rotation. The dose distributions are calculated by modelling the arced beam as a single broad beam defined by the irradiated surface of the patient. The algorithm is two-dimensional in that the anatomical cross section of the patient and the skin collimators are assumed identical in parallel planes outside the plane of calculation. The broad beam is modelled as a collection of strip beams, each strip beam being characterised by its planar fluence, mean projected angular direction and a root-mean-square spread about the mean direction. Using these parameters, the dose distribution is calculated using pencil-beam theory. Examples of strip-beam parameters and resulting dose distributions for patient geometries are presented. Features of the algorithm, which include (1) incorporation of pencil-beam theory for the calculation of dose in heterogeneous tissue, (2) run times of only about twice that of comparable-sized fixed electron fields and (3) the input requirement of only a single depth dose and four off-axis dose profiles of measured data, make the algorithm practical for clinical use.

Algorithms

Technique for verifying treatment fields using portal images with diagnostic quality.

The image quality of portal films for megavoltage photon beams, when using the double-exposure technique, is poor compared to diagnostic quality, X ray images. A technique is described to record on a single film a megavoltage portal image superimposed upon a diagnostic X ray image, which provides the radiotherapist with "diagnostic quality" portal images. The technique uses a commercially available X ray tube mounted on the head of a 60Co unit. The alignment procedure, which uses a leveling device to ensure that the X ray focal spot and 60Co source are at the same location for each exposure, is confirmed by registering on film the image of an alignment marker. An evaluation of film-screen combination showed therapy verification film in a rare earth intensifying screen cassette to be best suited for this technique. The relationship between off-axis dose and the penumbral region of the portal image has been evaluated and should be useful in the interpretation of portal verification film relative to the treatment volume.

Cobalt Radioisotopes

Measurement of dose distributions using film in therapeutic electron beams.

The feasibility of using film dosimetry data as the input data for patient treatment planning was evaluated. The central-axis depth dose and the off-axis ratios obtained from film measurements in a solid phantom were compared with those of ion-chamber measurements in water. Two techniques were used to generate isodose distributions. The first technique used only the film data, i.e., the central-axis depth dose and the off-axis ratios used for the reconstruction were determined from the film optical density (corrected for film nonlinearity). In the second technique, the central-axis depth dose measured by an ion chamber in a water phantom was combined with the off-axis ratios measured using film in the "solid water" phantom. The resulting isodose distributions from both techniques were compared with the ion-chamber measurements in water for 7-, 12-, and 18-MeV electrons, and the second technique showed better agreement with the ion-chamber measurements than did the first technique. The differences were within a clinically acceptable range.

Electrons

Pencil-beam redefinition algorithm for electron dose distributions.

A pencil-beam redefinition algorithm has been developed for the calculation of electron-beam dose distributions on a three-dimensional grid utilizing 3-D inhomogeneity correction. The concept of redefinition was first used for both fixed and arced electron beams by Hogstrom et al. but was limited to a single redefinition. The success of those works stimulated the development of the pencil-beam redefinition algorithm, the aim of which is to solve the dosimetry problems presented by deep inhomogeneities through development of a model that redefines the pencil beams continuously with depth. This type of algorithm was developed independently by Storchi and Huizenga who termed it the "moments method." Such a pencil beam within the patient is characterized by a complex angular distribution, which is approximated by a Gaussian distribution having the same first three moments as the actual distribution. Three physical quantities required for dose calculation and subsequent radiation transport--namely planar fluence, mean direction, and root-mean-square spread about the mean direction--are obtained from these moments. The primary difference between the moments method and the redefinition algorithm is that the latter subdivides the pencil beams into multiple energy bins. The algorithm then becomes a macroscopic method for transporting the complete phase space of the beam and allows the calculation of physical quantities such as fluence, dose, and energy distribution. Comparison of calculated dose distributions with measured dose distributions for a homogeneous water phantom, and for phantoms with inhomogeneities deep relative to the surface, show agreement superior to that achieved with the pencil-beam algorithm of Hogstrom et al. in the penumbral region and beneath the edges of air and bone inhomogeneities. The accuracy of the redefinition algorithm is within 4% and appears sufficient for clinical use, and the algorithm is structured for further expansion of the physical model if required for site-specific treatment planning problems.

Algorithms

Verification data for electron beam dose algorithms.

The Collaborative Working Group (CWG) of the National Cancer Institute (NCI) electron beam treatment planning contract has performed a set of 14 experiments that measured dose distributions for 28 unique beam-phantom configurations that simulated various patient anatomic structures and beam geometries. Multiple dose distributions were measured with film or diode detectors for each configuration, resulting in 78, 2-D planar dose distributions and one, 1-D depth-dose distribution. Measurements were made for 9- and 20-MeV electron beams, using primarily 6 x 6- and 15 x 15-cm applicators at several SSDs. Dose distributions were measured for shaped fields, irregular surfaces, and inhomogeneities (1-D, 2-D, and 3-D), which were designed to simulate many clinical electron treatments. The data were corrected for asymmetries, and normalized in an absolute manner. This set of measured data can be used for verification of electron beam dose algorithms and is available to others for that purpose.

Algorithms